col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-12
col-lg-12
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-12
col-lg-12
videoType
dynamic-media
videoDmUrl
https://delivery-p136806-e1377785.adobeaemcloud.com/adobe/assets/urn:aaid:aem:2f498c5c-f097-41d0-b377-f02ca7c72d26/play?assetname=How+Community+Forestry+Can+Strengthen+Sustainable+Landscape+Management+and+Land+Tenure+Security.mp4
keyFrameImage
videoDescription
A video recording of the "How Community Forestry Can Strengthen Sustainable Landscape Management and Land Tenure Security" session at the World Bank Land Conference 2024.
timestamp

00:00 It's already 11 minutes past 11,

00:03 so we suggest to start with the

00:06 next session

00:07 on

00:08 community forestry and land tenure security.

00:12 Um,

00:13 I'll give a brief introduction of myself.

00:15 My name is Willem von der Muur.

00:16 I'm a land tenure specialist,

00:18 um,

00:18 with the World Bank,

00:20 currently based in Jakarta,

00:22 Indonesia,

00:22 where I've been for the last,

00:24 uh,

00:24 couple of years,

00:26 um,

00:26 and

00:27 I think the session that we will have today is going to be very interesting,

00:31 particularly given the overarching theme of our land conference,

00:34 which is

00:35 land and climate action.

00:37 So

00:38 at this land conference so far we have been speaking

00:41 a lot about the role of the community and also

00:44 centralizing

00:46 uh local communities and indigenous peoples

00:49 and I think

00:50 this is particularly important to protect

00:52 both

00:53 critical landscapes including forest

00:55 and also promoting uh livelihoods

00:58 and strengthening land tenure security.

01:01 And

01:02 for decades now,

01:03 community forestry

01:04 is a program or a policy that has been implemented in many countries

01:09 that basically sits at the heart

01:11 of these agendas.

01:13 So just very quickly,

01:14 there are basically 3

01:16 rationales of why community forestry

01:19 has been promoted

01:20 as such a program.

01:22 So first,

01:22 um,

01:23 community forests

01:25 help protect forest cover

01:26 or they help protect us,

01:28 expand forest cover,

01:29 and also support sustainable landscape management.

01:34 And the rationale here is that local communities are often better placed

01:38 to protect the forest and manage the forest they know very well

01:42 rather than centralized government agencies.

01:45 And the second is,

01:47 um,

01:48 through community forestry

01:50 and particularly sustainable forestry activities,

01:52 communities can boost their income and enhance their livelihoods.

01:56 And then third,

01:57 community forestry is also promoted

02:00 as a form of enhancing

02:01 access of tenure rights or

02:03 land rights,

02:05 either to land,

02:06 forest,

02:07 or natural resources

02:09 within these forested landscapes.

02:12 And

02:12 this is on paper how community forest has been often

02:16 uh described and rationalized,

02:18 but often in practice

02:20 things are more complicated,

02:21 as many of you of course know.

02:23 um.

02:24 It has been promoted and implemented in many countries in the world,

02:28 but research shows that these three rationales

02:31 or these 3 objectives of community forestry

02:34 in practice,

02:35 they don't always go together.

02:36 There are sometimes trade-offs.

02:38 So while in many countries,

02:39 community forestry has worked

02:41 to expand forest cover

02:43 or to protect forest cover,

02:45 particularly the issue of tenure rights has sometimes been more challenging.

02:49 So there are in many cases trade-offs where.

02:52 Forest has been expanded as a part of or as a result of community forestry

02:57 and also communities' livelihoods have been

02:59 improved,

03:00 but then there were some restrictions with regard to tenure rights

03:04 or access so there tend to be trade offs in practice,

03:07 um.

03:09 So I think

03:10 with the forestry programs in place in many countries,

03:13 I think now is the time to really assess

03:15 what has worked well

03:16 and what can be done better and what is

03:18 going to be the future of community forestry programs.

03:21 So that's what we're going to talk about in this panel.

03:24 Um,

03:24 we will have um

03:26 very influential uh champions from governments

03:29 that will speak at the panel today

03:31 from some of the countries

03:32 that have some of the largest share of tropical forests remaining in the world,

03:36 um,

03:36 Indonesia and also Brazil.

03:39 Um,

03:39 and we will hear directly from their experiences

03:42 as practitioners and policymakers in the realm of community forestry,

03:46 and then we also have non-government speaker.

03:50 Unfortunately,

03:51 uh,

03:51 our speaker from the Democratic Republic of Congo couldn't make it,

03:55 uh,

03:55 to this panel.

03:56 uh,

03:56 Mr.

03:57 Agustin,

03:57 he unfortunately did not,

03:59 uh,

03:59 receive his visa in time.

04:01 um,

04:02 so we will have speakers today from Indonesia

04:05 and also from Brazil.

04:07 Um,

04:08 I will,

04:09 uh,

04:09 um,

04:10 introduce the speakers now,

04:11 which will each have a presentation of around 10 to 15 minutes,

04:15 followed by a panel discussion in which we will take,

04:18 uh,

04:18 some questions

04:20 from the audience.

04:21 So there won't be the online feature where you

04:23 can submit your questions we will do it directly

04:26 as to have a more livelier discussion,

04:28 um,

04:29 so the first,

04:30 uh,

04:30 speaker today for our panel is

04:32 Mr.

04:33 Andre

04:34 Aquino

04:35 who is currently the director of forest management

04:39 for the Ministry of Environment and Climate,

04:42 um,

04:42 in Brazil.

04:43 So Mr.

04:43 Andre is responsible for sustainable forest management in Brazil,

04:47 a very big task,

04:49 and he has only recently taken this position.

04:51 So he has been working with the World Bank

04:53 for over 20 years,

04:55 um,

04:55 and his last position within the World Bank was the

05:00 practice or program leader for sustainable development in Indonesia,

05:03 where he worked on forest management as well as on

05:06 mangrove protection.

05:08 So

05:08 without further ado,

05:09 I would like to give the floor to Mr.

05:11 Andre.

05:17 There's a lot of mischief on the move.

05:20 Thank you very much.

05:21 uh,

05:22 good morning ladies and gentlemen.

05:24 It's a great pleasure to be here,

05:26 to be back

05:27 to the World Bank,

05:28 and to meet so many of our colleagues

05:30 in particular to discuss this very engaging important

05:33 and complex issue

05:35 of

05:36 the interplay between

05:38 local communities,

05:39 indigenous people

05:41 and their forests.

05:42 Um,

05:43 I'm very glad to be here today speaking on

05:46 behalf of the government of Brazil where we are

05:48 making

05:49 significant efforts

05:51 to strengthen rights,

05:54 strengthen livelihoods of local communities,

05:57 and by so doing,

05:58 uh,

05:59 address

06:00 our biggest challenge now of,

06:01 of climate change,

06:02 right,

06:02 and biodiversity loss.

06:05 So

06:07 Very briefly,

06:08 our forests,

06:09 I mean,

06:10 it's,

06:10 uh,

06:11 it's,

06:12 it's,

06:12 you know,

06:12 Brazil is the 5th largest country in the world.

06:15 We have more or less 58% of our country still

06:18 covered in forest.

06:20 It's almost 500 million hectares.

06:23 It's a lot of land.

06:25 And most of it in the Amazon,

06:27 but not only just to be super clear about this,

06:30 right,

06:31 we have two tropical rainforests,

06:33 the Amazon,

06:34 which

06:36 you all know well,

06:38 and then the Atlantic rainforest,

06:39 which is basically where we have the largest

06:42 population concentration in Brazil like Rio Sao Paulo,

06:46 um.

06:47 And we have significant savannas,

06:49 the most biodiverse savannas in the world,

06:52 the Cerrado.

06:53 And dry land forest catching,

06:56 so

06:57 it's a country that has,

06:59 I mean,

06:59 it's Brazil is a forest country,

07:01 right?

07:01 I mean,

07:02 as,

07:02 as we know,

07:03 and it is

07:04 important for our economy,

07:05 but it's particularly important for

07:07 our people.

07:10 Um

07:11 This map here

07:13 shows uh

07:15 federal forests

07:17 under management by communities.

07:21 Except by indigenous people,

07:23 and I'll explain the difference here.

07:24 So um

07:25 we have 25 million hectares of forest that are

07:28 managed

07:29 by local communities.

07:32 And these include

07:34 sustainable use protected areas.

07:37 They include what we call sentimentos,

07:39 which are basically uh.

07:42 Settlement

07:43 where we did land reform.

07:45 Um,

07:46 and,

07:47 um.

07:49 Different types of protected areas,

07:50 so 25 million

07:52 on top of that we have 116 million hectares.

07:56 Under indigenous people's land.

07:58 So it's about

07:59 140 million hectares which we could say are managed

08:04 by communities.

08:05 And again,

08:06 um,

08:07 a great proportion of that.

08:09 In the Amazon

08:13 Now this graph here is a little bit

08:14 the evolution of community forestry management in Brazil.

08:17 It's not a very happy story,

08:18 to be honest.

08:19 uh,

08:21 community forestry management has been.

08:24 Touted as a,

08:27 a,

08:27 a significant an important tool,

08:29 right,

08:29 to bring these two

08:32 objectives together,

08:33 increase income,

08:34 improve welfare,

08:35 and at the same time conserve forest or increase forest cover.

08:40 In the 2000s,

08:41 it's a lot of that was discussed,

08:43 a lot of initiatives.

08:44 I mean there was the PPG7,

08:46 the pilot program of the G7 for rainforests in Brazil.

08:49 It was the first

08:50 big global pact

08:52 for uh the protection of rainforests.

08:55 Uh,

08:56 it was a trust fund managed by the World Bank actually,

08:58 and one of the pillars

09:00 was promoting community forestry

09:02 and a lot was done

09:03 in terms of strengthening capacity and just really testing out the model.

09:08 What it meant community forestry and at that moment,

09:11 to a large extent community forestry meant uh sustainable

09:15 harvesting of timber,

09:17 right?

09:17 So

09:18 there was a strong emphasis on

09:20 uh

09:21 basically

09:22 timber.

09:24 Um,

09:25 so from 2005,

09:27 uh,

09:28 we see

09:29 the area and the volume

09:31 of,

09:31 of wood harvested,

09:33 right,

09:33 so the green is the volume

09:35 and the area,

09:36 so we can see it has increased

09:39 the area under management and the volumes have increased,

09:42 but they are not huge,

09:43 200,000 cubic meters,

09:47 uh,

09:47 yearly,

09:48 which is basically when

09:49 it reached the peak.

09:52 Um,

09:53 so,

09:55 What,

09:56 what has happened,

09:57 right?

09:57 I mean,

09:57 uh,

09:58 why hasn't this,

10:00 uh,

10:00 taken off?

10:02 Much faster

10:04 since

10:05 it seems I mean we we we assume that it can generate

10:08 this double benefits of income and protection of force and so on.

10:16 So

10:17 just a little bit on our legalese,

10:19 not,

10:20 not to bore you a lot,

10:21 but,

10:21 uh,

10:22 legally

10:24 we had a program

10:26 to promote,

10:27 uh,

10:27 community forestry in which was,

10:29 uh,

10:30 adopted in 2009,

10:31 2009.

10:35 And

10:36 this program

10:38 annually,

10:39 the way it worked is that annually the government would.

10:43 Select areas.

10:46 Under which

10:47 I mean community forestry was already happening.

10:50 But there would be support,

10:52 there would be support for market access,

10:54 financial support,

10:55 and so on.

10:55 So

10:56 this went on for some time

10:57 and

10:58 the agency I work for,

11:00 uh,

11:00 the Brazilian Forest Service

11:02 was doing that along with the Protected Ares agency.

11:06 But in under the last government this program was canceled

11:09 as many other programs dealing with rights and so on,

11:12 you know what we went through,

11:13 um,

11:15 uh,

11:15 and uh there was also a change this the

11:17 Forest Service went to the Minister of Agriculture.

11:19 So now

11:20 under this new government,

11:22 I mean,

11:22 uh,

11:23 there is much more

11:24 emphasis on this issue and this program is being resumed.

11:29 Now

11:30 It's been resumed in different er

11:33 with with different settings and that's what I would like to tell you a little bit so.

11:37 But before that,

11:38 what?

11:40 Why has community forestry not

11:42 taken off as much as expected?

11:46 So,

11:47 first is,

11:48 I mean,

11:48 one issue that is the essence of this conference,

11:51 which is the issue of rights,

11:52 right?

11:52 So,

11:53 um,

11:54 still.

11:55 Communities face threats to their rights.

11:58 Um,

11:59 you've seen

12:00 issues of,

12:01 uh,

12:01 invasion of indigenous people's territories,

12:04 for instance,

12:05 uh,

12:06 by

12:07 illegal mining,

12:09 sometimes agriculture,

12:10 cattle ranching.

12:13 But there's the issue of communi local level

12:15 governance.

12:16 This is something that the panel just before talked a little bit about,

12:20 right?

12:20 So,

12:21 community capacity for collective decision.

12:25 Um,

12:26 It varies significantly,

12:28 right?

12:28 I mean we have today very strong communities.

12:31 I mean with very participatory,

12:33 transparent decision making processes,

12:36 traditional processes,

12:37 right?

12:37 and others that are still,

12:39 uh,

12:40 moving towards that.

12:41 that's something that takes time,

12:42 right?

12:42 It's something that I think anyone that works with this type of processes

12:46 know

12:46 it takes time.

12:47 It takes time and it takes consistency,

12:49 right?

12:49 The rules

12:51 need to be consistent so that the communities,

12:53 uh,

12:54 uh,

12:54 know what to expect.

12:56 Um

12:58 The issue of capacity on business.

13:00 So now moving from the right equa the,

13:01 the,

13:02 the,

13:02 the right side of the equation to the business side of the equation,

13:05 right?

13:05 Because at the end of the day,

13:06 it's about making money out of the force.

13:08 This

13:10 Has been,

13:11 it is,

13:11 is very challenging,

13:12 still is,

13:13 right?

13:13 So,

13:14 um,

13:15 I like to joke that

13:19 Community forestry management in the Amazon,

13:21 you're dealing with.

13:24 The most,

13:25 some of the most spectacular logistical challenges you can imagine,

13:29 right?

13:29 Imagine taking a log out of the,

13:31 the forest with those

13:32 big rivers and.

13:34 Basic roads

13:35 you're dealing with a very complicated business.

13:39 I mean,

13:39 timber is difficult business,

13:41 way more complicated than agriculture,

13:42 for instance.

13:43 You are dealing with the the reputation of the sector,

13:46 which is not good.

13:47 So even if you do it right in a proper manner,

13:50 it's hard to convince people that it's

13:52 been made in the right way,

13:54 so.

13:56 I,

13:57 I like to,

13:58 I,

13:58 I think,

13:58 and this is a little bit of my own analysis that one of

14:01 the difficulties with community forestry has exactly been the focus on timber.

14:05 It's a difficult business.

14:07 It's a very difficult business,

14:08 and,

14:08 uh,

14:09 even private companies struggle,

14:11 right?

14:11 So

14:12 it,

14:13 and then on top of that you have communities that have not,

14:17 I mean,

14:17 often really been integrated into markets,

14:20 right?

14:20 So they are not dealing with.

14:23 I mean the business acumen on a on a daily basis,

14:25 so

14:26 this issue of a business capacity is very important.

14:29 And then the financial returns.

14:32 Um,

14:32 there's been a lot of analysis on the financial

14:34 returns of sustainable timber harvesting at communal level.

14:39 And it's not

14:41 great,

14:41 it's not something that you would be running

14:44 to invest in,

14:45 so.

14:47 Then

14:48 this then also reduces really the uh the interest right of communities in,

14:52 in doing that.

14:53 Uh,

14:54 timber is complex,

14:55 market access barriers,

14:56 high upfront needs.

14:57 I mean,

14:57 you need machinery,

14:58 all of that.

14:59 Non-timber forest products,

15:01 great potential,

15:02 but they're seasonal,

15:03 uh,

15:03 and,

15:04 and each species is different in different markets.

15:08 And then the usual forest carbon.

15:10 Um,

15:10 this one,

15:11 I mean,

15:11 we just had a panel on this,

15:13 and

15:13 I mean.

15:15 I think that

15:16 if,

15:16 if,

15:17 if,

15:17 if there is someone who's not confused about the state of play in carbon markets,

15:22 please let me know because I think I mean if anything

15:25 it's gotten way more complicated,

15:27 right?

15:27 I mean

15:29 projects jurisdiction,

15:30 no

15:30 voluntary,

15:31 non-voluntary,

15:32 it's voluntary but maybe you need to be regulated it's it's very,

15:36 very confusing.

15:38 We have had an issue of partnerships,

15:40 unfair partnerships,

15:42 very big problem,

15:43 um,

15:43 in the timber sector

15:45 because one way of addressing some of these

15:47 barriers is that communities then sign contracts,

15:49 right,

15:50 with

15:50 companies that have the upfront finance or the machinery and so on,

15:54 and there have been deals that are unfair

15:57 and of course this is happening in carbon as well.

16:02 And access to finance,

16:03 I mean,

16:04 uh.

16:06 Having a loan.

16:08 From

16:09 even a subsidized loan from our commercial banks

16:13 for forestry business is a very hard job.

16:15 I mean,

16:16 our community last year

16:17 managed to do it

16:19 with a lot of support.

16:20 But it's difficult.

16:22 OK,

16:22 a lot of challenges.

16:23 Why are we still then trying to do this?

16:25 Um,

16:26 because there's a lot of opportunities,

16:28 right?

16:29 Well,

16:30 first is

16:31 community forest management may supply a lot of

16:34 timber to Brazil and reduce illegal timber.

16:36 We have estimated that one third of the,

16:38 uh,

16:39 the demand,

16:39 domestic

16:41 demand for timber that today is provided for

16:44 by the Amazon

16:45 could come from community forestry.

