col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-12
col-lg-12
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-12
col-lg-12
videoType
dynamic-media
videoDmUrl
https://delivery-p136806-e1377785.adobeaemcloud.com/adobe/assets/urn:aaid:aem:36ec5721-1814-4b3e-8049-7acd3380ab53/play?assetname=ABCDE2024-Keynote-Kemer.mp4
keyFrameImage
videoDescription
A video recording of the Keynote address with Michael Kremer (University of Chicago) at The Annual Bank Conference on Development Economics 2024 "The Great Incoherence: Growth and Human Development in An Era of Stagnation."
timestamp

00:06 Our keynote speaker up here,

00:08 and I think you're going to,

00:11 uh,

00:12 when this is all over,

00:14 when you've heard what he has to say,

00:15 you're gonna feel that you,

00:16 uh,

00:17 were lucky to be here today

00:19 to,

00:19 uh,

00:19 hear the thoughts of someone who is,

00:23 uh,

00:23 uh,

00:23 such a,

00:25 such a renowned

00:27 person in his field.

00:28 But you know,

00:28 he's not just any kind of renowned economist.

00:32 Um,

00:33 he is credited with transforming global research in development economics,

00:38 a field that he's been pursuing for many,

00:41 many years.

00:42 In fact,

00:43 uh,

00:45 in his early years as a student

00:46 at Harvard,

00:48 he wrote his senior thesis

00:50 comparing an employment guarantee program in India

00:54 with a food subsidy program in Sri Lanka.

00:57 So,

00:58 There you go,

00:59 uh,

00:59 when other people are writing about Lord knows what,

01:01 he was already looking at this important field

01:04 where he has continued to grow,

01:07 continued to develop,

01:08 and I'm talking about Professor Michael Kramer.

01:12 Uh,

01:12 he is at the University of Chicago Development Economics Program.

01:16 He's had a long,

01:16 illustrious career,

01:18 so many different places,

01:19 uh,

01:20 developing this field,

01:21 and so much so

01:23 that in 2019,

01:24 he co-won with two other economists,

01:27 uh,

01:27 the Nobel Prize in Economics.

01:30 Uh,

01:30 he is,

01:31 uh,

01:32 they were recognized for their,

01:33 uh,

01:34 experimental approach to alleviating global poverty.

01:38 This

01:38 groundbreak.

01:39 Breaking research has reshaped our understanding of the role of human capital,

01:43 poverty alleviation in developing countries.

01:46 Um,

01:46 there's,

01:47 you know,

01:47 if you look at his wiki page,

01:48 he,

01:49 I could go on and on,

01:49 but instead,

01:50 I'm going to now bring you Michael Kramer to the podium.

01:54 Michael,

01:54 welcome.

01:59 OK.

02:07 Great.

02:07 Thank you very much for that,

02:08 uh,

02:09 for that,

02:09 uh,

02:10 nice introduction.

02:11 Um,

02:12 So

02:13 earlier speakers noted the gap

02:16 uh between the ambitious targets that the world has set for itself on development,

02:21 on climate change,

02:23 um,

02:23 and the resources that have been made available and are likely to be made available

02:28 uh for that,

02:29 for those purposes.

02:30 Um,

02:31 and you know that naturally raises the question of how can we produce more

02:36 output

02:37 with,

02:38 uh,

02:38 with,

02:39 with a given input.

02:40 And

02:41 that's a classic question in economics and

02:44 how do we move out the production function

02:46 and in fact,

02:47 producing more with given resources

02:51 is technically the definition of innovation in economics

02:54 and so that's really

02:56 a topic that I,

02:57 I'd like to focus on.

02:59 Um,

03:00 let me just note

03:01 that

03:02 while I'm,

03:03 I'm going to talk about

03:05 um

03:06 The need for innovation and the role that innovation can

03:09 play in helping us get more out of resources,

03:11 you know,

03:12 that doesn't conflict at all with the idea that

03:14 more resources should be devoted to these important goals

03:19 to match the ambitions that we've set for ourselves.

03:22 And in fact,

03:23 you know,

03:23 I think I would argue that

03:27 To the extent that we can show that we can deliver more for resources,

03:30 that actually is very complimentary

03:32 uh with that goal.

03:33 So I,

03:34 I don't wanna

03:35 I think

03:36 sort of create a false opposition.

03:39 So I'll discuss a few individual innovations,

03:41 um,

03:43 but

03:43 beyond individual innovations,

03:45 I think we need to innovate on the system

03:47 that we have for promoting innovation and development.

03:52 You know,

03:52 we can often,

03:53 it's natural to take certain

03:56 institutional features of our system as constraints.

03:59 Um,

03:59 so for example,

04:00 most World Bank funds are lent to national

04:03 governments and national governments have to repay those loans

04:06 and they will appropriately think about,

04:09 you know,

04:09 is this a good loan for them to take.

04:12 Um,

04:13 but

04:13 you know there are some

04:14 investments,

04:15 uh,

04:16 particularly.

04:16 Investments in innovation

04:18 which can benefit many countries

04:20 and our international or even global public goods.

04:24 I know there's a lot of debate about

04:27 is it appropriate to take funds meant for development and

04:30 shift them to certain types of global public goods,

04:33 but within global public goods,

04:35 there's certainly a subset

04:36 that primarily are relevant for low and middle income countries,

04:40 for example,

04:41 Certain

04:42 health problems are most common in low and middle income countries.

04:45 Certain agricultural problems.

04:47 I don't think it's at all limited to those two sectors,

04:50 but

04:50 that type of global public investing,

04:53 I'll argue that investing in that type of global public good

04:56 does

04:56 offer an opportunity

04:59 to deliver more outcomes

05:01 for for

05:02 for a given amount of investment.

05:04 And that I think is.

05:06 If to the extent that our

05:08 current institutions aren't set up well to enable that,

05:11 maybe it's worth considering reforms

05:13 to some of our institutions for that purpose.

05:16 Um,

05:17 OK.

05:18 Um,

05:19 so let me just start with some things that I think are,

05:22 on the one hand,

05:23 probably almost everybody in this room knows at some level.

05:27 On the other hand,

05:28 the

05:28 magnitude of these effects are so enormous that I think it's worth,

05:32 uh,

05:33 you know,

05:33 periodically reminding ourselves of them.

05:36 So first,

05:37 let me just note the

05:38 tremendous impact of innovation

05:41 and

05:42 helping us achieve more with the,

05:44 with uh,

05:45 with given resources

05:46 in one area that's a focus of a lot of goals,

05:49 which is

05:50 uh child survival.

05:53 So this is,

05:53 uh,

05:54 what this graph shows

05:55 is

05:56 the top shows uh is a graph of health and income in 1900.

06:01 And so you see Italy there,

06:03 and in 1900,

06:05 300 out of every 1000 children

06:08 born in Italy died before their fifth birthday.

06:12 Now,

06:13 the bottom part of that shows the relationship in today,

06:17 uh,

06:17 today,

06:18 and I've highlighted Kenya.

06:20 In Kenya,

06:21 less than 5% of children die before their 5th birthday.

06:25 So,

06:25 you know,

06:26 huge improvement in human welfare,

06:28 almost unfathomable improvement in,

06:30 in human welfare.

06:32 And yet,

06:33 Is that because

06:34 Kenya got is today is richer than Italy?

06:37 No,

06:37 Kenya is actually,

06:38 Kenya today is actually slightly lower income than Italy in 1900.

06:43 The difference is a whole suite of innovations that enabled that,

06:47 and

06:48 you know that includes everything from a bunch of technological innovations,

06:52 development of antibiotics,

06:54 vaccines,

06:55 oral rehydration therapy,

06:57 but also social innovations

06:59 that provide the vast majority of women and

07:01 their children with access to prenatal care,

07:04 um,

07:04 attended delivery,

07:05 and essential healthcare.

07:07 I think there's lots of potential for further innovation,

07:10 um,

07:12 but,

07:12 you know,

07:13 while there's strong incentives for certain types of innovation,

07:16 um,

07:17 and,

07:18 you know,

07:18 purely exist

07:20 commercial incentives under our existing institutions

07:23 are somewhat weaker for other part,

07:25 other types of innovation that are socially very valuable.

07:29 Uh,

07:29 so within health,

07:31 you can think about a malaria vaccine,

07:33 for example.

07:34 Or

07:34 uh low cost water treatment for,

07:36 for rural areas.

07:38 I'll come back to the

07:40 discussion later of uh

07:42 of pneumococcal vaccine.

07:43 Um,

07:44 there's uh,

07:45 there are different strains of pneumococcus in high and

07:48 middle income countries and in lower income countries,

07:50 and vaccines were developed first,

07:52 as you can imagine,

07:53 for those in higher and middle income countries.

07:57 Let me,

07:57 I think economic theory can shed light on when there'll be

08:01 relatively large gaps and when there'll be smaller gaps between

08:05 commercial incentives and social incentives.

08:08 So,

08:08 uh,

08:09 you know,

08:09 there are,

08:09 there are multiple cases.

08:10 This is an,

08:11 you know,

08:11 very interesting area in economics,

08:13 uh,

08:13 very rich and complex,

08:15 but let me just give a couple of,

08:17 you know,

08:17 fairly straightforward examples.

08:19 One is the,

08:20 one is the case of uh

08:22 of,

08:23 of uh externalities.

08:25 So

08:26 some innovations create benefits,

08:27 not just for the user of the good,

08:29 but for other people.

08:31 Um,

08:32 so a good example of that would be an industrial innovation

08:35 or an agricultural innovation for that matter,

08:37 that reduces greenhouse gas emissions.

08:39 Um.

08:41 So I'll come to the case of green cement,

08:43 but cement produces a lot of emissions.

08:46 If we found a way of producing cement that released fewer emissions,

08:50 well,

08:50 that would be of enormous benefit to the world,

08:52 but it's not clear that

08:55 the buyers of cement would pay more for that.

