00:00 Hello,
00:01 everyone.
00:01 Thank you for this opportunity to present From Jobs to Careers,
00:05 Apparel Exports and Career Paths for Women
00:08 in Developing Countries.
00:10 This work is co-authored with Stacy Frederick,
00:12 Gladys Lopez Acevedo,
00:14 and Mexico Regara Bahia.
00:17 I am Raymond Robertson,
00:18 the director of the Massbacker Institute from Texas A&M University.
00:24 The motivation for this work begins with the fact that women's
00:28 engagement in the labor force reduces
00:30 poverty and increases economic development,
00:33 but not all engagement in the labor market is the same.
00:36 The literature misses the distinction between jobs and careers.
00:40 The goal of this report is to shift that debate
00:43 towards the subtle differences between jobs and careers.
00:47 And we take the apparel industry as our focus
00:50 case study in order to look at the relationship between apparel exports
00:55 and women's engagement in the labor force.
01:01 It is very well documented that exports,
01:03 particularly in apparel,
01:05 create job opportunities for women.
01:08 We have seen a number of different studies,
01:10 including those listed here,
01:11 which demonstrate the strong relationship between apparel exports
01:16 and jobs,
01:17 employment,
01:17 and higher wages,
01:18 particularly for women.
01:20 But does
01:21 it lead to better employment opportunities,
01:24 that is,
01:25 careers,
01:26 and if so,
01:27 how does that happen?
01:28 There's a lack of research
01:30 looking at those next steps for labor participation after the initial engagement
01:35 with the formal sector that comes with apparel exports.
01:42 So what is the next step?
01:43 We argue that the next step
01:45 is facilitating that transition from jobs to careers.
01:49 Development institutions are ready to take that next step,
01:52 but
01:53 their next moves depend on a number of key research questions,
01:58 including
01:59 how do we help realize the full potential of women in the economy?
02:03 What role does apparel exporting play
02:07 in the transition from jobs to careers?
02:09 And what are the relevant metrics to help
02:11 us understand this transition from jobs to careers?
02:18 Not surprisingly,
02:19 there's already a very large relationship about
02:22 the transition from jobs to careers,
02:24 but it focuses on developing.
02:27 And developed countries
02:29 separately.
02:29 There's a well-known U-shaped relationship between female
02:33 labor force participation and GDP per capita,
02:36 where
02:36 in the lowest income countries,
02:39 labor force participation rates for women
02:41 is very high,
02:43 but as incomes develop and as incomes increase,
02:47 the labor force participation rates on average tend to fall.
02:51 And once countries get more wealthy,
02:54 women start re-entering the labor.
02:56 Force in higher rates.
02:58 This
02:59 U-shaped relationship is emblematic and representative of
03:03 this transition from jobs to careers.
03:06 There's a lot of heterogeneity,
03:08 however,
03:09 throughout the developing countries,
03:10 as you can see in this graph,
03:12 and there's a lot of heterogeneity across apparel exporters.
03:16 So we try to take advantage of this heterogeneity to explore
03:20 the factors that contribute to that transition
03:23 within our sample of developing countries.
03:29 The transition from jobs to careers can broadly be represented with this figure.
03:34 This demonstrates
03:36 basically the path that women in the United States,
03:39 perhaps the most studied country for the transition of jobs to careers,
03:43 uh,
03:43 followed.
03:44 In the early
03:46 20th century,
03:47 in the late 19th century,
03:48 there was obviously a lot of
03:50 concentration.
03:51 in
03:51 informal work and in agriculture.
03:54 Then,
03:55 as industrial jobs became more available,
03:59 women shifted out of informal work and into agriculture,
04:02 into this factory work,
04:03 which included,
04:04 in particular,
04:05 apparel and other related sectors.
04:08 Then,
04:08 as education developed and institutional reform broke
04:11 down some of those barriers to women,
04:14 women shift into more mid-skill services,
04:16 professional services,
04:17 such as nursing,
04:19 and other types of professional services.
04:21 And then,
04:22 finally,
04:22 in the last step,
04:23 we see this transition
04:25 into careers,
04:26 which is directly related to a sense of identity,
04:29 so how do you identify and think of yourself,
04:32 uh,
04:33 as your,
04:35 Age progresses,
04:36 and
04:36 it is also highly related to high skill occupations.
04:40 What this figure demonstrates is the light colors demonstrate
04:43 more jobs and the darker blues represent more careers.
04:47 So you can see originally we think of jobs being
04:49 more prevalent in informal work and even factory work,
04:53 although it is possible for careers
04:55 to emerge in.
