Learn how the World Bank Group is helping countries with COVID-19 (coronavirus). Find Out

Skip to Main Navigation
Results Briefs June 11, 2019

Opening Up Markets and Opportunities for Ethnic Minorities in Vietnam’s Poorest Provinces

Image

Ms. Dua heads an enthusiastic group of Hmong women who produce traditional handicrafts and jointly manage a shop. Their income has doubled since the project commenced.


Vietnam’s poverty rate has reduced from almost 21 percent in 2010 when the Project started to less than 10% by end of 2016. The poor are heavily concentrated among ethnic minorities who live in the country’s remote mountainous regions. With support from the International Development Association, six mountainous provinces in Vietnam’s poorest region took a community-driven development approach to empower people—especially women—to expand their livelihood opportunities and gain access to markets.

Challenge

Ethnic minorities living in remote areas of the project provinces of Lai Chau, Dien Bien, Son La, Lao Cai, Hoa Binh and Yen Bai have very limited opportunities to increase their living standards due to low agricultural productivity; lack of productive infrastructure such as irrigation and roads; are vulnerable to natural disasters and climate change; and lack of access to healthcare, education and markets.

Approach

A core project activity was to organize small and marginal producers into Common Interest Groups (CIGs) around livelihood activities such as agriculture, livestock, forestry, fisheries and handicrafts to increase their share in key value chains. The project also built partnerships with government agencies, banks, agricultural extension systems, and other input service providers to enable CIGs to increase their access to finance, technical expertise, inputs, and services to boost productivity and increase production. also It further helped to establish market linkages with public, private, and cooperative enterprises to enhance the participation of poor people in value chains. The Project took a community-driven development approach, which ensured that any specific activity started and ended with the recipients themselves. Women gained a greater voice through strong representation in the Commune Development Boards and participating in the project activities designed for women groups.  Ethnic minority languages were used in village meetings, trainings, and communication materials leading to more inclusive project planning and implementation.

Results

After eight years of implementation (2010-2018), key project results include:

  • 11,178 CIGs  were established, owning a total investment of $29 million generating US$42 million worth of products and assets, and more than US$24 million worth of products were sold.
  • 75% of CIGs  have a sustained increase in their livelihood production assets.
  • 130 CIGs have achieved formal status as collaborative groups and Cooperatives, ensuring their sustainability.
  • 88% of CIGs make marketing decisions using market information from at least two different sources of information.
  • The infrastructures developed under the project is easing commute to the production sites, linking with market, increasing irrigated areas leading to improved yields, and improved access to water supply.
  • 3,844 km of rural roads were built, 826 bridges were built. 76% of farmers have benefited from new roads that have reduced their travel time to farm production areas.
  • 16,000 hectares of paddy field were irrigated by 1,335 irrigation schemes; 59,367 households were connected to 1,007 water supply schemes,
  • Almost 62% of households have easier access to markets and suppliers of farm inputs such as seed and fertilizer.
  • The Socio-Economic Development Planning (SEDP) tool for integrating communes’ needs and resources was institutionalized in all Project provinces.
  • 88% of women and ethnic minorities regularly participate in the village planning and decision-making processes – up from a baseline of 0.
  • 107 Productive Partnership were established with the involvement of 22,000 benefited households and 64 partners (enterprises, cooperatives, etc.)

 

Bank Group Contribution

A total of US$250 million in credits from the International Development Association helped to finance the project. The funds were invested in productive and economic infrastructure for regional linkages, block-grants to communes to finance small-scale sub-projects at the village level for productive infrastructure and livelihood improvement activities. These small projects were identified through participatory planning processes, improved capacity of project implementation and communities to participate in planning, and project management, monitoring and evaluation.

Partners

The Food and Agricultural Organization (FAO) provided technical assistance to the government in reviewing key project interventions and recommending ways to improve project implementation in such areas as production partnerships, infrastructure and regional linkages, and economic analysis of project investments. The Agriculture Businesses (private sector) has been instrumental in the production partnerships with the farmers in the Project.

Moving Forward

The experience and lessons from the project have contributed to changing the government of Vietnam’s policies and approach to the poverty reduction. Many of the good practices and approaches have already been applied in the Government of Vietnam’s programs, including the Socio-Economic Development Planning (SEDP) at the commune level, simplified community procurement, and CIG based livelihoods support, amongst other. National programs like New Rural Areas Development and Programme 135 took on the livelihood approach, participatory planning, and community procurement


Image
88%

of women and ethnic minorities regularly participate in the village planning and decision-making processes – up from a baseline of 0.


Beneficiaries

Realizing the handicrafts’ market potential with tourists, with support from the Second Northern Mountains Poverty Reduction Project, Ms. Dua gathered the community women and formed a CIG. Now Ms. Dua heads an enthusiastic group of 11 Hmong women who produce their traditional handicrafts and jointly manage a shop. The group members meet regularly, discuss their weaving and embroidery business and also talk about other aspects of their lives. The women’s group keeps meticulous records and has its own bank account. Profit is shared according to production. At the start of the Project, each woman made on average 650,000 VND (US$32) per month as additional income from the sale of hand-made embroidery and hemp items. Now they are making double that amount.