08:57 So there might be insufficient incentives to invest in that.

09:01 Another case is

09:03 innovations in provision of government services,

09:06 um,

09:07 such as improvements in tax administration,

09:09 for example.

09:10 You know,

09:10 if I think about,

09:11 you know,

09:12 we may not think of it,

09:13 uh,

09:14 today as one,

09:14 but value-added taxes were not common in most of the world.

09:18 Oh,

09:18 if we went further back and thanks.

09:20 In part to,

09:21 I don't know whether I'm allowed to say nice things about the IMF here,

09:24 but,

09:24 uh,

09:25 thanks in part to the uh to the,

09:27 the work of the IMF,

09:28 um,

09:29 you know,

09:29 these are now

09:29 common around the world,

09:30 and I think they,

09:31 they are an efficient way of raising,

09:33 raising taxes.

09:34 Um,

09:35 but you can also think about ways of provision,

09:37 providing health,

09:38 agricultural extension,

09:39 um,

09:40 you know,

09:41 education.

09:43 So I think there's a role and

09:44 it's difficult for firms to,

09:47 to make

09:49 money anywhere near,

09:50 I'm not saying you can make zero money,

09:52 but it's hard to get

09:53 for them to,

09:54 they don't have this,

09:55 the incentives that are commensurate with the social value of,

09:58 of some of these innovations.

10:00 Um,

10:00 I'd also note that some of these are global public goods as well,

10:04 and that creates a little bit of a free rider problem among countries.

10:08 Um.

10:09 So

10:10 if we look,

10:10 I've been talking,

10:12 given a few examples,

10:13 if you look at studies of the rate of return to innovation,

10:16 there are a number of them,

10:17 and they generate

10:18 very high estimates of the rate of return,

10:20 things like 60,

10:21 70%

10:23 annual rates of return,

10:24 uh,

10:24 social return.

10:25 Um,

10:26 so

10:27 I will,

10:28 I should note,

10:29 however,

10:30 that

10:31 innovation is first inherently risky,

10:33 and second,

10:34 it's very easy

10:35 to throw good money after bad.

10:38 And

10:39 When we think about institutions to encourage innovation,

10:43 we need things that will,

10:44 um,

10:45 you know,

10:45 accelerate the pace of innovation,

10:47 shape it to meet social needs,

10:50 but also we need to design institutions

10:52 that can limit some of the waste that might come if we're,

10:55 if we're,

10:56 if we're,

10:57 if we,

10:57 if we don't find a way of preventing throwing good money after bad.

11:01 So let me give a,

11:02 you know,

11:02 say a little bit about the rest of the talk.

11:04 I've been working on,

11:06 uh,

11:06 I've been chairing a commission on innovation for climate change,

11:09 food security,

11:10 and agriculture.

11:11 Um,

11:12 so I've been thinking about innovations around climate adaptation,

11:16 to some extent mitigation

11:17 in,

11:18 in around food security and agriculture.

11:20 So I'll say,

11:21 I'll

11:22 just as.

11:22 Examples,

11:23 I'll choose examples from that sector

11:25 and

11:25 sort of make the case that not only there's historical examples,

11:28 but there are things we could be doing

11:30 right now.

11:31 Um,

11:32 um,

11:33 second,

11:33 I'll discuss,

11:34 oh I see two ones there anyway,

11:36 um,

11:36 the,

11:36 um,

11:37 um,

11:38 uh,

11:39 institutions for,

11:39 for,

11:40 uh,

11:40 for innovation,

11:41 and I'll talk about two types of institutions.

11:43 OK.

11:46 OK,

11:47 so some

11:48 some innovations for climate adaptation.

11:51 So with climate change,

11:52 not only are we're seeing

11:54 higher temperatures,

11:55 for example,

11:55 but we're seeing increased uncertainty around weather.

11:58 And

11:59 um,

12:00 you know,

12:00 variation in daily precipitation is estimated to increase by about 5%

12:05 and temperature variability increases by

12:07 10 to 15% per.

12:09 Degrees Celsius of warming.

12:11 So

12:11 this is,

12:13 um,

12:13 and there's also

12:15 increased variation in the timing of agricultural seasons.

12:18 So if you think about a farmer who's used to

12:20 traditional times of year to plant for other operations,

12:24 certain rules of thumb,

12:25 those rules of thumb may not work anymore.

12:28 Now,

12:29 there's

12:30 a lot of technological progress on this,

12:32 so

12:33 it's now possible to predict rainy season or monsoon onset

12:38 up to a month in advance in,

12:39 in,

12:40 in many parts of the world,

12:42 um,

12:43 and,

12:43 you know,

12:44 AI is enabling

12:46 very,

12:46 very rapid advance in,

12:48 in some areas of weather forecasting.

12:50 And it allows customized weather forecasts to be made,

12:53 so it's not just a general weather forecast.

12:56 You know,

12:56 this is the probability of rain today,

12:58 probability tomorrow.

12:59 A farmer might need to know very specific information,

13:02 you know,

13:03 is it going to,

13:03 what's the prob,

13:04 what's the

13:05 probability of rain in the next 3 days?

13:07 Uh,

13:08 what's the,

13:08 or something much more complicated than that?

13:10 Should I

13:11 plan today or is it better to

13:13 take the option of waiting after that?

13:15 Well,

13:15 it's now.

13:16 You can set AI,

13:19 you know,

13:19 AI models can be optimized.

13:21 The,

13:21 the loss function on them in technical terms can be

13:24 set around whatever parameter is most important to the,

13:27 to the farmer,

13:28 and these can be run very quickly.

13:29 The big firms in this area like Nvidia and so on,

13:32 they have open access models that can easily be tweaked.

13:36 Talking to a researcher,

13:37 a colleague said,

13:39 you know,

13:39 a grad student or a postdoc can do this in a,

13:42 in a day.

13:43 Um,

13:44 the,

13:45 um,

13:46 now there's

13:47 a lot of evidence from multiple studies

13:49 that farmers adjust their behavior,

13:51 their agricultural behavior,

13:52 and their investment decisions in response to accurate weather forecasts.

13:56 But

13:57 nonetheless,

13:58 most farmers are not getting this information right now.

14:01 And

14:02 um you know,

14:03 there's a couple of RCTs that estimate benefits.

14:06 I don't want to claim it's just everywhere,

14:08 but a couple of RCTs,

14:09 randomized controlled trials,

14:12 find benefits over $100 per farmer,

14:14 and

14:15 the cost of,

14:16 of,

14:17 of

14:17 producing

14:18 these forecasts and even disseminating them,

14:21 you know.

14:22 Maybe 1/100 of that.

14:25 Um,

14:25 so,

14:26 um.

14:27 In part because they can be delivered digitally.

14:30 Um,

14:31 so

14:32 we've been working with the Indian government.

14:35 They just for the most recent monsoon,

14:38 um,

14:38 they delivered,

14:39 uh,

14:39 forecasts of monsoon onset and total rainfall in certain parts of India,

14:44 not,

14:44 uh,

14:44 not Mumbai,

14:45 which that wasn't

14:46 part of this pilot year,

14:48 um,

14:48 um,

14:49 uh,

14:49 4 to 9 million farmers.

14:51 Um,

14:52 and you know,

14:53 the government of India has a list of 100 million phone numbers,

14:56 uh,

14:57 farmers,

14:57 so it

14:58 should be very easy.

14:59 To expand this

15:00 and of course other countries in South Asia,

15:03 Africa,

15:04 in fact,

15:04 other areas,

15:05 Latin uh

15:06 Inter-American Development Bank to speak well of another nearby institution,

15:10 you know,

15:10 they're,

15:11 they're working with,

15:12 uh,

15:12 they're,

15:13 they're trying to extend this in Latin America.

15:16 Um,

15:16 now,

15:17 I don't want to claim this is all automatic,

15:19 you know,

15:19 things need,

15:20 when you're doing this,

15:21 you need to think through how do you

15:23 best communicate with farmers about probabilistic information,

15:26 um,

15:27 how do you build farmer trust.

15:29 You probably want to build in a bunch of A B tests to optimize these types of systems,

15:34 but the reason,

15:35 what time of even boring things,

15:36 what time of day do you send the messages to the farmer?

15:39 How many repetitions?

15:40 Well,

15:41 that's tech companies are doing A B tests like this all the time.

15:45 I think we could be,

15:46 we could be doing similar things,

15:47 and the benefits will exceed

15:49 beyond any one country.

15:51 OK.

15:52 OK,

15:53 let me turn to another,

15:54 you know,

15:54 that's sort of a technological innovation that also needs a bunch of

15:58 uh institutional and social adaptation.

16:00 Here's something that's

16:02 more

16:04 Not particularly technological at all.

16:06 It's just a

16:07 um a financial market innovation.

16:10 So,

16:10 obviously a vast literature on microfinance,

16:13 and

16:13 I think uh

16:14 that the latest wave is a little bit of an uptake,

16:17 uptake on that.

16:18 There was a lot of excitement,

16:20 and a lot of disillusionment,

16:21 but there's,

16:22 uh,

16:22 you know,

16:22 still some,

16:23 I,

16:23 I think people,

16:24 we don't want to throw out the baby with the bathwater on that.

16:27 But,

16:27 you know,

16:27 one area that's been somewhat disappointing is the effect on

16:31 productive investments.

16:33 Well,

16:33 one of the interesting areas of research that,

16:36 you know,

16:36 many people are involved in

16:37 is can we try to adjust the,

16:40 the

16:40 typical microfinance contract to make it

16:42 more conducive to expanding actual investment.

16:46 So here's a study that,

16:48 uh,

16:48 that I was involved in with uh Tawni Surrey and,

16:51 and,

16:51 uh,

16:52 and Billy Jack and Yost a lot.