16:47 Just to be super clear,

16:48 colleagues,

16:49 timber in Brazil does not,

16:50 I mean,

16:51 most of timber from Brazil does not come from the.

16:53 Amazon,

16:54 it's planted forest.

16:55 We have 9 million of very,

16:56 very super productive,

16:58 uh,

16:58 fast growing species,

16:59 and that's basically

17:01 what supplies our

17:02 timber needs.

17:03 But some comes from the Amazon sustainable timber management.

17:07 And what I'm trying to say here is that part of that,

17:10 a significant part of that could come from community lands.

17:15 And then there's the issue of carbon.

17:16 I mean,

17:16 there was the question

17:18 yesterday about how much carbon is stored in,

17:19 uh,

17:20 communi community lands,

17:21 right?

17:21 We did that for Brazil and we came to a lower figure of,

17:25 uh,

17:25 twice the annual Brazil,

17:28 the annual emissions of Brazil

17:29 stored in the forest carbon held by local communities and indigenous people.

17:34 Um,

17:35 the enabling environment in Brazil is very conducive for this now.

17:38 We have a number of new instruments that are being put in place.

17:41 We have a bioeconomy initiative that is all about empowering local communities,

17:45 giving access to credit.

17:47 We're working with our national bank,

17:48 Banco de Brazil,

17:50 in establishing new credit lines for communities.

17:52 The Bendes,

17:53 the National Development Bank,

17:55 has been providing new,

17:56 uh,

17:56 source of funding,

17:57 uh,

17:58 uh,

17:58 for this.

17:59 Uh,

18:00 we have a new plan to reduce deforestation.

18:03 That's,

18:03 I mean,

18:03 one of the most important thing,

18:04 and it has already achieved,

18:07 uh,

18:07 results.

18:07 I mean,

18:08 we are glad to announce that deforestation has reduced by 25%,

18:12 the lowest level since 2018,

18:14 um,

18:15 and.

18:17 The,

18:18 we also have a new law on traditional communities that's being,

18:21 uh,

18:22 not a law,

18:22 sorry,

18:23 a,

18:23 uh,

18:23 a new plan,

18:24 uh,

18:25 uh,

18:25 for that.

18:25 So

18:26 supportive enabling environment.

18:29 We believe that this increasing demand for

18:32 ethical trade for uh uh products,

18:35 I mean natural products,

18:37 it,

18:37 it,

18:37 it's on the,

18:38 on the,

18:38 on the rise right internationally and in Brazil,

18:41 so

18:41 there's increased demand,

18:42 particularly for non-timber forest products.

18:45 I like to talk about acai.

18:46 I mean,

18:47 by now everyone knows just go down the,

18:49 the,

18:49 the,

18:49 the road here and I mean a few years ago

18:52 you would think that this is

18:54 an indigenous language when actually it is,

18:56 right,

18:56 but now we know what it is,

18:58 um.

18:59 New source of funding

19:00 and then there is still the issue of payments for ecosystem services.

19:04 So one of the things that in Brazil we are trying to

19:05 shift the conversation towards is not talk about carbon markets so much but

19:11 payment for ecosystem services

19:12 more broadly.

19:14 We have a new law on payment for ecosystem not law again,

19:16 uh,

19:17 we have the regulation of a law.

19:19 The law had already been passed

19:21 and,

19:21 uh,

19:22 we are

19:23 looking into how to make PES work for traditional.

19:27 And in the communal territories.

19:31 We have successful initiatives.

19:32 I mean,

19:32 after these years,

19:33 many years of support,

19:34 many of you guys here,

19:36 I mean,

19:36 uh,

19:37 uh,

19:37 the World Bank,

19:38 the IADB,

19:39 the Germans,

19:40 uh,

19:40 uh,

19:40 the USA have been very,

19:42 uh,

19:42 uh,

19:43 supportive of,

19:43 of this agenda.

19:44 The,

19:44 the,

19:45 we have,

19:46 uh,

19:46 some blueprints of communities that manage that forest and make

19:50 significant

19:51 funding.

19:52 So it's a matter of scaling that up.

19:53 It is doable.

19:55 And uh this issue is super important and very exciting to see.

19:58 I mean,

19:59 communities in the Amazon

20:00 have a much higher level of capacity today than

20:04 1220 years ago,

20:05 right?

20:05 So

20:06 we're talking about a different level of engagement with these communities.

20:09 We're talking about a,

20:10 a very different type of dialogue

20:12 with them.

20:14 And,

20:14 um,

20:14 and this is the agency I work,

20:15 we have,

20:16 uh,

20:16 Brazil has amassed a lot of experience with forced concessions.

20:19 We are very different from Indonesia,

20:21 for instance,

20:21 that has

20:23 decades of concessions.

20:24 Concessions in Brazil are relatively

20:26 new.

20:27 Uh,

20:28 but now we have 15 years of experience

20:31 and a lot of the instruments we use in concessions like traceability,

20:36 uh,

20:37 uh,

20:37 monitoring of timber,

20:39 uh,

20:40 how the contracts are made,

20:42 they can be used in community forestry.

20:45 So basically with all of this in mind,

20:47 um,

20:48 we are now proposing what we call Community forestry 2.0,

20:51 a new program.

20:54 Focused on the multiple use of force.

20:57 Um,

20:59 So

21:00 not only timber,

21:01 non-timber forest products,

21:02 and

21:03 serve ecosystem services

21:05 by traditional people in communities,

21:08 strengthening local governance,

21:10 governance of the territories,

21:11 right?

21:11 So,

21:12 uh,

21:12 decision making,

21:14 um,

21:15 yesterday,

21:15 right,

21:16 there was a talk about FPI,

21:18 so the government is trying to.

21:20 Internalize that into

21:22 protocols,

21:24 uh.

21:26 That,

21:26 uh,

21:28 I used,

21:29 right,

21:29 whenever engaging

21:31 with local communities,

21:32 uh,

21:33 for different types of deals,

21:34 right?

21:34 Payment for ecosystem services,

21:36 uh,

21:36 timber or whatever.

21:39 And this is a little bit of the program.

21:41 I mean it's in the making,

21:42 uh,

21:42 but it would have a uh forest economy promotion pillar business,

21:47 institutional capacity and strengthening the capacity of uh cooperatives,

21:51 associations,

21:52 uh,

21:53 uh,

21:54 local,

21:54 uh,

21:55 enterprises.

21:57 Local

21:58 governance.

22:00 We are talking now about bio hubs,

22:02 so basically you would have

22:05 The protected area in the area around it

22:08 being supported

22:09 through access to finance,

22:11 technical assistance,

22:11 and so on.

22:13 Development of inclusive businesses,

22:15 including legal

22:18 institutional support

22:20 for communities

22:21 to engage in.

22:23 Businesses in deals,

22:24 right?

22:25 If they want,

22:26 right?

22:27 If,

22:27 if,

22:27 if they seek that,

22:30 um,

22:31 knowledge management and research and development.

22:35 I guess my time's come to an end just to conclude that uh uh the

22:40 the government of Brazil and the Brazilian and

22:42 the Ministry of Environment and the Forest Service

22:45 has made this whole

22:47 discussion again on bioeconomy a centerpiece of our agenda

22:51 and we are also bringing it globally

22:53 so as

22:54 many of you know,

22:55 Brazil is the president of the G20 this year

22:58 we took over from Indonesia,

22:59 India.

23:00 And now it's Brazil.

23:01 Next year it's South Africa,

23:02 so it's 4 years of developing countries in the presidency of the G20.

23:06 And,

23:06 uh,

23:07 just like Indonesia brought oceans to the agenda big time,

23:10 Brazil is bringing this topic of bioeconomy.

23:13 So we launched a global initiative on bioeconomy

23:17 and uh in in the G20,

23:19 and we are discussing the high level principles

23:21 of bioeconomy,

23:22 what it means,

23:23 uh,

23:24 really

23:25 because it's a term that's used in a very different manner.

23:28 But for us,

23:29 uh,

23:29 in particular the Forest Service to a large extent it's the sustainable use

23:32 of,

23:33 uh,

23:33 forest resources

23:35 again for the benefit of local people,

23:37 indigenous people,

23:38 and with respect to their rights.

23:40 Thanks a lot.

23:50 Thank you so much uh Andre for a very interesting,

23:52 uh,

23:53 presentation.

23:54 I think the challenges uh

23:56 are very clear in Brazil

23:57 but also some of the uh

24:00 results so far but we will discuss it more in depth during the,

24:02 uh,

24:03 discussion.

24:04 Let's move now to,

24:05 uh,

24:06 another side of the world,

24:07 uh,

24:07 in an equally fast,

24:09 uh country.

24:10 Indonesia,

24:11 um,

24:11 our next speaker is Doctor

24:14 Bambang Supriyanto,

24:15 who is the director general

24:17 of Social forestry of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry

24:21 and before,

24:21 uh,

24:22 we invite Bambang to the stage,

24:24 just a little bit of context.

24:25 So,

24:26 um,

24:26 I assume many of you were yesterday also in the

24:28 room when the minister of land from Indonesia presented on

24:32 the significant progress with land registration

24:35 in Indonesia.

24:37 The social forestry program in Indonesia is actually part of

24:41 the same program which is the agrarian reform program,

24:44 and the forest area in Indonesia,

24:46 the area that the state has designated to be a forest,

24:49 is actually 63% of the country.

24:51 And inside this area 12.7 million hectares have been assigned for social forestry

24:57 and customary forest.

24:59 And in the last couple of years,

25:01 uh,

25:01 the Ministry of Environment and Forestry has really.

25:03 Scaled up

25:04 both social forestry as well as the recognition of indigenous land rights,

25:08 and Mr.

25:08 Bambang,

25:09 who's going to present on

25:10 the challenges and results of this program,

25:12 has been there since the beginning.

25:14 So he's been

25:15 7 years now director general if I'm not mistaken,

25:17 and this actually coincides with the start of this program,

25:20 so he has a very rich experience and we're very excited to hear

25:24 directly from him

25:24 how Indonesia has managed to

25:26 accelerate this program,

25:28 please,

25:28 Mr.

25:28 Bambang.

25:40 Thank you,

25:40 Mr.

25:40 William.

25:42 Uh,

25:42 it is my pleasure

25:44 to be one of the speaker together with,

25:47 uh,

25:48 Mr.

25:48 Andre from Brazilian,

25:50 uh,

25:51 government

25:52 and also Gabriela from the Global

25:55 Alliance,

25:56 uh,

25:56 Landscape Alli Alliance.

25:59 Uh,

25:59 as a representative of Indonesia,

26:01 uh,

26:02 please allow me to present

26:04 the policy implementation.

26:07 Of how

26:09 community forestry can strengthen sustainable landscape management

26:12 and land tenure security in Indonesia.

26:16 The number of the villages in Indonesia

26:19 is more than

26:20 83 million.

26:22 Uh,

26:23 83,000 villages,

26:26 of which almost 26,000

26:29 villages

26:30 are located around

26:32 or in

26:33 forest area of 120 million hectares

26:37 where 36.7

26:39 is classified

26:41 as underdeveloped

26:42 with the several cases of

26:44 the neural conflict.

26:46 Due to limited forest utilization and

26:49 inequality

26:50 between private consensus and community access

26:53 of 43 million hectares.

26:56 Then,

26:57 since 2015,

26:59 the government

27:00 launched a social forestry program

27:03 with a target of 12.7 million hectares

27:07 or 30%

27:09 of permitted forest utilization by 2030.

27:15 Social forestry began in the late

27:18 90s focused on community empowerment.

27:22 However,

27:23 lacking in the microfinance and market.

27:27 And also contribution to the economic development.

27:30 Then since 2015,

27:32 the government of Indonesia

27:34 has improved and made several breakthrough

27:37 through the issuance of the ministerial regulation Number

27:41 839 and 4 2023

27:45 and the presidential regulation Number 28-2023 regarding

27:52 acceleration of social forestry management.

27:57 Social forestry

27:58 includes

28:00 Acknowledgement of customary forests,

28:03 which aim

28:05 to guarantee

28:07 their living area,

28:09 preserving ecosystem,

28:10 both forest and and environment,

28:12 and also protecting the local wisdom and

28:15 traditional knowledge related to the forest.

28:18 In order to ensure the community sustainable forest management,

28:22 it should be supported with the three,

28:25 pillar activity,

28:27 land use

28:28 access,

28:29 capacity building to human resources,

28:33 and collaboration

28:34 for the investment,

28:36 microfinance,

28:37 and also market opportunities.

28:40 Social forestry

28:43 social forestry permit is for 35 years.

28:47 During the period,

28:48 the farmer group received a facilitation,

28:51 not only from the government,

28:52 but also from the governance,

28:55 uh,

28:56 NGO

28:57 and also private

28:58 for the establishment

28:59 of the community institutional management system.

29:03 Forest management with one village and one cluster communities,

29:07 and establishment of business plan,

29:09 which is useful to build microfinance investment cooperation,

29:14 and off-taker market cooperation.

29:17 The long-term output of sustainable forest management

29:20 of social forestry indicated by decreasing.

29:24 The tenureural conflict,

29:27 enhancing

29:28 the land uh cover,

29:29 and increasing the community income.

29:33 The achievement of social forestry is almost 6.7 million hectares

29:39 and more than 1.3 million households already involved.

29:44 While in the achievement of acknowledgement of customary forest is

29:49 240,000 hectares

29:53 for 138.

29:56 Customary law communities.

29:58 These communities established social forestry business group

30:02 to work together as a team to enhance

30:05 their livelihood.

30:06 In current time,

30:08 there are more than 13,000 social forestry business groups

30:12 that divided into four classifications,

30:15 beginning implementation,

30:16 sustain,

30:17 and self-standing.

30:20 There are several challenges faced,

30:22 uh,

30:22 by the social forestry program toward 2030.

30:26 The first is acceleration of social forestry access distribution.

30:30 The target is 12.7,

30:32 now it's 6.7.

30:34 So we have,

30:35 uh,

30:35 uh,

30:35 45% left.

30:38 So we,

30:38 we,

30:39 we have,

30:39 uh,

30:39 7 years,

30:40 the time to finish this agrarian reform.

30:44 And the second

30:45 is

30:46 to,

30:47 uh,

30:47 for the quality improvement of Social forestry Business Group.

30:50 And the 3rd is the increased utilization

30:53 of the forest productivity

30:55 and added value for the regional economic and climate change

30:59 adaptation and mitigation action.

31:03 Presidential Regulation Number 28,

31:06 2023 and its implementation is designated

31:10 strategy to overcome those challenges,

31:13 including the approach of integrated area development

31:17 that has three focused collaboration,

31:20 which are

31:21 alignment of policy and regulation across sector

31:25 and headquarter and also local government,

31:28 and then also budget

31:29 allocation for the social forestry.

31:32 And integrating social forestry into national

31:35 and regional development planning document.

31:38 I'll give you one example in integrated area development of Lumaja

31:43 is Jaffa,

31:45 the landscape approach of Agro-Silver pastoral

31:48 and agro-industry

31:50 and promoting a network of eco-tourism package

31:53 sector yielded

31:55 per capita for

31:56 ₹3.7

31:58 million per month per household

32:01 or above the poverty line.

32:03 And also providing

32:05 the,

32:06 uh,

32:06 increase the employment

32:08 and also increased contribution of,

32:10 uh,

32:10 various sector.

32:12 We developed the GOCCups

32:14 as the National Register System for the Social forestry,

32:17 data updating,

32:19 monitoring,

32:19 evaluation,

32:21 and also information sources

32:23 and publication of the social forestry performance

32:27 as the basis of the policy determination reported by its facilitator

32:32 in real-time.

32:34 There was a survey

32:36 that was conducted by Katadata,

32:38 one of the media and research company in Indonesia in 2020 before COVID.

32:44 The rule

32:45 or

32:47 Uh,

32:47 the role of the facilitator was very important,

32:50 and after 5 years of receiving social forestry

32:53 license or permit,

32:54 the income has elevated

32:56 to 72%

32:58 or twice higher than before.

33:01 As a consequence of the social

33:03 capital in the forest area,

33:06 the community

33:07 communally protect the area from the illegal logging,

33:11 illegal mining,

33:12 and also forest fire.

33:14 This can contribute to the climate mitigation action.

33:19 Since 2021,

33:21 the Ministry of Environment and,

33:23 uh,

33:23 Forestry developed the systematic and integrated approach

33:27 in the management of the forest and other land use sector

33:31 toward

33:31 emission level that

33:33 called Indonesia follow NETSE

33:36 2030.

33:37 This approach is projected to contribution almost 60%

33:42 or equivalent

33:43 with a minus 140 million tons of CO2 equivalent

33:49 or net sin

33:50 by 2030

33:52 from the total greenhouse gas emission reduction

33:56 target that Indonesia wants to achieve through its own effort.

34:01 In line with this plan to achieve the 2030 social forestry target

34:06 of 12.7 million hectares,

34:08 it is hoped that the contribution

34:11 of social forestry will be around 24.6 million,

34:16 uh,

34:16 ton of CO2 equivalent

34:18 or 18%.

34:21 4 million hectares of social forestry are targets of Indonesia polu netsing.

34:26 That action

34:27 is divided into two actions,

34:30 namely adaptation.

34:32 Uh,

34:32 as a precondition and mitigation action that

34:35 is carried out with a strategy of implementing

34:39 sustainable forest management,

34:41 carbon stock,

34:42 and also peatland and high conservation value forests.

34:47 We also

34:48 do assessment to forecast the carbon trend in targeted

34:52 social forested area in volumeting 2030 between 2006,

34:56 2021.

34:59 This calculation indicates,

35:01 uh,

35:01 a positive contribution

35:03 to increasing

35:04 forest cover,

35:05 which can convert it into reducing emissions by approximately

35:10 32

35:11 million tons of CO2 equivalent.

