00:01 OK,
00:01 um,
00:02 why don't we get started,
00:02 Welcome everyone.
00:04 Uh,
00:04 so,
00:05 so nice to see all of you here and online.
00:08 Uh,
00:09 my name is Biju Rao.
00:10 Uh,
00:11 I am in the Development Research Group of the World Bank,
00:14 and I'm very pleased to introduce,
00:16 uh,
00:17 Michelle Lamont,
00:18 who I've known
00:19 for about 15 years now,
00:21 uh,
00:21 through our association of the Canadian Institute for Advanced Research.
00:25 Uh,
00:25 Michelle is one of the premier,
00:27 uh,
00:28 sociologists,
00:28 uh,
00:29 uh,
00:29 in the world.
00:30 She is a professor at Harvard
00:32 of Sociology and African American studies,
00:35 amongst many other hats that she wears.
00:37 Uh,
00:37 she was the director of the Weatherhead Center at Harvard for many years,
00:40 and she was president of the American Sociological Association.
00:43 Um,
00:44 and she's been to the bank a couple of times,
00:46 so this is the 3rd visit,
00:47 I think.
00:48 Um,
00:49 and she's here to speak about her new book on seeing others,
00:52 how recognition works
00:54 and how it can heal a divided world,
00:56 topics
00:57 that I think of fundamental importance to us today.
00:59 So
01:00 very pleased,
01:00 uh,
01:00 to have Michelle here.
01:01 Welcome,
01:02 and,
01:02 uh,
01:03 the two of us will be discussions.
01:04 I'll be discussing,
01:05 but we also have Michael Woolcock.
01:07 Michael and I have been,
01:08 uh,
01:08 partners in arms for over 20 years in the Development Research Group.
01:11 Michael is the only sociologist
01:14 in the,
01:14 in the research department.
01:16 And um and and so therefore plays a very unique role in the bank from that position.
01:22 OK,
01:23 so the way this will be organized is
01:24 Michelle will talk about for about 40-45 minutes.
01:27 Uh,
01:27 Michael will follow with about a 7-8 minute discussion.
01:30 I'll speak for 5 minutes.
01:32 Michelle may respond and then we'll open it up for questions both online and here.
01:36 So without any further ado,
01:38 let's get started.
01:39 Thanks.
01:43 Thank you so much for inviting me Bijo.
01:45 It's a real pleasure to be back here in,
01:48 uh,
01:48 2013,
01:50 Bijo was involved in a book titled Social Resilience in the Neoliberal Era,
01:55 and we came here and discussed it,
01:56 and you will see this book will come up,
01:58 uh,
01:58 several times in,
01:59 uh,
02:00 in my presentation.
02:01 So this new book is really building on many years of scholarship,
02:05 and actually I'm glad to be speaking here at the World Bank,
02:09 not only because it's a great honor.
02:11 But also because one of the objectives of the book was to alert economists
02:17 to phenomenon
02:18 to a phenomena that they
02:20 rarely study,
02:22 which is recognition
02:23 so you might wonder what is recognition.
02:25 I'll define it in a few minutes,
02:27 but I,
02:28 I want to really broaden how we think about inequality and throwing.
02:32 Uh,
02:32 recognition in the soup is,
02:34 is my way of doing this.
02:35 So,
02:36 uh,
02:36 and it's a book that was really,
02:37 it's a trade book
02:38 written for a wide audience
02:40 and a little didactic.
02:41 I do things like,
02:42 you know,
02:43 defining narratives which most social scientists know what they are,
02:47 but,
02:48 um,
02:48 anyway,
02:49 I'll start with the two covers here.
02:51 The yellow one is the,
02:52 the British version that Penguin released,
02:54 and as you can see they don't have exactly the same title.
02:58 Uh,
02:58 the Brits thought that,
02:59 uh,
03:00 the term recognition would be nonsensical to their readers,
03:03 so
03:03 they went for how to redefine worth,
03:05 but that's basically what the book is about,
03:07 and the image of the,
03:08 the white,
03:09 uh,
03:09 the cover,
03:10 uh,
03:10 with Simon and Schuster,
03:12 uh,
03:12 I think describes quite well what the book is about,
03:15 which is really about broadening the circle
03:18 of who matters.
03:19 And even if the,
03:20 the groups that are to be included vary in color and in characteristics,
03:25 the goal is really to make many people feel that they belong.
03:28 And the idea that dignity is as
03:30 important to subjective well-being as economic resources
03:34 is a controversial idea,
03:35 but really one of the key ideas that is driving,
03:39 uh,
03:39 the book,
03:39 and it's controversial in part because most of us social scientists
03:44 over the last 50 years or even longer have
03:46 been socializing the idea that material resources were primary.
03:50 I'm not saying that material resources are not important,
03:53 but equally important
03:54 is a feeling of dignity,
03:55 as you will see.
03:58 So we live in a moment where there's been an
04:00 explosion of social movements over the last few years.
04:04 Most of these social movements are making
04:07 uh what would be called recognition claims.
04:10 They are
04:11 denouncing the ways in which they feel that
04:14 their worth is not being recognized,
04:16 whether you think about Black Lives Matter,
04:18 the way in which,
04:19 you know,
04:20 uh.
04:21 Is is brutalizing a young African American man,
04:25 Black Lives Matter and the context in which I'm speaking
04:30 here is also the context in which the,
04:32 the,
04:33 the World Bank has released a very
04:35 important report on migrant migrants and refugees.
04:39 So of course the DACA movement is very much part of this
04:42 and how we go about.
04:44 Addressing the growing stigmatization of um uh
04:48 immigrants in this country where you know
04:51 although the country is created by immigrants new immigrants often say
04:55 well my immigrants when I came in we were all hard working
04:59 now those who are coming in are not necessarily hard working so
05:03 in order to understand these transformations.
05:05 We really need to
05:07 understand how seeds of ideas are planted in our environment
05:12 and look at what I call change agents,
05:15 people who are creating narratives about various groups.
05:18 Some of these narratives are deeply stigmatizing,
05:20 but they can be changed and they are being changed,
05:23 so we will
05:24 get to this.
05:26 So the question is really
05:28 how do you approach this object of trying to broaden the circle of who matters,
05:34 uh,
05:34 who belongs,
05:35 who is included in the us
05:38 so I approach it through interviews with people whose job
05:42 it is to to challenge ideas to create new ideas about
05:46 who's in and who's out and in some ways I think,
05:49 um,
05:50 the World Bank is part of this narrative industry.
05:53 And I also did,
05:54 uh,
05:55 interviews with my graduate students with a number of Gen Z's actually
05:58 they did the interviews because Gen Zs don't want to talk to boomers
06:02 and it's really about,
06:03 you know,
06:03 from the bottom up,
06:04 uh,
06:05 how
06:06 ordinary people are also trying to transform,
06:09 uh,
06:09 our understanding of who matters and that's very important because of,
06:13 uh,
06:13 the context of the declining faith in the American dream.
06:17 And uh I focus on the progressive and liberal end of
06:21 the the political spectrum so we're not gonna talk about everything,
06:24 but we're gonna talk about a very important segment of
06:27 our society.
06:28 The two t-shirts there you certainly recognize the black one,
06:31 and it's,
06:32 you know,
06:32 you have their
06:33 humans are humans,
06:34 right?
06:35 No human is illegal.
06:37 Well,
06:37 it's really about ordinary universalism,
06:39 the libration of what we all have as human beings,
06:42 and that's one of the merry.
06:44 The very,
06:44 uh,
06:46 frequent strategies that are used to counter,
06:49 um,
06:50 uh,
06:50 stigmatization and the other person with the white t-shirt
06:53 is Zachary Drucker
06:55 who's a trans person who served as an advisor on the show Transparent.
07:00 The show Transparent depicts the life of,
07:03 uh.
07:03 A woman in her advanced middle age who transitioned from men
07:07 to women and now she has to negotiate her new identity
07:11 with her children
07:12 or adult children and when I interviewed uh uh Joy Soloway,
07:16 who is the
07:17 creator of the show about
07:20 what drove them to want to create that show,
07:23 they said the goal is really to help the general audience,
07:27 uh.
07:28 Understand what the life of a trans person is
07:31 and to move beyond stereotypes to provide a multi-dimensional
07:35 understanding and to humanize them so
07:38 those are words that come back time and
07:40 time again in my interviews and this t-shirt says
07:43 I see you and this is something
07:45 I don't know if there are uh many uh
07:47 millennials and Gen Zs in the room.