16:54 Um,

16:54 this,

16:55 you see a picture here of a,

16:56 of a rainwater harvesting tank.

16:58 Dairy cattle need a lot of,

16:59 of water.

17:00 They need to be water every day.

17:02 And of course,

17:02 humans need water.

17:03 Um,

17:04 so,

17:04 um,

17:05 these,

17:05 these tanks,

17:06 you see them everywhere on top of roofs in urban areas,

17:09 but they can also be useful in agriculture.

17:12 They cost,

17:12 um,

17:13 but they cost $300

17:15 the 5000 L tank.

17:17 That's not,

17:18 that's not trivial for a,

17:19 for a farming family in Kenya to buy.

17:22 So we looked at just

17:24 You can,

17:25 if you take a look at that,

17:25 there's no moving parts.

17:26 It's pretty big,

17:27 hard to hide,

17:28 makes pretty good collateral.

17:30 So we worked with a savings and loan cooperative that tried

17:33 saying,

17:33 OK,

17:34 we'll just do an asset collateralized loan.

17:36 They got takeup of the loan product went from 2%

17:39 to 25%

17:42 without any increase in default.

17:43 Rates

17:44 and dairy farmers were producing more milk.

17:46 They were also better able to to get through periods when the rain was

17:50 was not coming.

17:51 And they,

17:51 they actually,

17:52 this was a study,

17:53 but the,

17:54 the dairy cooperative and the Associated Savings and Loan

17:56 Association continued the program afterwards with their own funds,

18:00 and other cooperatives are doing that.

18:02 This is another thing that I think,

18:04 you know,

18:05 you could invest in scale,

18:06 and here I think the gap between commercial and social incentives are much,

18:10 much smaller.

18:11 But if you think about each stage of taking this on a little bit more broadly,

18:15 you know,

18:16 it's another thing for a financial,

18:18 for a bank or some other financial provider

18:21 to expand access to this program,

18:22 working with savings and credit cooperatives or dairy cooperatives.

18:26 They would be taking some risks.

18:29 If they succeed in that,

18:31 a bunch of other

18:33 financial institutions are going to enter that market,

18:35 and they're not going to get a monopoly on this market.

18:37 They're going to have to share the profits in that.

18:39 If they fail,

18:40 they're going to take the losses.

18:42 So this is an area where,

18:44 to the extent that there is an institution that

18:47 is willing to provide

18:49 capital for climate resilience or try or willing to

18:53 willing to invest in

18:56 in.

18:56 Yeah,

18:56 these are also particularly favorable to,

18:58 to women because

19:00 women are often enough to do a lot of the

19:02 work of collecting water,

19:03 um,

19:03 that has that as a social objective,

19:05 it's worth

19:06 probably helping finance at least experimentation on that,

19:09 even if not,

19:10 you know,

19:10 not necessarily long run subsidies.

19:13 OK,

19:14 um.

19:16 OK.

19:17 So those are examples of uh,

19:18 of,

19:19 of types of innovation that um

19:21 that can be used,

19:22 and there's a long list just within agriculture,

19:25 food security,

19:26 climate change,

19:27 that we've got on our website for the commission,

19:29 we've got a,

19:29 a long,

19:30 a long list of,

19:31 of innovations with

19:33 evidence of impact and cost effectiveness that we think are,

19:36 are ready to scale.

19:37 Um.

19:39 Let me try to take a,

19:40 uh,

19:41 a little bit more of a,

19:43 of a systematic approach to this and

19:46 also

19:47 transition to

19:48 what I call meta-innovations,

19:50 innovations in the system for creating innovations.

19:53 Um,

19:54 so I'll talk about two things here.

19:56 Let's first talk about

19:58 open-tiered

19:59 evidence-based uh social innovation funds.

20:02 So that I'm involved with,

20:03 uh,

20:04 um,

20:04 um,

20:05 Development Innovation Ventures,

20:06 which is a part of USAI.

20:08 Um,

20:09 FID in France,

20:10 uh,

20:11 uh,

20:11 has a lot,

20:12 a lot of similarities.

20:14 Both of these are designed to be quite open to applications,

20:18 um,

20:18 and not necessarily top-down,

20:20 open to ideas,

20:22 um,

20:22 across sectors,

20:24 across countries,

20:25 both open to commercial scaling and to public scaling,

20:29 um,

20:29 but the,

20:30 you know,

20:30 how do you discipline that openness and how

20:32 do you avoid throwing good money after bad?

20:35 Well,

20:35 we have pretty strict rules about shared funding.

20:38 So there are very small grants of,

20:39 of,

20:40 of,

20:40 of,

20:40 uh,

20:41 for piloting.

20:42 But then to get more serious amounts of money,

20:44 um,

20:45 it has to go undergo rigorous testing for impact

20:49 and cost effectiveness

20:51 if it's something that would be scaled with public sector funding,

20:53 slightly different rules if it would be scaled uh through the private sector.

20:57 And then,

20:58 um,

20:58 and,

20:59 and then there's,

21:00 so we have funds available for that and then we have funds for

21:03 transitioning this to scale because,

21:05 That,

21:06 you know,

21:07 additional

21:07 tweaks are needed for that,

21:09 uh,

21:09 more than tweaks to adapt things for scale.

21:12 So me,

21:13 we've now been around for a bit over a decade,

21:16 uh,

21:16 um,

21:17 and

21:18 we can review the evidence from our full portfolio to

21:21 look at what's the rate of return to these investments

21:24 and maybe try to draw some lessons about which innovation scale.

21:28 Um,

21:29 so let me share some of this.

21:31 First,

21:32 here's a picture

21:33 of

21:34 our 1st 42 grants,

21:35 we took the 1st 2 years of our portfolio.

21:38 How much did uh different innovations scale?

21:40 And what you can see here is very skewed distribution.

21:44 And of course,

21:44 that's extremely typical of any type of innovation fund.

21:47 If you look at patent citations,

21:49 if you look at citations to academic articles,

21:52 you'll see exactly this.

21:53 And any venture capital fund knows,

21:55 you know,

21:56 they're not going to get hit with everything,

21:57 but if they invest in Google or Facebook,

22:00 then that's,

22:00 then they're gonna be

22:01 uh very successful.

22:03 In fact,

22:03 um,

22:04 um,

22:05 so

22:06 the,

22:06 so what are the,

22:07 what are some characteristics of things that scale?

22:11 Well,

22:11 we broke this down by

22:13 uh award stage.

22:15 And

22:16 you know,

22:17 there's a saying in development that pilots never scale,

22:20 so we thought we'd look at that empirically.

22:23 And indeed,

22:24 you know,

22:24 there's only a 17 scaling here is reaching a million people or more,

22:28 uh,

22:28 that's somewhat arbitrary how you count that.

22:30 I'll I'll come back to,

22:32 oh,

22:32 I think it is a better metric overall,

22:34 but

22:34 17% of the stage ones reached over a million people.

22:38 The stage threes

22:40 that,

22:41 you know,

22:41 there was only one of those,

22:42 and it succeeded.

22:44 you might say,

22:45 OK,

22:45 maybe the pilots aren't working out so well,

22:47 but here's a different way of looking at it.

22:50 Here's the

22:51 award value

22:52 and the number of people reached,

22:54 and the people reached per dollar,

22:55 and you get a totally different picture.

22:57 I don't want to play this up in

22:59 terms of statistically significant differences and so on.

23:02 They're not,

23:02 you know,

23:02 these are small samples and.

23:04 Uh,

23:05 not,

23:05 not,

23:05 uh,

23:05 causal estimates for those of you are,

23:08 you know,

23:08 who are,

23:08 uh,

23:08 technical here,

23:09 but,

23:10 um,

23:10 the,

23:11 you know,

23:11 I think the lesson to take away from this

23:13 is we shouldn't write off investing in pilots,

23:16 um,

23:17 and you're,

23:19 at least with this data,

23:20 you're actually reaching more person,

23:22 more people per dollar spent with that.

23:24 Um,

23:25 now.

23:27 You know,

23:27 what other lessons?

23:29 Well,

23:29 a huge thing was cost.

23:31 You know,

23:32 we,

23:32 we invested in innovations for low and middle income countries.

23:36 So

23:37 things that cost less than $3 per person

23:39 based on the documents when they came in,

23:41 they were much more likely to scale.

23:43 It

23:44 perhaps correlated with,

23:46 and I should note there's sort of

23:48 this

23:48 works both ways.

23:49 Once things scale,

23:51 unit costs go way down.

23:53 Um,

23:53 I think that's an insufficiently appreciated

23:56 point.

23:56 There's very good work by the International Rescue Committee.

23:59 Uh,

23:59 they look at the cost of,

24:01 of

24:02 cash transfers,

24:03 and you know,

24:04 some programs within the IRC,

24:06 they pay more than,

24:07 spend more than $1 to deliver.

24:09 A $1 to a recipient.

24:11 Others they spend 14 cents,

24:12 and the biggest determinant is the scale at which they operate the program.

24:16 So,

24:16 um,

24:16 but in any case,

24:17 interventions that have low cost are much more likely to scale.

24:21 Here's a

24:22 perhaps a

24:23 related implication.

24:25 You know,

24:26 when you're talking about an inexpensive product,

24:28 customer acquisition costs loom huge.

24:31 So

24:32 if you're,

24:33 you know,

24:33 a lot of social entrepreneurs like other entrepreneurs

24:36 think first of selling to the customer,

24:38 to an ultimate customer,

24:39 but actually

24:40 a lot of businesses sell to other businesses,

24:42 they sell to governments,

24:44 those that already have the network

24:46 by having a strategy of,

24:48 of going to

24:50 people who already have a network for reaching the ultimate customers,

24:53 they are much more likely to scale.

