col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-12
col-lg-12
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-12
col-lg-12
videoType
dynamic-media
videoDmUrl
https://delivery-p136806-e1377785.adobeaemcloud.com/adobe/assets/urn:aaid:aem:78ea7e82-8bd8-4904-b7ef-d7a391ad0986/play?assetname=Paris_Forum_Recording_Captions.mp4
imageMimeType
image/jpeg
keyFrameImage
videoDescription
Remarks by Axel van Trotsenburg, World Bank Senior Managing Director, at the 11th Edition of the Paris Forum 2024
timestamp

00:00 Thank you very much and good morning everybody.

00:02 Let me first thank the Paris Club as well as the G20 for organizing this.

00:08 What is of course

00:09 interesting is that when we are dealing with this

00:12 debt problems,

00:12 it seems to be an integral part of our financial relations internationally.

00:17 When you look at the last

00:20 probably 6 or so decades,

00:22 I think the Paris Club had something close

00:24 to 500 restructurings involving more than 100 countries.

00:29 So sometimes you ask yourself how is that possible,

00:32 and I have studied that now since 40 years starting back when I

00:37 was at the university and then at the OECD at the bank.

00:40 I think we need to actually see that we are here in a continuous learning process

00:46 and adjustment process,

00:47 and there are a couple of factors is extremely important,

00:50 and they were already mentioned

00:53 also in the previous section.

00:55 I think the first one is

00:56 that we need to deal with the underlying

01:00 debt problem.

01:01 What are the what are the drivers for that?

01:04 That problem

01:05 and there are internal and external factors,

01:07 but we cannot

01:09 deny that if we don't deal with it you can

01:11 have the best debt workout will not have any effect.

01:15 And so what we need to actually deal with is,

01:19 particularly in the internal area is with underlying macro issues,

01:23 fiscal issues,

01:24 and they will need to be addressed.

01:26 And therefore

01:27 I think some

01:28 Mentioned that

01:29 domestic resource mobilization is key for a permanent solution to this.

01:34 Similarly on the external debt,

01:36 clearly we need to keep that in mind

01:38 with what is happening with international interest rates,

01:41 particularly the effects on the poorest countries.

01:43 So this is one important area.

01:46 The second is the importance of what I would say long term debt sustainability.

01:52 It needs to be the DSA needs to be

01:55 fully integrated into economic and particularly fiscal policymaking.

02:01 The unfortunate truth is that this is often not happening,

02:05 but I would again make a passionately on the DSA that this needs to be much more

02:12 valued in the policymakers,

02:14 and there are two big aspects.

02:18 There is the liquidity and solvency

02:20 aspect to work that out,

02:22 as well as the social dimensions.

02:24 On the liquidity,

02:26 what we are seeing.

02:27 is that we need to ensure,

02:29 particularly for the low income countries,

02:32 large positive net flows.

02:35 These countries have huge challenges,

02:37 and we cannot delink that from the social dimension.

02:41 Keep in mind,

02:42 for example,

02:42 in the IA countries,

02:44 their debt service is now 7.5% of GDP.

02:48 Mind you,

02:48 this is not only external debt service,

02:50 it's also the domestic debt service.

02:54 And this is more than education and health combined.

02:58 So if we completely delink that,

03:01 this is one of the challenges these countries are facing.

03:04 So we need to keep

03:05 this also in mind that the social dimensions are important.

03:09 I would say this was one of the lessons when I dealt

03:11 with HIPIC that we always needed to take that into account.

03:14 Because

03:16 the situation is fragile in these countries.

03:18 The second thing is the solvency.

03:22 How we actually make sure that these

03:26 workouts are indeed consistent with the longer term debt sustainability.

03:31 In the past we tended always to focus only on external debt.

03:35 We need now to take also the domestic debt much more into account,

03:40 and that is not easy,

03:43 particularly when we have in many of these lower income countries fairly fragile

03:50 and incipient financial systems.

03:53 We need to be careful

03:55 about this,

03:56 but we need also to keep in mind that in many countries

03:59 the domestic public debt is often half of the total debt,

04:03 and that is

04:05 required.

04:06 Then we will need with the solvency to say,

04:09 well,

04:09 we may need to engage in a

04:12 NPV reduction.

04:15 Then the key factors,

04:16 I think for successful workouts is speed matters,

04:20 and I think here we need to say that the Zambia case took far too long.

04:26 We need to learn on this,

04:27 how we can better,

04:31 you know,

04:31 accelerate this process.