07:49 I think probably many
07:51 you all look so young
07:52 um.
07:54 But uh these are things that are very central in the culture of our students,
07:57 for instance,
07:59 so the book Social Resilience in the neoliberal Era,
08:01 which came out in 2013 was very much,
08:04 uh,
08:05 written in the context where,
08:07 um,
08:08 a lot of the new media were covering the,
08:11 the work of Angela Duckworth with its focus on individual grit.
08:15 And uh Bijou and I were part of a research group that actually met for 19 years
08:21 to try to discuss and understand better
08:23 the conditions that lead to more successful societies
08:27 by which we mean societies that are able to um
08:31 uh build on the capabilities of group to
08:34 respond to the challenges that come their way
08:36 and instead of focusing on psychological factors such as grit,
08:40 we're really interested in.
08:42 How you can create societies that give people the tools to be all they can be,
08:47 if you will,
08:48 and the tools we were particularly interested in were institutions
08:51 and what cultural sociologists,
08:53 which is my trade,
08:54 talk,
08:55 uh,
08:55 call cultural repertoires or scripts.
08:58 So what are the ideas that surround us in our daily life on which we can.
09:03 Uh,
09:03 draw to make sense of our world.
09:05 So instead of looking at meaning as located at the intracranial level,
09:10 it's really analyzed in terms of the supply side of idea who produces the ideas,
09:15 what's the content,
09:16 and how it orients us
09:18 and institutions of course includes,
09:20 you know,
09:21 organizations such as the World Bank or,
09:23 you know,
09:24 the law
09:25 and uh both the.
09:26 Institutions in the cultural repertoire provide us tools to
09:30 mobilize as we're facing,
09:32 you know,
09:32 various challenges.
09:33 So
09:34 the example I give here is the way in which
09:37 the adoption of same-sex marriage across a number of states
09:40 is correlated with the rapid decline
09:42 in attempted suicide among LGBTQ college students
09:46 in part because those institutions,
09:49 same-sex marriage were,
09:51 uh,
09:51 sending them a message that you're worthy.
09:54 You have access to one of the most sacred institution in our society,
09:58 so this is an example of,
09:59 you know,
10:01 diffusing such repertoire really add up.
10:04 So the case study really is about the production and and diffusion of
10:08 other ways of thinking about our society.
10:11 And you will see in a second what I mean by other ways.
10:14 So the research was done during the pandemic,
10:17 which was in some ways fortunate because we were able to get access to a great many
10:22 very influential change agents
10:24 who work across a number of,
10:26 uh,
10:27 institutions who would probably we would not have
10:28 been able to interview them under normal circumstances.
10:32 And the number of stand-up comics or,
10:35 um,
10:36 Hollywood creative,
10:37 for instance,
10:38 Mike Schur who created
10:40 The Good Place and Park and Recreation,
10:42 the list is long,
10:43 you will see it in a second,
10:45 but also,
10:46 uh,
10:46 policy people like Heather Boucher,
10:48 uh,
10:49 we touch on a large number of sectors where
10:51 new narratives are really essential to what's happening,
10:54 and we try to understand what people are doing and why they're doing it.
10:58 And then the 80 interviews with college students,
11:01 Gen Zs who were born after
11:03 97 or so.
11:05 And half of them are privileged middle class kids,
11:07 the other half are less privileged,
11:09 and they are in 32 colleges
11:11 in the Northeast and the Midwest,
11:13 and we wanted to understand
11:15 what were the
11:16 challenges that they were experiencing and what kind of life did they imagine the,
11:21 the kind of solution they have for,
11:23 for,
11:23 uh,
11:24 the problems we face,
11:25 and we interviewed them before the pandemic and
11:28 then again during the summer of 2020.
11:30 So the key concept here is the concept of recognition.
11:34 And by this I don't mean like I I recognize that this is
11:38 an apple or I recognize that this is Jim on the street.
11:42 It's really about defining a group in a positive way as worthy
11:46 and that's a cultural process.
11:48 It's something that is happening all the time.
11:51 And it's something that as human beings we can all feed
11:54 and that institution can feed
11:56 so my argument is very squarely against the argument
12:00 about tribalism that has been promoted by Jonathan Haidt,
12:04 the psychologist at um.
12:07 NYU,
12:08 who talks about how we are wired,
12:10 this argument about we are wired normally brings about,
12:13 you know,
12:13 evolution
12:15 narrowly we have been
12:16 led to automatically do these things.
12:19 The approach to broadening the boundaries
12:21 and weakening the boundaries between groups
12:23 is very different.
12:24 Instead of grounding it in human nature,
12:27 it's really grounded in the processes,
12:29 institutional and cultural processes that we.
12:32 Uh,
12:32 inhabit and,
12:33 and create,
12:35 so it's far less deterministic,
12:36 and my position in human nature is we have a lot of narratives about human nature,
12:40 but when we talk about it or study it,
12:43 it's a little bit like archaeologists who have little
12:45 figments of evidence and build builds big,
12:48 big stories around them.
12:49 So I tend to be skeptical and
12:51 I really want to approach these questions as a sociologist to focus on.
12:56 The accomplishment and the transformation of categories.
12:59 The counterpart to recognition is stigmatization,
13:02 a concept that you're probably familiar with,
13:04 associated with Irving Goffman,
13:06 a great sociologist of the 20th century,
13:09 and it's just the opposite of recognition.
13:11 It's really about
13:12 characterizing groups,
13:13 uh,
13:14 negatively,
13:15 and the,
13:16 the stigma is often moral.
13:18 So let's say immigrants are
13:21 rapists.
13:21 And they are lazy,
13:23 they don't carry their weight,
13:24 they lack self-reliance
13:26 and,
13:26 uh,
13:27 or you know gay people are
13:29 lack morality because they engage in promiscuity on and on and on.
13:34 So the,
13:34 the relationship between the symbolic boundaries that are about the
13:38 description of groups that are negative and the social boundaries,
13:41 which is their lack of access,
13:43 the way in which they are discriminated against
13:46 is something.
13:47 That I've really spent a lot of time studying in my work
13:50 focusing on the meaning making part of the the question how is it that these,
13:55 these moral boundaries are being created and the and
13:58 working hand in hand these two processes which really unfold
14:02 as we live our life result in shared definition
14:05 of cultural membership who's in and who's out,
14:08 who do we feel
14:09 that we have responsibilities toward,
14:12 uh,
14:13 who should we support through our taxes,
14:15 etc.
14:16 So,
14:17 um,
14:19 I think studying these processes is very important
14:22 because recognition matters in so many ways.
14:25 It matters for health,
14:26 for instance,
14:27 we've learned
14:28 through COVID.
14:29 And we knew that before that uh what
14:31 uh epidemiologists talk about as the allostatic load,
14:36 the wear and tear of everyday life,
14:38 the daily experience of microaggression
14:41 gets under the skin
14:42 to create very great disparities in health outcomes,
14:46 subjective well-being,
14:47 or
14:48 physical health.
14:50 Uh,
14:50 it matters.
14:50 Think about,
14:51 um,
14:52 parents of LGBTQ youth who don't accept how these kids define themselves,
14:58 and they ask their kids to leave the house and then the kid gets
15:02 to become homeless.
15:03 Well,
15:03 that's a case where,
15:05 um,
15:06 uh,
15:06 you know,
15:07 stigma creates poverty,
15:09 so we,
15:09 uh,
15:10 we need to think about the relationship
15:12 between resources and stigmatization and recognition.
15:15 In a more bidirectional way it's one of the ideas that I'm,
15:19 uh,
15:20 and it also matters for politics as you will see in a second,
15:23 so you have this,
15:24 uh,
15:25 recent report which is very much about taking stock of the changes in the context of,
15:29 uh,
15:30 um,
15:31 you know,
15:32 climate change where the number of people who are moving has just been increasing.
15:36 Enormously and we have a number of organizations,
15:38 not only the World Bank
15:40 but other organizations as well who are acting as
15:43 agents of change in transforming the discourse we have
15:46 about such groups that have been historically stigmatized.
15:50 I want to flash this report from the
15:52 UN Human Development unit.
15:56 And actually I was the co-director of the advisory board for this uh report
16:02 which is really came out during the pandemic and it's really about how do we face
16:07 the challenges that are coming our way and
16:09 it introduces a much more multi-dimensional understanding.
