col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-12
col-lg-12
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-12
col-lg-12
videoType
dynamic-media
videoDmUrl
https://delivery-p136806-e1377785.adobeaemcloud.com/adobe/assets/urn:aaid:aem:a243b55a-fae3-4f7e-8e04-96cd1203b2f9/play?assetname=B-READY_SpringMeetings_DataPlayground.mp4
keyFrameImage
timestamp

00:00 We are here today to talk about something that matters to all of us,

00:04 jobs.

00:05 Let's start with a question.

00:09 Who do you think creates most of the jobs in the world?

00:14 Anyone?

00:16 What's your name?

00:17 I'm Destabasta.

00:19 What do you think?

00:20 I think it should be large companies like maybe Tata Group.

00:23 They must employ millions of people.

00:25 OK.

00:26 Debas Mta here said it must be large companies like the Tata Group which

00:31 employs more than a million people.

00:33 So her answer is large companies.

00:35 That's a sensible guess.

00:37 Anyone else who wants to try?

00:39 Yes.

00:39 What's your name,

00:40 sir?

00:40 Taylor

00:40 Taylor.

00:41 I think it's collectively SMEs that create the most.

00:45 SMEs,

00:45 of course,

00:46 they are the backbone of the economy in most countries.

00:51 What's more,

00:51 both of your answers have something in common.

00:55 All those companies that you talked about,

00:58 whether it is small,

00:59 medium,

01:00 or large in size,

01:01 whether it's privately held or public listed,

01:05 they are all part of what we call the private sector.

01:08 Consistently,

01:09 data shows that it is a private sector

01:12 that creates most of the jobs in the world.

01:17 So here's the next one.

01:19 Since the private sector creates most of the jobs,

01:22 what percentage of jobs do you think

01:25 are in the private sector?

01:27 Is it 60%,

01:29 75%,

01:31 90%?

01:32 Who wants to make a guess?

01:33 Yes,

01:33 please.

01:33 What's your name?

01:34 75%.

01:35 Sorry,

01:35 I'm Thomas.

01:37 Thomas,

01:37 75%,

01:39 3 quarters.

01:40 Anyone else?

01:41 Yes.

01:43 90 90%,

01:46 exactly 90% of the jobs are in the private sector.

01:51 That means if we care about jobs,

01:53 we really have to care about the private sector.

01:57 But here's the thing,

01:58 for the private sector to grow,

02:00 it has to have a fertile business environment.

02:04 What does that mean?

02:05 It means that we have to have

02:09 High quality rules for the private sector.

02:13 We have to have strong public services

02:16 and we have to have operational efficiency to combine and

02:20 deliver the rules and public services efficiently in practice.

02:25 All these conditions together fertilize

02:28 the private sector's business environment,

02:31 helping it to grow,

02:32 innovate and create more jobs.

02:35 So

02:36 are we ready

02:37 to deliver these conditions to the private sector?

02:42 According to the first ever business ready report,

02:45 which is the World Bank Group flagship report,

02:48 most countries,

02:49 especially the developing ones,

02:51 are not yet fully business ready.

02:54 To be specific,

02:56 of all the countries that were covered in the first business ready report,

03:00 they are only 60% on average ready to support the private sector.

03:05 That means a lot of the good rules,

03:08 public services and operational efficiency that we just talked about

03:12 are not yet there in many places.

03:15 So the question becomes,

03:16 my friends,

03:17 how do we close that gap?

03:22 And that's where business ready,

03:24 be ready in short comes in.

03:26 Be ready is a compass,

03:28 a compass that

03:29 helps measure what is working and what is not,

03:32 how to support businesses and in turn create good jobs.

03:37 Be Ready covers 10 essential topics

03:39 from business entry

03:41 to utility services,

03:42 market competition,

03:44 labor,

03:44 taxation.

03:45 These are the nuts and bolts of the environment,

03:48 the business environment.

03:50 This is what impacts everyday

03:52 existing firms,

03:54 potential firms,

03:55 workers,

03:56 consumers,

03:57 the ecosystem overall.

03:59 And

04:00 to measure this,

04:01 we collect nearly 1200 indicators

04:05 from about 2000 data points.

04:08 This is a really extensive assessment.

04:10 It's meant to help countries understand what

04:12 is working and what effectively is not.