35:15 The strategy of adaptation and mitigation

35:17 action of social forestry targeted area,

35:20 if the uh pri primary forest,

35:23 keep it as a forest,

35:25 build the alternative income in the buffer zone.

35:28 Secondary forest

35:29 is for the carbon enhancement

35:32 through enrichment,

35:33 uh,

35:33 planning program.

35:35 And the community activities are forest restoration

35:38 as a form of the climate mitigation.

35:41 One of the best practices for the,

35:44 uh,

35:44 for the improvement of land cover

35:47 is in community forest in Yogyakarta in,

35:50 uh,

35:50 Central Java.

35:51 From 2006 to 2021,

35:54 there was a positive trend from dryland farming to the,

35:57 uh,

35:57 plantation forest.

36:00 This research indicate that the community activities

36:03 are able

36:04 to control land,

36:06 uh,

36:06 conserve,

36:06 uh,

36:07 conversion

36:07 activity in the forest area

36:10 and can improve the quality of the forest cover

36:13 from non,

36:14 uh,

36:15 non-forest agriculture

36:16 to

36:17 agroforestry and plantation forests.

36:21 That is my presentation.

36:23 Thank you for the listening.

36:33 Thank you so much Doctor Bambang.

36:35 I think that was a very,

36:36 uh,

36:36 impressive story.

36:38 So 6.7

36:39 million hectares of social forestry

36:42 schemes already allocated to Indonesia in the last couple of years

36:46 and a plan to scale this up even further to reach 12.7

36:51 million hectares

36:52 and what I think was very interesting as well is how the social forestry.

36:55 Program in Indonesia is

36:57 directly linked to the country's

37:00 climate change mitigation and adaptation agenda,

37:03 and I personally would be interested to hear

37:05 more about this and also how

37:07 these two different angles come into play

37:09 with social forestry

37:10 um in Indonesia.

37:12 So

37:12 we now move on to our third speaker which is Gabriela Rodriguez

37:18 Eklund from

37:19 uh Brazil.

37:20 So Gabriela is currently the technical

37:23 director of the Global Land Alliance.

37:27 She's a geographer and land governance,

37:30 uh,

37:30 professional,

37:31 and she worked previously in the tenure facility and several development banks,

37:37 including

37:37 the World Bank as well.

37:39 Um,

37:40 and she is focused on enhancing land tenure security,

37:43 um,

37:43 particularly for indigenous peoples and local communities,

37:46 and her presentation today will continue to talk about community forestry,

37:51 uh,

37:51 a little bit more in a global perspective,

37:53 but also focus on the issue.

37:55 Of the voluntary

37:56 carbon markets

37:57 which Andre earlier already alluded to is something that confuses many of us

38:02 and particularly the issue of land tenure within those schemes is going to be

38:06 uh very challenging.

38:07 So without further ado,

38:09 please Gabriela,

38:09 the floor is yours.

38:18 Hi,

38:18 good morning,

38:18 everyone.

38:19 Uh,

38:19 very pleased to be here and to hear

38:21 the very interesting presentations from Brazil and Indonesia.

38:24 Uh,

38:25 yeah,

38:25 the voluntary carbon market has been already in the 2nd day,

38:28 very much in the focus of this conference,

38:30 right?

38:31 Much as a very big risk and threat

38:34 for indigenous and local communities.

38:36 But here I would like to bring,

38:38 try to bring a more

38:39 holistic perspective,

38:41 bringing also the dimension of the private sector together with

38:43 that of indigenous communities and local communities and the government.

38:47 This is based on a perspective

38:49 note that we are preparing currently at the Global Land Alliance

38:53 to highlight some of the major impediments that we

38:56 think are some of the major impediments to responsible investments

38:59 and what kind of new actions we can,

39:01 you know,

39:02 think about and uh

39:04 initiate to address these impediments.

39:08 So first of all,

39:08 very

39:09 quick,

39:10 uh.

39:12 OK,

39:12 so,

39:13 uh,

39:14 very quick background.

39:17 This is,

39:17 uh,

39:18 so very quick background.

39:19 I don't need to repeat very much what has become the,

39:21 you know,

39:22 a fact except in this conference that.

39:24 We know that indigenous and local communities

39:27 customarily hold much of the world tropical forests

39:30 and are to be trusted as for forest

39:32 gardens because their livelihoods depend on this forest,

39:35 their culture,

39:35 their identity,

39:37 so it is a question of survival

39:39 why they have to defend this forest and it's

39:42 OK

39:43 and it is,

39:43 uh,

39:44 you know,

39:44 there is plenty of scientific evidence now showing that,

39:47 you know,

39:47 forests that are held by indigenous local communities are

39:50 better conserved.

39:52 But we also know that securing land rights of local communities,

39:55 indigenous peoples

39:57 is key for

39:58 social justice,

39:59 the environment,

40:01 and livelihoods as well.

40:03 So

40:04 taking a global perspective,

40:06 you know,

40:06 we have seen a lot of progress and,

40:08 and challenges in,

40:09 in,

40:09 in Brazil and Indonesia.

40:11 There has been progress in the recognition of forest tenure.

40:15 Uh,

40:16 this is shown by,

40:17 you know,

40:17 the tenure tracking tool that is kept by,

40:19 uh,

40:20 the Rights and Resources Initiative.

40:22 Uh,

40:23 the,

40:23 the lands designated for indigenous peoples and local communities have increased

40:27 from 1% to 4% of forest areas,

40:30 and those owned

40:31 by indigenous people's local communities increased from 18% to 24%,

40:36 uh,

40:36 between 2002 and 2017.

40:39 However,

40:41 many of these lands still remain to be recognized.

40:43 Legal frameworks are not complete.

40:46 Some countries don't recognize those rights.

40:49 Some countries lack the regulations to make that recognition happen on the ground.

40:54 But also the devolution of rights,

40:56 the level of devolution is also limited.

40:58 We talk about community forestry.

40:59 It can

41:00 include different degrees of

41:02 devolution of rights from very

41:03 limited participation to significant participation

41:06 to more devolution of land rights and full ownership.

41:09 So here again we have to see land terror as a bond of rights.

41:13 So

41:14 clearly much action is still needed to continue securing these rights.

41:19 And

41:20 the question is now

41:22 about the voluntary carbon market.

41:23 Is it really

41:24 an opportunity or a threat for indigenous peoples?

41:27 Clearly now it's mostly seen as

41:29 a threat,

41:30 right?

41:30 So before I start,

41:32 a very quick background to try to,

41:34 you know,

41:34 for those who are not familiar with this very

41:36 complex beast that is the voluntary carbon market,

41:39 really.

41:41 So basically,

41:42 since the start of the

41:43 Kyoto Protocol,

41:44 we know that you know market mechanisms have been

41:48 developed

41:49 to try to finance reduction of emissions

41:51 from deforestation as a financing mechanism.

41:53 We have both compliance markets

41:55 that have taken a longer time to develop because of all the regulatory part.

41:59 It's very complex.

42:00 In the meanwhile,

42:01 voluntary carbon markets have taken off,

42:03 and these are markets where

42:05 basically

42:05 Polluters

42:07 buy credits from projects to meet voluntary targets,

42:11 contrary to the compliance market,

42:13 where they are trying,

42:13 either governments or the private sector,

42:15 they are trying to meet

42:19 required targets from the legal framework of

42:21 their international commitments in the NDCs.

42:24 So

42:24 this market includes a huge number of actors.

42:28 Uh,

42:28 from,

42:29 you know,

42:29 the funders and investors of projects

42:32 to communities on the ground,

42:34 uh,

42:34 project proponents who are implementing the projects who

42:37 can be in the communities or not,

42:38 project developers who are,

42:39 you know,

42:40 helping

42:41 prepare all the technical documentation calculations

42:43 to submit to the registries,

42:45 and then you have the independent validation bodies that have to,

42:48 you know,

42:48 validate these documents to submit to the registries,

42:51 but also.

42:52 Verify the emission reductions to,

42:54 you know,

42:55 get the credits issued.

42:56 You have the registries which are who have,

42:59 by the way,

43:00 different standards,

43:01 not only one standard.

43:02 You have 4 big registries

43:04 of which,

43:05 uh,

43:05 you know,

43:06 Vera and the gold standard,

43:07 for example,

43:08 those lots of very small registries,

43:10 and then you have also the rating agencies that

43:12 have appeared to actually provide services to the buyers.

43:15 To rate the credits that have been rated by the credit agencies,

43:19 the registries,

43:20 uh,

43:21 you have brokers who can,

43:22 this is a speculative market,

43:24 it's something very important to know right now,

43:26 you know,

43:26 you can,

43:26 the,

43:27 the,

43:27 the,

43:27 the,

43:28 the

43:28 brokers can buy credits and wait until the

43:30 price increases to sell them in the market,

43:32 which raises big questions about,

43:34 you know,

43:34 the ethics when it comes to distributing

43:36 benefits to local communities and indigenous peoples,

43:38 right?

43:39 Uh,

43:39 you have the buyers and now recently you have initiatives

43:42 to enhance the integrity and the transparency of the market,

43:47 so

43:48 it's a very complex market and on top of that,

43:50 you know,

43:51 they can have conflict of interest

43:53 between these markets.

43:54 Some actors take different roles.

43:55 You have

43:56 developers who are also

43:58 brokers and investors at the same time in projects,

44:01 uh,

44:02 at the same time,

44:02 communities can be proponents or not.

44:05 It's extremely difficult to navigate actually.

44:09 So,

44:10 um.

44:12 When it comes to forestry,

44:13 you know,

44:14 community forestry in general,

44:15 in the voluntary carbon market,

44:17 uh,

44:18 looking at the,

44:18 this is the data is wrong,

44:20 the report from last year for,

44:21 uh,

44:21 ecosystem Marketplace which issued these annual reports,

44:25 the forestry and land use projects which includes REDD projects,

44:29 afforestation,

44:30 reforestation,

44:31 revenue.

44:31 Vegetation and improved forest management,

44:33 which is really what you know concerns indigenous peoples and local communities.

44:37 It's the largest they represent the largest volume of,

44:40 uh,

44:40 credits traded in the voluntary market,

44:43 and most of these credits are actually traded,

44:46 uh,

44:47 have been registered by IEA,

44:48 one of the major registries,

44:49 73%,

44:51 uh,

44:52 last year they recorded 381 projects in this category.

44:56 Under 22 standards in 43 countries and

45:00 uh the largest number of red projects uh

45:03 the red projects among these projects are also the last

45:06 in terms of number of credits sorry one thing is the

45:09 the volume trader,

45:10 the other is the number of credits.

45:12 The red projects represent the largest number of

45:14 credits each in the voluntary carbon market.

45:16 They have actual actually very high price.

45:18 There is a high,

45:18 high demand for these credits.

45:20 Uh,

45:21 most of the credits last year was issued in South America.

45:25 Brazil had the high,

45:27 the highest number of projects.

45:29 Indonesia had the highest number of,

45:31 uh,

45:32 credits issued,

45:33 uh,

45:33 but also in,

45:34 I guess,

45:35 in Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa.

45:36 So it's really like the developing countries that these projects are coming from.

45:40 Um,

45:41 but really,

45:42 so.

45:43 There's a lot of volume and things happening in the volatile carbon market,

45:47 and the question again is really.

45:49 Does the voluntary carbon market represent an opportunity or risk given

45:53 you know the large amount of financing coming from these private

45:56 companies?

45:58 So in 2020,

45:59 the volume um

46:01 traded was $2 billion.

46:03 It's expected to increase to $250 billion by 230.

46:07 I don't,

46:07 I'm not gonna say this is right,

46:09 it's just a prediction,

46:11 but,

46:11 and the market was,

46:12 you know,

46:12 really under crisis last year.

46:15 But basically,

46:16 you know,

46:16 in theory,

46:17 in principle,

46:18 if this market worked well,

46:20 we could think in an ideal world that it would

46:23 help mobilize funds to secure the tenure under for,

46:26 you know,

46:26 communities and local and,

46:27 uh,

46:27 indigenous peoples.

46:29 Uh,

46:29 it could also help reach these communities in a more direct way,

46:32 in the same way that,

46:33 you know,

46:34 private businesses get funds from banks and funds.

46:37 They don't need to go through all these rules.

46:39 They're more flexible

46:41 again,

46:41 if it was well regulated and well functioning,

46:43 transparent,

46:44 the funds could reach directly indigenous peoples.

46:47 The payments.

46:49 Could

46:49 crucially,

46:50 right,

46:50 the payments for reduction of emissions are very long term.

46:54 So that means the sustainable income for communities

46:57 to maintain the security in their territories

47:00 which is also intrinsically linked to actually the success of community forestry.

47:04 So to sustain the security

47:06 and to sustain the the the community forestry we need tenure security.

47:10 And it could also be ideally a driving force to

47:13 push for a higher recognition of rights by governments,

47:15 for example,

47:16 because of all the investments that could come to these communities.

47:19 However,

47:19 we know it's been very well expressed in this conference.

47:23 We have big problems right now with the current market.

47:26 The projects tend to be,

47:28 I have to highlight these projects and projects.

47:31 You

47:31 can have very good projects in the voluntary carbon market,

47:34 but right now it's under scrutiny because

47:37 there's a great number of projects

47:39 that are,

47:41 you know,

47:41 basically grabbing community land

47:44 without

47:45 respecting their land rights,

47:47 without respecting.

47:49 These projects are very top down.

47:50 They are not identified

47:52 most often from the communities,

47:54 but from,

47:55 you know,

47:56 to maximize the amount of mitigation from the land cover.

47:59 And,

48:01 um,

48:02 so there's no,

48:03 no ethic process or very poor ethic process being done in this market

48:07 and in the last couple of years really,

48:09 uh,

48:10 the market has been under intense scrutiny

48:12 by indigenous peoples and local communities,

48:13 I think more than ever before.

48:16 Um,

48:16 and also there's very you know removing the fact that very rarely,

48:21 uh,

48:22 local communities are owners or co-owners of these projects but

48:25 they should really should be based on their customary rights.

48:28 They have also very little

48:30 or uh

48:33 you know,

48:33 remuneration from these projects uh in fact,

48:36 they're starting to,

48:37 you know,

48:37 um.

48:38 Um,

48:40 uh,

48:40 oppose that and,

48:41 and,

48:41 and actually it's not just,

48:43 you know,

48:44 the community as a whole,

48:45 but we also start questioning the internal benefit sharing.

48:48 So when a community receives incomes,

48:49 what happens at the level of the community inside the community?

48:52 How are these benefits being distributed?

48:55 Uh,

48:55 so,

48:56 and also there's a danger given what's happening now.

48:58 There is a call for higher,

48:59 you know,

49:00 higher scale projects,

49:01 higher speed,

49:01 efficiency,

49:02 and the search for profit.

49:03 So this problem might worsen if we don't address,

49:06 you know,

49:07 the deep causes of this,

49:09 you know,

49:10 irresponsible investments.

49:12 So what I would like to highlight here,

49:13 I think at the conference we,

49:15 it,

49:15 it's very,

49:16 it's very clear and we keep telling the private sector

49:18 you have to respect FEC.

49:20 You have to respect land rights.

49:23 Land rights have to be recognized,

49:25 but we are talking different languages.

49:28 They are in a different sector.

49:29 There is no dialogue between those sectors,

49:30 and we are not aware enough of the actual other causes beyond the lack of intention.

49:38 Beyond the fact that they might not care about indigenous rights,

49:40 what is really causing this

49:43 incapability

49:44 of acting responsibly when you have

49:47 very strong legal frameworks,

49:50 international conventions,

49:51 standards,

49:52 lots of documents?

49:53 What is happening?

49:53 Why are they acting this way?

49:56 We need to look closer and to talk to the sector as well.

49:59 So,

50:00 uh,

50:02 first set of,

50:03 uh,

50:03 impediments are the classic ones that lie in the weak,

50:06 you know,

50:07 uh,

50:08 governance of land.

50:09 And here we,

50:10 we talk a lot about,

50:11 about the government

50:12 government policies.

50:13 So we have

50:14 a gap in recognition,

50:15 uh,

50:16 not only the land rights are not recognized,

50:18 but the carbon rights are rarely explicitly recognized in legislation.

50:22 There's a gap in formalization,

50:23 so basically,

50:24 you know,

50:25 there might be a law,

50:26 but the rights are actually not all the way recognized up to having,

50:28 you know,

50:29 either a title or a concession on

50:31 whatever,

50:31 you know,

50:32 uh,

50:32 constitutes the full,

50:34 you know,

50:34 security,

50:35 legal security of that right.

50:37 Uh,

50:37 you also have irregularity and uncertainty.

50:39 You have irregular titles and concessions of competing planes.

50:42 An actor in the private sector

50:44 for them.

50:45 Property equals title

50:47 so if they have a title

50:49 they think they have a proof of property

50:51 and you know when one looks closely and and starts searching on cases you might have

50:56 documentation that says they have a title,

50:57 but actually you have a lot of underlying claims and conflicts

51:01 and they are absolutely not aware of that.

51:04 Uh,

51:04 finally there's an information gap because when you're doing

51:07 the due diligence of a project in the private sector

51:10 you need to look for information.

51:12 You don't have cadastral services,

51:14 registries,

51:15 you know,

51:15 maps.

51:16 There's been,

51:16 there's efforts right now,

51:17 for example,

51:18 you know,

51:18 landmark to map to

51:20 put up there the amount of information that is in the polygons of indigenous lands,

51:24 but they don't know where to look for the information.

51:26 So how to do a due diligence if

51:29 there's no access to information of where indigenous lands are.

51:32 Uh,

51:34 but now I think we need to go deeper and look at what are the problems,

51:38 you know,

51:38 inside the sector,

51:40 the lack of capacity.

