00:00 We are here today to talk about something that matters to all of us,
00:04 jobs.
00:05 Let's start with a question.
00:09 Who do you think creates most of the jobs in the world?
00:14 Anyone?
00:16 What's your name?
00:17 I'm Destabasta.
00:19 What do you think?
00:20 I think it should be large companies like maybe Tata Group.
00:23 They must employ millions of people.
00:25 OK.
00:26 Debas Mta here said it must be large companies like the Tata Group which
00:31 employs more than a million people.
00:33 So her answer is large companies.
00:35 That's a sensible guess.
00:37 Anyone else who wants to try?
00:39 Yes.
00:39 What's your name,
00:40 sir?
00:40 Taylor
00:40 Taylor.
00:41 I think it's collectively SMEs that create the most.
00:45 SMEs,
00:45 of course,
00:46 they are the backbone of the economy in most countries.
00:51 What's more,
00:51 both of your answers have something in common.
00:55 All those companies that you talked about,
00:58 whether it is small,
00:59 medium,
01:00 or large in size,
01:01 whether it's privately held or public listed,
01:05 they are all part of what we call the private sector.
01:08 Consistently,
01:09 data shows that it is a private sector
01:12 that creates most of the jobs in the world.
01:17 So here's the next one.
01:19 Since the private sector creates most of the jobs,
01:22 what percentage of jobs do you think
01:25 are in the private sector?
01:27 Is it 60%,
01:29 75%,
01:31 90%?
01:32 Who wants to make a guess?
01:33 Yes,
01:33 please.
01:33 What's your name?
01:34 75%.
01:35 Sorry,
01:35 I'm Thomas.
01:37 Thomas,
01:37 75%,
01:39 3 quarters.
01:40 Anyone else?
01:41 Yes.
01:43 90 90%,
01:46 exactly 90% of the jobs are in the private sector.
01:51 That means if we care about jobs,
01:53 we really have to care about the private sector.
01:57 But here's the thing,
01:58 for the private sector to grow,
02:00 it has to have a fertile business environment.
02:04 What does that mean?
02:05 It means that we have to have
02:09 High quality rules for the private sector.
02:13 We have to have strong public services
02:16 and we have to have operational efficiency to combine and
02:20 deliver the rules and public services efficiently in practice.
02:25 All these conditions together fertilize
02:28 the private sector's business environment,
02:31 helping it to grow,
02:32 innovate and create more jobs.
02:35 So
02:36 are we ready
02:37 to deliver these conditions to the private sector?
02:42 According to the first ever business ready report,
02:45 which is the World Bank Group flagship report,
02:48 most countries,
02:49 especially the developing ones,
02:51 are not yet fully business ready.
02:54 To be specific,
02:56 of all the countries that were covered in the first business ready report,
03:00 they are only 60% on average ready to support the private sector.
03:05 That means a lot of the good rules,
03:08 public services and operational efficiency that we just talked about
03:12 are not yet there in many places.
03:15 So the question becomes,
03:16 my friends,
03:17 how do we close that gap?
03:22 And that's where business ready,
03:24 be ready in short comes in.
03:26 Be ready is a compass,
03:28 a compass that
03:29 helps measure what is working and what is not,
03:32 how to support businesses and in turn create good jobs.
03:37 Be Ready covers 10 essential topics
03:39 from business entry
03:41 to utility services,
03:42 market competition,
03:44 labor,
03:44 taxation.
03:45 These are the nuts and bolts of the environment,
03:48 the business environment.
03:50 This is what impacts everyday
03:52 existing firms,
03:54 potential firms,
03:55 workers,
03:56 consumers,
03:57 the ecosystem overall.
03:59 And
04:00 to measure this,
04:01 we collect nearly 1200 indicators
04:05 from about 2000 data points.
04:08 This is a really extensive assessment.
04:10 It's meant to help countries understand what
04:12 is working and what effectively is not.
04:16 This is the most comprehensive picture we've ever had
04:19 of
04:20 Moscow we've ever had of
04:23 how to build a business environment that supports jobs.
04:28 Let's see indicators in practice.
04:30 Let's see how this all works with the specific indicators
04:34 that we have.
04:36 Let's start at the very beginning.
04:38 A very good place to start.
04:40 If Julie Andrews wanted to register a business,
04:42 how long could it take?