04:33 It has been said there is a lot of willingness to do so,

04:37 but the devil is in the detail,

04:38 and we need to continue working on this.

04:41 Secondly,

04:42 coordination.

04:43 Matters massively and I think here we need to recognize that there are massive

04:50 developments going on.

04:51 The Paris Club credits,

04:52 the non-Paris Club credits have become

04:55 much more important.

04:56 So therefore I think one needs to have much more

04:59 of a process on how we understand each other,

05:02 and I think the common framework

05:04 is the approach,

05:05 but also the Global sovereign debt roundtable.

05:08 I think this is important to.

05:11 Create more understanding with non- Paris Club creditors,

05:15 but also with the private sector what are the needs and how we can better work on this.

05:20 It is,

05:20 I think,

05:21 also a great way of creating much more trust how actually each other's

05:27 needs are being heard and how we can do better on this.

05:31 But in this area of coordination we need still to do more.

05:35 Then the next one is transparency and better debt reporting.

05:39 Let's also say that one of the delays is also the debt reconciliation.

05:44 It takes forever

05:46 and so here we can do a lot better.

05:49 My view is we need to proceed to far more to a radical transparency.

05:55 We have the bank had a mandate since the 50s to report,

05:59 but we can report much better and that would help speed up.

06:03 The restructuring process because also official and private creditors

06:08 in the realm of equitable burden sharing,

06:12 they need to know what their exposure is in nominal and MPV terms.

06:16 And if we don't have that good debt reporting,

06:20 it is going to delay and quite frankly this is one

06:23 of the factors what is delaying what can multilateral institutions.

06:28 Like the World Bank,

06:29 do we need to be committed on the whole range either in the reform process,

06:35 can be structural reform

06:36 with the IMF on our DPOs.

06:40 It has to be on debt management.

06:42 And here I think we need to be also supported.

06:46 We do that through the framework,

06:49 but we need to see that debt management capacity is not.

06:52 Built only when

06:54 donor flows are going to support that,

06:57 but that it is sustained.

06:59 Let me remind you,

07:00 at the end of the hippie,

07:01 at the end 90s,

07:02 the amount of meetings we had,

07:04 including in this room

07:05 to improve debt management was incredible,

07:08 and there was a lot of money available and then

07:11 it slowed down and ultimately debt management also suffered.

07:15 We cannot do that again.

07:17 We need also to provide support for debt workers that can be through guarantees,

07:21 that can be

07:22 through enhancements and through IA operations.

07:25 Finally,

07:26 on the positive net flows.

07:28 This is absolutely critical and particularly in the.

07:33 We are trying to ensure last year we had $18 billion in net flows,

07:38 positive flows.

07:39 I think we will need to continue that.

07:42 That means also for the donors who are here is

07:44 that we need to ensure a successful IA 21.

07:49 Replenishment.

07:50 Finally,

07:50 an important lesson from the hippic days was

07:54 always that we need to keep the link between debt and development

07:59 and particularly the social dimensions.

08:01 I think this was when the enhanced hippy game.

08:04 There were the PRSP,

08:06 the famous poverty.

08:08 Strategy papers,

08:09 but what is important is

08:11 you cannot delink that,

08:12 and that should always be kept in mind,

08:14 particularly with the low income countries,

08:17 that there is a way forward

08:18 and that we may need to keep in mind when we do the debt restructurings as well.

08:25 So with that,

08:26 let me turn this back.