51:41 So we always say,

51:42 you know,

51:42 indigenous peoples need to be supported,

51:43 etc.

51:44 and that's crucial,

51:44 and the governments too,

51:45 but

51:46 what's happening in that sector.

51:48 We have insufficient or equivocal requirements on land and related rights

51:52 actually,

51:53 so the standards,

51:54 when you read the requirements,

51:56 they started being developed very recently.

51:58 This industry started really focusing on the environment

52:02 and on accurate accounting of carbon emissions reductions.

52:05 So they spent millions of dollars to get those

52:08 methodologies and requirements right and only recently they realized

52:11 that social requirements are important and co-benefits are important.

52:15 So

52:16 there's a,

52:17 it's very not very present and the way in these

52:19 these requirements are written are very top down and very,

52:23 they don't,

52:23 you know,

52:24 not compatible with the best,

52:25 best international practices.

52:27 Uh,

52:27 and now we have,

52:28 uh,

52:29 last year in initiative from the Integrity Council

52:32 for the Voluntary Carbon Market trying to,

52:33 to

52:34 bring this core carbon principles that basically

52:37 every carbon registry will need to have

52:39 to have an ethical seal to sell their credits in the market.

52:43 So this has been developed with the part.

52:44 of indigenous peoples and local communities,

52:46 but still it's very recent.

52:48 It's going to be tested,

52:49 and I think it needs to be very closely monitored

52:52 on whether it's really up to the up to the intentions of protecting land rights.

52:57 There's

52:58 requirements for land rights that are in there,

52:59 but we need to monitor how they are being implemented.

53:02 Then the implementation of land related retirements is

53:05 lagging behind in the in the voluntary market

53:07 obviously based on the violations,

53:10 uh,

53:10 but also yeah,

53:11 based on the the way in which these policies are are written

53:15 and some,

53:16 some,

53:16 uh,

53:17 potential causes of that are limited

53:19 knowledge and understanding of tenure requirements.

53:21 I mean this is a very complex

53:23 word,

53:23 the tenure rights,

53:24 bundle of rights,

53:26 you know,

53:26 people outside the land tenure in international

53:28 development are not familiar with these concepts.

53:30 It's completely they're completely oblivious to that

53:34 in general.

53:34 So how to do due diligence if they don't even know what they're talking about?

53:38 Uh,

53:38 there are insufficient or inadequate guidelines and tools for due diligence.

53:42 Actually,

53:42 many tools have been developed recently.

53:44 There's information and reports and guidelines

53:47 for the private sector for responsible land investment in general,

53:51 but,

53:52 uh,

53:53 we have to wonder what it's written in the language

53:56 that is,

53:57 you know.

53:58 Proper for the private sector that is adapted for their understanding

54:03 and also I think they might be suffering from an information overload

54:06 given that these people are focused on very efficient investments so.

54:10 Uh,

54:11 I think there's a need for developing

54:13 for repackaging the existing guidelines

54:16 and tools for due diligence of,

54:18 you know,

54:19 these projects actually,

54:20 so developing very specific tools

54:23 for or with them to be able to do this due diligence

54:26 and also maybe there is a difficulty for accessing,

54:29 you know,

54:30 the required expertise because you need very,

54:32 you know,

54:32 specific expertise to do the due diligence of these projects and understand.

54:36 The legal framework of Indonesia,

54:37 Colombia,

54:38 Republic of Congo,

54:39 Solomon Islands,

54:39 wherever you are doing an investment.

54:42 Um,

54:42 and finally,

54:43 of course,

54:44 the cost and time of due diligence FPI,

54:46 uh,

54:47 it's,

54:47 it's very expensive.

54:48 It's not compatible with the for-profit logic,

54:51 and maybe that we have to explore some ways of,

54:54 uh,

54:54 you know,

54:55 complementing,

54:56 preparing the communities for the market

54:59 so that I think as Ramos was saying in a presentation

55:01 this morning that,

55:02 you know,

55:03 ideally we would not want these investments to

55:06 from the tenure facility

55:07 to happen without the rights being recognized before.

55:10 Uh,

55:11 and finally,

55:12 there's a limited information and transparency.

55:14 The,

55:14 the maps of projects,

55:15 the polygons are available in most of the standards,

55:18 but you have to dig for them.

55:20 Why not have a map,

55:22 you know,

55:22 that displays all the existing projects since these are public anyway?

55:26 They should be more easily available to increase accountability.

55:30 And also in terms of distribution of benefits and agreement terms,

55:33 those are completely intransparent,

55:35 and that doesn't help the accountability of

55:37 community representatives

55:39 and it doesn't allow community members to

55:41 keep their community representatives accountable as well.

55:44 So there's a lot of limitations that are much more specific

55:47 that I think we need to start thinking about if we want to really

55:51 address this issue.

55:53 In addition to continue pushing

55:55 for respect of rights.

55:57 A advocacy of course is extremely important.

55:59 And finally,

56:00 so these are three stakeholders,

56:02 right?

56:02 The governments,

56:03 the the stakeholders in the carbon market,

56:05 and indigenous peoples in local communities,

56:07 as you know,

56:08 many presentations are highlighting in this in this conference,

56:11 uh,

56:11 there is a lack of rights recognition of access to financial resources,

56:15 access to that information and knowledge and expertise,

56:17 because really they should be the ones initiating these projects

56:20 and engaging the carbon market and not the other way around.

56:24 Um,

56:25 so there's a lot of the parenting that needs to change.

56:29 So you know

56:31 I'm going to highlight 5 actions here that we're thinking of presenting,

56:34 you know,

56:35 and,

56:35 uh,

56:36 as a call for action.

56:37 This doesn't exclude the need obviously to

56:40 continue making progress on,

56:41 on governance

56:43 and on,

56:43 you know,

56:44 enabling indigenous peoples

56:46 to self-govern

56:48 their resources,

56:49 you know,

56:49 to determine what kind of projects they want to do,

56:52 who they want to sell the benefits to,

56:54 and all that.

56:54 So but this is a new actions,

56:56 so this is why I want,

56:57 I wanted to highlight them.

56:59 So one example would be a review and evaluation of the land 1 requirements

57:03 from major standards and the core carbon principles,

57:07 um.

57:08 To

57:09 including yeah because they they're starting to be implemented

57:12 so.

57:14 And another one will be to package guides and develop tools for

57:18 and with actors in the voluntary carbon market.

57:21 Uh,

57:22 basically to give them the tools and higher capacity and

57:26 efficiency to be able to do this due diligence.

57:29 Another possible action is actually to try to,

57:32 you know,

57:33 create a global centralized database

57:36 on,

57:37 uh,

57:37 of carbon projects to increase the transparency and accountability,

57:40 including for indigenous communities,

57:42 you know,

57:42 and their supporters to see,

57:44 you know,

57:45 what's,

57:45 what's already out there and violating their rights first and also,

57:48 you know,

57:49 if anything new comes up

57:51 that conflicts with their actual customary or legal rights.

57:55 Another possible action is the community driven

57:57 mapping of carbon resources and rights.

58:00 So I think,

58:01 uh,

58:01 I don't know if,

58:02 um,

58:03 it was mentioned in the Brazil presentation,

58:04 but also before that,

58:05 you know,

58:05 the,

58:06 the,

58:06 the old sometimes the old ways of

58:08 doing capacity building and not necessarily work.

58:11 We need to

58:11 work on that in different ways.

58:13 Maybe one day is learning by doing

58:15 and this would be like.

58:17 An exercise,

58:18 you know,

58:19 to both build capacity on the complex voluntary carbon market but also to

58:23 make planning of resources in the present and for the future

58:27 and to manage to integrate this market in a in a just way.

58:31 And finally,

58:32 uh,

58:33 very important,

58:34 tenure security needs to be included as a basis,

58:37 uh,

58:38 basic activity actually of car because it's the basis for

58:41 the success of

58:42 community forestry,

58:43 right,

58:44 and as a co-benefit of

58:46 carbon projects,

58:48 um,

58:49 so

58:50 sorry,

58:50 I'm,

58:50 I'm over time and,

58:51 uh,

58:52 but I maybe can add more when,

58:53 when we have our discussion.

58:55 Thank you.

59:06 Check.

59:08 Thank you so much,

59:09 uh,

59:09 Gabriela,

59:10 for a very interesting presentation.

59:11 I particularly like the,

59:12 uh,

59:13 5 action points at the end of your

59:15 presentation.

59:16 I think that's very,

59:17 uh,

59:18 powerful to really,

59:19 uh,

59:20 advocate for,

59:21 for concrete action into,

59:23 uh,

59:23 improving,

59:24 uh,

59:24 these programs.

59:26 So

59:27 we're now starting our panel discussion with 3,

59:30 very interesting speakers with very

59:32 interesting presentations on community forestry.

59:35 Um,

59:35 so we will,

59:36 uh,

59:36 open the floor for a few rounds of questions

59:40 before doing that,

59:40 so I will take

59:41 the opportunity myself to ask a question to the speakers.

59:44 Uh,

59:45 one thing that I find particularly interesting

59:47 in the presentations that we've seen is this

59:50 issue of indigenous peoples.

59:51 Rights and

59:53 we've seen sort of a differentiation between on the one hand,

59:56 community forestry programs

59:58 and then on the other hand,

59:59 indigenous people's land tenure and there is

1:00:03 sort of an intersection between them,

1:00:05 but from the policy framework there seems to be some kind of differentiation

1:00:09 and I was wondering myself,

1:00:11 indigenous peoples.

1:00:13 Already have a collective territory which they already control

1:00:17 and manage,

1:00:17 and they know how to manage the resources.

1:00:20 So the question then would be

1:00:22 why would they need

1:00:23 a

1:00:24 government-driven

1:00:25 community forestry program if they already

1:00:28 have the.

1:00:28 To do it themselves and how does

1:00:31 the policy

1:00:32 in Brazil

1:00:33 and in Indonesia

1:00:35 tackle this issue.

1:00:36 So that's that's my first question.

1:00:37 Maybe

1:00:39 Pamang,

1:00:39 I see you are already grabbing a microphone but pointing to

1:00:43 Andre.

1:00:45 Bambang,

1:00:46 do you want to take this question?

1:00:47 Thank you.

1:00:48 OK,

1:00:48 thank you.

1:00:49 We use customary people rather than indigenous people in Indonesia

1:00:54 and the government through agrarian reform.

1:00:58 Uh,

1:00:58 to accelerate the acknowledgement of the customary,

1:01:02 uh,

1:01:02 forest.

1:01:03 So according to our act,

1:01:06 the

1:01:08 Customary,

1:01:09 uh,

1:01:10 forests should be given to the customary people or other people

1:01:14 as long as they,

1:01:16 they,

1:01:16 uh,

1:01:16 fulfill four requirements.

1:01:19 The first is

1:01:20 there is a community,

1:01:21 uh,

1:01:22 they have a leader,

1:01:24 they have,

1:01:25 uh,

1:01:26 territory,

1:01:27 and then they have,

1:01:28 uh,

1:01:28 legal,

1:01:29 uh,

1:01:30 local wisdom and also traditional forest relative to the,

1:01:34 uh,

1:01:34 forest.

1:01:35 And last is,

1:01:36 uh,

1:01:36 they have a community.

1:01:38 And all of these should be recognized by,

1:01:41 uh,

1:01:41 local regulations,

1:01:43 local regulation.

1:01:44 Until now,

1:01:45 yes,

1:01:46 since 2016,

1:01:47 we already give to the

1:01:50 customary forests

1:01:52 to the 138.

1:01:54 Uh,

1:01:55 the total area is 240,000 hectares.

1:01:59 And we have also indicative area.

1:02:02 This is submitted by the NGO,

1:02:05 uh,

1:02:05 as a facilitator of them.

1:02:08 Actually,

1:02:08 the map

1:02:09 is 20.6 million hectares,

1:02:12 and then we have to

1:02:14 clarify together in the fields,

1:02:17 and we already indicate

1:02:19 at least 1.2 million hectares for the indigenous

1:02:23 or customary people in Indonesia.

1:02:26 So the policy has already mainstream for the customary people over there.

1:02:31 Thank you.

1:02:36 Yep,

1:02:37 just uh very briefly.

1:02:39 Most of the um.

1:02:41 Custom most most of the collective

1:02:44 forest lands,

1:02:46 uh,

1:02:46 in Brazil,

1:02:46 they are under

1:02:48 indigenous people's management by far so it's 115 million.

1:02:52 And the rest is 25 million,

1:02:53 so it's

1:02:54 5 times more,

1:02:55 right?

1:02:56 So,

1:02:57 um.

1:02:58 But the issue of the recognition of IP rights

1:03:00 is is indeed something that I didn't discuss.

1:03:03 I focused in our program,

1:03:06 this community forest management focuses really more on the.

1:03:10 Um,

1:03:11 let's say the business side of things,

1:03:13 right,

1:03:13 so it's the generation of value from standing for

1:03:17 whether through,

1:03:19 uh.

1:03:20 Products value chains timber,

1:03:22 non-timber,

1:03:23 uh,

1:03:24 or ecosystem services right so

1:03:26 that's more and now to do that

1:03:29 a whole range of things are needed so access to finance.

1:03:33 So this whole issue like in Indonesia with the coup right the like access to

1:03:37 um

1:03:38 small and medium enterprises

1:03:39 so

1:03:40 it's a lot in our case it's a lot about working

1:03:43 with um

1:03:45 entities that promote small and medium enterprises uh banks.

1:03:49 And this territorial

1:03:52 approach

1:03:53 as a way of

1:03:55 um.

1:03:56 Now here at the World Bank they are using the word like productive alliances.

1:03:59 It was the,

1:04:00 the,

1:04:00 there was a word before,

1:04:01 but anyway,

1:04:01 these ideas of like a territorial

1:04:03 element because you're gonna have a processing factory that will,

1:04:06 uh,

1:04:07 serve a number of communities.

1:04:08 So

1:04:10 this program is much more

1:04:11 linked to this issue

1:04:13 on the IP recognition

1:04:15 and,

1:04:15 uh,

1:04:16 we have colleagues here from the Ministry of uh yeah,

1:04:18 one thing

1:04:19 that I should have mentioned actually yesterday and today.

1:04:23 Brazil now has a ministry for the first time,

1:04:25 a ministry of indigenous affairs,

1:04:27 right?

1:04:27 So it's the,

1:04:28 and,

1:04:28 uh,

1:04:28 the minister actually was supposed to come here,

1:04:30 Sonaguaajara,

1:04:31 but she didn't because,

1:04:32 as you know,

1:04:32 we are having,

1:04:33 uh,

1:04:34 a natural disaster going on.

1:04:36 But so

1:04:37 we have a full ministry

1:04:39 and

1:04:40 the process of recognition of indigenous people's territories continue.

1:04:45 Now

1:04:46 It's

1:04:47 complicated,

1:04:48 right?

1:04:49 More and more so because,

1:04:50 uh,

1:04:51 now,

1:04:51 uh,

1:04:52 many of the areas where,

1:04:53 where

1:04:54 you still have claims for recognition,

1:04:56 they are on the contested areas,

1:04:58 so it takes time.

1:04:59 But

1:04:59 again,

1:05:00 that's not so much what this program will look at it takes that as like a given,

1:05:05 let's say it like.

1:05:07 Actually,

1:05:07 sorry,

1:05:07 this is a super important point

1:05:09 because we're just discussing all the criteria

1:05:11 of eligibility and there will be a criteria

1:05:13 for the program that some sort of rights will need to be ascertained before.

1:05:18 So we will not

1:05:20 deal with that.

1:05:21 That will be the minister of indigenous affairs.

1:05:23 Thanks.

1:05:27 Please,

1:05:28 please,

1:05:28 and,

1:05:28 and,

1:05:29 and just very quickly also,

1:05:30 you,

1:05:30 you mentioned a lot about the compliance issue and,

1:05:33 and the lack of ethic,

1:05:34 but you at the same time mentioned that the carbon

1:05:36 markets could also be an opportunity for the IP.

1:05:39 So if you could briefly touch upon that,

1:05:41 that would be,

1:05:42 that would be great.

1:05:43 I think.

1:05:49 Is it working?

1:05:51 No.

1:05:51 What I meant,

1:05:52 I mean,

1:05:53 potentially

1:05:54 the voluntary market can mobilize billions of dollars

1:05:57 from the private sector

1:05:59 to finance,

1:06:00 you know,

1:06:01 conservation.

1:06:03 Tenure

1:06:04 co-benefits sustainable forest management,

1:06:06 and there are actually initiatives that are,

1:06:08 you know,

1:06:09 channeling money,

1:06:10 for example,

1:06:11 directly to agroforestry to do that,

1:06:14 but I think the,

1:06:14 the lack of compliance doesn't mean that the

1:06:17 market cannot channel resources in a responsible way.

1:06:20 It's the,

1:06:20 it's a very immature market,

1:06:22 extremely unregulated,

1:06:24 completely wild,

1:06:25 and I think,

1:06:26 and also.

1:06:28 There's many things we can question also about the carbon market.

1:06:31 I mean,

1:06:31 there's,

1:06:31 uh,

1:06:31 for example,

1:06:32 the,

1:06:32 the,

1:06:32 the red plus is being,

1:06:34 um,

1:06:35 there's a big question in terms of,

1:06:37 uh,

1:06:37 additionality,

1:06:38 permanence permanence,

1:06:39 and the ability to actually estimate realistically the amount of carbon

1:06:43 because

1:06:44 forest ecosystems are

1:06:46 uncertain.

1:06:47 Political events,

1:06:48 political changes,

1:06:49 changes of governments,

1:06:50 what they can do to a big forest in the country is completely uncertain.

1:06:54 So these baselines that are set by part of carbon projects that are being attacked,

1:06:57 they will never be

1:06:59 realistic and certain actually.