04:56 Factory work,
04:57 uh,
04:57 and then in mid-skill services,
04:59 you see a higher incidence of careers as jobs sort of fade out,
05:03 and there are people in sort of high-skill occupations
05:07 that
05:07 do consider those to be jobs.
05:10 So there's not a perfect correlation between,
05:13 uh,
05:13 high skill occupations and
05:15 the distinction between jobs and careers,
05:17 but there is a significant amount of overlap,
05:19 and we rely on that
05:21 as we go through our report.
05:25 So,
05:26 what form does this report take?
05:29 Well,
05:29 the overall outline in our report is broken into 5 chapters.
05:33 The first chapter describes this distinction between jobs and careers,
05:38 and talks about why it is so important to focus on this distinction.
05:43 Chapter 2 looks at whether or not apparel exports support
05:46 this quiet revolution that was seen in the United States
05:50 of this transition from jobs to careers.
05:53 Since we find that that's not ubiquitous,
05:55 does not happen everywhere,
05:57 we focus then on chapter 3,
05:59 which includes 3 barriers to career development.
06:03 Then in chapter 4,
06:04 we look at how the apparel export strategy fits
06:08 into that jobs to careers transition.
06:11 And then finally,
06:12 we conclude
06:13 with policy recommendations in the last chapter.
06:20 In chapter one,
06:21 we focus on why jobs versus careers.
06:24 We focus on this question and review the
06:26 academic literature and where it has taken us.
06:29 What we illustrate in this chapter is
06:31 that the transition from jobs to careers within
06:34 Uh,
06:34 a canonical inner-temporal household labor supply
06:37 model can also be very revealing,
06:39 so that
06:40 the,
06:41 this model of household labor supply reveals that women's participation in the
06:46 labor force depends a great deal on the value that households place
06:51 on the production within the home,
06:54 and who does that kind of production.
06:56 The shift from jobs to careers demonstrates a shift in attitudes within
07:01 the household where women's work outside the household is valued much more
07:06 than women's
07:07 work within the household,
07:08 and that facilitates this increase in labor supply.
07:12 It also provides a theoretical foundation for our transition indicators,
07:17 which come
07:18 both from theory and from the literature.
07:21 And finally,
07:22 this chapter explores the potential development effects in the economy.
07:26 As I'm sure most of you know,
07:28 including women in the labor force has
07:30 a number of important pro-development effects.
07:34 It reduces the number of children,
07:36 it increases the amount of investment parents can make in the,
07:39 Children,
07:40 including health and education,
07:41 and it also provides models,
07:44 role models for young girls looking to expand their career horizons.
07:49 So there's a number of ways that this is really critical
07:52 for increasing and facilitating economic development.
08:00 In chapter 2 of the report,
08:01 we focus on the question,
08:03 do apparel exports support a quiet revolution?
08:07 This refers to Claudia Golden's seminal work
08:10 looking at the transition in the United States
08:13 that women experience from jobs to careers over a 100-year period.
08:18 In some of Claudia Golden's work,
08:20 we draw upon her examples of indicators
08:24 of
08:25 the transition from jobs to careers,
08:28 and we use 5 of those in this chapter.
08:31 The first one is investment in human capital,
08:34 which represents the long-run view that women might have
08:39 to invest in education or more job skills to
08:43 make them more productive in the labor market.
08:46 The long-run view is important because investing in these skills pays off over time
08:51 and therefore having that long-run
08:53 view
08:54 increases the incentive to make those investments.
08:57 We also focus on earning gaps between men and women,
09:01 particularly of married women and single women,
09:04 and how that compares within the family as an important indicator.
09:08 As
09:09 people make the transition from jobs to careers,
09:11 we would expect those earning gaps to close.
09:14 We also look at lifetime labor force participation.
09:18 With the jobs mentality,
09:20 people would more likely not expect to spend a
09:24 lot of their lifetime within the job market,
09:26 and as a result,
09:28 they don't make those kinds of long-run investments in careers,
09:31 whether it's uh industry-specific human capital or general human
09:35 capital that would pay off in the longer run.
09:38 And so we see that in
09:40 a situation where there's more careers,
09:42 we see higher rates of lifetime labor force participation.
09:47 Another measure is the distribution of employment,
09:49 and we talk about this a lot more coming up in additional slides,
09:53 where that balance between sectors that are more likely to hire women
09:58 and those that are less likely to hire women plays an important role as well.
10:02 And then finally,
10:03 we focus on labor force participation of married women.