24:55 And then finally,

24:56 and obviously I'm a biased party on this,

24:58 um,

24:59 but

25:00 having some

25:01 rigorous evidence of,

25:03 of impact

25:04 uh through a randomized controlled trial,

25:06 that was,

25:07 a lot of people think of that as slowing things down,

25:10 as inconsistent with lean innovation.

25:13 We actually see in our data

25:15 that the proposals that came in with that were much more likely to scale

25:19 than the ones that didn't,

25:20 and that's very correlated with having a

25:22 a development economics researcher in there.

25:25 I think that,

25:26 you know,

25:26 there are many stories about why that relationship might be there,

25:30 but I'll speculate that,

25:31 You know,

25:32 in a,

25:32 in a lot of,

25:33 in a lot of fields,

25:35 it's

25:36 considered very normal for researchers to get

25:38 involved in developing products and certainly in,

25:41 in computer science and,

25:43 in,

25:43 uh,

25:43 in biotech.

25:45 I think there are some

25:47 areas within economics,

25:49 actually,

25:49 you know,

25:50 um,

25:50 economic theory,

25:51 there are,

25:52 there are researchers who get very involved with auction design,

25:55 etc.

25:56 I think

25:57 some areas of,

25:58 of development economics are now starting to,

26:01 to be such an area,

26:02 um,

26:03 and particularly uh um

26:05 areas that involve randomized controlled trials.

26:08 Um,

26:08 they

26:09 bring the researcher very close to the problem that they're,

26:11 that the researcher is studying,

26:13 get perspectives from the customer from a variety of different places.

26:17 Um,

26:18 anyway,

26:18 that's a separate discussion,

26:19 but empirically that doesn't seem to be a negative and if anything

26:23 seems to be a pretty strong positive.

26:26 OK,

26:26 so

26:28 I mentioned,

26:28 you know,

26:28 you can count the number of users different ways,

26:31 um,

26:32 but we did try to calculate the benefits.

26:34 If you remember this chart back here,

26:36 um,

26:37 the things,

26:38 most of these we couldn't quantify.

26:40 They weren't,

26:40 couldn't express them in dollar values,

26:43 didn't have a,

26:43 have a good RCT evidence,

26:45 but the ones in red,

26:46 we could.

26:47 So for 5 out of these 43,

26:50 we,

26:50 we could put a dollar value on the benefits.

26:53 And we add up that.

26:54 Dollar value.

26:55 Our total portfolio,

26:56 our total investment was $16 million over this period.

27:00 If we look at the total benefits,

27:02 $260 million

27:04 so 17 times as big.

27:05 And um

27:07 um

27:07 so

27:08 I think that suggests that this is an area with very high returns.

27:12 You might then say,

27:13 well,

27:14 how can there be high returns?

27:15 We don't think that government investment programs

27:18 are,

27:18 you know,

27:18 governments are good at picking winners.

27:21 I think there are

27:22 really two reasons for that.

27:23 I would,

27:24 I would speculate.

27:25 One is that

27:27 these are social returns,

27:28 these are not necessarily private returns.

27:30 So the biggest winner,

27:32 so to speak,

27:33 was

27:33 a software firm in Cambridge,

27:35 Massachusetts that developed software for community health workers.

27:39 That got,

27:39 that reached,

27:40 you know,

27:41 Indian,

27:41 that was used for Indian community health workers,

27:44 reached 60 million clients,

27:47 mothers.

27:48 There's strong evidence of impact,

27:50 health impact,

27:51 but did they make much money?

27:53 No,

27:54 for two reasons.

27:55 First,

27:56 um,

27:56 you know,

27:56 I don't think they were being paid that much for it.

27:59 Second,

28:00 the Indian government.

28:01 Understandably eventually went with their own supplier

28:04 and they they lost this business,

28:06 but the Indian government's continuing to

28:08 get software for community health workers.

28:10 It's just not

28:11 now if you're a private investor,

28:13 you know,

28:13 Warren Buffett talks about

28:15 you want a moat,

28:16 you know,

28:16 you want some first mover advantage for the things you invest in.

28:20 If you're a public investor.

28:22 If you're,

28:22 you know,

28:23 we're part of the US government promoting development,

28:25 if others are going to come in and imitate,

28:27 then that generates more benefits for society.

28:30 That's not necessarily a negative,

28:31 it's actually in some ways a positive.

28:34 OK.

28:34 Um,

28:35 the other thing,

28:36 so that's why I think it's possible,

28:38 why not all the great ideas will be scooped up by the private sector.

28:41 Some of them are

28:42 good for society,

28:43 but not necessarily commercially good.

28:45 But the other element,

28:46 and here this is speculation,

28:47 is,

28:48 I think the discipline of saying we don't invest large amounts

28:50 of money until there's rigorous evidence of impact and cost effectiveness,

28:55 I think that was important in avoiding some,

28:57 some wasteful investments.

29:00 OK,

29:01 we talked about,

29:02 you know,

29:02 one,

29:03 final,

29:03 uh,

29:04 uh,

29:04 set of,

29:05 of things,

29:06 uh,

29:06 a

29:07 sort of a meta-innovation which is

29:09 trying directly to incentivize the private sector to harness the,

29:13 uh,

29:14 the great inventiveness they've shown in developing products for,

29:17 uh,

29:17 where there is a commercial market,

29:19 for areas that where there's social needs,

29:21 but where the market isn't as attractive.

29:24 So

29:25 intellectual property systems,

29:27 they reward innovators with monopoly rights for some period of time.

29:31 That's great in that it focuses attention on things people are willing to pay for,

29:37 but a downside

29:38 is that

29:39 there's a monopoly,

29:40 and that creates,

29:41 in the bloodless language of economics,

29:43 static losses.

29:44 But in the,

29:45 in some cases,

29:46 you know,

29:47 that means fewer people might get access to life saving drugs or.

29:50 Scenes,

29:51 uh,

29:51 so we might be worried about it.

29:52 And there's

29:53 interminable debates and shifts back and forth on intellectual property rights.

29:58 And I think that's because the ins

30:00 working within the current institutional framework,

30:03 sort of,

30:04 do you want more of one and less of the other,

30:05 or do you want to switch it?

30:07 These are two really important goals,

30:08 access and,

30:09 and incentives for R&D.

30:11 Well,

30:11 we can break that,

30:12 that whole paradigm

30:13 if we just expand the set of institutions.

30:17 And

30:17 I think there's opportunities to simultaneously

30:20 incentivize R&D and improve access.

30:22 So let me

30:23 talk about one effort that I was involved in.

30:26 Which is something called an advanced market commitment.

30:29 So those are legal commitments made by governments or by donors,

30:33 um,

30:33 to pay

30:34 uh a top up,

30:36 um,

30:36 for,

30:37 uh,

30:38 in this case a vaccine meeting certain uh

30:40 uh specifications

30:42 if the governments are,

30:43 are want to want to

30:45 pay something for it,

30:46 and if the firm agrees to some uh maximum price.

30:51 That basically

30:53 offers the opportunity by committing

30:56 to buy this and to buy a large quantity

30:58 that offers the opportunity,

30:59 the firm an opportunity to go from a

31:02 relatively high priced market serving a small number of people

31:06 to

31:07 much higher volumes at a somewhat lower unit price.

31:11 That can increase their total incentives and it can,

31:13 can get access.

31:15 So an advance market commitment was set out for pneumococcus,

31:18 um,

31:18 $1.5 billion was committed.

31:21 Um,

31:21 there's a,

31:22 um,

31:23 these were the prices that were chosen.

31:25 Here's some evidence on,

31:28 uh,

31:28 so three vaccines were developed against pneumococcus,

31:31 two by,

31:32 by large multinational firms,

31:34 a third recently developed in India,

31:36 um.

31:38 This was,

31:39 um,

31:39 you know,

31:40 this was rolled out

31:42 very,

31:42 very quickly relative to most vaccines,

31:45 um,

31:45 I think in part because of the structure of the advanced market commitment.

31:49 So I've shown a comparison between the pneumococcus vaccine

31:52 and the rotavirus vaccine which didn't have one.

31:55 It's estimated that

31:56 700,000 lives have been saved by the pneumococcus vaccine,

31:59 so,

32:00 um,

32:00 this,

32:01 this can,

32:01 you know,

32:02 potentially have a very large

32:03 impact,

32:04 hundreds of millions of doses have been,

32:06 have been delivered.

32:07 Um,

32:08 OK.

32:08 I think this approach could be used in other,

32:11 in other cases.

32:12 I won't go through this slide,

32:13 but,

32:14 you know,

32:14 cement.

32:15 7% of greenhouse gas emissions.

32:19 Governments consume and the US government consumes about half of cement in the US.

32:23 It's,

32:24 um,

32:25 there's,

32:25 it's very,

32:27 it's very polluting.

32:28 The value of a ton of cement

32:31 is

32:31 pretty much the same as the value of the carbon

32:34 that's emitted.

32:35 There are technologies for producing greener cement,

32:38 um,

32:39 but the social benefits of that would be great,

32:41 but the commercial incentives to invest aren't.

32:44 You know,

32:44 if governments

32:46 perhaps assisted by institutions like the World Bank could say,

32:49 hey,

32:50 we'll commit that if somebody develops a greener cement.

32:53 We will help finance the purchase of that in a

32:56 way that is tied to the reductions in carbon.

32:59 Well,

32:59 that's something that could help provide the stimulus,

33:02 and

33:03 you know,

33:03 governments often introduce regulations

33:06 after technology is developed.

33:08 If you just announce that in advance,

33:10 you might stimulate the development of the technology.

33:13 Um,

33:14 so,

33:15 you know,

33:15 overall high rate of return to innovations.