16:13 Of the tools that are at our disposal to do this,
16:17 so I invite you to look at it if you haven't had a chance yet.
16:20 Other
16:22 organizations are really fixated now on the recognition gap.
16:25 It's the case for the EU.
16:27 They just released this report on the urban,
16:30 uh,
16:31 uh,
16:32 rural urban divide,
16:33 and it's all about the recognition gap between,
16:36 uh,
16:36 urban and rural population across the EU,
16:39 and they use this concept recognition gap to really make sense of what's happening.
16:43 And the impact on politics of course
16:46 which you know this divide has often being used to explain the Brexit
16:50 outcome.
16:52 So for me the intellectual agenda and although you know most of you uh
16:57 you're all social scientists so I I threw into the presentation
17:01 some material that normally I don't give when I give public talks
17:05 but since we're all part of the same tribe I
17:07 thought I would bring in a little bit
17:10 more the scientific content and the articles on which I draw.
17:14 So in in the book,
17:15 uh,
17:16 because all this is in the footnote of course it's not forefronted
17:19 but the goal is really to develop an empirical sociology of recognition
17:23 and stigmatization and that's important because
17:24 the literature we've had until now
17:26 is largely philosophical
17:28 with people like um.
17:31 Uh,
17:31 Axel Hannet or Nancy Frasier,
17:33 who are very prominent political philosophers,
17:36 and really to understand our cultural processes broaden cultural citizenship,
17:40 so I draw on a number of papers,
17:42 including the paper addressing the recognition gaps
17:45 that was my presidential address at the ASA
17:48 in 2018.
17:50 So
17:50 you can turn to these papers if you're interested.
17:53 So basically what's at stake is to try to broaden how we think about inequality.
17:59 So on this slide here,
18:00 you have different ways of conceptualizing it.
18:03 So many people go from a macrosocial structure.
18:07 To,
18:07 uh,
18:08 the cognitive,
18:09 uh,
18:09 what's happening in people's head,
18:11 right with nothing in between,
18:12 and I give here several examples of books that do this,
18:16 but the last,
18:17 uh,
18:18 column is really about conceptualizing the,
18:20 the meso level
18:22 asking ourselves how is it
18:24 that,
18:24 uh,
18:25 what's coming into our head at the intracranial level is filtered by,
18:30 you know,
18:30 the cultural producers and by the institutions in which we live.
18:34 So we can schematically understand the production of inequality
18:38 as coming through various processes and of course
18:41 the economists at the World Bank would have
18:44 a quite different image of how this is accomplished,
18:47 but in my field
18:48 in sociology
18:50 we will talk about things such as processes such as opportunities.
18:53 Hoarding and closure,
18:54 which are totally classical,
18:56 you know,
18:57 I think about the,
18:58 the Brahmin in India.
18:59 Uh,
18:59 this is basically both domination.
19:02 A lot of these Asian concepts that we all studied
19:06 as undergraduate exploitation,
19:07 domination,
19:08 bureaucratization are all central to
19:11 the production of inequality.
19:12 And the second type of process comes through the growing literature on how
19:18 people exercise closure to their tastes.
19:21 So,
19:21 uh,
19:22 you know,
19:22 if you decide that this person,
19:24 for instance,
19:24 I don't know,
19:26 uh,
19:26 dresses very badly or doesn't share your taste or your sense of distinction,
19:31 you're not going to be drawn to them.
19:33 So it's really about group status group formation.
19:36 And the third level,
19:37 which is really what I'm interested in,
19:39 is all these processes that are constantly feeding
19:42 our life as we go around the world.
19:44 So,
19:45 um,
19:46 this is too rapid,
19:47 but it gives you a little bit of an idea of,
19:49 you know,
19:50 ecological effects is really about neighborhood effects.
19:53 Tons of sociologists have written on this,
19:55 but the point is to say there are some blind spots
19:58 in the way that social scientists have been thinking about inequality.
20:02 And my ambition is not to
20:05 transform it radically but really shed light on
20:08 aspects of the processes that have been neglected
20:11 and which I think are very,
20:12 very important.
20:14 So the general background of this book is really the poly crisis in which we've been
20:20 living over the last few years and of course it's not only an American story,
20:25 uh,
20:25 the,
20:25 the report of the human development,
20:28 uh,
20:28 the 21 report really shows us the ways in which it operates
20:33 at the global level
20:35 and,
20:35 uh,
20:35 it's a combination of the growing inequality
20:38 we've experienced for the last several decades,
20:40 political polarization,
20:41 COVID,
20:42 but also.
20:43 The growing exclusion of a number of groups,
20:46 you know,
20:47 as soon as Trump came to power,
20:48 we had
20:49 travel ban against Muslim countries.
20:52 You had a lot of declarations against
20:54 LGBTQ people,
20:56 and of course the DACA policies on and on and on.
20:59 So
21:00 it's easy to make an argument that although since 1945,
21:05 a growing portion of the population has come to be defined as part of us
21:09 over the last few years,
21:10 there's been a lot of backstab stepping.
21:13 And that's extremely
21:16 concerning and that has generated a decline in the faith in the American dream,
21:20 which is a huge problem for the younger generation.
21:23 And uh the
21:25 broader context and the aspects of uh these processes that I'm interested in
21:30 is really to look at how we define the ideal self
21:34 uh
21:34 that is being communicated to all of us as we watch
21:38 Netflix or as we read the paper or as we consume
21:41 as we lead our lives.
21:43 So what uh this I'm talking here about the neo liberal scripts of self
21:48 which is a very set way you know
21:51 uh pattern of ways that we're supposed to be as human beings
21:55 and um.
21:57 The ideal worker,
21:58 if you will,
21:59 and one of the most sacred values that comes with the American
22:02 dream is this notion of self-reliance that we should not be sponges,
22:07 we should not depend on others
22:09 to make a living,
22:10 that we should all stand on our own feet,
22:12 so that's also being called the privatization of risk.
22:16 And the pursuit of status,
22:18 wealth,
22:18 and consumption as an ultimate goal,
22:20 uh,
22:20 the pursuit of socioeconomic success
22:23 as something that is to,
22:24 to motivate all of us and organize our life
22:27 so you get a college degree,
22:29 you get a professional degree,
22:31 your goal is to get a nice house with the white
22:33 picket fence and to raise your family in an environment where
22:37 you're pursuing what some people call
22:40 the uh
22:42 um.
22:43 The treadmill of consumption,
22:44 you know,
22:45 so you're just consuming and consuming,
22:47 and this also requires being extremely competitive and believing in meritocracy.
22:54 But this is now coming very much under attack since many
22:57 young people think that this is simply not accessible to them
23:01 with the 2008 financial crisis,
23:05 uh,
23:05 the millennials hit the job market and weren't able to find jobs.
23:09 They have not been able to buy houses.
23:11 When we interview our Gen Zs,
23:13 many people say no.
23:14 I mean the pursuit of.
23:16 Assumption is really not something that
23:18 is realistic for us,
23:20 and we need to have other goals.
23:21 So what are we going to come up with
23:23 as a way to motivate our lives
23:26 and that is surprising for boomers and I think many parents are expecting,
23:31 are experiencing clashes with their kids as they are pushing
23:34 one set of ideals which many,
23:37 you know,
23:37 young people feel,
23:39 uh,
23:39 are not gonna be delivering for them.
23:42 So this package of cultural behavior,
23:44 if you will,
23:45 all sustained meritocracy,
23:47 the idea that those who end up at the top
23:50 of the social hierarchy are those who are most hardworking and most deserving.
23:54 And yet when we think about meritocracy we typically
23:58 make abstraction of all the advantages that middle
24:01 class people have or upper middle class people
24:04 if you raise your kid in Chenvi Chase or
24:07 you know if you are yourself a family with two PhDs,
24:11 there's no question.
24:12 Your kids are not playing the same sandbox as the other kids.
24:16 They start with huge advantages,
24:18 but the celebration of meritocracy that surrounds us everywhere is not fully,
24:22 uh,
24:24 acknowledging this.
24:25 So it's a little bit like being born on an escalator and you
24:27 go up much faster than anyone else because you have all these attributes.
24:31 So,
24:31 but this is not only an American story
24:34 because there's been a steep increase in belief
24:38 in meritocracy across a number of advanced industrial societies
24:43 over several decades.