10:07 A lot of times,
10:08 women,
10:09 When they first enter the labor force as young single women,
10:12 are mainly focused on jobs,
10:14 just trying to get an income in order to survive.
10:17 Then when they get married,
10:18 oftentimes they'll drop out.
10:20 When we see the transition from jobs to careers,
10:22 however,
10:23 married women are much more likely to stay in the labor force because
10:27 working in the labor force gives them a sense of identity.
10:31 So we evaluate each of these indicators for all 7
10:35 different apparel exporting countries in our sample,
10:38 and we find that the different apparel exporters are at
10:41 different stages of this transition from jobs to careers,
10:44 leading to different policy recommendations.
10:50 Chapter 3
10:52 represents 3 barriers to career development.
10:55 In this chapter,
10:56 we outline 3 different obstacles
10:59 which are prevalent in developing countries that make it more difficult
11:03 for women to make the transition
11:05 from jobs to careers.
11:07 Let's talk about these each in turn.
11:13 The first barrier is a low demand for services due to insufficient national income,
11:19 and what we mean by this is that women
11:21 tend to concentrate in different sectors in the economy.
11:25 Some of those sectors that are more likely to be hiring women
11:29 are much more prevalent in high income.
11:32 So what you see here is that high-income countries are much
11:36 more likely to engage in a number of professional services,
11:39 whether that's doctors,
11:40 nurses,
11:41 healthcare,
11:42 uh,
11:42 generally,
11:42 or other types of professional services,
11:45 uh,
11:45 higher levels of education,
11:46 for example,
11:47 of teachers,
11:48 and
11:49 those,
11:49 And those types of engagements are much
11:52 more prevalent in these higher income countries.
11:55 In lower-income countries,
11:56 we see
11:57 there's a much higher prevalence of agriculture,
12:00 and in the middle-income countries,
12:02 we see this industry,
12:04 uh,
12:04 is sort of the broad sector.
12:06 So we also see sort of a similar U shape here and looking at agriculture,
12:11 industry and services when it comes Come to
12:13 this transition from low income to high income.
12:16 Finding ways to break down these barriers
12:19 of occupational and industrial segregation for women
12:23 is an important way to facilitate
12:25 the advancement of women from jobs to careers.
12:28 Just creating more of these opportunities in a broader range of sectors
12:33 would help countries at a lower income level,
12:36 uh,
12:36 engage
12:37 as careers.
12:41 The second barrier is another one that's very well known,
12:44 and that is low education levels.
12:47 But low education levels play a particularly important role
12:50 in this job to career transition because
12:53 we usually think of careers as being the types of
12:57 uh occupational activities that require
13:00 more
13:01 about your education at the hiring process,
13:04 or they might require much more advanced levels of education.
13:08 In areas or countries where females have a much more difficult
13:13 time getting education or education levels are lower on average,
13:17 means that they're investing less in those types of skills
13:20 which are going to be valued over the longer run
13:23 in a career environment.
13:25 And what you see here is that we compare this across our 7.
13:28 Countries and illustrate the fact that women
13:30 are in very different
13:32 places across these different countries based on their education levels,
13:36 and that means that from a policy recommendation,
13:39 clearly Cambodia,
13:40 Bangladesh,
13:40 Pakistan
13:41 might be
13:42 more focused on uh
13:45 education than say,
13:46 Egypt or Sri Lanka.
13:50 The 3rd barrier is low female employment within industries.
13:55 This is different from barrier 1,
13:57 which said that the industries that tend to employ women
14:00 are in lower demand in lower-income countries.
14:04 In contrast to that,
14:06 this barrier talks about within industries,
14:09 and women tend to be hired in much
14:11 higher proportions in some industries than others,
14:15 but even when we look at those industries that tend to hire a lot of women,
14:19 which is generally your higher skilled service occupations,
14:23 we look at these apparel exporting countries and find that in many of them,
14:28 women's representation is Much lower than we would have expected,
14:32 given the patterns we've seen around the world.
14:35 So in particular,
14:36 if you look at
14:37 women's business,
14:38 uh,
14:38 women Business and law index scores by indicators,
14:41 according to this table,
14:43 you see that
14:44 women are facing segregation and a lot of resistance
14:49 to expanding employment within
14:52 those industries that might be more likely to hire them generally.
14:55 So this goes beyond just sort of the rules and the norms in society,
15:00 but it goes to specific
15:02 industry uh regulations and
15:05 um other types of restrictions that
15:07 make it more difficult for women
15:09 to expand their careers within the labor force.
