Learn how the World Bank Group is helping countries with COVID-19 (coronavirus). Find Out

BRIEF

RESPECT Study for women at high risk of HIV infection in Dar-es-Salaam, Tanzania

October 3, 2016

Image
Photo: Arne Hoel / World Bank

Evaluation Highlights
  • Despite recent progress in expanding AIDS treatment, innovative solutions for HIV prevention are a priority. UNAIDS reported that in 2013 approximately 2.3 million people were newly infected and it appears that information and education campaigns to promote safer sexual behavior are less effective than anticipated at stemming the HIV spread.
  • Using financial incentives to encourage safer sex has shown some promise. The question is whether financial programs can work on a large scale, how they can be structured to remain cost effective and how to make them work in urban versus rural settings.
  • The evaluation in Tanzania will provide valuable information on the impact of cash transfers on high risk women, building up the body of evidence on what works for policymaking that can help stem the spread of HIV/AIDS.

Context:

Preventing HIV infection is a priority in Tanzania, where an estimated 1.6 million people—about six percent of the population—are infected with the virus. Women are disproportionally infected and in 2011, some 60 percent of those living with HIV in Tanzania were women.  Urban sex workers have especially high rates of infection, estimated at 31 percent.

A previous SIEF-funded impact evaluation in Tanzania, known as the RESPECT study, found that giving women cash for testing negative for a set of curable sexually transmitted infections reduced the rate of these infections.  The current study is an extension of that and will test the conditional cash framework (the cash transfers are not funded by SIEF) on a high risk population of female sex-workers and women visiting bars in the evening in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania’s largest city. The evidence generated will be important for policymakers and international health groups working throughout sub-Saharan Africa to reduce the spread of sexually transmitted diseases.

 

SIEF cluster Health
Country Tanzania
Evaluation sample:   4,031 women
Timeline 2014-2017
Policy tools conditional cash transfers, HIV/AIDS testing

 

Intervention/evaluation:

The evaluation will focus on women 18 years and older in Dar es Salaam who meet the following criteria:

  • Have exchanged sexual intercourse for money in the past six months or had multiple male sexual partners in the past month
  • Are HIV negative at enrollment
  • Are not currently pregnant, by self-report
  • Have lived in Dar es Salaam for the past three months
  • Are able to adequately grant informed consent
  • A total of 4,031 women will be recruited for the study, using the “chain referral” sampling method. Recruitment will start with local health staff who work in the female sex worker and high-risk communities. They will select “seeds” from among these communities and give them each three coded coupons to give to peers who meet the criteria for the study. These peers will be considered the first wave of participants. After they complete the initial survey, they’ll be given three coupons as well to recruit others. Both the initial group who get the coupons and the later recruits will receive training on the program, eligibility for recruitment, the voluntary nature of the study and related information.

Once 4,031 women have been signed up, they will be offered an initial test for HIV and sexually transmitted diseases. They also will get counseled on protecting themselves from sexually transmitted diseases and they will receive male condoms and told about the use. Women who test positive for HIV won’t be eligible for the study and they will be directed to appropriate services. Those who test positive for the other diseases will get a voucher to use for free treatment at a nearby pharmacy and they will still be eligible for the study. The women will then be randomly divided into a treatment and a control group.

The treatment and control groups will be both tested every three months for HIV and three other sexually transmitted infections. Women in both groups will get counseling about prevention and treatment and they will also receive free treatment should they test positive. The difference between the treatment and control groups is that women in the treatment group will get $20 every three months if all their tests for sexually transmitted diseases are negative.

It will be stressed to all participants in the study that stopping or taking a break from sex work or from trading sex for money is a strategy for avoiding infection. Women in the treatment group who stop risky behavior will still be eligible for the cash transfers during the course of the study if they test negative for the sexually transmitted diseases.

As part of the study, researchers will carry out in-depth interviews with a subsample of the participants, focusing on the things that affect women’s ability to protect their health and practice safe sex in the context of the conditional cash transfer program.

Policy impacts:

The results from this impact evaluation will be useful for policy makers across Africa looking to stop the spread of HIV by focusing on high-risk populations. The HIV/AIDS crisis has extraordinarily high social and economic costs. Prevention—which is far cheaper than treatment—is a priority, especially in Africa.  Financial incentives for high-risk populations, along with other innovative and effective prevention approaches, are therefore of critical interest to health care practitioners and policy makers alike.

Researchers:

  • Marianna Balampama, Ifakara Health Institute
  • Jan Cooper, University of California Berkeley
  • William H. Dow, University of California, Berkeley
  • Dr. Admirabilis Kalolella, Ifakara Health Institute
  • Laura Packel, University of California San Francisco
  • Damien de Walque, World Bank