1:07:00 So the,

1:07:01 the,

1:07:01 the way of treating itself is being questioned

1:07:04 and,

1:07:04 uh,

1:07:05 there was a very important paper actually published last year

1:07:07 in Science saying that forest ecosystems are very uncertain.

1:07:11 And we need to think about another way

1:07:13 to measure actually the emission reductions from red

1:07:16 focusing on resilience

1:07:18 because what what makes systems sustainable is resilience.

1:07:20 You need to finance the resilience factors and tenure

1:07:23 is a key resilience factor.

1:07:25 So I think there's a very important argument for tenure in red,

1:07:29 but you know when we haven't found a way to make these markets responsible,

1:07:33 they are there.

1:07:34 The investors,

1:07:35 despite the crisis last year because of all the scrutiny in the,

1:07:38 in the carbon market.

1:07:39 The clients want to continue purchasing high quality.

1:07:42 There's a high demand for high quality carbon

1:07:44 that was in the ecosystem marketplace report.

1:07:47 So whether we like or not this market,

1:07:48 the demand is there.

1:07:49 It's unregulated.

1:07:51 If it's allowed,

1:07:52 it needs to,

1:07:52 it needs to behave

1:07:54 and if we can help it behave better,

1:07:56 I think indigenous peoples and local communities will be better off.

1:08:00 Thank you.

1:08:02 So

1:08:02 let's now open the floor.

1:08:04 We have a microphone,

1:08:05 uh,

1:08:05 here in front.

1:08:06 So if there's anyone from the audience that would like to ask a question to

1:08:11 either

1:08:11 one of the speakers or to all speakers,

1:08:14 um,

1:08:14 please step forward and,

1:08:16 uh,

1:08:16 quickly introduce yourself,

1:08:18 um,

1:08:19 um,

1:08:19 ask the question,

1:08:20 and also,

1:08:21 um,

1:08:22 if addressed to anyone,

1:08:23 please,

1:08:24 uh,

1:08:24 mention to whom it is addressed so we can do

1:08:26 a first round of perhaps let's say

1:08:29 3 questions.

1:08:32 Who would like to step forward first and break the ice here.

1:08:35 That microphone is waiting.

1:08:39 Right

1:08:41 Uh

1:08:44 Hello everyone,

1:08:45 uh,

1:08:45 my name is Solange.

1:08:46 I'm the president of the Rights and Resources Initiative.

1:08:50 Happy to be here and thank you very much

1:08:52 to all the panelists for the great presentations.

1:08:55 I have many questions,

1:08:55 but I'll just ask one and give the floor to others.

1:08:58 Uh,

1:08:58 I wanted to ask to Andres from Brazil.

1:09:01 Uh,

1:09:01 Brazil will be hosting,

1:09:03 uh,

1:09:04 COP 30

1:09:05 in 2025,

1:09:07 and I would like to know how forests

1:09:10 will be at the center of the agenda,

1:09:12 but also the rights of indigenous peoples and

1:09:15 local communities and what will be their involvement.

1:09:18 Thank you.

1:09:19 Yes,

1:09:19 yes,

1:09:19 yes.

1:09:25 Thank you,

1:09:26 Solange.

1:09:27 Any other,

1:09:28 uh.

1:09:30 Questions from the audience at this point?

1:09:32 Yes.

1:09:40 Hi,

1:09:40 so a question for Gabriela though I think the other

1:09:42 speakers may be interested to weigh in as well.

1:09:45 You mentioned the opportunity to work with

1:09:46 actors in the voluntary carbon market to establish

1:09:49 some of this commitment to recognizing tenure

1:09:52 rights for indigenous peoples and local communities.

1:09:55 I'm curious to hear you say more about what that could

1:09:56 look like and from if the other panelists are interested,

1:10:00 um,

1:10:00 possible connections to national legal frameworks on

1:10:03 carbon trading that can do that,

1:10:05 can center tenure rights as a precondition.

1:10:11 So

1:10:13 Let's,

1:10:14 let's,

1:10:14 let's see if there's one more question from the audience before we,

1:10:17 we,

1:10:17 we'll take the,

1:10:18 the first round of answers.

1:10:26 Please

1:10:29 Peter Van Nostrom,

1:10:31 Delft University of Technology,

1:10:32 it was mentioned several times that the tenure aspect is very important.

1:10:37 I also heard about good progress in Indonesia and Brazil in the registration.

1:10:44 What are

1:10:45 the gaps that still need to be addressed in

1:10:49 formalizing or recording?

1:10:51 The tenure aspect.

1:10:56 OK.

1:10:59 OK,

1:11:00 thanks.

1:11:00 So

1:11:01 perhaps let's,

1:11:02 uh,

1:11:02 start with,

1:11:03 um,

1:11:04 Andre.

1:11:05 So the question on COP 30 and how

1:11:07 Brazil is planning to,

1:11:10 uh,

1:11:11 centralize forest and the issue of indigenous people rights uh around this agenda.

1:11:19 No,

1:11:19 thanks a lot,

1:11:20 Solange,

1:11:20 because that gives me the chance to talk a little bit about this,

1:11:22 right,

1:11:23 because that for that one we have a very good response,

1:11:25 um.

1:11:26 So,

1:11:27 uh,

1:11:27 Brazil is really taking the opportunity of COP 30,

1:11:29 the first COP in the Amazon to bring force to the forefront,

1:11:33 right,

1:11:33 of climate action

1:11:35 and not only at the COP.

1:11:36 I mean,

1:11:36 as I said,

1:11:37 Brazil is the president of the G20

1:11:39 this year,

1:11:40 and again we are bringing this topic,

1:11:41 the initiative on bioeconomy is about this.

1:11:44 Brazil has set up a task force.

1:11:46 It's called the task force.

1:11:49 The task force.

1:11:51 To mobilize

1:11:52 action against climate,

1:11:54 so it's like a

1:11:55 a different group within the G20

1:11:59 bringing together for the first time ministers of finance,

1:12:02 environment,

1:12:02 and central banks together of all the G20 nations.

1:12:06 So like for the United States you have the Federal Reserve

1:12:09 with the EPA,

1:12:10 Department of the Interior,

1:12:11 and so on coming to these meetings extremely.

1:12:14 Interesting.

1:12:15 And the good thing about the G20 is that it's not negotiation,

1:12:18 right?

1:12:18 It's the non-negotiation

1:12:20 sphere.

1:12:20 It's not the COP.

1:12:22 So the idea is to focus much more on implementation.

1:12:24 So we are using that,

1:12:26 uh,

1:12:26 to bring

1:12:28 climate action and forests

1:12:31 to the forefront.

1:12:34 COP 30 and participation of indigenous people,

1:12:36 um,

1:12:37 the,

1:12:39 some of the groups,

1:12:40 the,

1:12:40 the coalitions of indigenous people in Brazil like AIB and COA,

1:12:44 they are planning very,

1:12:46 very big events.

1:12:47 I just heard actually last week that they are planning

1:12:48 that they're gonna have an event of 12,000 indigenous people

1:12:53 uh around the COP,

1:12:55 so the participation of indigenous people will be big.

1:12:58 How will the government ensure that there is a linkage between

1:13:01 whatever right civil society

1:13:03 organizes and the official process?

1:13:06 We have something that we call the social cop.

1:13:08 It's like a concept we have in Brazil's the socioeconomic forum,

1:13:12 right?

1:13:12 I mean,

1:13:12 we used to organize that and,

1:13:15 uh,

1:13:16 for the G20,

1:13:17 we are gonna have that.

1:13:18 So there's the official summit of the leaders,

1:13:21 the,

1:13:21 the,

1:13:21 the,

1:13:22 but there's gonna be a social one before that and that.

1:13:26 Uh,

1:13:26 event

1:13:27 formalizes like a,

1:13:29 uh,

1:13:30 the,

1:13:30 the list of recommendations

1:13:32 to the leaders,

1:13:33 and it's a super complex governance that,

1:13:36 uh,

1:13:36 like filters and it's all led by civil society

1:13:38 including

1:13:39 some indigenous people's organizations so

1:13:41 COP 30 will have a lot of,

1:13:43 uh,

1:13:43 of participation of indigenous people

1:13:46 and one thing to what we are trying to bring to the table on forests,

1:13:50 it's an alternative to forest carbon.

1:13:52 So Brazil has launched the COP 28,

1:13:55 the tropical forest forever facility.

1:13:57 Um,

1:13:58 we have now just set up a steering committee with the some of the

1:14:02 largest tropical nations Indonesia,

1:14:05 DRC,

1:14:07 Ghana,

1:14:08 Malaysia,

1:14:09 Colombia,

1:14:10 um,

1:14:11 and,

1:14:11 uh,

1:14:11 uh,

1:14:13 uh,

1:14:13 industrial countries,

1:14:14 uh,

1:14:15 the US,

1:14:16 uh,

1:14:16 UK,

1:14:16 France,

1:14:17 uh,

1:14:17 Norway,

1:14:18 and a few others.

1:14:19 And uh it's,

1:14:19 it's a new mechanism that's trying to uh create value.

1:14:23 I mean,

1:14:24 basically reward

1:14:25 tropical forest countries for maintaining forest cover,

1:14:28 but it's not based on carbon,

1:14:30 and I can talk to you more about this later,

1:14:33 OK.

1:14:34 Bambang,

1:14:35 please.

1:14:36 OK,

1:14:36 thank you,

1:14:37 uh,

1:14:37 William.

1:14:38 So there are two questions related to Indonesia.

1:14:40 The one is about the land registration

1:14:43 for the social forestry.

1:14:46 We have a national registration system,

1:14:48 uh,

1:14:48 what we call as COOs,

1:14:50 and,

1:14:51 uh,

1:14:51 those,

1:14:52 uh,

1:14:52 results will be put into one map policy together with,

1:14:55 uh,

1:14:56 ATR,

1:14:57 uh,

1:14:57 with,

1:14:57 uh,

1:14:59 non,

1:14:59 uh,

1:15:00 land,

1:15:00 uh,

1:15:01 registration.

1:15:02 So in,

1:15:02 put it into one.

1:15:04 Um,

1:15:05 the most important thing is the gap is not only giving the access,

1:15:09 but the facilitation,

1:15:12 how the sustainable forest management can be conducted by the community,

1:15:17 uh,

1:15:17 in a proper way.

1:15:18 That's why the government assigned the facilitator,

1:15:21 uh,

1:15:21 facilitator,

1:15:22 government or non-government organization

1:15:24 with the incentive of them.

1:15:26 So institutional setup and then forest management and how to link

1:15:30 with the,

1:15:31 you know,

1:15:32 for the

1:15:33 Uh,

1:15:34 income

1:15:35 for the better life of them.

1:15:37 This is,

1:15:37 uh,

1:15:37 the first question,

1:15:38 and the second for the carbon.

1:15:41 So we already measure the contribution of the social forestry,

1:15:45 6.7 million hectares,

1:15:46 but we

1:15:47 are just count 4.06

1:15:51 million hectares

1:15:52 in between 2016 and 2021.

1:15:56 We compare with the data of 2006,

1:15:59 20

1:16:01 2015,

1:16:03 and the result,

1:16:04 additional forest cover,

1:16:05 and then we can convert it to tonsil to equivalent.

1:16:09 And there is

1:16:10 already,

1:16:11 uh,

1:16:11 we,

1:16:11 for the payment,

1:16:12 the carbon payment,

1:16:14 we use a results-based payment.

1:16:16 For the voluntary,

1:16:17 not yet.

1:16:19 So,

1:16:19 not yet.

1:16:20 So we have a presidential regulation number 98 2021,

1:16:26 and also the ministerial regulation for the implementation

1:16:29 22,

1:16:30 22 2021 also.

1:16:33 So

1:16:34 we already,

1:16:35 uh,

1:16:35 uh,

1:16:36 you know,

1:16:36 uh,

1:16:37 enjoy

1:16:38 the carbon,

1:16:39 uh,

1:16:39 payment from the,

1:16:41 uh,

1:16:41 Global Climate Fund,

1:16:42 yeah,

1:16:43 for the community,

1:16:44 and also,

1:16:45 uh,

1:16:45 FCPF FCPF,

1:16:47 and the next uh biocarbon in GMB also.

1:16:51 The most important thing is,

1:16:53 you know,

1:16:53 the,

1:16:53 the budget,

1:16:54 uh,

1:16:55 we

1:16:56 use for the adaptation and also for the mitigation.

1:16:59 As I said before,

1:17:00 for the adaptation,

1:17:02 for the,

1:17:02 uh,

1:17:02 you know,

1:17:03 training,

1:17:04 how to uh enhance the community empowerment,

1:17:07 this is,

1:17:07 uh,

1:17:07 the most.

1:17:08 And also for,

1:17:10 um,

1:17:11 selection of the species

1:17:13 related with the changing of the climate,

1:17:15 this is also very important.

1:17:17 And mitigation,

1:17:18 restoring,

1:17:19 and also alternative income for the buffer.

1:17:22 So,

1:17:23 this is my explanation.

1:17:24 Thank you.

1:17:29 Yeah,

1:17:29 hi,

1:17:29 thank you for the,

1:17:31 the question

1:17:32 on

1:17:33 how can an initiative responsible initiative look like,

1:17:36 right?

1:17:36 How can we imagine a responsible initiative in the carbon market

1:17:39 and what's the role of,

1:17:40 of,

1:17:40 uh,

1:17:41 the legal framework?

1:17:42 I think it's a.

1:17:43 The,

1:17:43 the,

1:17:44 the answer is like we talk a lot about collective action

1:17:47 in the,

1:17:48 in the

1:17:49 for climate,

1:17:49 right?

1:17:50 Collective uh we need action from

1:17:52 government,

1:17:53 from the allies of indigenous peoples,

1:17:54 local communities,

1:17:55 from local communities,

1:17:56 indigenous peoples and the private sector,

1:17:58 so.

1:17:59 The the role of the legal framework in governance is of course absolutely key

1:18:04 to regulate these markets further

1:18:06 starting by carbon rights,

1:18:08 what are the carbon rights of indigenous peoples,

1:18:10 how to secure these carbon rights and not

1:18:12 let it to interpretation or to contract negotiation,

1:18:15 uh,

1:18:16 but also in terms of registering carbon projects,

1:18:18 for example,

1:18:19 in a country,

1:18:20 so

1:18:20 you know there's a certain level of control and compliance with it,

1:18:23 so they're able to control compliance with legislation.

1:18:26 Also in terms of disclosure of information,

1:18:28 a certain to a certain extent these contracts are extremely private.

1:18:32 Do we wanna go into,

1:18:33 you know,

1:18:33 disclosing information about sharing of benefits,

1:18:35 the structuring of agreements,

1:18:37 the governance of agreements,

1:18:38 all these things the government can do

1:18:40 to,

1:18:40 uh,

1:18:41 you know,

1:18:41 improve the,

1:18:42 the,

1:18:42 the,

1:18:43 the integrity of these markets.

1:18:44 But then when it comes to the,

1:18:46 to the private sector,

1:18:47 I think,

1:18:48 um.

1:18:50 The role of the private sector should be the same

1:18:52 as the international development institutions and funders of indigenous people.

1:18:55 It's to enable indigenous communities

1:18:58 to self-determine in a way in which they can manage their

1:19:01 forests sustainably.

1:19:02 And obtain rights from that and they can make some profit from that,

1:19:06 but I think their role is to enable just in the same way as the bank enables a

1:19:10 a private entrepreneur

1:19:11 to do their business.

1:19:12 Why can't indigenous communities,

1:19:14 local indigenous people and local communities be entitled to the same kind of

1:19:18 trusting support where they get the money.

1:19:20 You know,

1:19:21 and,

1:19:21 uh,

1:19:22 and support to do what they want to do.

1:19:24 So that's how the sector should behave.

1:19:26 But maybe they,

1:19:27 you know,

1:19:27 the,

1:19:28 we also need to support indigenous communities and,

1:19:30 uh,

1:19:31 indigenous peoples in local communities need support

1:19:33 to be to level the field to be able to,

1:19:36 you know,

1:19:36 negotiate these agreements.

1:19:38 But there are examples out there.

1:19:39 Another thing that,

1:19:40 uh,

1:19:41 a responsible initiative looks like is transparency.

1:19:44 There's

1:19:45 I found an initiative as there out there,

1:19:47 a small one that has

1:19:49 all their documentation

1:19:50 on their website,

1:19:51 all the requirements,

1:19:53 how much benefits they make,

1:19:55 how many credits they sold,

1:19:57 how many,

1:19:57 how much money this is really,

1:19:59 I think what.

1:20:00 The communities and the international community is entitled to because

1:20:04 carbon credits it's not like any other good

1:20:06 we they're expected to have like uh

1:20:09 this you know

1:20:10 nonprofit contribution to the world so we

1:20:12 can't just treat them as any other commodity

1:20:14 but I think there's there's ways to

1:20:16 to

1:20:17 to improve the current situation at least.

1:20:21 Thank you so much.

1:20:22 So the organizers,

1:20:24 uh,

1:20:24 just reminded us that uh

1:20:26 we have to wrap up and I also don't want to keep you from your lunch.

1:20:30 So

1:20:31 should you have any additional questions to one of the speakers,

1:20:34 feel free to uh approach them during the lunch break.

1:20:37 Just to quickly conclude,

1:20:39 I think

1:20:39 we learned a lot about the progress uh with community

1:20:42 forestry in the respective countries that we heard about today.

1:20:46 I think the benefits are very obvious,

1:20:49 but the challenge of tenure security is still there.

1:20:52 But we are hearing that there is progress in these countries,

1:20:55 for example,

1:20:56 what Mr.

1:20:57 Andre mentioned about

1:20:59 thinking about

1:21:01 prioritizing or Making a 10 year

1:21:04 security a requirement for this program,

1:21:06 I think that's a big step in the right direction.