15:13 So it's really critical then to look both within
15:16 industries as well as across industries
15:19 to identify barriers within these countries.
15:26 Next we move to chapter 4,
15:28 which looks at how does an apparel export growth strategy fit into
15:33 the jobs to careers transition.
15:36 And one of the things that we know about the apparel
15:39 industry is that it's highly characterized by global value chains.
15:44 So here we look at the relationship of different
15:47 activities within global value chains and country roles,
15:50 and how that relates to occupational skill and country income levels.
15:55 And what you see is that in lower-income
15:58 countries,
15:58 uh,
15:59 they're mainly focused on manufacturing,
16:01 which is,
16:01 say,
16:02 cut and sew,
16:03 cut,
16:03 make,
16:03 and trim.
16:04 Uh,
16:05 they're interested in basically assembly.
16:07 Here though,
16:08 as countries increase,
16:09 they move more in their income,
16:11 they shift into
16:13 design and post-sale services,
16:15 marketing and R&D.
16:16 So as
16:18 these activities within the global value chain expand,
16:22 we see more and more opportunities for women potentially shifting into careers.
16:28 So one of the things that we
16:30 uh recommend and focus on particularly in this chapter is how apparel is unique
16:36 and how expanding,
16:38 upgrading,
16:39 and increasing the value-added within the global value chain could
16:43 Really help create additional opportunities for women to
16:46 shift from jobs which might be more likely
16:49 to be found in just simple manufacturing into those careers,
16:53 which is the R&D
16:54 and marketing.
16:55 Governments can play an important role in this process.
17:02 Finally,
17:02 we move to chapter 5,
17:04 which is the policy recommendations.
17:06 And here we see that there are 4 key
17:08 policy recommendations that come out of this report.
17:12 One of the main ones that we begin
17:13 with is increasing participation of female production workers
17:17 in these export-oriented apparel manufacturing-related industries.
17:21 In other words,
17:22 expanding apparel production does a good job at taking that first step
17:27 in bringing women out of agriculture and out of informality into the formal sector
17:33 to help
17:34 create a pattern and experience in the formal
17:37 labor markets.
17:38 We see that some countries have already been
17:41 taking important steps along that path,
17:43 including Bangladesh,
17:44 Egypt,
17:45 Arab Republic,
17:46 and so on.
17:47 If you look at the 2nd policy recommendation,
17:50 we recommend that increasing the number
17:53 of female supervisors and upgrading jobs within
17:56 those industries is an important way to create opportunities
18:00 for women to shift from jobs to careers.
18:03 So specific ways to do this are implementing internships
18:06 and skill-specific training programs with An eye of changing
18:10 the perspective from the short term to the long-term
18:14 for women engaged in the formal sector.
18:16 Providing career pathways
18:19 for women is really,
18:20 really important.
18:22 This includes focusing on programs supplying graduates who are employable
18:26 that are consistent with the stages
18:28 of
18:30 industrial policy and the current stages of industrial development.
18:34 Our 3rd policy recommendation is to increase access to education
18:38 to promote female participation in careers.
18:41 Careers
18:42 usually involve much more education in the labor force,
18:45 and it's important to increase educational opportunities.
18:49 And finally,
18:50 and perhaps most importantly,
18:51 is breaking those glass ceilings.
18:53 Removing legal barriers that reduce women's access to and
18:57 the permanence in employment opportunities is absolutely critical,
19:00 as well as promoting inclusive workplace practices
19:04 and engaging with foreign support and involvement.
19:06 This is something that's relevant for all the countries in our sample
19:10 and is very critical for making this transition.
19:13 Overall,
19:14 most jobs or careers in an industry will not secure women positions if
19:18 their human capital is too low or those barriers are in place.
19:22 Women cannot do it necessarily,
19:25 uh,
19:25 with these cultural barriers in place,
19:27 right?
19:28 So,
19:28 it's really important to achieve this goal of,
19:31 of having more
19:32 women in higher skilled,
19:34 longer horizon,
19:35 better paid and life fulfilling occupations.
19:37 And to get there,
19:39 we need national programs that would consider these
19:42 implementations at the same time.
19:44 Fortunately,
19:45 today,
19:45 we argue that thanks to vast empirical evidence and successful policies,
19:49 the quiet revolution
19:51 of women's advancement from jobs to careers need not take
19:54 the 100 years that it took in the United States,
19:56 and we can do it much faster in developing countries.
19:59 Thank you for your attention.
- add-style
- lp-body-content