showAllTimestamps
no
transcript
Thank you very much and good morning everybody. Let me first thank the Paris Club as well as the G20 for organizing this. What is of course interesting is that when we are dealing with this debt problems, it seems to be an integral part of our financial relations internationally. When you look at the last probably 6 or so decades, I think the Paris Club had something close to 500 restructurings involving more than 100 countries. So sometimes you ask yourself how is that possible, and I have studied that now since 40 years starting back when I was at the university and then at the OECD at the bank. I think we need to actually see that we are here in a continuous learning process and adjustment process, and there are a couple of factors is extremely important, and they were already mentioned also in the previous section. I think the first one is that we need to deal with the underlying debt problem. What are the what are the drivers for that? That problem and there are internal and external factors, but we cannot deny that if we don't deal with it you can have the best debt workout will not have any effect. And so what we need to actually deal with is, particularly in the internal area is with underlying macro issues, fiscal issues, and they will need to be addressed. And therefore I think some Mentioned that domestic resource mobilization is key for a permanent solution to this. Similarly on the external debt, clearly we need to keep that in mind with what is happening with international interest rates, particularly the effects on the poorest countries. So this is one important area. The second is the importance of what I would say long term debt sustainability. It needs to be the DSA needs to be fully integrated into economic and particularly fiscal policymaking. The unfortunate truth is that this is often not happening, but I would again make a passionately on the DSA that this needs to be much more valued in the policymakers, and there are two big aspects. There is the liquidity and solvency aspect to work that out, as well as the social dimensions. On the liquidity, what we are seeing. is that we need to ensure, particularly for the low income countries, large positive net flows. These countries have huge challenges, and we cannot delink that from the social dimension. Keep in mind, for example, in the IA countries, their debt service is now 7.5% of GDP. Mind you, this is not only external debt service, it's also the domestic debt service. And this is more than education and health combined. So if we completely delink that, this is one of the challenges these countries are facing. So we need to keep this also in mind that the social dimensions are important. I would say this was one of the lessons when I dealt with HIPIC that we always needed to take that into account. Because the situation is fragile in these countries. The second thing is the solvency. How we actually make sure that these workouts are indeed consistent with the longer term debt sustainability. In the past we tended always to focus only on external debt. We need now to take also the domestic debt much more into account, and that is not easy, particularly when we have in many of these lower income countries fairly fragile and incipient financial systems. We need to be careful about this, but we need also to keep in mind that in many countries the domestic public debt is often half of the total debt, and that is required. Then we will need with the solvency to say, well, we may need to engage in a NPV reduction. Then the key factors, I think for successful workouts is speed matters, and I think here we need to say that the Zambia case took far too long. We need to learn on this, how we can better, you know, accelerate this process. It has been said there is a lot of willingness to do so, but the devil is in the detail, and we need to continue working on this. Secondly, coordination. Matters massively and I think here we need to recognize that there are massive developments going on. The Paris Club credits, the non-Paris Club credits have become much more important. So therefore I think one needs to have much more of a process on how we understand each other, and I think the common framework is the approach, but also the Global sovereign debt roundtable. I think this is important to. Create more understanding with non- Paris Club creditors, but also with the private sector what are the needs and how we can better work on this. It is, I think, also a great way of creating much more trust how actually each other's needs are being heard and how we can do better on this. But in this area of coordination we need still to do more. Then the next one is transparency and better debt reporting. Let's also say that one of the delays is also the debt reconciliation. It takes forever and so here we can do a lot better. My view is we need to proceed to far more to a radical transparency. We have the bank had a mandate since the 50s to report, but we can report much better and that would help speed up. The restructuring process because also official and private creditors in the realm of equitable burden sharing, they need to know what their exposure is in nominal and MPV terms. And if we don't have that good debt reporting, it is going to delay and quite frankly this is one of the factors what is delaying what can multilateral institutions. Like the World Bank, do we need to be committed on the whole range either in the reform process, can be structural reform with the IMF on our DPOs. It has to be on debt management. And here I think we need to be also supported. We do that through the framework, but we need to see that debt management capacity is not. Built only when donor flows are going to support that, but that it is sustained. Let me remind you, at the end of the hippie, at the end 90s, the amount of meetings we had, including in this room to improve debt management was incredible, and there was a lot of money available and then it slowed down and ultimately debt management also suffered. We cannot do that again. We need also to provide support for debt workers that can be through guarantees, that can be through enhancements and through IA operations. Finally, on the positive net flows. This is absolutely critical and particularly in the. We are trying to ensure last year we had $18 billion in net flows, positive flows. I think we will need to continue that. That means also for the donors who are here is that we need to ensure a successful IA 21. Replenishment. Finally, an important lesson from the hippic days was always that we need to keep the link between debt and development and particularly the social dimensions. I think this was when the enhanced hippy game. There were the PRSP, the famous poverty. Strategy papers, but what is important is you cannot delink that, and that should always be kept in mind, particularly with the low income countries, that there is a way forward and that we may need to keep in mind when we do the debt restructurings as well. So with that, let me turn this back.
showAllTranscripts
no
duration
PT8M28S
scene7File
worldbank/Paris_Forum_Recording_Captions
scene7Domain
https://worldbank.scene7.com/
scene7FileAvs
worldbank/Paris_Forum_Recording_Captions-AVS
title
Paris Forum Recording Captions
description
Paris Forum Recording Captions
showTimestampAndTranscript
yes
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-3
col-lg-3
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-7
col-lg-7
  • add-style
  • lp-body-content
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-2
col-lg-2