1:21:09 Indonesia,

1:21:10 there's a strong

1:21:11 policy pillar on the recognition of customary forests,

1:21:15 but then

1:21:16 with the carbon market,

1:21:17 it seems that there's a lot to be done.

1:21:19 But the thinking of the importance of tenure security,

1:21:24 I think is a critical

1:21:25 first step,

1:21:26 and I'm sure that in a couple of years when we reconvene for this conference,

1:21:30 we'll see hopefully a lot of progress in this regard.

1:21:34 So once again,

1:21:34 please give an applause to the speakers.

1:21:41 And thank you very much.

showAllTimestamps
no
transcript
It's already 11 minutes past 11, so we suggest to start with the next session on community forestry and land tenure security. Um, I'll give a brief introduction of myself. My name is Willem von der Muur. I'm a land tenure specialist, um, with the World Bank, currently based in Jakarta, Indonesia, where I've been for the last, uh, couple of years, um, and I think the session that we will have today is going to be very interesting, particularly given the overarching theme of our land conference, which is land and climate action. So at this land conference so far we have been speaking a lot about the role of the community and also centralizing uh local communities and indigenous peoples and I think this is particularly important to protect both critical landscapes including forest and also promoting uh livelihoods and strengthening land tenure security. And for decades now, community forestry is a program or a policy that has been implemented in many countries that basically sits at the heart of these agendas. So just very quickly, there are basically 3 rationales of why community forestry has been promoted as such a program. So first, um, community forests help protect forest cover or they help protect us, expand forest cover, and also support sustainable landscape management. And the rationale here is that local communities are often better placed to protect the forest and manage the forest they know very well rather than centralized government agencies. And the second is, um, through community forestry and particularly sustainable forestry activities, communities can boost their income and enhance their livelihoods. And then third, community forestry is also promoted as a form of enhancing access of tenure rights or land rights, either to land, forest, or natural resources within these forested landscapes. And this is on paper how community forest has been often uh described and rationalized, but often in practice things are more complicated, as many of you of course know. um. It has been promoted and implemented in many countries in the world, but research shows that these three rationales or these 3 objectives of community forestry in practice, they don't always go together. There are sometimes trade-offs. So while in many countries, community forestry has worked to expand forest cover or to protect forest cover, particularly the issue of tenure rights has sometimes been more challenging. So there are in many cases trade-offs where. Forest has been expanded as a part of or as a result of community forestry and also communities' livelihoods have been improved, but then there were some restrictions with regard to tenure rights or access so there tend to be trade offs in practice, um. So I think with the forestry programs in place in many countries, I think now is the time to really assess what has worked well and what can be done better and what is going to be the future of community forestry programs. So that's what we're going to talk about in this panel. Um, we will have um very influential uh champions from governments that will speak at the panel today from some of the countries that have some of the largest share of tropical forests remaining in the world, um, Indonesia and also Brazil. Um, and we will hear directly from their experiences as practitioners and policymakers in the realm of community forestry, and then we also have non-government speaker. Unfortunately, uh, our speaker from the Democratic Republic of Congo couldn't make it, uh, to this panel. uh, Mr. Agustin, he unfortunately did not, uh, receive his visa in time. um, so we will have speakers today from Indonesia and also from Brazil. Um, I will, uh, um, introduce the speakers now, which will each have a presentation of around 10 to 15 minutes, followed by a panel discussion in which we will take, uh, some questions from the audience. So there won't be the online feature where you can submit your questions we will do it directly as to have a more livelier discussion, um, so the first, uh, speaker today for our panel is Mr. Andre Aquino who is currently the director of forest management for the Ministry of Environment and Climate, um, in Brazil. So Mr. Andre is responsible for sustainable forest management in Brazil, a very big task, and he has only recently taken this position. So he has been working with the World Bank for over 20 years, um, and his last position within the World Bank was the practice or program leader for sustainable development in Indonesia, where he worked on forest management as well as on mangrove protection. So without further ado, I would like to give the floor to Mr. Andre. There's a lot of mischief on the move. Thank you very much. uh, good morning ladies and gentlemen. It's a great pleasure to be here, to be back to the World Bank, and to meet so many of our colleagues in particular to discuss this very engaging important and complex issue of the interplay between local communities, indigenous people and their forests. Um, I'm very glad to be here today speaking on behalf of the government of Brazil where we are making significant efforts to strengthen rights, strengthen livelihoods of local communities, and by so doing, uh, address our biggest challenge now of, of climate change, right, and biodiversity loss. So Very briefly, our forests, I mean, it's, uh, it's, it's, you know, Brazil is the 5th largest country in the world. We have more or less 58% of our country still covered in forest. It's almost 500 million hectares. It's a lot of land. And most of it in the Amazon, but not only just to be super clear about this, right, we have two tropical rainforests, the Amazon, which you all know well, and then the Atlantic rainforest, which is basically where we have the largest population concentration in Brazil like Rio Sao Paulo, um. And we have significant savannas, the most biodiverse savannas in the world, the Cerrado. And dry land forest catching, so it's a country that has, I mean, it's Brazil is a forest country, right? I mean, as, as we know, and it is important for our economy, but it's particularly important for our people. Um This map here shows uh federal forests under management by communities. Except by indigenous people, and I'll explain the difference here. So um we have 25 million hectares of forest that are managed by local communities. And these include sustainable use protected areas. They include what we call sentimentos, which are basically uh. Settlement where we did land reform. Um, and, um. Different types of protected areas, so 25 million on top of that we have 116 million hectares. Under indigenous people's land. So it's about 140 million hectares which we could say are managed by communities. And again, um, a great proportion of that. In the Amazon Now this graph here is a little bit the evolution of community forestry management in Brazil. It's not a very happy story, to be honest. uh, community forestry management has been. Touted as a, a, a significant an important tool, right, to bring these two objectives together, increase income, improve welfare, and at the same time conserve forest or increase forest cover. In the 2000s, it's a lot of that was discussed, a lot of initiatives. I mean there was the PPG7, the pilot program of the G7 for rainforests in Brazil. It was the first big global pact for uh the protection of rainforests. Uh, it was a trust fund managed by the World Bank actually, and one of the pillars was promoting community forestry and a lot was done in terms of strengthening capacity and just really testing out the model. What it meant community forestry and at that moment, to a large extent community forestry meant uh sustainable harvesting of timber, right? So there was a strong emphasis on uh basically timber. Um, so from 2005, uh, we see the area and the volume of, of wood harvested, right, so the green is the volume and the area, so we can see it has increased the area under management and the volumes have increased, but they are not huge, 200,000 cubic meters, uh, yearly, which is basically when it reached the peak. Um, so, What, what has happened, right? I mean, uh, why hasn't this, uh, taken off? Much faster since it seems I mean we we we assume that it can generate this double benefits of income and protection of force and so on. So just a little bit on our legalese, not, not to bore you a lot, but, uh, legally we had a program to promote, uh, community forestry in which was, uh, adopted in 2009, 2009. And this program annually, the way it worked is that annually the government would. Select areas. Under which I mean community forestry was already happening. But there would be support, there would be support for market access, financial support, and so on. So this went on for some time and the agency I work for, uh, the Brazilian Forest Service was doing that along with the Protected Ares agency. But in under the last government this program was canceled as many other programs dealing with rights and so on, you know what we went through, um, uh, and uh there was also a change this the Forest Service went to the Minister of Agriculture. So now under this new government, I mean, uh, there is much more emphasis on this issue and this program is being resumed. Now It's been resumed in different er with with different settings and that's what I would like to tell you a little bit so. But before that, what? Why has community forestry not taken off as much as expected? So, first is, I mean, one issue that is the essence of this conference, which is the issue of rights, right? So, um, still. Communities face threats to their rights. Um, you've seen issues of, uh, invasion of indigenous people's territories, for instance, uh, by illegal mining, sometimes agriculture, cattle ranching. But there's the issue of communi local level governance. This is something that the panel just before talked a little bit about, right? So, community capacity for collective decision. Um, It varies significantly, right? I mean we have today very strong communities. I mean with very participatory, transparent decision making processes, traditional processes, right? and others that are still, uh, moving towards that. that's something that takes time, right? It's something that I think anyone that works with this type of processes know it takes time. It takes time and it takes consistency, right? The rules need to be consistent so that the communities, uh, uh, know what to expect. Um The issue of capacity on business. So now moving from the right equa the, the, the, the right side of the equation to the business side of the equation, right? Because at the end of the day, it's about making money out of the force. This Has been, it is, is very challenging, still is, right? So, um, I like to joke that Community forestry management in the Amazon, you're dealing with. The most, some of the most spectacular logistical challenges you can imagine, right? Imagine taking a log out of the, the forest with those big rivers and. Basic roads you're dealing with a very complicated business. I mean, timber is difficult business, way more complicated than agriculture, for instance. You are dealing with the the reputation of the sector, which is not good. So even if you do it right in a proper manner, it's hard to convince people that it's been made in the right way, so. I, I like to, I, I think, and this is a little bit of my own analysis that one of the difficulties with community forestry has exactly been the focus on timber. It's a difficult business. It's a very difficult business, and, uh, even private companies struggle, right? So it, and then on top of that you have communities that have not, I mean, often really been integrated into markets, right? So they are not dealing with. I mean the business acumen on a on a daily basis, so this issue of a business capacity is very important. And then the financial returns. Um, there's been a lot of analysis on the financial returns of sustainable timber harvesting at communal level. And it's not great, it's not something that you would be running to invest in, so. Then this then also reduces really the uh the interest right of communities in, in doing that. Uh, timber is complex, market access barriers, high upfront needs. I mean, you need machinery, all of that. Non-timber forest products, great potential, but they're seasonal, uh, and, and each species is different in different markets. And then the usual forest carbon. Um, this one, I mean, we just had a panel on this, and I mean. I think that if, if, if, if there is someone who's not confused about the state of play in carbon markets, please let me know because I think I mean if anything it's gotten way more complicated, right? I mean projects jurisdiction, no voluntary, non-voluntary, it's voluntary but maybe you need to be regulated it's it's very, very confusing. We have had an issue of partnerships, unfair partnerships, very big problem, um, in the timber sector because one way of addressing some of these barriers is that communities then sign contracts, right, with companies that have the upfront finance or the machinery and so on, and there have been deals that are unfair and of course this is happening in carbon as well. And access to finance, I mean, uh. Having a loan. From even a subsidized loan from our commercial banks for forestry business is a very hard job. I mean, our community last year managed to do it with a lot of support. But it's difficult. OK, a lot of challenges. Why are we still then trying to do this? Um, because there's a lot of opportunities, right? Well, first is community forest management may supply a lot of timber to Brazil and reduce illegal timber. We have estimated that one third of the, uh, the demand, domestic demand for timber that today is provided for by the Amazon could come from community forestry. Just to be super clear, colleagues, timber in Brazil does not, I mean, most of timber from Brazil does not come from the. Amazon, it's planted forest. We have 9 million of very, very super productive, uh, fast growing species, and that's basically what supplies our timber needs. But some comes from the Amazon sustainable timber management. And what I'm trying to say here is that part of that, a significant part of that could come from community lands. And then there's the issue of carbon. I mean, there was the question yesterday about how much carbon is stored in, uh, communi community lands, right? We did that for Brazil and we came to a lower figure of, uh, twice the annual Brazil, the annual emissions of Brazil stored in the forest carbon held by local communities and indigenous people. Um, the enabling environment in Brazil is very conducive for this now. We have a number of new instruments that are being put in place. We have a bioeconomy initiative that is all about empowering local communities, giving access to credit. We're working with our national bank, Banco de Brazil, in establishing new credit lines for communities. The Bendes, the National Development Bank, has been providing new, uh, source of funding, uh, uh, for this. Uh, we have a new plan to reduce deforestation. That's, I mean, one of the most important thing, and it has already achieved, uh, results. I mean, we are glad to announce that deforestation has reduced by 25%, the lowest level since 2018, um, and. The, we also have a new law on traditional communities that's being, uh, not a law, sorry, a, uh, a new plan, uh, uh, for that. So supportive enabling environment. We believe that this increasing demand for ethical trade for uh uh products, I mean natural products, it, it, it's on the, on the, on the rise right internationally and in Brazil, so there's increased demand, particularly for non-timber forest products. I like to talk about acai. I mean, by now everyone knows just go down the, the, the, the road here and I mean a few years ago you would think that this is an indigenous language when actually it is, right, but now we know what it is, um. New source of funding and then there is still the issue of payments for ecosystem services. So one of the things that in Brazil we are trying to shift the conversation towards is not talk about carbon markets so much but payment for ecosystem services more broadly. We have a new law on payment for ecosystem not law again, uh, we have the regulation of a law. The law had already been passed and, uh, we are looking into how to make PES work for traditional. And in the communal territories. We have successful initiatives. I mean, after these years, many years of support, many of you guys here, I mean, uh, uh, the World Bank, the IADB, the Germans, uh, uh, the USA have been very, uh, uh, supportive of, of this agenda. The, the, we have, uh, some blueprints of communities that manage that forest and make significant funding. So it's a matter of scaling that up. It is doable. And uh this issue is super important and very exciting to see. I mean, communities in the Amazon have a much higher level of capacity today than 1220 years ago, right? So we're talking about a different level of engagement with these communities. We're talking about a, a very different type of dialogue with them. And, um, and this is the agency I work, we have, uh, Brazil has amassed a lot of experience with forced concessions. We are very different from Indonesia, for instance, that has decades of concessions. Concessions in Brazil are relatively new. Uh, but now we have 15 years of experience and a lot of the instruments we use in concessions like traceability, uh, uh, monitoring of timber, uh, how the contracts are made, they can be used in community forestry. So basically with all of this in mind, um, we are now proposing what we call Community forestry 2.0, a new program. Focused on the multiple use of force. Um, So not only timber, non-timber forest products, and serve ecosystem services by traditional people in communities, strengthening local governance, governance of the territories, right? So, uh, decision making, um, yesterday, right, there was a talk about FPI, so the government is trying to. Internalize that into protocols, uh. That, uh, I used, right, whenever engaging with local communities, uh, for different types of deals, right? Payment for ecosystem services, uh, timber or whatever. And this is a little bit of the program. I mean it's in the making, uh, but it would have a uh forest economy promotion pillar business, institutional capacity and strengthening the capacity of uh cooperatives, associations, uh, uh, local, uh, enterprises. Local governance. We are talking now about bio hubs, so basically you would have The protected area in the area around it being supported through access to finance, technical assistance, and so on. Development of inclusive businesses, including legal institutional support for communities to engage in. Businesses in deals, right? If they want, right? If, if, if they seek that, um, knowledge management and research and development. I guess my time's come to an end just to conclude that uh uh the the government of Brazil and the Brazilian and the Ministry of Environment and the Forest Service has made this whole discussion again on bioeconomy a centerpiece of our agenda and we are also bringing it globally so as many of you know, Brazil is the president of the G20 this year we took over from Indonesia, India. And now it's Brazil. Next year it's South Africa, so it's 4 years of developing countries in the presidency of the G20. And, uh, just like Indonesia brought oceans to the agenda big time, Brazil is bringing this topic of bioeconomy. So we launched a global initiative on bioeconomy and uh in in the G20, and we are discussing the high level principles of bioeconomy, what it means, uh, really because it's a term that's used in a very different manner. But for us, uh, in particular the Forest Service to a large extent it's the sustainable use of, uh, forest resources again for the benefit of local people, indigenous people, and with respect to their rights. Thanks a lot. Thank you so much uh Andre for a very interesting, uh, presentation. I think the challenges uh are very clear in Brazil but also some of the uh results so far but we will discuss it more in depth during the, uh, discussion. Let's move now to, uh, another side of the world, uh, in an equally fast, uh country. Indonesia, um, our next speaker is Doctor Bambang Supriyanto, who is the director general of Social forestry of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry and before, uh, we invite Bambang to the stage, just a little bit of context. So, um, I assume many of you were yesterday also in the room when the minister of land from Indonesia presented on the significant progress with land registration in Indonesia. The social forestry program in Indonesia is actually part of the same program which is the agrarian reform program, and the forest area in Indonesia, the area that the state has designated to be a forest, is actually 63% of the country. And inside this area 12.7 million hectares have been assigned for social forestry and customary forest. And in the last couple of years, uh, the Ministry of Environment and Forestry has really. Scaled up both social forestry as well as the recognition of indigenous land rights, and Mr. Bambang, who's going to present on the challenges and results of this program, has been there since the beginning. So he's been 7 years now director general if I'm not mistaken, and this actually coincides with the start of this program, so he has a very rich experience and we're very excited to hear directly from him how Indonesia has managed to accelerate this program, please, Mr. Bambang. Thank you, Mr. William. Uh, it is my pleasure to be one of the speaker together with, uh, Mr. Andre from Brazilian, uh, government and also Gabriela from the Global Alliance, uh, Landscape Alli Alliance. Uh, as a representative of Indonesia, uh, please allow me to present the policy implementation. Of how community forestry can strengthen sustainable landscape management and land tenure security in Indonesia. The number of the villages in Indonesia is more than 83 million. Uh, 83,000 villages, of which almost 26,000 villages are located around or in forest area of 120 million hectares where 36.7 is classified as underdeveloped with the several cases of the neural conflict. Due to limited forest utilization and inequality between private consensus and community access of 43 million hectares. Then, since 2015, the government launched a social forestry program with a target of 12.7 million hectares or 30% of permitted forest utilization by 2030. Social forestry began in the late 90s focused on community empowerment. However, lacking in the microfinance and market. And also contribution to the economic development. Then since 2015, the government of Indonesia has improved and made several breakthrough through the issuance of the ministerial regulation Number 839 and 4 2023 and the presidential regulation Number 28-2023 regarding acceleration of social forestry management. Social forestry includes Acknowledgement of customary forests, which aim to guarantee their living area, preserving ecosystem, both forest and and environment, and also protecting the local wisdom and traditional knowledge related to the forest. In order to ensure the community sustainable forest management, it should be supported with the three, pillar activity, land use access, capacity building to human resources, and collaboration for the investment, microfinance, and also market opportunities. Social forestry social forestry permit is for 35 years. During the period, the farmer group received a