33:18 I think we should be investing more

33:21 and But I think we also should think about

33:23 potential new institutions

33:25 uh to accelerate

33:27 investment and innovation,

33:29 shape it towards human needs that

33:31 might not otherwise attract commercial investment,

33:33 and then structure those institutions

33:36 so that

33:36 as you know,

33:37 with advanced market commitments,

33:38 the payment's only made if the product is developed.

33:41 So with uh

33:42 um so that in ways that are

33:44 uh limit,

33:45 limit potential waste and limit throwing good money after bad.

33:48 Thanks very much.

33:58 Oh yeah,

33:58 I'm happy to,

33:59 happy to take a,

34:01 a,

34:01 a few questions and I'll,

34:02 maybe I'll gather them up and then uh then

34:04 try to answer at least some,

34:06 uh

34:16 Hello,

34:16 my name is Juliet Adams.

34:18 I'm also an educator,

34:19 and I'm very much interested to hear your perspective of

34:24 innovation and creativity in the education system,

34:27 especially as it pertains to the US.

34:29 Thank you.

34:31 Sorry,

34:31 especially as it pertains to what

34:33 the US,

34:34 OK.

34:35 Yeah.

34:48 I

34:49 I was wondering,

34:50 um,

34:51 have you

34:52 talked or exchanged ideas with either Jim Kim or Melinda Gates?

34:57 Uh,

34:57 your work sounds

34:59 very similar to Farsley Abed's at at Brax,

35:03 and as early as 2015,

35:05 both,

35:06 uh,

35:07 Jim,

35:07 Kim and Melinda Gates

35:10 were using that in the middle of women empowerment

35:13 and then moving that through into technology.

35:16 So I was just wondering if you'd come,

35:18 uh uh I think there might be some very strong multipliers there.

35:33 Um,

35:34 hello.

35:34 Um,

35:35 so my question is,

35:36 in a decade or two,

35:37 do you think

35:38 that,

35:39 um,

35:39 entrepreneurship and innovation

35:42 from an economics point of view would,

35:44 um,

35:45 would contribute to solving unemployment?

35:47 And if so,

35:48 to what extent

35:50 can we rely

35:51 on,

35:52 um,

35:53 entrepreneurship and innovation,

35:54 especially,

35:55 um,

35:56 uh,

35:57 tech-based,

35:57 uh,

35:58 um,

35:58 enterprises?

36:08 Uh,

36:08 hi.

36:09 Uh,

36:09 my question is,

36:10 uh,

36:11 what do you think

36:12 higher education

36:14 can do to facilitate and promote innovation,

36:17 mostly universities.

36:18 Thank you.

36:20 OK.

36:21 OK.

36:21 Uh,

36:22 OK,

36:26 great.

36:27 Uh,

36:27 I think I already have more than I can handle.

36:29 Um,

36:30 um,

36:31 let me,

36:31 uh,

36:31 first,

36:32 um,

36:33 take the,

36:33 the,

36:34 the first question at least,

36:35 uh,

36:36 on,

36:36 on education,

36:37 and maybe this will link a little bit to,

36:39 to higher education as well.

36:42 I,

36:43 there's

36:45 There's,

36:45 I think,

36:46 a lot of poten,

36:47 there's a lot of excitement in

36:50 about artificial intelligence,

36:51 to take one example,

36:52 and I think

36:53 um

36:54 there's,

36:55 I think,

36:56 you know,

36:57 some people have the view that there's a lot of uh

37:00 of

37:01 huge amount of potential for artificial intelligence to

37:05 help in education,

37:06 um,

37:06 and some people have the view that there's

37:09 a lot of hype.

37:10 Now I think both things are.

37:12 Um,

37:13 um,

37:14 so how do we,

37:15 how do you make progress in this area?

37:17 Well,

37:18 you know,

37:18 first,

37:18 why is there,

37:19 why is there a lot of potential?

37:21 A lot of children fall very far behind

37:25 where the official curriculum is.

37:27 In that type of a situation,

37:29 it's very hard to benefit from the,

37:31 from the existing curriculum,

37:34 and you know,

37:35 those,

37:35 as we'll hear in the next session,

37:36 COVID's obviously worsened that problem,

37:38 but it was there,

37:39 uh,

37:39 it was there before.

37:41 Well,

37:41 and very important principles to meet the learner where they are.

37:45 So you can develop personalized adaptive learning systems

37:49 and,

37:50 you know,

37:50 AI can be very good at that,

37:52 at trying to understand where the student is and,

37:54 and trying to,

37:55 to help them.

37:56 Um,

37:57 now,

37:58 and then trying to figure out how best to communicate with that individual learner,

38:01 for example.

38:02 And the,

38:03 and they're very encouraging results on some

38:05 of these personalized adaptive learning systems,

38:08 huge learning gains.

38:09 At the same time,

38:11 it's

38:12 far from trivial to think about how do you integrate this into

38:16 an

38:16 into a,

38:17 into an education system that isn't built around that.

38:20 So that's going to,

38:21 working on that's going to require a combination of technological innovation

38:25 and it's going to require

38:27 a lot of social innovation.

38:29 I'm working on the ground with teachers,

38:30 with ministries of education to make progress on that,

38:33 and I'll probably require

38:35 a lot of trial and error.

38:37 And

38:37 multiple approaches,

38:39 approaches that are involved working with the students,

38:41 approaches that involve

38:42 maybe helping teachers develop lesson plans,

38:45 approaches that

38:47 involve working at the level

38:48 of the,

38:49 of the headmaster of the education system to provide support to teachers.

38:53 There's a huge amount,

38:55 huge potential in this area,

38:57 and you know,

38:57 you saw that chart.

38:59 There's going to be a lot of,

39:00 of,

39:00 of,

39:00 of the skewness of the distribution.

39:02 There'll be a lot of failures in this area.

39:04 But I think the point is if you think about this from an overall portfolio

39:08 investment approach,

39:10 you can afford some failures if we can get

39:12 learning gains.

39:13 You know,

39:14 what drives growth in the,

39:15 in the end,

39:16 well,

39:17 many things drive growth,

39:18 but technological change drives growth and

39:22 capital drives growth.

39:23 Human capital.

39:24 Accounts for correctly measured accounts for a

39:27 huge fraction of overall capital investment,

39:30 and that's a big sector of total big share

39:33 of total investments in countries that have high population growth

39:37 and skewed age distributions.

39:39 We have a chance now,

39:40 you know,

39:40 we've

39:41 terrible education results in much of the world.

39:43 We have a chance to improve that.

39:45 You know,

39:45 investing and improving that seems like a,

39:48 a,

39:48 a great case of the need for,

39:50 for innovation.

39:51 Um,

39:51 what can higher education do?

39:53 Um,

39:54 you know,

39:55 certainly,

39:56 um,

39:56 I think there's,

39:57 you know,

39:58 many of the,

39:59 you know,

39:59 many of the successful innovations I,

40:01 I mentioned involved researchers,

40:04 often university-based researchers in many of this.

40:07 I,

40:07 I,

40:07 uh,

40:08 I also think that

40:11 I think that having,

40:12 uh,

40:13 I,

40:13 I guess I would add 22 elements.

40:16 One is,

40:16 I think having openness

40:18 so that they can

40:19 develop their own partnerships and and propose their own ideas,

40:23 even if they're not coming from a,

40:24 a top-down analysis that we've done at USAI about,

40:28 you know,

40:28 these are the priority sectors.

40:29 Deliberately set it up that way

40:31 and obviously USA has a lot of areas it declares priorities,

40:34 but having openness

40:36 to input from

40:37 uh from researchers I think and others,

40:39 entrepreneurs

40:40 makes a lot of sense.

40:41 Um,

40:42 the other thing is sometimes you do need bigger

40:45 you know DARPA-like projects

40:47 to focus on goals.

40:49 OK.

40:49 Um,

40:50 let me,

40:50 um,

40:51 you know,

40:52 I think,

40:52 uh,

40:52 I won't go into detail on some of the other

40:55 issues,

40:55 but I think there's

40:56 a lot of creative things that can be done on gender.

40:59 You know,

40:59 I mentioned one thing related to gender,

41:01 Gender Innovation lab,

41:02 uh,

41:03 at the World Bank,

41:04 obviously does,

41:04 you know,

41:05 amazing work.

41:06 Um,

41:07 um,

41:07 the,

41:08 um,

41:09 and the

41:09 You know,

41:09 wonderful,

41:11 you know,

41:11 really exciting things on prevention of gender-based violence and

41:15 very exciting results on that from a number of,

41:17 of academic researchers,

41:19 I think,

41:19 trying to

41:20 think about how to scale those up,

41:22 um,

41:22 that's going to require additional work to convert those to scalable products,

41:25 but

41:26 it's vital.

41:27 Um,

41:28 the,

41:28 um,

41:30 The issue of entrepreneurship and unemployment.

41:34 I think this is a really interesting and important issue one.

41:39 You know,

41:40 people have focused a lot on the negative side of technology in terms of employment.

41:44 There are a lot of people

41:46 in,

41:47 and again,

41:48 the scenario where there's,

41:49 I think,

41:49 a lot of potential and a lot of hype,

41:51 but

41:52 there's,

41:53 there are a lot of people who are not very mobile

41:56 and who can't necessarily go to where the jobs are and can't do them.

41:59 If you think of farmers,

42:01 you know,

42:01 in rain-fed agriculture,

42:03 sometimes they have a lot of time during some parts of the year.

42:05 If you think of

42:07 women,

42:07 you know,

42:08 there might be.

42:08 Jobs in the city or in certain places that women can undertake,

42:12 but they're not able to move

42:14 to take those jobs.

42:15 Well,

42:16 to the extent that

42:17 technological advance can make things more mobile,

42:20 maybe the jobs can move to where the

42:21 where the people are who can do them

42:25 and.

42:28 And I,

42:28 I think I,

42:29 maybe I'll,

42:29 I'll leave it at that,

42:30 but thank you very much.