24:45 So this paper by Jonathan Meis shows that between 1930 and 2010,
24:51 uh,
24:51 a large number of countries have seen really
24:54 a large increase in number of people who believe
24:57 that meritocracy is,
24:58 is important and that it works.
25:01 So just to take for examples you can see here
25:03 that it's highest in the UK and the United States,
25:06 which are also the countries that are
25:08 often given as examples of neoliberal societies
25:11 where the state has operated.
25:13 Um,
25:14 really as a machine to,
25:15 to remove the,
25:17 the limitation that could prevent,
25:19 uh,
25:20 the full functioning of the market,
25:22 so this neo-liberal scripts of self go hand in hand with
25:25 a market focused society where market fundamentalism
25:29 is the objective
25:30 of the 23 countries.
25:32 That Jonathan Maisch studied all but 5,
25:35 there did not see an increase in meritocracy,
25:38 and that includes
25:40 Austria,
25:40 Canada,
25:41 and France.
25:42 So we're talking about a world,
25:44 at least,
25:45 uh,
25:45 you know,
25:45 advanced industrial society.
25:47 These
25:48 cultural scripts are diffused very,
25:50 very broadly
25:51 in the context of the crisis of the American dream,
25:54 which increasingly means nothing for most people.
25:57 Uh,
25:57 we all know about the decline in upward mobility.
26:00 The work of,
26:01 uh,
26:02 Raj Chetty has been covered,
26:04 or,
26:04 you know,
26:04 Piketty has been covered massively by the media
26:08 and,
26:08 uh,
26:08 children.
26:09 The number of,
26:09 of young people who believe that getting a college
26:12 degree is worth it has been declining sharply.
26:15 So in a context where many people,
26:17 um.
26:18 Some people continue to believe in the American dream
26:21 and that's especially popular among immigrants after all,
26:24 many of them came here because of the American dream
26:27 and yet when we interview people about it,
26:29 it comes to mean absolutely everything and nothing.
26:32 Having a good family is the American dream,
26:35 and many people think that they can attain it themselves,
26:38 but most people can't,
26:40 so it's very,
26:40 very shaky.
26:42 And um.
26:44 One of the problems with the American dream,
26:46 the first two chapters of the book really
26:49 are about people above and people below,
26:51 and
26:52 people above being the middle class people,
26:54 30-40% of the population,
26:57 depending on how you define it,
26:59 and people below being all the people who are non-college educated who
27:02 and the college degree operates like a caste in our system.
27:06 If you don't have the college degree you're in bad,
27:08 bad luck.
27:09 So,
27:09 uh,
27:10 it really leads to a bifurcation of our society where
27:14 some people like everyone in this room are part of those who
27:17 are celebrated as successful because we have these college degrees and we have
27:22 professional jobs and we can consume
27:24 and we are also presumed to have all these,
27:26 you know,
27:27 neoliberal scripts of self,
27:29 but the working class and low income
27:31 people have been increasingly stigmatized and uh.
27:35 Uh,
27:35 Anne Case and Angus Deaton have written plenty about this,
27:39 uh,
27:39 death by despair.
27:41 Uh,
27:41 many working class people have experienced their downward mobility.
27:45 So,
27:45 um,
27:46 what we see is,
27:47 you know,
27:48 it,
27:48 and that,
27:48 uh,
27:49 stigmatization of working class and low income people
27:51 is often extended
27:53 to immigrants and people of.
27:55 Color and other people who are presumed to not be self-reliant,
27:59 so,
27:59 um,
28:00 in 2000 I published a book titled The Dignity
28:03 of Working Man Morality and the Boundaries of Race,
28:05 Class,
28:06 and Immigration
28:07 for which I interviewed a lot of black and white workers
28:09 in New York and white and North African workers in France
28:13 and um.
28:15 I asked them what kind of people do they feel inferior and superior
28:18 to and what I found in both countries is that they very seamlessly
28:23 went from
28:24 I'm the kind of guy who pays my bills,
28:26 who makes sure my kids stay out of trouble,
28:29 the kind of people I cannot stand are people who are sponging our society,
28:33 especially these black people and the low income people
28:36 and the immigrant people who don't pull their weight
28:38 so you can see that you go from.
28:40 You know,
28:41 general hierarchy that justifies their own position to
28:44 drawing moral boundaries against other groups and the moral
28:47 and the social boundaries are growing,
28:49 uh,
28:49 working hand in hand,
28:50 and that's very,
28:51 very widely spread.
28:53 So all this,
28:55 this American dream as it is weakening,
28:57 uh,
28:58 we have uh on the media,
29:00 if you think about Netflix,
29:02 uh,
29:02 a celebration of the upper middle class that all of us can watch every night,
29:07 think of shows
29:08 like White Lotus or Suits or Succession,
29:12 it's all,
29:12 you know,
29:13 eye candy for people who are.
29:14 Looking at these amazing apartments and buildings and rich people and couture
29:18 outfits
29:20 and in general,
29:21 uh
29:21 there's a book that I cite here by Richard Bush that shows that
29:25 when it comes to American television domestic situation comedy,
29:29 the vast majority of the characters are upper middle class people.
29:32 Some of them are not worthy of admiration,
29:35 but many of them are presented as heroes,
29:38 and it's very rare that you find
29:39 working class characters that are presented as worthy of admiration.
29:43 And the representation of working class people
29:46 on those shows has declined steeply.
29:48 So all this to say if you're a working class man in America or a working class person,
29:52 it's very difficult
29:54 to see images of who you are that would be,
29:57 you know,
29:58 sustaining your sense of your worth.
30:00 So all this is feeding into the poly crisis that I,
30:04 I mentioned,
30:05 uh,
30:05 earlier,
30:06 and we hit the cultural dead end.
30:08 Which is manifested in a major health mental health crisis
30:13 which we see not only
30:15 among people,
30:16 uh,
30:16 below the lower 50% of the population but also people above
30:21 we know and for those of us who teach in elite
30:25 colleges you can see an enormous demand for
30:28 mental health services among among our students.
30:30 It's grown exponentially.
30:32 Uh,
30:32 for the last few years,
30:34 and studies have shown that,
30:36 uh,
30:36 the mental health issues are connected to an overemphasis on money and work.
30:41 People are on this,
30:43 uh,
30:43 treadmill of consumption,
30:45 and they work and they work,
30:46 and it just creates more stress,
30:48 and,
30:48 uh,
30:48 it's a crisis,
30:49 including for the non-Hispanic whites who are the alleged winner of the system.
30:54 So this,
30:54 this crisis hits not only people at the top of the.
30:58 Uh,
30:59 annual household income,
31:00 uh,
31:01 hierarchy,
31:02 but also at the bottom.
31:03 So,
31:04 uh,
31:05 this is,
31:05 you know,
31:05 you've read probably about the loneliness crisis also that is hitting our society,
31:10 it's much more dire in the US than in other advanced industrial societies.
31:15 So
31:16 this is kind of my depressing diagnostic,
31:18 which is the first two chapters of the book
31:21 and then you have to decide am I gonna continue to read that story or not?
31:24 Well,
31:24 I can tell you you should because it gets better.
31:27 So it gets better when you look at
31:30 the people who are creating the new narratives that are
31:32 the alternative and what I found in the book,
31:35 what the story I'm going to tell you
31:37 is that for a lot of people if they find that this American dream
31:41 is a dead end,
31:42 they need to come up with something else.
31:44 When I started writing this book,
31:46 it was in part because I was a little depressed during the
31:49 the Trump era and I felt like,
31:50 OK,
31:51 we were supposed.
31:51 To have this great arc of history,
31:54 you know,
31:54 justice spreading and that we're all going backwards,
31:57 so I need to understand where people get hope
31:59 and I read the social science literature on hope and what I found is
32:03 people get it through narratives by being exposed to
32:07 visions of the worlds that are presenting
32:10 presented to them by others
32:12 that give them a path,
32:13 a vision of what else reality could be.
32:17 So I approached these uh
32:19 cult these agents of change as people who are offering us alternative vision of what
32:25 life could be and that could feed
32:27 uh not only the aspiration of population as a
32:29 whole but also that of the young college students who
32:32 who were really facing a
32:35 uh emotional dead end in terms of mental health.
32:38 So the book then pivots and becomes really
32:41 a story of where those new narratives are produced
32:45 and how do they diffuse
32:46 it then the book becomes very different
32:49 and the question is who produces them
32:51 and what kind of content they have
32:54 so I can talk about a few,
32:56 there's tons of things that are.