04:16 This is the most comprehensive picture we've ever had

04:19 of

04:20 Moscow we've ever had of

04:23 how to build a business environment that supports jobs.

04:28 Let's see indicators in practice.

04:30 Let's see how this all works with the specific indicators

04:34 that we have.

04:36 Let's start at the very beginning.

04:38 A very good place to start.

04:40 If Julie Andrews wanted to register a business,

04:42 how long could it take?

04:45 How long does it take to register a business

04:48 in the country that it takes the most?

04:50 Any guesses?

04:52 Yes,

04:53 who are you?

04:54 What's your name?

04:55 Zelda,

04:56 Zelda,

04:56 where are you from?

04:57 Ah,

04:58 Meravahiel.

04:59 So what is your guess?

05:00 How many days can it take to register a firm?

05:02 Maybe 30,

05:03 30 days.

05:04 Many other guesses

05:06 here we have.

05:07 OK,

05:08 hello.

05:09 Who are you?

05:09 Are you from

05:10 Margarita from Italy.

05:12 Margarita.

05:13 Hi,

05:13 what's your guess?

05:14 I would say maybe about 2 months,

05:17 2 months,

05:17 60 days.

05:18 In fact,

05:19 it takes a bit longer than that.

05:21 It takes 80 days to register a domestic firm

05:24 and even longer to register a foreign firm,

05:26 106 days,

05:28 almost 4 months.

05:29 If we were to start the process now,

05:32 we may be done by August.

05:34 So

05:35 a smooth registration process for domestic firms,

05:37 comparable entry conditions for foreign firms,

05:40 promote entrepreneurship.

05:41 There's much room to improve here.

05:44 Now,

05:45 we registered our business,

05:47 we made our plans.

05:50 And the power is out.

05:52 No,

05:52 no need to look at your

05:53 phones,

05:54 guys.

05:54 No power,

05:55 no battery.

05:57 In the country that it takes

05:59 where we have most outages,

06:01 how many outages does a business experience in a typical month?

06:05 Yes,

06:06 I'm here.

06:08 Tiffany from China.

06:09 Hi Tiffany from China.

06:10 How many guesses?

06:11 How many altitudes?

06:12 55.

06:13 Any other guesses?

06:15 OK,

06:15 here

06:16 1010.

06:17 Well,

06:18 a bit more than that,

06:19 more like up to 22 per month,

06:22 almost 1 per day.

06:24 This is really disruptive.

06:26 Reliable electricity services promote

06:29 promote predictable production processes and boost the firms' productivity.

06:34 So imagine all these cuts,

06:35 they are really disruptive.

06:36 They prevent firms from growing.

06:38 They prevent firms from hiring.

06:40 It's a huge challenge that we must overcome.

06:42 And going now from from energy from electricity

06:46 to the businesses most important

06:48 resources,

06:49 workers,

06:50 or in fact

06:51 prospective workers,

06:52 national employment service centers provide career

06:55 guidance and also connect job seekers

06:58 with employers,

07:00 so we would expect to see them all over,

07:01 right?

07:03 But in fact.

07:05 1

07:06 in 5 countries don't have national employment service centers

07:10 and nearly 25%,

07:11 1 in 4,

07:12 don't offer public training programs.

07:15 This is a challenge.

07:17 Young people face a system that does not prepare them and

07:20 that does not connect them with the jobs of tomorrow,

07:23 a challenge that we must overcome.

07:26 Now,

07:27 going from young businesses

07:30 going from young people to young businesses,

07:32 incubators and accelerators,

07:34 incubators and accelerators,

07:36 they promote job creation by supporting young startups

07:39 or even established startups.

07:41 We expect to see them all over,

07:42 right?

07:46 Any,

07:46 any guesses?

07:51 10%,

07:52 a little bit more than that,

07:54 60%.

07:55 Well,

07:56 maybe not that much,

07:57 but still.

08:01 But still over 20%,

08:03 22% to be precise,

08:06 so.

08:08 When

08:08 we don't promote

08:10 job creation,

08:11 when we don't have accelerators,

08:12 when we don't have incubators,

08:14 we are

08:15 creating,

08:15 we are restricting the possibility for these young firms to grow,

08:18 and then jobs don't follow.