42:36 Yeah

showAllTimestamps
no
transcript
Our keynote speaker up here, and I think you're going to, uh, when this is all over, when you've heard what he has to say, you're gonna feel that you, uh, were lucky to be here today to, uh, hear the thoughts of someone who is, uh, uh, such a, such a renowned person in his field. But you know, he's not just any kind of renowned economist. Um, he is credited with transforming global research in development economics, a field that he's been pursuing for many, many years. In fact, uh, in his early years as a student at Harvard, he wrote his senior thesis comparing an employment guarantee program in India with a food subsidy program in Sri Lanka. So, There you go, uh, when other people are writing about Lord knows what, he was already looking at this important field where he has continued to grow, continued to develop, and I'm talking about Professor Michael Kramer. Uh, he is at the University of Chicago Development Economics Program. He's had a long, illustrious career, so many different places, uh, developing this field, and so much so that in 2019, he co-won with two other economists, uh, the Nobel Prize in Economics. Uh, he is, uh, they were recognized for their, uh, experimental approach to alleviating global poverty. This groundbreak. Breaking research has reshaped our understanding of the role of human capital, poverty alleviation in developing countries. Um, there's, you know, if you look at his wiki page, he, I could go on and on, but instead, I'm going to now bring you Michael Kramer to the podium. Michael, welcome. OK. Great. Thank you very much for that, uh, for that, uh, nice introduction. Um, So earlier speakers noted the gap uh between the ambitious targets that the world has set for itself on development, on climate change, um, and the resources that have been made available and are likely to be made available uh for that, for those purposes. Um, and you know that naturally raises the question of how can we produce more output with, uh, with, with a given input. And that's a classic question in economics and how do we move out the production function and in fact, producing more with given resources is technically the definition of innovation in economics and so that's really a topic that I, I'd like to focus on. Um, let me just note that while I'm, I'm going to talk about um The need for innovation and the role that innovation can play in helping us get more out of resources, you know, that doesn't conflict at all with the idea that more resources should be devoted to these important goals to match the ambitions that we've set for ourselves. And in fact, you know, I think I would argue that To the extent that we can show that we can deliver more for resources, that actually is very complimentary uh with that goal. So I, I don't wanna I think sort of create a false opposition. So I'll discuss a few individual innovations, um, but beyond individual innovations, I think we need to innovate on the system that we have for promoting innovation and development. You know, we can often, it's natural to take certain institutional features of our system as constraints. Um, so for example, most World Bank funds are lent to national governments and national governments have to repay those loans and they will appropriately think about, you know, is this a good loan for them to take. Um, but you know there are some investments, uh, particularly. Investments in innovation which can benefit many countries and our international or even global public goods. I know there's a lot of debate about is it appropriate to take funds meant for development and shift them to certain types of global public goods, but within global public goods, there's certainly a subset that primarily are relevant for low and middle income countries, for example, Certain health problems are most common in low and middle income countries. Certain agricultural problems. I don't think it's at all limited to those two sectors, but that type of global public investing, I'll argue that investing in that type of global public good does offer an opportunity to deliver more outcomes for for for a given amount of investment. And that I think is. If to the extent that our current institutions aren't set up well to enable that, maybe it's worth considering reforms to some of our institutions for that purpose. Um, OK. Um, so let me just start with some things that I think are, on the one hand, probably almost everybody in this room knows at some level. On the other hand, the magnitude of these effects are so enormous that I think it's worth, uh, you know, periodically reminding ourselves of them. So first, let me just note the tremendous impact of innovation and helping us achieve more with the, with uh, with given resources in one area that's a focus of a lot of goals, which is uh child survival. So this is, uh, what this graph shows is the top shows uh is a graph of health and income in 1900. And so you see Italy there, and in 1900, 300 out of every 1000 children born in Italy died before their fifth birthday. Now, the bottom part of that shows the relationship in today, uh, today, and I've highlighted Kenya. In Kenya, less than 5% of children die before their 5th birthday. So, you know, huge improvement in human welfare, almost unfathomable improvement in, in human welfare. And yet, Is that because Kenya got is today is richer than Italy? No, Kenya is actually, Kenya today is actually slightly lower income than Italy in 1900. The difference is a whole suite of innovations that enabled that, and you know that includes everything from a bunch of technological innovations, development of antibiotics, vaccines, oral rehydration therapy, but also social innovations that provide the vast majority of women and their children with access to prenatal care, um, attended delivery, and essential healthcare. I think there's lots of potential for further innovation, um, but, you know, while there's strong incentives for certain types of innovation, um, and, you know, purely exist commercial incentives under our existing institutions are somewhat weaker for other part, other types of innovation that are socially very valuable. Uh, so within health, you can think about a malaria vaccine, for example. Or uh low cost water treatment for, for rural areas. I'll come back to the discussion later of uh of pneumococcal vaccine. Um, there's uh, there are different strains of pneumococcus in high and middle income countries and in lower income countries, and vaccines were developed first, as you can imagine, for those in higher and middle income countries. Let me, I think economic theory can shed light on when there'll be relatively large gaps and when there'll be smaller gaps between commercial incentives and social incentives. So, uh, you know, there are, there are multiple cases. This is an, you know, very interesting area in economics, uh, very rich and complex, but let me just give a couple of, you know, fairly straightforward examples. One is the, one is the case of uh of, of uh externalities. So some innovations create benefits, not just for the user of the good, but for other people. Um, so a good example of that would be an industrial innovation or an agricultural innovation for that matter, that reduces greenhouse gas emissions. Um. So I'll come to the case of green cement, but cement produces a lot of emissions. If we found a way of producing cement that released fewer emissions, well, that would be of enormous benefit to the world, but it's not clear that the buyers of cement would pay more for that. So there might be insufficient incentives to invest in that. Another case is innovations in provision of government services, um, such as improvements in tax administration, for example. You know, if I think about, you know, we may not think of it, uh, today as one, but value-added taxes were not common in most of the world. Oh, if we went further back and thanks. In part to, I don't know whether I'm allowed to say nice things about the IMF here, but, uh, thanks in part to the uh to the, the work of the IMF, um, you know, these are now common around the world, and I think they, they are an efficient way of raising, raising taxes. Um, but you can also think about ways of provision, providing health, agricultural extension, um, you know, education. So I think there's a role and it's difficult for firms to, to make money anywhere near, I'm not saying you can make zero money, but it's hard to get for them to, they don't have this, the incentives that are commensurate with the social value of, of some of these innovations. Um, I'd also note that some of these are global public goods as well, and that creates a little bit of a free rider problem among countries. Um. So if we look, I've been talking, given a few examples, if you look at studies of the rate of return to innovation, there are a number of them, and they generate very high estimates of the rate of return, things like 60, 70% annual rates of return, uh, social return. Um, so I will, I should note, however, that innovation is first inherently risky, and second, it's very easy to throw good money after bad. And When we think about institutions to encourage innovation, we need things that will, um, you know, accelerate the pace of innovation, shape it to meet social needs, but also we need to design institutions that can limit some of the waste that might come if we're, if we're, if we're, if we, if we don't find a way of preventing throwing good money after bad. So let me give a, you know, say a little bit about the rest of the talk. I've been working on, uh, I've been chairing a commission on innovation for climate change, food security, and agriculture. Um, so I've been thinking about innovations around climate adaptation, to some extent mitigation in, in around food security and agriculture. So I'll say, I'll just as. Examples, I'll choose examples from that sector and sort of make the case that not only there's historical examples, but there are things we could be doing right now. Um, um, second, I'll discuss, oh I see two ones there anyway, um, the, um, um, uh, institutions for, for, uh, for innovation, and I'll talk about two types of institutions. OK. OK, so some some innovations for climate adaptation. So with climate change, not only are we're seeing higher temperatures, for example, but we're seeing increased uncertainty around weather. And um, you know, variation in daily precipitation is estimated to increase by about 5% and temperature variability increases by 10 to 15% per. Degrees Celsius of warming. So this is, um, and there's also increased variation in the timing of agricultural seasons. So if you think about a farmer who's used to traditional times of year to plant for other operations, certain rules of thumb, those rules of thumb may not work anymore. Now, there's a lot of technological progress on this, so it's now possible to predict rainy season or monsoon onset up to a month in advance in, in, in many parts of the world, um, and, you know, AI is enabling very, very rapid advance in, in some areas of weather forecasting. And it allows customized weather forecasts to be made, so it's not just a general weather forecast. You know, this is the probability of rain today, probability tomorrow. A farmer might need to know very specific information, you know, is it going to, what's the prob, what's the probability of rain in the next 3 days? Uh, what's the, or something much more complicated than that? Should I plan today or is it better to take the option of waiting after that? Well, it's now. You can set AI, you know, AI models can be optimized. The, the loss function on them in technical terms can be set around whatever parameter is most important to the, to the farmer, and these can be run very quickly. The big firms in this area like Nvidia and so on, they have open access models that can easily be tweaked. Talking to a researcher, a colleague said, you know, a grad student or a postdoc can do this in a, in a day. Um, the, um, now there's a lot of evidence from multiple studies that farmers adjust their behavior, their agricultural behavior, and their investment decisions in response to accurate weather forecasts. But nonetheless, most farmers are not getting this information right now. And um you know, there's a couple of RCTs that estimate benefits. I don't want to claim it's just everywhere, but a couple of RCTs, randomized controlled trials, find benefits over $100 per farmer, and the cost of, of, of producing these forecasts and even disseminating them, you know. Maybe 1/100 of that. Um, so, um. In part because they can be delivered digitally. Um, so we've been working with the Indian government. They just for the most recent monsoon, um, they delivered, uh, forecasts of monsoon onset and total rainfall in certain parts of India, not, uh, not Mumbai, which that wasn't part of this pilot year, um, um, uh, 4 to 9 