32:57 Being done,
32:58 but one of them is to move from a uni-dimensional
33:02 matrix of worth,
33:03 the American dream,
33:04 upward mobility,
33:06 get rich to a much more pluralistic vision
33:09 where it's not only people who are doing well financially who will be admired.
33:13 So you know,
33:14 uh,
33:14 enterprises,
33:15 for instance,
33:16 that.
33:17 Uh,
33:17 recognizes that workers are also caregivers and give them time,
33:21 give employees time to bring
33:23 their mother,
33:23 their children to the,
33:25 to the doctor,
33:26 uh,
33:26 on Friday afternoon would really sustain the
33:29 well-being of their workers and would also
33:31 create much more loyalty toward employers.
33:34 So there's
33:35 a lot that is being done in all kinds of settings and workplaces.
33:38 There's also this liberation of ordinary universalism which is
33:42 central to the life of working class people.
33:44 In this book,
33:45 The Dignity Working Bank that I talked about,
33:47 they constantly talked about
33:49 you have to treat people like people,
33:51 you know,
33:51 this is a very deep faith that also,
33:53 you know,
33:54 Trump frankly cultivates,
33:56 uh,
33:56 that,
33:56 you know,
33:57 people who are treating badly other humans are just despicable,
34:00 and he presents the upper middle class as very much engaged into this
34:03 and also the Democratic Party as doing it
34:07 and also there's a process of stigma reduction.
34:09 How is stigma reduced that I'm gonna talk about in a few minutes.
34:13 So,
34:14 uh,
34:14 uh,
34:15 to state it again,
34:16 I draw on all these interviews and how did I decide who to interview.
34:20 There's a concept that social scientists use which
34:23 is the concept of the public sphere,
34:25 which comes from a German philosopher,
34:27 Jurgen Habermass.
34:29 He developed it thinking about,
34:30 you know,
34:31 basically,
34:32 uh,
34:32 18th century bourgeois man
34:34 hanging out in the cafes of Vienna.
34:37 Discussing the matters of the day
34:39 and you know discussing normative questions deliberating about where our
34:43 society should go well that's not how it works anymore
34:45 so there's a lot of work that has been done on what the contemporary public sphere
34:50 looks like so here you have two recent citations that have done that
34:54 and um you have,
34:56 you know,
34:56 massive
34:57 social movement industry and massive philanthropic
35:01 sector that are contributing to producing ideas so.
35:04 Um,
35:05 that's a little bit what I had in mind as I
35:07 thought about where am I going to find these interviewees.
35:13 Sorry,
35:13 and I came up with this,
35:14 uh,
35:15 Venn diagram
35:17 which really shows,
35:18 uh,
35:18 represents basically
35:20 the various sectors of society.
35:23 That are producing a new narratives so it's not exhaustive
35:27 but it's certainly uh a good you know sizable
35:31 the the sampling was not sys systematic
35:34 uh but we really I
35:36 by choosing the respondents of course it depended on
35:39 the contact I had to be able to find people so
35:42 a lot of it was,
35:43 you know,
35:44 come and go
35:46 approximative
35:47 but we did cover a lot of sectors so you can
35:50 while I drink water you can look at this site.
35:54 I have a cold today.
36:00 So you can see here,
36:01 you know,
36:01 Steven Greenhouse,
36:02 the leading New York Times labor journalist,
36:06 social policy you have Heather Bushey,
36:08 you have
36:09 Greenberg and Ezra Levin who created Indivisible,
36:11 which was the Democratic Party's answer to,
36:14 uh,
36:15 the Tea Party.
36:20 Leaders in the climate justice movement such as Bill McKibben,
36:24 uh.
36:27 Kimberly Crenshaw,
36:28 who created intersectionality theory,
36:32 um,
36:32 it goes on and on.
36:35 So this gives you a little bit of an idea
36:37 and then we created we have two papers that are just on the Hollywood
36:42 uh creative and the stand-up comics that are under review
36:46 so we were able in some cases we have 75 of
36:48 such people in the sample so we were really able to examine
36:52 very closely how it's operating in specific subsectors.
37:00 So I'll tell you uh a little bit about uh how it is done by giving you the example of uh
37:06 a group of black photographers and queer photographers I was able to interview.
37:12 So,
37:12 um,
37:13 Lyle Ashton Harris,
37:15 uh,
37:16 creates portraits that depict,
37:18 um,
37:18 queer people,
37:20 and when I interviewed him about what he's doing,
37:22 the language he used was very much one of
37:26 creating,
37:26 uh,
37:27 three dimensional depictions of stigmatized groups,
37:29 so going beyond stereotypes,
37:32 humanizing them,
37:33 depicting them with dignity.
37:36 Depend creating or depicting them the way that they would like themselves to
37:40 be depicted and I like this one in particular because you can see
37:44 that
37:45 the word dignity is kind of expressed in how they hold their bodies and in their
37:50 in their eyes and um
37:52 yes,
37:53 5 minutes.
37:53 OK,
37:54 I'm gonna rush then
37:55 so it really goes beyond making people visible
37:58 and another very important one is um.
38:02 If you Google on YouTube Question Bridge,
38:04 you will see this video,
38:06 uh,
38:06 created by Hank Williams Williams,
38:09 and he asked 150 black men what does it mean to be a black man,
38:13 and they said there's nothing,
38:15 uh,
38:15 that we have in common except that we all
38:17 experience discrimination on a daily basis and stereotyping.
38:21 But what's interesting with this example
38:24 is that he was able to join forces
38:27 with an important philanthropy called the Campaign for Black Male Achievement.
38:32 Which had the resources to diffuse this video
38:34 across a large number of schools and community centers
38:38 to create conversation around
38:40 the stereotyping of black men,
38:42 so it's an example where you have a narrative that is produced
38:45 and you have an alliance that is created
38:48 between the creator and philanthropies that
38:50 are really engaged in diffusing messages
38:54 that provides alternative.
38:56 And when I interviewed the leader of the campaign for black male achievement,
38:59 he said very explicitly,
39:01 we're into changing narratives
39:03 we're into instead of talking about people in terms
39:05 of the problem and what's wrong with them,
39:07 poverty and the face of crime,
39:10 we really are trying to define them by their aspiration.
39:14 So then I,
39:15 and that's very important this focus on narrative
39:18 because at the same time the Fo Foundation,
39:20 one of the largest foundation in the US,
39:23 uh launches an initiative to fight,
39:25 um,
39:26 inequality.
39:27 And they define this initiative as capturing hearts and
39:30 minds and instead of only focusing on the economic dimension
39:34 of social life they really attack the
39:37 narrative dimension and how we perceive reality
39:39 and other foundations are doing the same thing with other other groups
39:44 and I propose in the book this uh notion of recognition.
39:48 Chain
39:48 to talk about the
39:50 alliances that are created between the funders and the creators to really
39:54 scale up
39:56 the new narratives and I think
39:58 one example Ford Foundation realizes this movie Rama
40:02 which is about which won an Oscar and it's about two indigenous domestic workers.
40:08 In Mexico
40:09 and uh you see them in a three dimensional way you follow them as
40:13 one of them is trying to decide whether to get an abortion or not
40:17 and really it humanizes them
40:19 and Ford makes this film possible
40:21 but it's also done in collaboration with the National
40:24 Alliance for Domestic Workers which is a very important union
40:28 so all this to say this is a huge booming sector of the world
40:32 that we live in that is often
40:34 invisible with these narratives being really engineered.
40:38 So I don't have much time.
40:39 I'll just say two words about the Gen Zs.
40:42 They are telling the boomers,
40:43 move over.
40:44 You guys have really screwed up with the,
40:46 uh,
40:47 you know,
40:47 climate change.
40:49 Uh,
40:49 we are now in the cockpit.
40:50 We're in charge of everything,
40:52 and,
40:53 uh,
40:53 they are
40:54 really embracing this notion of inclusion
40:56 through the notion of ordinary universalism.
40:58 They are really allergic to.
41:00 Uh,
41:00 reinforcing group hierarchies,
41:02 they,
41:03 that's why the pronouns,
41:05 the bathrooms
41:06 are really important to them.
41:07 Uh,
41:08 for many boomers this is like,
41:09 come on guys,
41:10 you're a snowflake,
41:11 get over it.
41:12 No,
41:12 for them it's very serious,
41:13 and I think it's important to understand this
41:16 against the background of the decline of the American dream.