04:45 How long does it take to register a business
04:48 in the country that it takes the most?
04:50 Any guesses?
04:52 Yes,
04:53 who are you?
04:54 What's your name?
04:55 Zelda,
04:56 Zelda,
04:56 where are you from?
04:57 Ah,
04:58 Meravahiel.
04:59 So what is your guess?
05:00 How many days can it take to register a firm?
05:02 Maybe 30,
05:03 30 days.
05:04 Many other guesses
05:06 here we have.
05:07 OK,
05:08 hello.
05:09 Who are you?
05:09 Are you from
05:10 Margarita from Italy.
05:12 Margarita.
05:13 Hi,
05:13 what's your guess?
05:14 I would say maybe about 2 months,
05:17 2 months,
05:17 60 days.
05:18 In fact,
05:19 it takes a bit longer than that.
05:21 It takes 80 days to register a domestic firm
05:24 and even longer to register a foreign firm,
05:26 106 days,
05:28 almost 4 months.
05:29 If we were to start the process now,
05:32 we may be done by August.
05:34 So
05:35 a smooth registration process for domestic firms,
05:37 comparable entry conditions for foreign firms,
05:40 promote entrepreneurship.
05:41 There's much room to improve here.
05:44 Now,
05:45 we registered our business,
05:47 we made our plans.
05:50 And the power is out.
05:52 No,
05:52 no need to look at your
05:53 phones,
05:54 guys.
05:54 No power,
05:55 no battery.
05:57 In the country that it takes
05:59 where we have most outages,
06:01 how many outages does a business experience in a typical month?
06:05 Yes,
06:06 I'm here.
06:08 Tiffany from China.
06:09 Hi Tiffany from China.
06:10 How many guesses?
06:11 How many altitudes?
06:12 55.
06:13 Any other guesses?
06:15 OK,
06:15 here
06:16 1010.
06:17 Well,
06:18 a bit more than that,
06:19 more like up to 22 per month,
06:22 almost 1 per day.
06:24 This is really disruptive.
06:26 Reliable electricity services promote
06:29 promote predictable production processes and boost the firms' productivity.
06:34 So imagine all these cuts,
06:35 they are really disruptive.
06:36 They prevent firms from growing.
06:38 They prevent firms from hiring.
06:40 It's a huge challenge that we must overcome.
06:42 And going now from from energy from electricity
06:46 to the businesses most important
06:48 resources,
06:49 workers,
06:50 or in fact
06:51 prospective workers,
06:52 national employment service centers provide career
06:55 guidance and also connect job seekers
06:58 with employers,
07:00 so we would expect to see them all over,
07:01 right?
07:03 But in fact.
07:05 1
07:06 in 5 countries don't have national employment service centers
07:10 and nearly 25%,
07:11 1 in 4,
07:12 don't offer public training programs.
07:15 This is a challenge.
07:17 Young people face a system that does not prepare them and
07:20 that does not connect them with the jobs of tomorrow,
07:23 a challenge that we must overcome.
07:26 Now,
07:27 going from young businesses
07:30 going from young people to young businesses,
07:32 incubators and accelerators,
07:34 incubators and accelerators,
07:36 they promote job creation by supporting young startups
07:39 or even established startups.
07:41 We expect to see them all over,
07:42 right?
07:46 Any,
07:46 any guesses?
07:51 10%,
07:52 a little bit more than that,
07:54 60%.
07:55 Well,
07:56 maybe not that much,
07:57 but still.
08:01 But still over 20%,
08:03 22% to be precise,
08:06 so.
08:08 When
08:08 we don't promote
08:10 job creation,
08:11 when we don't have accelerators,
08:12 when we don't have incubators,
08:14 we are
08:15 creating,
08:15 we are restricting the possibility for these young firms to grow,
08:18 and then jobs don't follow.
08:21 So
08:21 if all of this,
08:22 all of these numbers,
08:23 all of these figures that we have been
08:24 pointing out here sound somewhat familiar to you,
08:27 it's also because they are,
08:29 because they have been
08:30 coming here in our in our be ready spot on the data wall,
08:33 so they should not be so foreign to you.
08:36 Now
08:37 it's true
08:38 that,
08:38 as we would expect,
08:39 that richer economies,
08:41 richer countries.