million farmers. Um, and you know, the government of India has a list of 100 million phone numbers, uh, farmers, so it should be very easy. To expand this and of course other countries in South Asia, Africa, in fact, other areas, Latin uh Inter-American Development Bank to speak well of another nearby institution, you know, they're, they're working with, uh, they're, they're trying to extend this in Latin America. Um, now, I don't want to claim this is all automatic, you know, things need, when you're doing this, you need to think through how do you best communicate with farmers about probabilistic information, um, how do you build farmer trust. You probably want to build in a bunch of A B tests to optimize these types of systems, but the reason, what time of even boring things, what time of day do you send the messages to the farmer? How many repetitions? Well, that's tech companies are doing A B tests like this all the time. I think we could be, we could be doing similar things, and the benefits will exceed beyond any one country. OK. OK, let me turn to another, you know, that's sort of a technological innovation that also needs a bunch of uh institutional and social adaptation. Here's something that's more Not particularly technological at all. It's just a um a financial market innovation. So, obviously a vast literature on microfinance, and I think uh that the latest wave is a little bit of an uptake, uptake on that. There was a lot of excitement, and a lot of disillusionment, but there's, uh, you know, still some, I, I think people, we don't want to throw out the baby with the bathwater on that. But, you know, one area that's been somewhat disappointing is the effect on productive investments. Well, one of the interesting areas of research that, you know, many people are involved in is can we try to adjust the, the typical microfinance contract to make it more conducive to expanding actual investment. So here's a study that, uh, that I was involved in with uh Tawni Surrey and, and, uh, and Billy Jack and Yost a lot. Um, this, you see a picture here of a, of a rainwater harvesting tank. Dairy cattle need a lot of, of water. They need to be water every day. And of course, humans need water. Um, so, um, these, these tanks, you see them everywhere on top of roofs in urban areas, but they can also be useful in agriculture. They cost, um, but they cost $300 the 5000 L tank. That's not, that's not trivial for a, for a farming family in Kenya to buy. So we looked at just You can, if you take a look at that, there's no moving parts. It's pretty big, hard to hide, makes pretty good collateral. So we worked with a savings and loan cooperative that tried saying, OK, we'll just do an asset collateralized loan. They got takeup of the loan product went from 2% to 25% without any increase in default. Rates and dairy farmers were producing more milk. They were also better able to to get through periods when the rain was was not coming. And they, they actually, this was a study, but the, the dairy cooperative and the Associated Savings and Loan Association continued the program afterwards with their own funds, and other cooperatives are doing that. This is another thing that I think, you know, you could invest in scale, and here I think the gap between commercial and social incentives are much, much smaller. But if you think about each stage of taking this on a little bit more broadly, you know, it's another thing for a financial, for a bank or some other financial provider to expand access to this program, working with savings and credit cooperatives or dairy cooperatives. They would be taking some risks. If they succeed in that, a bunch of other financial institutions are going to enter that market, and they're not going to get a monopoly on this market. They're going to have to share the profits in that. If they fail, they're going to take the losses. So this is an area where, to the extent that there is an institution that is willing to provide capital for climate resilience or try or willing to willing to invest in in. Yeah, these are also particularly favorable to, to women because women are often enough to do a lot of the work of collecting water, um, that has that as a social objective, it's worth probably helping finance at least experimentation on that, even if not, you know, not necessarily long run subsidies. OK, um. OK. So those are examples of uh, of, of types of innovation that um that can be used, and there's a long list just within agriculture, food security, climate change, that we've got on our website for the commission, we've got a, a long, a long list of, of innovations with evidence of impact and cost effectiveness that we think are, are ready to scale. Um. Let me try to take a, uh, a little bit more of a, of a systematic approach to this and also transition to what I call meta-innovations, innovations in the system for creating innovations. Um, so I'll talk about two things here. Let's first talk about open-tiered evidence-based uh social innovation funds. So that I'm involved with, uh, um, um, Development Innovation Ventures, which is a part of USAI. Um, FID in France, uh, uh, has a lot, a lot of similarities. Both of these are designed to be quite open to applications, um, and not necessarily top-down, open to ideas, um, across sectors, across countries, both open to commercial scaling and to public scaling, um, but the, you know, how do you discipline that openness and how do you avoid throwing good money after bad? Well, we have pretty strict rules about shared funding. So there are very small grants of, of, of, of, uh, for piloting. But then to get more serious amounts of money, um, it has to go undergo rigorous testing for impact and cost effectiveness if it's something that would be scaled with public sector funding, slightly different rules if it would be scaled uh through the private sector. And then, um, and, and then there's, so we have funds available for that and then we have funds for transitioning this to scale because, That, you know, additional tweaks are needed for that, uh, more than tweaks to adapt things for scale. So me, we've now been around for a bit over a decade, uh, um, and we can review the evidence from our full portfolio to look at what's the rate of return to these investments and maybe try to draw some lessons about which innovation scale. Um, so let me share some of this. First, here's a picture of our 1st 42 grants, we took the 1st 2 years of our portfolio. How much did uh different innovations scale? And what you can see here is very skewed distribution. And of course, that's extremely typical of any type of innovation fund. If you look at patent citations, if you look at citations to academic articles, you'll see exactly this. And any venture capital fund knows, you know, they're not going to get hit with everything, but if they invest in Google or Facebook, then that's, then they're gonna be uh very successful. In fact, um, um, so the, so what are the, what are some characteristics of things that scale? Well, we broke this down by uh award stage. And you know, there's a saying in development that pilots never scale, so we thought we'd look at that empirically. And indeed, you know, there's only a 17 scaling here is reaching a million people or more, uh, that's somewhat arbitrary how you count that. I'll I'll come back to, oh, I think it is a better metric overall, but 17% of the stage ones reached over a million people. The stage threes that, you know, there was only one of those, and it succeeded. you might say, OK, maybe the pilots aren't working out so well, but here's a different way of looking at it. Here's the award value and the number of people reached, and the people reached per dollar, and you get a totally different picture. I don't want to play this up in terms of statistically significant differences and so on. They're not, you know, these are small samples and. Uh, not, not, uh, causal estimates for those of you are, you know, who are, uh, technical here, but, um, the, you know, I think the lesson to take away from this is we shouldn't write off investing in pilots, um, and you're, at least with this data, you're actually reaching more person, more people per dollar spent with that. Um, now. You know, what other lessons? Well, a huge thing was cost. You know, we, we invested in innovations for low and middle income countries. So things that cost less than $3 per person based on the documents when they came in, they were much more likely to scale. It perhaps correlated with, and I should note there's sort of this works both ways. Once things scale, unit costs go way down. Um, I think that's an insufficiently appreciated point. There's very good work by the International Rescue Committee. Uh, they look at the cost of, of cash transfers, and you know, some programs within the IRC, they pay more than, spend more than $1 to deliver. A $1 to a recipient. Others they spend 14 cents, and the biggest determinant is the scale at which they operate the program. So, um, but in any case, interventions that have low cost are much more likely to scale. Here's a perhaps a related implication. You know, when you're talking about an inexpensive product, customer acquisition costs loom huge. So if you're, you know, a lot of social entrepreneurs like other entrepreneurs think first of selling to the customer, to an ultimate customer, but actually a lot of businesses sell to other businesses, they sell to governments, those that already have the network by having a strategy of, of going to people who already have a network for reaching the ultimate customers, they are much more likely to scale. And then finally, and obviously I'm a biased party on this, um, but having some rigorous evidence of, of impact uh through a randomized controlled trial, that was, a lot of people think of that as slowing things down, as inconsistent with lean innovation. We actually see in our data that the proposals that came in with that were much more likely to scale than the ones that didn't, and that's very correlated with having a a development economics researcher in there. I think that, you know, there are many stories about why that relationship might be there, but I'll speculate that, You know, in a, in a lot of, in a lot of fields, it's considered very normal for researchers to get involved in developing products and certainly in, in computer science and, in, uh, in biotech. I think there are some areas within economics, actually, you know, um, economic theory, there are, there are researchers who get very involved with auction design, etc. I think some areas of, of development economics are now starting to, to be such an area, um, and particularly uh um areas that involve randomized controlled trials. Um, they bring the researcher very close to the problem that they're, that the researcher is studying, get perspectives from the customer from a variety of different places. Um, anyway, that's a separate discussion, but empirically that doesn't seem to be a negative and if anything seems to be a pretty strong positive. OK, so I mentioned, you know, you can count the number of users different ways, um, but we did try to calculate the benefits. If you remember this chart back here, um, the things, most of these we couldn't quantify. They weren't, couldn't express them in dollar values, didn't have a, have a good RCT evidence, but the ones in red, we could. So for 5 out of these 43, we, we could put a dollar value on the benefits. And we add up that. Dollar value. Our total portfolio, our total investment was $16 million over this period. If we look at the total benefits, $260 million so 17 times as big. And um um so I think that suggests that this is an area with very high returns. You might then say, well, how can there be high returns? We don't think that government investment programs are, you know, governments are good at picking winners. I think there are really two reasons for that. I would, I would speculate. One is that these are social returns, these are not necessarily private returns. So the biggest winner, so to speak, was a software firm in Cambridge, Massachusetts that developed software for community health workers. That got, that reached, you know, Indian, that was used for Indian community health workers, reached 60 million clients, mothers. There's strong evidence of impact, health impact, but did they make much money? No, for two reasons. First, um, you know, I don't think they were being paid that much for it. Second, the Indian government. Understandably eventually went with their own supplier and they they lost this business, but the Indian government's continuing to get software for community health workers. It's just not now if you're a private investor, you know, Warren Buffett talks about you want a moat, you know, you want some first mover advantage for the things you invest in. If you're a public investor. If you're, you