facilitation, not only from the government, but also from the governance, uh, NGO and also private for the establishment of the community institutional management system. Forest management with one village and one cluster communities, and establishment of business plan, which is useful to build microfinance investment cooperation, and off-taker market cooperation. The long-term output of sustainable forest management of social forestry indicated by decreasing. The tenureural conflict, enhancing the land uh cover, and increasing the community income. The achievement of social forestry is almost 6.7 million hectares and more than 1.3 million households already involved. While in the achievement of acknowledgement of customary forest is 240,000 hectares for 138. Customary law communities. These communities established social forestry business group to work together as a team to enhance their livelihood. In current time, there are more than 13,000 social forestry business groups that divided into four classifications, beginning implementation, sustain, and self-standing. There are several challenges faced, uh, by the social forestry program toward 2030. The first is acceleration of social forestry access distribution. The target is 12.7, now it's 6.7. So we have, uh, uh, 45% left. So we, we, we have, uh, 7 years, the time to finish this agrarian reform. And the second is to, uh, for the quality improvement of Social forestry Business Group. And the 3rd is the increased utilization of the forest productivity and added value for the regional economic and climate change adaptation and mitigation action. Presidential Regulation Number 28, 2023 and its implementation is designated strategy to overcome those challenges, including the approach of integrated area development that has three focused collaboration, which are alignment of policy and regulation across sector and headquarter and also local government, and then also budget allocation for the social forestry. And integrating social forestry into national and regional development planning document. I'll give you one example in integrated area development of Lumaja is Jaffa, the landscape approach of Agro-Silver pastoral and agro-industry and promoting a network of eco-tourism package sector yielded per capita for ₹3.7 million per month per household or above the poverty line. And also providing the, uh, increase the employment and also increased contribution of, uh, various sector. We developed the GOCCups as the National Register System for the Social forestry, data updating, monitoring, evaluation, and also information sources and publication of the social forestry performance as the basis of the policy determination reported by its facilitator in real-time. There was a survey that was conducted by Katadata, one of the media and research company in Indonesia in 2020 before COVID. The rule or Uh, the role of the facilitator was very important, and after 5 years of receiving social forestry license or permit, the income has elevated to 72% or twice higher than before. As a consequence of the social capital in the forest area, the community communally protect the area from the illegal logging, illegal mining, and also forest fire. This can contribute to the climate mitigation action. Since 2021, the Ministry of Environment and, uh, Forestry developed the systematic and integrated approach in the management of the forest and other land use sector toward emission level that called Indonesia follow NETSE 2030. This approach is projected to contribution almost 60% or equivalent with a minus 140 million tons of CO2 equivalent or net sin by 2030 from the total greenhouse gas emission reduction target that Indonesia wants to achieve through its own effort. In line with this plan to achieve the 2030 social forestry target of 12.7 million hectares, it is hoped that the contribution of social forestry will be around 24.6 million, uh, ton of CO2 equivalent or 18%. 4 million hectares of social forestry are targets of Indonesia polu netsing. That action is divided into two actions, namely adaptation. Uh, as a precondition and mitigation action that is carried out with a strategy of implementing sustainable forest management, carbon stock, and also peatland and high conservation value forests. We also do assessment to forecast the carbon trend in targeted social forested area in volumeting 2030 between 2006, 2021. This calculation indicates, uh, a positive contribution to increasing forest cover, which can convert it into reducing emissions by approximately 32 million tons of CO2 equivalent. The strategy of adaptation and mitigation action of social forestry targeted area, if the uh pri primary forest, keep it as a forest, build the alternative income in the buffer zone. Secondary forest is for the carbon enhancement through enrichment, uh, planning program. And the community activities are forest restoration as a form of the climate mitigation. One of the best practices for the, uh, for the improvement of land cover is in community forest in Yogyakarta in, uh, Central Java. From 2006 to 2021, there was a positive trend from dryland farming to the, uh, plantation forest. This research indicate that the community activities are able to control land, uh, conserve, uh, conversion activity in the forest area and can improve the quality of the forest cover from non, uh, non-forest agriculture to agroforestry and plantation forests. That is my presentation. Thank you for the listening. Thank you so much Doctor Bambang. I think that was a very, uh, impressive story. So 6.7 million hectares of social forestry schemes already allocated to Indonesia in the last couple of years and a plan to scale this up even further to reach 12.7 million hectares and what I think was very interesting as well is how the social forestry. Program in Indonesia is directly linked to the country's climate change mitigation and adaptation agenda, and I personally would be interested to hear more about this and also how these two different angles come into play with social forestry um in Indonesia. So we now move on to our third speaker which is Gabriela Rodriguez Eklund from uh Brazil. So Gabriela is currently the technical director of the Global Land Alliance. She's a geographer and land governance, uh, professional, and she worked previously in the tenure facility and several development banks, including the World Bank as well. Um, and she is focused on enhancing land tenure security, um, particularly for indigenous peoples and local communities, and her presentation today will continue to talk about community forestry, uh, a little bit more in a global perspective, but also focus on the issue. Of the voluntary carbon markets which Andre earlier already alluded to is something that confuses many of us and particularly the issue of land tenure within those schemes is going to be uh very challenging. So without further ado, please Gabriela, the floor is yours. Hi, good morning, everyone. Uh, very pleased to be here and to hear the very interesting presentations from Brazil and Indonesia. Uh, yeah, the voluntary carbon market has been already in the 2nd day, very much in the focus of this conference, right? Much as a very big risk and threat for indigenous and local communities. But here I would like to bring, try to bring a more holistic perspective, bringing also the dimension of the private sector together with that of indigenous communities and local communities and the government. This is based on a perspective note that we are preparing currently at the Global Land Alliance to highlight some of the major impediments that we think are some of the major impediments to responsible investments and what kind of new actions we can, you know, think about and uh initiate to address these impediments. So first of all, very quick, uh. OK, so, uh, very quick background. This is, uh, so very quick background. I don't need to repeat very much what has become the, you know, a fact except in this conference that. We know that indigenous and local communities customarily hold much of the world tropical forests and are to be trusted as for forest gardens because their livelihoods depend on this forest, their culture, their identity, so it is a question of survival why they have to defend this forest and it's OK and it is, uh, you know, there is plenty of scientific evidence now showing that, you know, forests that are held by indigenous local communities are better conserved. But we also know that securing land rights of local communities, indigenous peoples is key for social justice, the environment, and livelihoods as well. So taking a global perspective, you know, we have seen a lot of progress and, and challenges in, in, in Brazil and Indonesia. There has been progress in the recognition of forest tenure. Uh, this is shown by, you know, the tenure tracking tool that is kept by, uh, the Rights and Resources Initiative. Uh, the, the lands designated for indigenous peoples and local communities have increased from 1% to 4% of forest areas, and those owned by indigenous people's local communities increased from 18% to 24%, uh, between 2002 and 2017. However, many of these lands still remain to be recognized. Legal frameworks are not complete. Some countries don't recognize those rights. Some countries lack the regulations to make that recognition happen on the ground. But also the devolution of rights, the level of devolution is also limited. We talk about community forestry. It can include different degrees of devolution of rights from very limited participation to significant participation to more devolution of land rights and full ownership. So here again we have to see land terror as a bond of rights. So clearly much action is still needed to continue securing these rights. And the question is now about the voluntary carbon market. Is it really an opportunity or a threat for indigenous peoples? Clearly now it's mostly seen as a threat, right? So before I start, a very quick background to try to, you know, for those who are not familiar with this very complex beast that is the voluntary carbon market, really. So basically, since the start of the Kyoto Protocol, we know that you know market mechanisms have been developed to try to finance reduction of emissions from deforestation as a financing mechanism. We have both compliance markets that have taken a longer time to develop because of all the regulatory part. It's very complex. In the meanwhile, voluntary carbon markets have taken off, and these are markets where basically Polluters buy credits from projects to meet voluntary targets, contrary to the compliance market, where they are trying, either governments or the private sector, they are trying to meet required targets from the legal framework of their international commitments in the NDCs. So this market includes a huge number of actors. Uh, from, you know, the funders and investors of projects to communities on the ground, uh, project proponents who are implementing the projects who can be in the communities or not, project developers who are, you know, helping prepare all the technical documentation calculations to submit to the registries, and then you have the independent validation bodies that have to, you know, validate these documents to submit to the registries, but also. Verify the emission reductions to, you know, get the credits issued. You have the registries which are who have, by the way, different standards, not only one standard. You have 4 big registries of which, uh, you know, Vera and the gold standard, for example, those lots of very small registries, and then you have also the rating agencies that have appeared to actually provide services to the buyers. To rate the credits that have been rated by the credit agencies, the registries, uh, you have brokers who can, this is a speculative market, it's something very important to know right now, you know, you can, the, the, the, the, the brokers can buy credits and wait until the price increases to sell them in the market, which raises big questions about, you know, the ethics when it comes to distributing benefits to local communities and indigenous peoples, right? Uh, you have the buyers and now recently you have initiatives to enhance the integrity and the transparency of the market, so it's a very complex market and on top of that, you know, they can have conflict of interest between these markets. Some actors take different roles. You have developers who are also brokers and investors at the same time in projects, uh, at the same time, communities can be proponents or not. It's extremely difficult to navigate actually. So, um. When it comes to forestry, you know, community forestry in general, in the voluntary carbon market, uh, looking at the, this is the data is wrong, the report from last year for, uh, ecosystem Marketplace which issued these annual reports, the forestry and land use projects which includes REDD projects, afforestation, reforestation, revenue. Vegetation and improved forest management, which is really what you know concerns indigenous peoples and local communities. It's the largest they represent the largest volume of, uh, credits traded in the voluntary market, and most of these credits are actually traded, uh, have been registered by IEA, one of the major registries, 73%, uh, last year they recorded 381 projects in this category. Under 22 standards in 43 countries and uh the largest number of red projects uh the red projects among these projects are also the last in terms of number of credits sorry one thing is the the volume trader, the other is the number of credits. The red projects represent the largest number of credits each in the voluntary carbon market. They have actual actually very high price. There is a high, high demand for these credits. Uh, most of the credits last year was issued in South America. Brazil had the high, the highest number of projects. Indonesia had the highest number of, uh, credits issued, uh, but also in, I guess, in Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa. So it's really like the developing countries that these projects are coming from. Um, but really, so. There's a lot of volume and things happening in the volatile carbon market, and the question again is really. Does the voluntary carbon market represent an opportunity or risk given you know the large amount of financing coming from these private companies? So in 2020, the volume um traded was $2 billion. It's expected to increase to $250 billion by 230. I don't, I'm not gonna say this is right, it's just a prediction, but, and the market was, you know, really under crisis last year. But basically, you know, in theory, in principle, if this market worked well, we could think in an ideal world that it would help mobilize funds to secure the tenure under for, you know, communities and local and, uh, indigenous peoples. Uh, it could also help reach these communities in a more direct way, in the same way that, you know, private businesses get funds from banks and funds. They don't need to go through all these rules. They're more flexible again, if it was well regulated and well functioning, transparent, the funds could reach directly indigenous peoples. The payments. Could crucially, right, the payments for reduction of emissions are very long term. So that means the sustainable income for communities to maintain the security in their territories which is also intrinsically linked to actually the success of community forestry. So to sustain the security and to sustain the the the community forestry we need tenure security. And it could also be ideally a driving force to push for a higher recognition of rights by governments, for example, because of all the investments that could come to these communities. However, we know it's been very well expressed in this conference. We have big problems right now with the current market. The projects tend to be, I have to highlight these projects and projects. You can have very good projects in the voluntary carbon market, but right now it's under scrutiny because there's a great number of projects that are, you know, basically grabbing community land without respecting their land rights, without respecting. These projects are very top down. They are not identified most often from the communities, but from, you know, to maximize the amount of mitigation from the land cover. And, um, so there's no, no ethic process or very poor ethic process being done in this market and in the last couple of years really, uh, the market has been under intense scrutiny by indigenous peoples and local communities, I think more than ever before. Um, and also there's very you know removing the fact that very rarely, uh, local communities are owners or co-owners of these projects but they should really should be based on their customary rights. They have also very little or uh you know, remuneration from these projects uh in fact, they're starting to, you know, um. Um, uh, oppose that and, and, and actually it's not just, you know, the community as a whole, but we also start questioning the internal benefit sharing. So when a community receives incomes, what happens at the level of the community inside the community? How are these benefits being distributed? Uh, so, and also there's a danger given what's happening now. There is a call for higher, you know, higher scale projects, higher speed, efficiency, and the search for profit. So this problem might worsen if we don't address, you know, the deep causes of this, you know, irresponsible investments. So what I would like to highlight here, I think at the conference we, it, it's very, it's very clear and we keep telling the private sector you have to respect FEC. You have to respect land rights. Land rights have to be recognized, but we are talking different languages. They are in a different sector. There is no dialogue between those sectors, and we are not aware enough of the actual other causes beyond the lack of intention. Beyond the fact that they might not care about indigenous rights, what is really causing this incapability of acting responsibly when you have very strong legal frameworks, international conventions, standards, lots of documents? What is happening? Why are they acting this way? We need to look closer and to talk to the sector as well. So, uh, first set of, uh, impediments are the classic ones that lie in the weak, you know, uh, governance of land. And here we, we talk a lot about, about the government government policies. So we have a gap in recognition, uh, not only the land rights are not recognized, but the carbon rights are rarely explicitly recognized in legislation. There's a gap in formalization, so basically, you know, there might be a law, but the rights are actually not all the way recognized up to having, you know, either a title or a concession on whatever, you know, uh, constitutes the full, you know, security, legal security of that right. Uh, you also have irregularity and uncertainty. You have irregular titles and concessions of competing planes. An actor in the private sector for them. Property equals title so if they have a title they think they have a proof of property and you know when one looks closely and and starts searching on cases you might have documentation that says they have a title, but actually you have a lot of underlying claims and conflicts and they are absolutely not aware of that. Uh, finally there's an information gap because when you're doing the due diligence of a project in the private sector you need to look for information. You don't have cadastral services, registries, you know, maps. There's been, there's efforts right now, for example, you know, landmark to map to put up there the amount of information that is in the polygons of indigenous lands, but they don't know where to look for the information. So how to do a due diligence if there's no access to information of where indigenous lands are. Uh, but now I think we need to go deeper and look at what are the problems, you know, inside the sector, the lack of capacity. So we always say, you know, indigenous peoples need to be supported, etc. and that's crucial, and the governments too, but what's happening in that sector. We have insufficient or equivocal requirements on land and related rights actually, so the standards, when you read the requirements, they started being developed very recently. This industry started really focusing on the environment and on accurate accounting of carbon emissions reductions. So they spent millions of dollars to get those methodologies and requirements right and only recently they realized that social requirements are important and co-benefits are important. So there's a, it's very not very present and the way in these these requirements are written are very top down and very, they don't, you know, not compatible with the best, best international practices. Uh, and now we have, uh, last year in initiative from the Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market trying to, to bring this core carbon principles that basically every carbon registry will need to have to have an ethical seal to sell their credits in the market. So this has been developed with the part. of indigenous peoples and local communities, but still it's very recent. It's going to be tested, and I think it needs to be very closely monitored on whether it's really up to the up to the intentions of protecting land rights. There's requirements for land rights that are in there, but we need to monitor how they are being implemented. Then the implementation of land related retirements is lagging behind in the in the voluntary market obviously based on the violations, uh, but also yeah, based on the the way in which these policies are are written and some, some, uh, potential causes of that are limited knowledge and understanding of tenure requirements. I mean this is a very complex word, the tenure rights, bundle of rights, you know, people outside the land tenure in international development are not familiar with these concepts. It's completely they're completely oblivious to that in general. So how to do due diligence if they don't even know what they're talking about? Uh, there are insufficient or inadequate guidelines and tools for due diligence. Actually, many tools have been developed recently. There's information and reports and guidelines for the private sector for responsible land investment in general, but, uh, we have to wonder what it's written in the language that is, you know. Proper for the private sector that is adapted for their understanding and also I think they might be suffering from an information overload given that these people are focused on very efficient investments so. Uh, I think there's a need for developing for repackaging the existing guidelines and tools for due diligence of, you know, these projects actually, so developing very specific tools for or with them to be able to do this due diligence and also maybe there is a difficulty for accessing, you know, the required expertise because you need very, you know, specific expertise to do the due diligence of these projects and understand. The legal framework of Indonesia, Colombia, Republic of Congo, Solomon Islands, wherever you are doing an investment. Um, and finally, of course, the cost and time of due diligence FPI, uh, it's, it's very expensive. It's not compatible with the for-profit logic, and maybe that we have to explore some ways of, uh, you know, complementing, preparing the communities for the market so that I think as Ramos was saying in a presentation this morning that, you know, ideally we would not want these investments to from the tenure facility to happen without the rights being recognized before. Uh, and finally, there's a limited information and transparency. The, the maps of projects, the polygons are available in most of the standards, but you have to dig for them. Why not have a map, you know, that displays all the existing projects since these are public anyway? They should be more easily available to increase accountability. And also in terms of distribution of benefits and agreement terms, those are completely intransparent, and that doesn't help