08:21 So

08:21 if all of this,

08:22 all of these numbers,

08:23 all of these figures that we have been

08:24 pointing out here sound somewhat familiar to you,

08:27 it's also because they are,

08:29 because they have been

08:30 coming here in our in our be ready spot on the data wall,

08:33 so they should not be so foreign to you.

08:36 Now

08:37 it's true

08:38 that,

08:38 as we would expect,

08:39 that richer economies,

08:41 richer countries.

08:45 Richer countries tend to be more business ready

08:48 and perhaps that's that's also why they are richer,

08:51 right?

08:52 We have Estonia and

08:53 Singapore here as good examples.

08:56 But this is not the full story.

08:59 We have seen

09:00 that

09:01 with targeted

09:02 policies,

09:03 well thought policies and reforms,

09:05 any country,

09:07 anywhere,

09:08 at any income level can create a business environment that promotes jobs,

09:13 that supports jobs.

09:15 Good examples here are Colombia,

09:18 Georgia.

09:20 Rwanda

09:21 and Vietnam.

09:23 Now

09:24 let's all continue to push for the jobs agenda,

09:26 and we can't do so

09:28 without listening to the businesses.

09:30 Exactly.

09:32 When we talk about being business ready.

09:34 We have to listen to the managers and business owners.

09:37 This is where the World Bank Enterprise Surveys comes in handy.

09:41 The,

09:41 the Enterprise surveys data is a firm level data.

09:44 That tells us exactly what businesses experience directly

09:47 from the top manager and business owners.

09:50 Just in just over the last 3 years,

09:52 we have interviewed close to 70,000 businesses

09:55 in more than 100 economies.

09:59 Now,

09:59 let's play some guessing game.

10:01 Um,

10:02 alright.

10:04 Can we have your name and where you're from?

10:07 Uh,

10:08 I'm Sarah.

10:09 I'm from Morocco.

10:10 All right,

10:11 Sarah from Morocco.

10:15 There we go.

10:16 Sarah from Morocco,

10:18 which do you think might be the top obstacle facing businesses in Morocco?

10:26 I'd say firms would not like to pay taxes,

10:29 maybe tax rates.

10:30 Tax rate,

10:31 very,

10:31 very,

10:31 very,

10:32 very

10:32 well educated guess.

10:34 But in fact,

10:35 tax rate is not even in the top three obstacle for Morocco.

10:39 The top obstacle facing businesses in Morocco is actually

10:44 informal competitors.

10:46 Ah.

10:47 Now,

10:47 let's do another person.

10:48 Um,

10:49 let's pick you.

10:53 Uh

10:54 Hi,

10:54 I'm Daniela from El Salvador.

10:57 Alright.

10:58 Daniela from El Salvador.

11:01 Which do you think might be the top obstacle facing businesses in El Salvador?

11:06 Uh,

11:06 that's a very good question.

11:09 I think it would be uh less

11:12 education available for workers,

11:13 perhaps.

11:14 Alright,

11:15 labor skills.

11:16 Very,

11:16 very good guess.

11:17 It is actually 3.

11:19 Alright.

11:20 But the most cited top obstacle in El Salvador is actually.

11:25 Access to finance.

11:27 Alright.

11:28 Now,

11:28 as we just see,

11:30 obstacles facing

11:32 Obstacles to doing business

11:34 very much differ from economy to economy.

11:37 But when we look across all economies,

11:41 Some obstacles consistently rise to the top.

11:44 There we go.

11:45 Consistently rise to the top.

11:47 According to data from recent enterprise surveys,

11:50 access to finance is the most cited top obstacle to businesses.

11:54 This is cited by almost 14% of all businesses interviewed over the last 3 years.

12:00 And the next 5 most cited top obstacles

12:02 are displayed here on the screen,

12:04 and that includes tax rates

12:05 and also labor skills,

12:07 which is also covered by B rating.

12:10 Now that we have seen the data,

12:12 we have heard from businesses,

12:14 and countries like Rwanda and Colombia have shown us what is possible.

12:18 Let us all make full use of this data

12:21 to create a business environment.

12:23 One business environment that minimizes obstacles.

12:27 So that business can focus on innovating,

12:29 growing,

12:30 and hiring workers.

12:32 And with that,

12:33 let's guide off this playground,

12:35 alright?

12:36 And join us in Be Ready and Enterprise surveys.

12:39 And let's improve business environment.

12:42 Let's create jobs.

12:44 And it's off to the races now.