41:19 If for them there's no way forward through,
41:21 uh,
41:22 making money and consumption,
41:23 they have to think about how to create a better society today,
41:26 and that's what they're trying to do.
41:28 And they are still interested in work and to the American dream to some extent,
41:33 but unlike my generation,
41:34 they're very committed to,
41:36 um,
41:37 you know,
41:38 work,
41:38 uh,
41:39 life balance
41:40 and to the therapeutic culture that has become omnipresent for that generation
41:44 which was not a point of reference for my generation.
41:48 So really I think you have a sea change which manifests itself differently
41:52 for the middle class,
41:53 the privileged,
41:54 and the less privileged,
41:55 uh,
41:55 young people and how they think that they'll be able to
41:58 contribute to social change with more privileged people
42:01 really thinking they can lead the change,
42:03 whereas
42:03 the working class students say,
42:05 well,
42:05 I have to help my parents pay the bills,
42:07 so their approach is quite different and they're very aware of how
42:10 the constraints they live in are,
42:12 you know,
42:13 shaping what they can and cannot do.
42:16 So I guess uh if I had a little more time I'd
42:19 discuss more what are the other strategies that are available to broaden inclusion
42:24 but I think I'll just leave this for later
42:27 right?
42:27 because I should probably stop now
42:30 just say that this represents a little bit how um.
42:34 Uh,
42:35 stigma can be reduced,
42:37 and the point is the reduction of stigma,
42:39 uh,
42:39 operates through,
42:41 uh,
42:41 actors such as knowledge workers and social movement activists
42:44 who are drawing on the resources of our environment.
42:47 So that's very,
42:48 very different than the grid story that Angela Dockworth tells us
42:52 and that is also dominant in the media.
42:54 So in my wildest dream,
42:56 uh,
42:56 this story and this vision of how to
42:58 transform our society would become more salient,
43:00 but we don't know if it's gonna happen.
43:02 So I think I'll stop here
43:04 and uh I look forward to uh
43:07 the comments and the
43:09 questions from Michael and
43:12 Liu.
43:13 Thank you,
43:13 Michelle,
43:14 Michael.
43:18 Very good thank you.
43:18 I'm,
43:19 I've just got 3 points to make and I wanna create as
43:22 much time as possible for others to to pose questions it's.
43:27 I can
43:28 Talk with Michelle at other times,
43:30 um,
43:30 these are things that are discussed in the book or mentioned,
43:33 but they're for me,
43:34 uh,
43:34 things that at least from a development point of view,
43:36 for those of us who work for the World Bank or related development organizations.
43:41 Um,
43:42 the kind of things that I'm gonna talk about are,
43:44 are ones that I think are especially salient when you are
43:48 working on,
43:49 on projects that are,
43:50 or initiatives,
43:52 uh,
43:52 or policies of one kind or another that are trying to,
43:54 in,
43:55 uh,
43:55 function in very different kind of places and.
43:59 I'm gonna start with just looking at some,
44:00 you know,
44:01 the,
44:01 the sustainable development goals,
44:02 for example,
44:03 which are the sort of the,
44:05 the most
44:06 consulted,
44:07 uh,
44:07 human project in history and they we have these things because of an
44:11 extraordinary effort to to try and create a global consensus around things.
44:16 Mum,
44:17 but I think it's important to recognize that
44:19 this is that particular way of thinking about development,
44:22 setting goals and trying to achieve them through some kind of intentionality.
44:27 Um,
44:27 is,
44:27 is itself a very particular way of thinking about how one changes the world or
44:32 whether what the world itself should be moving in a particular kind of direction.
44:35 So when we invoke
44:37 a language of progress,
44:38 for example,
44:39 progress itself,
44:40 the,
44:40 the very idea of it had to be invented.
44:42 It's a very
44:44 nice little literature on,
44:45 on the invention of progress.
44:47 Um,
44:48 but I think
44:48 when we look around the world we actually have very different visions of what,
44:52 of what progress is.
44:54 Those of us who work for the World Bank have pretty clear understandings of that.
44:58 Uh,
44:58 our twin goals are all about
45:00 setting for us what we,
45:01 what we think counts as progress,
45:03 meeting those particular targets.
45:05 Um,
45:07 but,
45:07 uh,
45:08 you know,
45:08 if what counts as progress is the expansion and
45:11 consolidation of my domain of dominion over others,
45:15 or if progress is my children internalizing a deep normative belief
45:19 that their country or community is inherently superior to others,
45:24 or if I regard the present moment as decadent.
45:27 Ah,
45:27 a fall from grace of a previous golden era,
45:30 corrupted by modern life and insidiously championed by
45:33 heathen others such as woke urban elites,
45:35 etc.
45:36 If that's the narrative you have in your head for what counts as progress,
45:40 ah,
45:40 then it's a very different vision for what,
45:42 for what,
45:43 uh,
45:44 is articulated as normal and normative with inside the
45:47 World Bank and the most amongst most development agencies.
45:50 Which is to say I think we need a a much
45:53 more self-awareness as as development professionals that we are in fact
45:57 championing a very particular way of thinking about
45:59 the ends and the means of attaining progress.
46:02 Um,
46:03 but there are other visions of all of that,
46:04 and I think one of the big
46:06 existential challenges,
46:07 and indeed probably the biggest challenge that humans have always faced
46:11 is how to reconcile these ultimately
46:14 very different ways of,
46:15 of,
46:15 of champion of understanding and enacting
46:18 what counts as progress,
46:19 both as a goal and as a means by which it might be realized.
46:23 Um,
46:24 so for some people,
46:25 for example,
46:25 the end of Roe v.
46:26 Wade last year was itself progress
46:29 because that was going backwards.
46:30 It was undoing what people regard as a great evil,
46:34 and I think
46:35 that's
46:36 the kinds of tools that we're,
46:38 we're talking about here with regards
46:39 to mobilizing narratives or changing different,
46:41 uh,
46:41 frameworks for how people talk and think and act and are in these kind of spaces.
46:47 Those kind of tools can be mobilized by all sorts of people,
46:49 and we are seeing that tragically.
46:51 Uh,
46:52 with all the,
46:52 the,
46:52 the,
46:53 the wars going on,
46:54 uh,
46:54 in Middle East and in Ukraine right now,
46:56 there,
46:57 the,
46:57 the framing of these things is,
46:58 is equally contested
47:00 on,
47:01 on all sides
47:02 as much as it then manifests itself in war.
47:05 But I think for,
47:06 uh,
47:06 the everyday work of doing development,
47:09 being very conscious of the fact that we are invoking a particular way of thinking
47:13 about the world and where it should be going and how it should be changed
47:17 is something that we need to be much more sensitive to.
47:20 As an extension of that,
47:21 I think that
47:22 uh
47:24 one of the tasks of requiring a more
47:28 fluid capacity to be able to move in and
47:30 out of these different kinds of visions of progress is
47:33 experiential and not just cognitive and not just doing
47:36 more uh training programs and not just uh,
47:39 Uh,
47:40 trying to have the right attitude to these things,
47:42 I think most of the things that I've,
47:44 I think this is,
47:44 I hope this is probably true for you as well,
47:46 that
47:47 it was some experience in your life that really
47:49 changed how you came to think about yourself,
47:52 about your,
47:52 your own situation and those around you.
47:55 So I think it'd be good to,
47:56 in the,
47:57 in to as part of an extension of this book is to look at
48:00 the,
48:01 the,
48:01 the,
48:01 the particular kinds of programmatic things that can be done to
48:04 try and really put people for extended periods of time.
48:08 In a very different world
48:10 and see what that actually feels like.
48:12 Uh,
48:13 I think city year programs,
48:15 uh,
48:15 the Peace Corps,
48:16 those kind of things were all
48:18 done,
48:19 not so much because they were gonna change the world.
48:21 They were gonna do much more work of changing the people who were doing that,
48:23 and I think that's,
48:25 uh,
48:25 an important goal in and of itself.
48:27 But I think it's also really important to recognize that these are practices
48:31 that can and need to be cultivated over long periods of time.
48:35 A quick anecdote.
48:37 Uh,
48:37 in 2019,
48:39 the fates aligned to put me in New Zealand a week after the mass,
48:43 the mass murder of,
48:44 of 50 Muslims inside,
48:46 uh,
48:47 in,
48:47 in New Zealand,
48:48 and I was there,
48:49 as it turned out,
48:50 a week after all this had happened,
48:51 so I got to see
48:53 how a country was dealing with its equivalent of 9/11,
48:56 roughly the same percentage of New Zealanders died
48:59 in that particular moment as died during 9/11 here.