the accountability of community representatives and it doesn't allow community members to keep their community representatives accountable as well. So there's a lot of limitations that are much more specific that I think we need to start thinking about if we want to really address this issue. In addition to continue pushing for respect of rights. A advocacy of course is extremely important. And finally, so these are three stakeholders, right? The governments, the the stakeholders in the carbon market, and indigenous peoples in local communities, as you know, many presentations are highlighting in this in this conference, uh, there is a lack of rights recognition of access to financial resources, access to that information and knowledge and expertise, because really they should be the ones initiating these projects and engaging the carbon market and not the other way around. Um, so there's a lot of the parenting that needs to change. So you know I'm going to highlight 5 actions here that we're thinking of presenting, you know, and, uh, as a call for action. This doesn't exclude the need obviously to continue making progress on, on governance and on, you know, enabling indigenous peoples to self-govern their resources, you know, to determine what kind of projects they want to do, who they want to sell the benefits to, and all that. So but this is a new actions, so this is why I want, I wanted to highlight them. So one example would be a review and evaluation of the land 1 requirements from major standards and the core carbon principles, um. To including yeah because they they're starting to be implemented so. And another one will be to package guides and develop tools for and with actors in the voluntary carbon market. Uh, basically to give them the tools and higher capacity and efficiency to be able to do this due diligence. Another possible action is actually to try to, you know, create a global centralized database on, uh, of carbon projects to increase the transparency and accountability, including for indigenous communities, you know, and their supporters to see, you know, what's, what's already out there and violating their rights first and also, you know, if anything new comes up that conflicts with their actual customary or legal rights. Another possible action is the community driven mapping of carbon resources and rights. So I think, uh, I don't know if, um, it was mentioned in the Brazil presentation, but also before that, you know, the, the, the old sometimes the old ways of doing capacity building and not necessarily work. We need to work on that in different ways. Maybe one day is learning by doing and this would be like. An exercise, you know, to both build capacity on the complex voluntary carbon market but also to make planning of resources in the present and for the future and to manage to integrate this market in a in a just way. And finally, uh, very important, tenure security needs to be included as a basis, uh, basic activity actually of car because it's the basis for the success of community forestry, right, and as a co-benefit of carbon projects, um, so sorry, I'm, I'm over time and, uh, but I maybe can add more when, when we have our discussion. Thank you. Check. Thank you so much, uh, Gabriela, for a very interesting presentation. I particularly like the, uh, 5 action points at the end of your presentation. I think that's very, uh, powerful to really, uh, advocate for, for concrete action into, uh, improving, uh, these programs. So we're now starting our panel discussion with 3, very interesting speakers with very interesting presentations on community forestry. Um, so we will, uh, open the floor for a few rounds of questions before doing that, so I will take the opportunity myself to ask a question to the speakers. Uh, one thing that I find particularly interesting in the presentations that we've seen is this issue of indigenous peoples. Rights and we've seen sort of a differentiation between on the one hand, community forestry programs and then on the other hand, indigenous people's land tenure and there is sort of an intersection between them, but from the policy framework there seems to be some kind of differentiation and I was wondering myself, indigenous peoples. Already have a collective territory which they already control and manage, and they know how to manage the resources. So the question then would be why would they need a government-driven community forestry program if they already have the. To do it themselves and how does the policy in Brazil and in Indonesia tackle this issue. So that's that's my first question. Maybe Pamang, I see you are already grabbing a microphone but pointing to Andre. Bambang, do you want to take this question? Thank you. OK, thank you. We use customary people rather than indigenous people in Indonesia and the government through agrarian reform. Uh, to accelerate the acknowledgement of the customary, uh, forest. So according to our act, the Customary, uh, forests should be given to the customary people or other people as long as they, they, uh, fulfill four requirements. The first is there is a community, uh, they have a leader, they have, uh, territory, and then they have, uh, legal, uh, local wisdom and also traditional forest relative to the, uh, forest. And last is, uh, they have a community. And all of these should be recognized by, uh, local regulations, local regulation. Until now, yes, since 2016, we already give to the customary forests to the 138. Uh, the total area is 240,000 hectares. And we have also indicative area. This is submitted by the NGO, uh, as a facilitator of them. Actually, the map is 20.6 million hectares, and then we have to clarify together in the fields, and we already indicate at least 1.2 million hectares for the indigenous or customary people in Indonesia. So the policy has already mainstream for the customary people over there. Thank you. Yep, just uh very briefly. Most of the um. Custom most most of the collective forest lands, uh, in Brazil, they are under indigenous people's management by far so it's 115 million. And the rest is 25 million, so it's 5 times more, right? So, um. But the issue of the recognition of IP rights is is indeed something that I didn't discuss. I focused in our program, this community forest management focuses really more on the. Um, let's say the business side of things, right, so it's the generation of value from standing for whether through, uh. Products value chains timber, non-timber, uh, or ecosystem services right so that's more and now to do that a whole range of things are needed so access to finance. So this whole issue like in Indonesia with the coup right the like access to um small and medium enterprises so it's a lot in our case it's a lot about working with um entities that promote small and medium enterprises uh banks. And this territorial approach as a way of um. Now here at the World Bank they are using the word like productive alliances. It was the, the, there was a word before, but anyway, these ideas of like a territorial element because you're gonna have a processing factory that will, uh, serve a number of communities. So this program is much more linked to this issue on the IP recognition and, uh, we have colleagues here from the Ministry of uh yeah, one thing that I should have mentioned actually yesterday and today. Brazil now has a ministry for the first time, a ministry of indigenous affairs, right? So it's the, and, uh, the minister actually was supposed to come here, Sonaguaajara, but she didn't because, as you know, we are having, uh, a natural disaster going on. But so we have a full ministry and the process of recognition of indigenous people's territories continue. Now It's complicated, right? More and more so because, uh, now, uh, many of the areas where, where you still have claims for recognition, they are on the contested areas, so it takes time. But again, that's not so much what this program will look at it takes that as like a given, let's say it like. Actually, sorry, this is a super important point because we're just discussing all the criteria of eligibility and there will be a criteria for the program that some sort of rights will need to be ascertained before. So we will not deal with that. That will be the minister of indigenous affairs. Thanks. Please, please, and, and, and just very quickly also, you, you mentioned a lot about the compliance issue and, and the lack of ethic, but you at the same time mentioned that the carbon markets could also be an opportunity for the IP. So if you could briefly touch upon that, that would be, that would be great. I think. Is it working? No. What I meant, I mean, potentially the voluntary market can mobilize billions of dollars from the private sector to finance, you know, conservation. Tenure co-benefits sustainable forest management, and there are actually initiatives that are, you know, channeling money, for example, directly to agroforestry to do that, but I think the, the lack of compliance doesn't mean that the market cannot channel resources in a responsible way. It's the, it's a very immature market, extremely unregulated, completely wild, and I think, and also. There's many things we can question also about the carbon market. I mean, there's, uh, for example, the, the, the red plus is being, um, there's a big question in terms of, uh, additionality, permanence permanence, and the ability to actually estimate realistically the amount of carbon because forest ecosystems are uncertain. Political events, political changes, changes of governments, what they can do to a big forest in the country is completely uncertain. So these baselines that are set by part of carbon projects that are being attacked, they will never be realistic and certain actually. So the, the, the way of treating itself is being questioned and, uh, there was a very important paper actually published last year in Science saying that forest ecosystems are very uncertain. And we need to think about another way to measure actually the emission reductions from red focusing on resilience because what what makes systems sustainable is resilience. You need to finance the resilience factors and tenure is a key resilience factor. So I think there's a very important argument for tenure in red, but you know when we haven't found a way to make these markets responsible, they are there. The investors, despite the crisis last year because of all the scrutiny in the, in the carbon market. The clients want to continue purchasing high quality. There's a high demand for high quality carbon that was in the ecosystem marketplace report. So whether we like or not this market, the demand is there. It's unregulated. If it's allowed, it needs to, it needs to behave and if we can help it behave better, I think indigenous peoples and local communities will be better off. Thank you. So let's now open the floor. We have a microphone, uh, here in front. So if there's anyone from the audience that would like to ask a question to either one of the speakers or to all speakers, um, please step forward and, uh, quickly introduce yourself, um, um, ask the question, and also, um, if addressed to anyone, please, uh, mention to whom it is addressed so we can do a first round of perhaps let's say 3 questions. Who would like to step forward first and break the ice here. That microphone is waiting. Right Uh Hello everyone, uh, my name is Solange. I'm the president of the Rights and Resources Initiative. Happy to be here and thank you very much to all the panelists for the great presentations. I have many questions, but I'll just ask one and give the floor to others. Uh, I wanted to ask to Andres from Brazil. Uh, Brazil will be hosting, uh, COP 30 in 2025, and I would like to know how forests will be at the center of the agenda, but also the rights of indigenous peoples and local communities and what will be their involvement. Thank you. Yes, yes, yes. Thank you, Solange. Any other, uh. Questions from the audience at this point? Yes. Hi, so a question for Gabriela though I think the other speakers may be interested to weigh in as well. You mentioned the opportunity to work with actors in the voluntary carbon market to establish some of this commitment to recognizing tenure rights for indigenous peoples and local communities. I'm curious to hear you say more about what that could look like and from if the other panelists are interested, um, possible connections to national legal frameworks on carbon trading that can do that, can center tenure rights as a precondition. So Let's, let's, let's see if there's one more question from the audience before we, we, we'll take the, the first round of answers. Please Peter Van Nostrom, Delft University of Technology, it was mentioned several times that the tenure aspect is very important. I also heard about good progress in Indonesia and Brazil in the registration. What are the gaps that still need to be addressed in formalizing or recording? The tenure aspect. OK. OK, thanks. So perhaps let's, uh, start with, um, Andre. So the question on COP 30 and how Brazil is planning to, uh, centralize forest and the issue of indigenous people rights uh around this agenda. No, thanks a lot, Solange, because that gives me the chance to talk a little bit about this, right, because that for that one we have a very good response, um. So, uh, Brazil is really taking the opportunity of COP 30, the first COP in the Amazon to bring force to the forefront, right, of climate action and not only at the COP. I mean, as I said, Brazil is the president of the G20 this year, and again we are bringing this topic, the initiative on bioeconomy is about this. Brazil has set up a task force. It's called the task force. The task force. To mobilize action against climate, so it's like a a different group within the G20 bringing together for the first time ministers of finance, environment, and central banks together of all the G20 nations. So like for the United States you have the Federal Reserve with the EPA, Department of the Interior, and so on coming to these meetings extremely. Interesting. And the good thing about the G20 is that it's not negotiation, right? It's the non-negotiation sphere. It's not the COP. So the idea is to focus much more on implementation. So we are using that, uh, to bring climate action and forests to the forefront. COP 30 and participation of indigenous people, um, the, some of the groups, the, the coalitions of indigenous people in Brazil like AIB and COA, they are planning very, very big events. I just heard actually last week that they are planning that they're gonna have an event of 12,000 indigenous people uh around the COP, so the participation of indigenous people will be big. How will the government ensure that there is a linkage between whatever right civil society organizes and the official process? We have something that we call the social cop. It's like a concept we have in Brazil's the socioeconomic forum, right? I mean, we used to organize that and, uh, for the G20, we are gonna have that. So there's the official summit of the leaders, the, the, the, but there's gonna be a social one before that and that. Uh, event formalizes like a, uh, the, the list of recommendations to the leaders, and it's a super complex governance that, uh, like filters and it's all led by civil society including some indigenous people's organizations so COP 30 will have a lot of, uh, of participation of indigenous people and one thing to what we are trying to bring to the table on forests, it's an alternative to forest carbon. So Brazil has launched the COP 28, the tropical forest forever facility. Um, we have now just set up a steering committee with the some of the largest tropical nations Indonesia, DRC, Ghana, Malaysia, Colombia, um, and, uh, uh, uh, industrial countries, uh, the US, uh, UK, France, uh, Norway, and a few others. And uh it's, it's a new mechanism that's trying to uh create value. I mean, basically reward tropical forest countries for maintaining forest cover, but it's not based on carbon, and I can talk to you more about this later, OK. Bambang, please. OK, thank you, uh, William. So there are two questions related to Indonesia. The one is about the land registration for the social forestry. We have a national registration system, uh, what we call as COOs, and, uh, those, uh, results will be put into one map policy together with, uh, ATR, uh, with, uh, non, uh, land, uh, registration. So in, put it into one. Um, the most important thing is the gap is not only giving the access, but the facilitation, how the sustainable forest management can be conducted by the community, uh, in a proper way. That's why the government assigned the facilitator, uh, facilitator, government or non-government organization with the incentive of them. So institutional setup and then forest management and how to link with the, you know, for the Uh, income for the better life of them. This is, uh, the first question, and the second for the carbon. So we already measure the contribution of the social forestry, 6.7 million hectares, but we are just count 4.06 million hectares in between 2016 and 2021. We compare with the data of 2006, 20 2015, and the result, additional forest cover, and then we can convert it to tonsil to equivalent. And there is already, uh, we, for the payment, the carbon payment, we use a results-based payment. For the voluntary, not yet. So, not yet. So we have a presidential regulation number 98 2021, and also the ministerial regulation for the implementation 22, 22 2021 also. So we already, uh, uh, you know, uh, enjoy the carbon, uh, payment from the, uh, Global Climate Fund, yeah, for the community, and also, uh, FCPF FCPF, and the next uh biocarbon in GMB also. The most important thing is, you know, the, the budget, uh, we use for the adaptation and also for the mitigation. As I said before, for the adaptation, for the, uh, you know, training, how to uh enhance the community empowerment, this is, uh, the most. And also for, um, selection of the species related with the changing of the climate, this is also very important. And mitigation, restoring, and also alternative income for the buffer. So, this is my explanation. Thank you. Yeah, hi, thank you for the, the question on how can an initiative responsible initiative look like, right? How can we imagine a responsible initiative in the carbon market and what's the role of, of, uh, the legal framework? I think it's a. The, the, the answer is like we talk a lot about collective action in the, in the for climate, right? Collective uh we need action from government, from the allies of indigenous peoples, local communities, from local communities, indigenous peoples and the private sector, so. The the role of the legal framework in governance is of course absolutely key to regulate these markets further starting by carbon rights, what are the carbon rights of indigenous peoples, how to secure these carbon rights and not let it to interpretation or to contract negotiation, uh, but also in terms of registering carbon projects, for example, in a country, so you know there's a certain level of control and compliance with it, so they're able to control compliance with legislation. Also in terms of disclosure of information, a certain to a certain extent these contracts are extremely private. Do we wanna go into, you know, disclosing information about sharing of benefits, the structuring of agreements, the governance of agreements, all these things the government can do to, uh, you know, improve the, the, the, the integrity of these markets. But then when it comes to the, to the private sector, I think, um. The role of the private sector should be the same as the international development institutions and funders of indigenous people. It's to enable indigenous communities to self-determine in a way in which they can manage their forests sustainably. And obtain rights from that and they can make some profit from that, but I think their role is to enable just in the same way as the bank enables a a private entrepreneur to do their business. Why can't indigenous communities, local indigenous people and local communities be entitled to the same kind of trusting support where they get the money. You know, and, uh, and support to do what they want to do. So that's how the sector should behave. But maybe they, you know, the, we also need to support indigenous communities and, uh, indigenous peoples in local communities need support to be to level the field to be able to, you know, negotiate these agreements. But there are examples out there. Another thing that, uh, a responsible initiative looks like is transparency. There's I found an initiative as there out there, a small one that has all their documentation on their website, all the requirements, how much benefits they make, how many credits they sold, how many, how much money this is really, I think what. The communities and the international community is entitled to because carbon credits it's not like any other good we they're expected to have like uh this you know nonprofit contribution to the world so we can't just treat them as any other commodity but I think there's there's ways to to to improve the current situation at least. Thank you so much. So the organizers, uh, just reminded us that uh we have to wrap up and I also don't want to keep you from your lunch. So should you have any additional questions to one of the speakers, feel free to uh approach them during the lunch break. Just to quickly conclude, I think we learned a lot about the progress uh with community forestry in the respective countries that we heard about today. I think the benefits are very obvious, but the challenge of tenure security is still there. But we are hearing that there is progress in these countries, for example, what Mr. Andre mentioned about thinking about prioritizing or Making a 10 year security a requirement for this program, I think that's a big step in the right direction. Indonesia, there's a strong policy pillar on the recognition of customary forests, but then with the carbon market, it seems that there's a lot to be done. But the thinking of the importance of tenure security, I think is a critical first step, and I'm sure that in a couple of years when we reconvene for this conference, we'll see hopefully a lot of progress in this regard. So once again, please give an applause to the speakers. And thank you very much.
showAllTranscripts
no
duration
PT1H22M2S
scene7File
worldbank/How Community Forestry Can Strengthen Sustainable Landscape Management and Land Tenure Security
scene7Domain
https://worldbank.scene7.com/
scene7FileAvs
worldbank/How Community Forestry Can Strengthen Sustainable Landscape Management and Land Tenure Security-AVS
title
How Community Forestry Can Strengthen Sustainable Landscape Management and Land Tenure Security
description
How Community Forestry Can Strengthen Sustainable Landscape Management and Land Tenure Security
showTimestampAndTranscript
yes
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-3
col-lg-3
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-7
col-lg-7
  • add-style
  • lp-body-content

A video recording of the "How Community Forestry Can Strengthen Sustainable Landscape Management and Land Tenure Security" session of the 2024 World Bank Land Conference.

The World Bank Land Conference is the premier forum for the land sector, bringing together participants from governments, development partners, civil society, academia, and the private sector to showcase research, discuss issues and good practice, and inform policy dialogue.

Chair: Willem van der Muur, Land Tenure Specialist, The World Bank

Speakers:

  • Bambang Supriyanto, Director General of Social Forestry and Environmental Partnership at the Ministry of Environment and Forestry, Indonesia
  • Augustin Mpoyi, Senior Technical Adviser at the Council for Environmental Defence through Legality and Traceability (CODELT)
  • André Aquino, Lead Environmental Specialist, The World Bank
  • Gabriela Rodrigues Eklund, Technical Director, Global Land Alliance
lp-heading-top-medium
lp-heading-bottom-medium
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-2
col-lg-2