12:46 Are we all ready.

showAllTimestamps
no
transcript
We are here today to talk about something that matters to all of us, jobs. Let's start with a question. Who do you think creates most of the jobs in the world? Anyone? What's your name? I'm Destabasta. What do you think? I think it should be large companies like maybe Tata Group. They must employ millions of people. OK. Debas Mta here said it must be large companies like the Tata Group which employs more than a million people. So her answer is large companies. That's a sensible guess. Anyone else who wants to try? Yes. What's your name, sir? Taylor Taylor. I think it's collectively SMEs that create the most. SMEs, of course, they are the backbone of the economy in most countries. What's more, both of your answers have something in common. All those companies that you talked about, whether it is small, medium, or large in size, whether it's privately held or public listed, they are all part of what we call the private sector. Consistently, data shows that it is a private sector that creates most of the jobs in the world. So here's the next one. Since the private sector creates most of the jobs, what percentage of jobs do you think are in the private sector? Is it 60%, 75%, 90%? Who wants to make a guess? Yes, please. What's your name? 75%. Sorry, I'm Thomas. Thomas, 75%, 3 quarters. Anyone else? Yes. 90 90%, exactly 90% of the jobs are in the private sector. That means if we care about jobs, we really have to care about the private sector. But here's the thing, for the private sector to grow, it has to have a fertile business environment. What does that mean? It means that we have to have High quality rules for the private sector. We have to have strong public services and we have to have operational efficiency to combine and deliver the rules and public services efficiently in practice. All these conditions together fertilize the private sector's business environment, helping it to grow, innovate and create more jobs. So are we ready to deliver these conditions to the private sector? According to the first ever business ready report, which is the World Bank Group flagship report, most countries, especially the developing ones, are not yet fully business ready. To be specific, of all the countries that were covered in the first business ready report, they are only 60% on average ready to support the private sector. That means a lot of the good rules, public services and operational efficiency that we just talked about are not yet there in many places. So the question becomes, my friends, how do we close that gap? And that's where business ready, be ready in short comes in. Be ready is a compass, a compass that helps measure what is working and what is not, how to support businesses and in turn create good jobs. Be Ready covers 10 essential topics from business entry to utility services, market competition, labor, taxation. These are the nuts and bolts of the environment, the business environment. This is what impacts everyday existing firms, potential firms, workers, consumers, the ecosystem overall. And to measure this, we collect nearly 1200 indicators from about 2000 data points. This is a really extensive assessment. It's meant to help countries understand what is working and what effectively is not. This is the most comprehensive picture we've ever had of Moscow we've ever had of how to build a business environment that supports jobs. Let's see indicators in practice. Let's see how this all works with the specific indicators that we have. Let's start at the very beginning. A very good place to start. If Julie Andrews wanted to register a business, how long could it take? How long does it take to register a business in the country that it takes the most? Any guesses? Yes, who are you? What's your name? Zelda, Zelda, where are you from? Ah, Meravahiel. So what is your guess? How many days can it take to register a firm? Maybe 30, 30 days. Many other guesses here we have. OK, hello. Who are you? Are you from Margarita from Italy. Margarita. Hi, what's your guess? I would say maybe about 2 months, 2 months, 60 days. In fact, it takes a bit longer than that. It takes 80 days to register a domestic firm and even longer to register a foreign firm, 106 days, almost 4 months. If we were to start the process now, we may be done by August. So a smooth registration process for domestic firms, comparable entry conditions for foreign firms, promote entrepreneurship. There's much room to improve here. Now, we registered our business, we made our plans. And the power is out. No, no need to look at your phones, guys. No power, no battery. In the country that it takes where we have most outages, how many outages does a business experience in a typical month? Yes, I'm here. Tiffany from China. Hi Tiffany from China. How many guesses? How many altitudes? 