49:03 Uh,
49:03 and it was profoundly moving to be part of
49:08 a country for a week,
49:09 as much as it sometimes hurts me as an Australian to say this about New Zealand,
49:12 um,
49:14 just to see how
49:16 Normal
49:17 dealing with really wrenchingly difficult problems are
49:21 and not returning vengeance,
49:23 not giving the attention to people that are that do that kind of work,
49:27 but being able to
49:29 find a different way of being able to process atrocity that isn't vengeful.
49:34 How and how does New Zealand do that?
49:35 I think
49:36 partly because it has a long history,
49:38 a 160 year history
49:41 of having very public
49:43 conversations periodically.
49:45 about how to deal with its relations
49:47 with with its indigenous people and the white European settler population.
49:52 Every decade,
49:52 every New Zealander has to go through this
49:54 process of having really hard public conversations about how
49:58 do we negotiate this.
50:00 And it's not like they've had this all sorted out,
50:01 but if you read the original Waitangi Treaty.
50:04 Uh,
50:05 it was 19th century prose and expressing 19th century sensibilities,
50:09 but over time,
50:10 over time,
50:11 this whole set of repertoires has evolved so that
50:14 having these big hard conversations,
50:17 still hard,
50:17 but they know how to do it.
50:19 And it's not like they went to a training school to learn it,
50:21 it just was baked into them from the beginning that this is who we are if we
50:24 are able and willing to have hard conversations
50:27 that only have the answers that we can create
50:30 by doing that negotiating.
50:32 So,
50:32 at the one weak moment,
50:34 the exact moment when,
50:35 when the atrocities were all occurred,
50:37 I would guess just by eyeballing it,
50:39 that roughly 1/3 of New Zealand's white women wore hijabs
50:44 to work that day.
50:45 And the beauty of it was there wasn't this big campaign,
50:48 oh,
50:48 let's be in solidarity with our brothers and sisters,
50:50 if you can,
50:51 uh,
50:51 if you want to wear a hijab,
50:53 please do.
50:54 The question they were asking me was when I asked,
50:56 wasn't this sort of slightly controversial?
50:57 Was it,
50:58 was anybody pushing back against this?
50:59 The question back to me was,
51:01 why
51:01 wouldn't you want to do that?
51:04 Right?
51:04 That's the starting point.
51:05 Why would you not want to be in solidarity with people when they're suffering?
51:09 Uh,
51:09 they played,
51:10 they had an Islamic call to prayer on the
51:13 national state-run television at that exact moment as well.
51:16 And I'm looking around going,
51:17 jeez,
51:17 would they play that on ABC,
51:19 NBC,
51:19 or CBS here in the United States?
51:21 Uh,
51:22 I don't think so.
51:23 Right,
51:23 but again,
51:24 but,
51:24 but why wouldn't you do that?
51:26 Like
51:26 the,
51:26 the,
51:27 the burden was always back on,
51:28 on those asking the questions about,
51:30 isn't it just normal that you want to be in solidarity with people,
51:33 and those moments,
51:34 it was that,
51:34 I think,
51:35 that made this whole
51:38 exercise of inclusion and recognition,
51:40 able to do the hard work when it was hardest,
51:42 not when it was just trying to get along
51:44 on an everyday basis like deal with the fact that
51:47 blood is boiling.
51:48 People are really pissed off with each other.
51:50 How do you create a space for that kind of negotiating to happen?
51:55 Final point,
51:55 um,
51:57 Uh,
51:58 I think there's a difference between being part of
51:59 an advocacy campaign and being a part of a,
52:01 of a managerial,
52:04 uh,
52:05 taking responsibility for these things afterwards,
52:07 um.
52:08 We call it the uh careful what you wish for kind of problem,
52:11 um,
52:11 and I think that's one of the reasons for me why Hamilton,
52:13 the,
52:13 the musical is so fantastic,
52:15 right,
52:16 not just because of
52:17 the different uh ways in which the music is sung and
52:19 by the different actors and all the rest of it,
52:22 but it's not just about the campaign
52:24 to,
52:24 to end,
52:25 uh,
52:26 the colonization of the British.
52:28 The last bit of it is,
52:29 oh jeez,
52:30 we actually won,
52:31 we succeeded in this great goal.
52:33 Now we've got to do things like figure out a foreign policy,
52:35 now we've got to figure out monetary policy,
52:36 we've gotta do all these boring things that go
52:38 with having succeeded at achieving what we're trying to achieve.
52:42 And I think that's the forgotten part of a lot
52:44 of what we do when we're advocating for particular things,
52:47 the the the work of advocating and the word of governing.
52:50 Are really different and helping people to
52:54 uh be able to assume responsibility for
52:57 managing a world that should be more inclusive
53:00 is a is a is a different kind of skill to being a champion for that to occur.
53:04 There's a different types of work and I would think it'd be really helpful to
53:08 think more about how do we create leadership that's able to do that kind of work,
53:12 not just advocate for it.
53:13 Thanks.
53:15 Thanks,
53:15 Michael.
53:16 Um,
53:18 You know,
53:18 firstly,
53:18 I'd recommend that everybody reads this book.
53:20 It's,
53:21 uh,
53:22 it really
53:22 gives us,
53:23 particularly those who are trained as economists,
53:25 a different way of seeing things.
53:27 Um,
53:28 but what I want to spend my 5 minutes doing
53:30 is to think about how it might affect our own work at the bank,
53:33 yeah.
53:35 The thing to take away from this,
53:36 I think more than anything else is Michelle said,
53:38 see people as three dimensional.
53:40 Yeah.
53:41 In our work in development and in our work in economics we don't,
53:45 we might even,
53:46 we might talk about multi-dimensional measures of this or that,
53:48 but at the end
53:49 we're seeing people as subjects,
53:51 people we do things to,
53:53 presumably to make them better off,
53:54 but they are them,
53:55 we are us,
53:56 the experts,
53:57 we're gonna make them better off by doing things to them,
53:59 yeah,
54:00 and we do things to them in three different broad
54:02 sets of sort of
54:03 lenses,
54:04 three broad paradigms
54:06 the neo liberal,
54:06 which is markets and.
54:08 You know,
54:08 uh,
54:08 uh,
54:09 investments in education and health.
54:10 Not saying any of,
54:11 any of this is wrong or unimportant,
54:13 but I'm just sort of trying to categorize them,
54:14 right?
54:14 So the neoliberal is broadly that,
54:16 yeah,
54:17 uh,
54:18 uh,
54:19 uh,
54:19 the second is neo-K Keynesian,
54:20 which is broadly about equality of opportunity.
54:21 Yeah,
54:22 again,
54:22 uh,
54:23 equalize education,
54:23 equalize access to this,
54:25 uh,
54:25 legislate against,
54:26 uh,
54:26 discrimination,
54:28 uh,
54:28 make sure everybody has equal opportunity.
54:30 Important stuff,
54:30 taxes,
54:31 public finance,
54:32 all of that kind of stuff that,
54:33 that we.
54:34 Get trained on as economists and the third
54:36 is something that's come up more in the last 10 years which I call neo paternalistic.
54:40 Let's RCT the heck out of them,
54:42 yeah,
54:42 find that particular intervention that we can randomize and we can fix things
54:47 beautifully
54:47 or let's nudge the heck out of them.
54:49 Let's nudge them in this way or that way because,
54:51 hey,
54:51 a Nobel Prize has been won in that subject,
54:53 right?
54:53 So in other words,
54:54 we are the experts,
54:55 we're such great social scientists,
54:57 we know exactly what to do.
55:00 In my 23 years at the bank we've actually
55:02 moved much more away from Michelle's point of view
55:06 to these points of view.
55:07 When I came,
55:07 Jim Wolfsson was president.
55:08 Michael and I were both hired at that time,
55:10 when in fact
55:11 all World Bank staff were required to spend a week
55:14 with a poor family in a poor country before they even got started.
55:17 That created empathy
55:19 that created understanding,
55:20 yeah.
55:21 We had the voices of the poor,
55:23 this big dialogue with 60 countries about what do people feel?
55:26 All of that has gone out of the window
55:27 over the last 2020 years,
55:28 yeah.
55:29 How do we bring it back?