know, we're part of the US government promoting development, if others are going to come in and imitate, then that generates more benefits for society. That's not necessarily a negative, it's actually in some ways a positive. OK. Um, the other thing, so that's why I think it's possible, why not all the great ideas will be scooped up by the private sector. Some of them are good for society, but not necessarily commercially good. But the other element, and here this is speculation, is, I think the discipline of saying we don't invest large amounts of money until there's rigorous evidence of impact and cost effectiveness, I think that was important in avoiding some, some wasteful investments. OK, we talked about, you know, one, final, uh, uh, set of, of things, uh, a sort of a meta-innovation which is trying directly to incentivize the private sector to harness the, uh, the great inventiveness they've shown in developing products for, uh, where there is a commercial market, for areas that where there's social needs, but where the market isn't as attractive. So intellectual property systems, they reward innovators with monopoly rights for some period of time. That's great in that it focuses attention on things people are willing to pay for, but a downside is that there's a monopoly, and that creates, in the bloodless language of economics, static losses. But in the, in some cases, you know, that means fewer people might get access to life saving drugs or. Scenes, uh, so we might be worried about it. And there's interminable debates and shifts back and forth on intellectual property rights. And I think that's because the ins working within the current institutional framework, sort of, do you want more of one and less of the other, or do you want to switch it? These are two really important goals, access and, and incentives for R&D. Well, we can break that, that whole paradigm if we just expand the set of institutions. And I think there's opportunities to simultaneously incentivize R&D and improve access. So let me talk about one effort that I was involved in. Which is something called an advanced market commitment. So those are legal commitments made by governments or by donors, um, to pay uh a top up, um, for, uh, in this case a vaccine meeting certain uh uh specifications if the governments are, are want to want to pay something for it, and if the firm agrees to some uh maximum price. That basically offers the opportunity by committing to buy this and to buy a large quantity that offers the opportunity, the firm an opportunity to go from a relatively high priced market serving a small number of people to much higher volumes at a somewhat lower unit price. That can increase their total incentives and it can, can get access. So an advance market commitment was set out for pneumococcus, um, $1.5 billion was committed. Um, there's a, um, these were the prices that were chosen. Here's some evidence on, uh, so three vaccines were developed against pneumococcus, two by, by large multinational firms, a third recently developed in India, um. This was, um, you know, this was rolled out very, very quickly relative to most vaccines, um, I think in part because of the structure of the advanced market commitment. So I've shown a comparison between the pneumococcus vaccine and the rotavirus vaccine which didn't have one. It's estimated that 700,000 lives have been saved by the pneumococcus vaccine, so, um, this, this can, you know, potentially have a very large impact, hundreds of millions of doses have been, have been delivered. Um, OK. I think this approach could be used in other, in other cases. I won't go through this slide, but, you know, cement. 7% of greenhouse gas emissions. Governments consume and the US government consumes about half of cement in the US. It's, um, there's, it's very, it's very polluting. The value of a ton of cement is pretty much the same as the value of the carbon that's emitted. There are technologies for producing greener cement, um, but the social benefits of that would be great, but the commercial incentives to invest aren't. You know, if governments perhaps assisted by institutions like the World Bank could say, hey, we'll commit that if somebody develops a greener cement. We will help finance the purchase of that in a way that is tied to the reductions in carbon. Well, that's something that could help provide the stimulus, and you know, governments often introduce regulations after technology is developed. If you just announce that in advance, you might stimulate the development of the technology. Um, so, you know, overall high rate of return to innovations. I think we should be investing more and But I think we also should think about potential new institutions uh to accelerate investment and innovation, shape it towards human needs that might not otherwise attract commercial investment, and then structure those institutions so that as you know, with advanced market commitments, the payment's only made if the product is developed. So with uh um so that in ways that are uh limit, limit potential waste and limit throwing good money after bad. Thanks very much. Oh yeah, I'm happy to, happy to take a, a, a few questions and I'll, maybe I'll gather them up and then uh then try to answer at least some, uh Hello, my name is Juliet Adams. I'm also an educator, and I'm very much interested to hear your perspective of innovation and creativity in the education system, especially as it pertains to the US. Thank you. Sorry, especially as it pertains to what the US, OK. Yeah. I I was wondering, um, have you talked or exchanged ideas with either Jim Kim or Melinda Gates? Uh, your work sounds very similar to Farsley Abed's at at Brax, and as early as 2015, both, uh, Jim, Kim and Melinda Gates were using that in the middle of women empowerment and then moving that through into technology. So I was just wondering if you'd come, uh uh I think there might be some very strong multipliers there. Um, hello. Um, so my question is, in a decade or two, do you think that, um, entrepreneurship and innovation from an economics point of view would, um, would contribute to solving unemployment? And if so, to what extent can we rely on, um, entrepreneurship and innovation, especially, um, uh, tech-based, uh, um, enterprises? Uh, hi. Uh, my question is, uh, what do you think higher education can do to facilitate and promote innovation, mostly universities. Thank you. OK. OK. Uh, OK, great. Uh, I think I already have more than I can handle. Um, um, let me, uh, first, um, take the, the, the first question at least, uh, on, on education, and maybe this will link a little bit to, to higher education as well. I, there's There's, I think, a lot of poten, there's a lot of excitement in about artificial intelligence, to take one example, and I think um there's, I think, you know, some people have the view that there's a lot of uh of huge amount of potential for artificial intelligence to help in education, um, and some people have the view that there's a lot of hype. Now I think both things are. Um, um, so how do we, how do you make progress in this area? Well, you know, first, why is there, why is there a lot of potential? A lot of children fall very far behind where the official curriculum is. In that type of a situation, it's very hard to benefit from the, from the existing curriculum, and you know, those, as we'll hear in the next session, COVID's obviously worsened that problem, but it was there, uh, it was there before. Well, and very important principles to meet the learner where they are. So you can develop personalized adaptive learning systems and, you know, AI can be very good at that, at trying to understand where the student is and, and trying to, to help them. Um, now, and then trying to figure out how best to communicate with that individual learner, for example. And the, and they're very encouraging results on some of these personalized adaptive learning systems, huge learning gains. At the same time, it's far from trivial to think about how do you integrate this into an into a, into an education system that isn't built around that. So that's going to, working on that's going to require a combination of technological innovation and it's going to require a lot of social innovation. I'm working on the ground with teachers, with ministries of education to make progress on that, and I'll probably require a lot of trial and error. And multiple approaches, approaches that are involved working with the students, approaches that involve maybe helping teachers develop lesson plans, approaches that involve working at the level of the, of the headmaster of the education system to provide support to teachers. There's a huge amount, huge potential in this area, and you know, you saw that chart. There's going to be a lot of, of, of, of the skewness of the distribution. There'll be a lot of failures in this area. But I think the point is if you think about this from an overall portfolio investment approach, you can afford some failures if we can get learning gains. You know, what drives growth in the, in the end, well, many things drive growth, but technological change drives growth and capital drives growth. Human capital. Accounts for correctly measured accounts for a huge fraction of overall capital investment, and that's a big sector of total big share of total investments in countries that have high population growth and skewed age distributions. We have a chance now, you know, we've terrible education results in much of the world. We have a chance to improve that. You know, investing and improving that seems like a, a, a great case of the need for, for innovation. Um, what can higher education do? Um, you know, certainly, um, I think there's, you know, many of the, you know, many of the successful innovations I, I mentioned involved researchers, often university-based researchers in many of this. I, I, uh, I also think that I think that having, uh, I, I guess I would add 22 elements. One is, I think having openness so that they can develop their own partnerships and and propose their own ideas, even if they're not coming from a, a top-down analysis that we've done at USAI about, you know, these are the priority sectors. Deliberately set it up that way and obviously USA has a lot of areas it declares priorities, but having openness to input from uh from researchers I think and others, entrepreneurs makes a lot of sense. Um, the other thing is sometimes you do need bigger you know DARPA-like projects to focus on goals. OK. Um, let me, um, you know, I think, uh, I won't go into detail on some of the other issues, but I think there's a lot of creative things that can be done on gender. You know, I mentioned one thing related to gender, Gender Innovation lab, uh, at the World Bank, obviously does, you know, amazing work. Um, um, the, um, and the You know, wonderful, you know, really exciting things on prevention of gender-based violence and very exciting results on that from a number of, of academic researchers, I think, trying to think about how to scale those up, um, that's going to require additional work to convert those to scalable products, but it's vital. Um, the, um, The issue of entrepreneurship and unemployment. I think this is a really interesting and important issue one. You know, people have focused a lot on the negative side of technology in terms of employment. There are a lot of people in, and again, the scenario where there's, I think, a lot of potential and a lot of hype, but there's, there are a lot of people who are not very mobile and who can't necessarily go to where the jobs are and can't do them. If you think of farmers, you know, in rain-fed agriculture, sometimes they have a lot of time during some parts of the year. If you think of women, you know, there might be. Jobs in the city or in certain places that women can undertake, but they're not able to move to take those jobs. Well, to the extent that technological advance can make things more mobile, maybe the jobs can move to where the where the people are who can do them and. And I, I think I, maybe I'll, I'll leave it at that, but thank you very much. Yeah
showAllTranscripts
no
duration
PT42M37S
scene7File
worldbank/ABCDE2024-Keynote-Kemer
scene7Domain
https://worldbank.scene7.com/
scene7FileAvs
worldbank/ABCDE2024-Keynote-Kemer-AVS
title
ABCDE2024 Keynote Kemer
description
ABCDE2024 Keynote Kemer
showTimestampAndTranscript
yes
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-3
col-lg-3
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-7
col-lg-7
  • add-style
  • lp-body-content
A video recording of the Keynote address with Michael Kremer (University of Chicago) at the Annual Bank Conference on Development Economics 2024 "The Great Incoherence: Growth and Human Development in An Era of Stagnation."
lp-heading-top-medium
lp-heading-bottom-medium
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-2
col-lg-2