55. Any other guesses? OK, here 1010. Well, a bit more than that, more like up to 22 per month, almost 1 per day. This is really disruptive. Reliable electricity services promote promote predictable production processes and boost the firms' productivity. So imagine all these cuts, they are really disruptive. They prevent firms from growing. They prevent firms from hiring. It's a huge challenge that we must overcome. And going now from from energy from electricity to the businesses most important resources, workers, or in fact prospective workers, national employment service centers provide career guidance and also connect job seekers with employers, so we would expect to see them all over, right? But in fact. 1 in 5 countries don't have national employment service centers and nearly 25%, 1 in 4, don't offer public training programs. This is a challenge. Young people face a system that does not prepare them and that does not connect them with the jobs of tomorrow, a challenge that we must overcome. Now, going from young businesses going from young people to young businesses, incubators and accelerators, incubators and accelerators, they promote job creation by supporting young startups or even established startups. We expect to see them all over, right? Any, any guesses? 10%, a little bit more than that, 60%. Well, maybe not that much, but still. But still over 20%, 22% to be precise, so. When we don't promote job creation, when we don't have accelerators, when we don't have incubators, we are creating, we are restricting the possibility for these young firms to grow, and then jobs don't follow. So if all of this, all of these numbers, all of these figures that we have been pointing out here sound somewhat familiar to you, it's also because they are, because they have been coming here in our in our be ready spot on the data wall, so they should not be so foreign to you. Now it's true that, as we would expect, that richer economies, richer countries. Richer countries tend to be more business ready and perhaps that's that's also why they are richer, right? We have Estonia and Singapore here as good examples. But this is not the full story. We have seen that with targeted policies, well thought policies and reforms, any country, anywhere, at any income level can create a business environment that promotes jobs, that supports jobs. Good examples here are Colombia, Georgia. Rwanda and Vietnam. Now let's all continue to push for the jobs agenda, and we can't do so without listening to the businesses. Exactly. When we talk about being business ready. We have to listen to the managers and business owners. This is where the World Bank Enterprise Surveys comes in handy. The, the Enterprise surveys data is a firm level data. That tells us exactly what businesses experience directly from the top manager and business owners. Just in just over the last 3 years, we have interviewed close to 70,000 businesses in more than 100 economies. Now, let's play some guessing game. Um, alright. Can we have your name and where you're from? Uh, I'm Sarah. I'm from Morocco. All right, Sarah from Morocco. There we go. Sarah from Morocco, which do you think might be the top obstacle facing businesses in Morocco? I'd say firms would not like to pay taxes, maybe tax rates. Tax rate, very, very, very, very well educated guess. But in fact, tax rate is not even in the top three obstacle for Morocco. The top obstacle facing businesses in Morocco is actually informal competitors. Ah. Now, let's do another person. Um, let's pick you. Uh Hi, I'm Daniela from El Salvador. Alright. Daniela from El Salvador. Which do you think might be the top obstacle facing businesses in El Salvador? Uh, that's a very good question. I think it would be uh less education available for workers, perhaps. Alright, labor skills. Very, very good guess. It is actually 3. Alright. But the most cited top obstacle in El Salvador is actually. Access to finance. Alright. Now, as we just see, obstacles facing Obstacles to doing business very much differ from economy to economy. But when we look across all economies, Some obstacles consistently rise to the top. There we go. Consistently rise to the top. According to data from recent enterprise surveys, access to finance is the most cited top obstacle to businesses. This is cited by almost 14% of all businesses interviewed over the last 3 years. And the next 5 most cited top obstacles are displayed here on the screen, and that includes tax rates and also labor skills, which is also covered by B rating. Now that we have seen the data, we have heard from businesses, and countries like Rwanda and Colombia have shown us what is possible. Let us all make full use of this data to create a business environment. One business environment that minimizes obstacles. So that business can focus on innovating, growing, and hiring workers. And with that, let's guide off this playground, alright? And join us in Be Ready and Enterprise surveys. And let's improve business environment. Let's create jobs. And it's off to the races now. Are we all ready.
showAllTranscripts
no
duration
PT13M
scene7File
worldbank/B-READY_SpringMeetings_DataPlayground
scene7Domain
https://worldbank.scene7.com/
scene7FileAvs
worldbank/B-READY_SpringMeetings_DataPlayground-AVS
title
B READY SpringMeetings DataPlayground
description
B READY SpringMeetings DataPlayground
showTimestampAndTranscript
yes
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-3
col-lg-3
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-7
col-lg-7
  • add-style
  • lp-body-content

How can a conducive business environment support jobs in the private sector worldwide? Get facts and figures from a lively talk from experts of the World Bank Business Ready project.

This presentation was delivered at the Data Playground of the World Bank/IMF Spring Meetings 2025 in Washington DC.

lp-heading-top-medium
lp-heading-bottom-medium
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-2
col-lg-2