08:45 Richer countries tend to be more business ready
08:48 and perhaps that's that's also why they are richer,
08:51 right?
08:52 We have Estonia and
08:53 Singapore here as good examples.
08:56 But this is not the full story.
08:59 We have seen
09:00 that
09:01 with targeted
09:02 policies,
09:03 well thought policies and reforms,
09:05 any country,
09:07 anywhere,
09:08 at any income level can create a business environment that promotes jobs,
09:13 that supports jobs.
09:15 Good examples here are Colombia,
09:18 Georgia.
09:20 Rwanda
09:21 and Vietnam.
09:23 Now
09:24 let's all continue to push for the jobs agenda,
09:26 and we can't do so
09:28 without listening to the businesses.
09:30 Exactly.
09:32 When we talk about being business ready.
09:34 We have to listen to the managers and business owners.
09:37 This is where the World Bank Enterprise Surveys comes in handy.
09:41 The,
09:41 the Enterprise surveys data is a firm level data.
09:44 That tells us exactly what businesses experience directly
09:47 from the top manager and business owners.
09:50 Just in just over the last 3 years,
09:52 we have interviewed close to 70,000 businesses
09:55 in more than 100 economies.
09:59 Now,
09:59 let's play some guessing game.
10:01 Um,
10:02 alright.
10:04 Can we have your name and where you're from?
10:07 Uh,
10:08 I'm Sarah.
10:09 I'm from Morocco.
10:10 All right,
10:11 Sarah from Morocco.
10:15 There we go.
10:16 Sarah from Morocco,
10:18 which do you think might be the top obstacle facing businesses in Morocco?
10:26 I'd say firms would not like to pay taxes,
10:29 maybe tax rates.
10:30 Tax rate,
10:31 very,
10:31 very,
10:31 very,
10:32 very
10:32 well educated guess.
10:34 But in fact,
10:35 tax rate is not even in the top three obstacle for Morocco.
10:39 The top obstacle facing businesses in Morocco is actually
10:44 informal competitors.
10:46 Ah.
10:47 Now,
10:47 let's do another person.
10:48 Um,
10:49 let's pick you.
10:53 Uh
10:54 Hi,
10:54 I'm Daniela from El Salvador.
10:57 Alright.
10:58 Daniela from El Salvador.
11:01 Which do you think might be the top obstacle facing businesses in El Salvador?
11:06 Uh,
11:06 that's a very good question.
11:09 I think it would be uh less
11:12 education available for workers,
11:13 perhaps.
11:14 Alright,
11:15 labor skills.
11:16 Very,
11:16 very good guess.
11:17 It is actually 3.
11:19 Alright.
11:20 But the most cited top obstacle in El Salvador is actually.
11:25 Access to finance.
11:27 Alright.
11:28 Now,
11:28 as we just see,
11:30 obstacles facing
11:32 Obstacles to doing business
11:34 very much differ from economy to economy.
11:37 But when we look across all economies,
11:41 Some obstacles consistently rise to the top.
11:44 There we go.
11:45 Consistently rise to the top.
11:47 According to data from recent enterprise surveys,
11:50 access to finance is the most cited top obstacle to businesses.
11:54 This is cited by almost 14% of all businesses interviewed over the last 3 years.
12:00 And the next 5 most cited top obstacles
12:02 are displayed here on the screen,
12:04 and that includes tax rates
12:05 and also labor skills,
12:07 which is also covered by B rating.
12:10 Now that we have seen the data,
12:12 we have heard from businesses,
12:14 and countries like Rwanda and Colombia have shown us what is possible.
12:18 Let us all make full use of this data
12:21 to create a business environment.
12:23 One business environment that minimizes obstacles.
12:27 So that business can focus on innovating,
12:29 growing,
12:30 and hiring workers.
12:32 And with that,
12:33 let's guide off this playground,
12:35 alright?
12:36 And join us in Be Ready and Enterprise surveys.
12:39 And let's improve business environment.
12:42 Let's create jobs.
12:44 And it's off to the races now.
12:46 Are we all ready.
- add-style
- lp-body-content
How can a conducive business environment support jobs in the private sector worldwide? Get facts and figures from a lively talk from experts of the World Bank Business Ready project.
This presentation was delivered at the Data Playground of the World Bank/IMF Spring Meetings 2025 in Washington DC.