55:30 So let me talk about three ways in which we can do it.
55:32 The first is empathy and dialogue.
55:34 Yeah,
55:36 part,
55:36 part of what we should understand about ourselves
55:38 as an organization is we are a bureaucracy.
55:40 We do things in categories and systems,
55:42 in silos,
55:42 all the GPs competing with each other
55:44 for,
55:45 for,
55:45 for,
55:45 for the space of the,
55:46 on the pie and
55:47 power struggles all over the place.
55:49 Game of Thrones,
55:50 people getting
55:51 heads getting sliced off,
55:52 people getting promoted and demoted.
55:53 This is unimportant
55:55 in that mess.
55:56 How do we bring in Michelle's point of view?
55:58 So first,
55:59 Empathy and dialogue,
56:01 what does that mean?
56:02 Dialogue not with each other.
56:03 We do that all the time we talk too much
56:06 dialogue with those who we are trying to work with to make
56:09 them better off in ways that they want to be better off
56:12 in not ways in which we think that they should be better off.
56:15 How do we change that mindset,
56:16 as Michael said,
56:17 to make that happen
56:18 now
56:19 if you're interested,
56:19 I'm happy to have a longer conversation with that later,
56:21 but secondly,
56:22 narratives.
56:24 When we're trying to understand how to make people better off,
56:26 we do
56:27 these household surveys and get a number and say if you're below that,
56:30 you're poor,
56:30 above that,
56:31 you're not poor.
56:32 We do subjective welfare.
56:34 Well,
56:34 let's do something else.
56:35 I'll tell you what I'm trying to do.
56:36 I'm trying to
56:37 with large populations
56:39 have conversations.
56:41 I mean,
56:41 you know,
56:41 it's kind of if I came to you.
56:43 And the first thing I see at a coffee shop or something,
56:45 I come with a set of questions is how old are you?
56:47 How many kids do you have,
56:48 you know,
56:48 how much money do you make?
56:49 You'll think I'm some kind of a
56:51 very nasty human being,
56:52 but that's how we do,
56:53 but that's how we collect data,
56:54 yeah.
56:55 Why don't we have a conversation,
56:57 understand what people are thinking from there.
56:58 What do you think is a good life?
57:00 No,
57:00 I'm not going to tell you that welfare,
57:01 you're better off if you get so much more money.
57:03 What do you think is a good life?
57:05 Are you meeting those things that make you
57:07 better off?
57:08 What do you want your kids to be when they grow up?
57:10 That we do aspirations,
57:11 but do we ask them
57:12 how are you going to get there?
57:14 Yeah,
57:15 what other things do you want your kids to be other than a high salaried person?
57:18 What are your aspirations in terms of making them good human beings?
57:21 We can do this at scale.
57:22 We can change how we collect data to understand those narratives
57:25 better and change the narratives of how we do development.
57:28 And the third one
57:29 is deliberation and participation.
57:31 There's a huge group of the bank that CDD is the heck out of things,
57:34 yeah.
57:34 Uh,
57:35 and,
57:35 and those are done through sciences.
57:36 I've written a book on the subject we're interested that got
57:38 me into a lot of trouble a few years ago,
57:40 but,
57:40 but that
57:42 process of taking these complex
57:44 networks and complex narratives and complex ways of bringing people together,
57:48 making them more cohesive
57:49 and trundling it through,
57:50 forcing it through a funnel
57:52 of bank projects
57:53 is where the problem lies.
57:55 Yeah,
57:56 we can change that
57:57 by making that process of dialogue central to everything we do,
58:01 whether it's an infrastructure project,
58:03 whether it's a
58:04 project on education,
58:05 not just throwing money at communities and saying manage it yourselves,
58:09 which create all kinds of problems,
58:11 yeah,
58:11 so we can do this,
58:12 but it requires a different kind of mindset.
58:15 It requires a different kind of
58:16 understanding moving beyond equality of opportunity
58:19 to what Mike Walton and I called in 2004
58:21 in Culture and Public Action equality of agency.
58:24 Yeah,
58:24 give people the ability
58:26 to see the world in a way that we see the world,
58:28 understand their point of view rather than ours,
58:30 rather than imposing ours.
58:31 We can do this.
58:32 It is possible.
58:33 It requires a different mindset,
58:35 different incentive structures,
58:36 and gets centrally important
58:38 when we have to deal with collectives all the time to
58:41 deal with the complexities of climate change which we're all thankfully now
58:44 deeply concerned with.
58:45 Yeah,
58:45 so I'm gonna stop there.
58:46 Thank you.
58:52 Uh,
58:54 yeah,
58:54 so Michelle,
58:55 5 minutes,
58:55 yeah.
58:56 Well,
58:57 I,
58:57 you know,
58:58 I'm just extremely sympathetic to the perspective that you both,
59:02 uh,
59:02 shared there.
59:03 Um,
59:04 what I keep from,
59:05 um,
59:06 Michael's comments,
59:07 the importance of the experiential aspect is,
59:11 uh,
59:11 extremely crucial,
59:12 the interaction.
59:14 Uh,
59:14 a colleague of,
59:15 uh,
59:15 Bijo and I,
59:16 uh,
59:16 Francis Capoleta,
59:18 wrote a book exactly on that.
59:19 Doing things together really transforms people,
59:22 and the alternative to this,
59:24 uh,
59:25 uh,
59:25 neopetroism that,
59:26 uh,
59:27 Bijo was talking about is exactly about interacting and understanding.
59:32 Incidentally,
59:32 as I'm promoting the book,
59:34 um,
59:35 my publicist wants me to write things for like the Harvard Business Review,
59:39 and they want me to come up with the 4 points
59:41 that a manager can implement in the workplace to transform things,
59:45 and my takeaway is it's about understanding the life of others,
59:48 but they don't think that
59:50 preaching understanding is a solution.
59:52 So I it totally resonates with what you're saying,
59:54 you know,
59:55 being able to walk in someone else's shoes
59:57 for a manager to understand that uh the
1:00:01 an employee needs to bring her elderly mother to the doctor once in a while,
1:00:05 you know,
1:00:05 really gives an element of recognition that really feeds a very different uh.
1:00:10 A way of interacting and I think the uh
1:00:12 the issue of the production of solidarity,
1:00:15 which is a social process,
1:00:17 uh,
1:00:17 it is accomplished and it is,
1:00:19 it can be accomplished.
1:00:20 One person
1:00:22 who's influenced my thinking is uh
1:00:24 Al Pla who is the vice president for
1:00:27 research at the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation,
1:00:29 and he launched a big initiative
1:00:31 called,
1:00:32 uh,
1:00:32 the Culture of Health,
1:00:33 and it involves mostly promoting solidarity.
1:00:36 So before taking that job he was in LA
1:00:39 where he.
1:00:39 was in charge of
1:00:41 earthquake preparedness
1:00:43 and he put big billboards all over the city saying,
1:00:45 you know,
1:00:45 get to know your neighbors,
1:00:47 you will need them one day.
1:00:48 So the issue of you know distributing messages about how
1:00:53 solidarity is really essential.
1:00:55 So the New Zealand example that Michael gave us is so excellent
1:00:59 and of course I'm not the only one in the
1:01:00 room who was thinking about what's happening in Israel and Gaza
1:01:04 along these lines,
1:01:05 you know what would be possible in the current context to.
1:01:09 To move away from this,
1:01:11 you know,
1:01:11 escalation
1:01:12 to really
1:01:13 let people
1:01:15 understand each other,
1:01:16 and I think one of the things that's needed.
1:01:18 I,
1:01:19 you know,
1:01:19 mentioned plurality of criteria of worth.
1:01:22 I want to mention an anecdote from the book.
1:01:23 I did.
1:01:24 I cite the work of a
1:01:26 psychologist who's interviewed janitors who work on campuses all over the world,
1:01:30 and he mentions the janitors in Malaysia,
1:01:33 these old ladies who take care of the bedrooms of the students,
1:01:37 and instead of,
1:01:38 you know,
1:01:38 them being deeply stigmatized.
1:01:40 In these relationships they present themselves as good aunties
1:01:43 who are giving them
1:01:45 advice on nutrition and their health,
1:01:47 you know,
1:01:47 and take care of them in the
1:01:49 absence of the mother so it's a it's totally anecdotal,
1:01:52 but it's an example of how
1:01:54 a shift in frame can make a huge difference,
1:01:57 um,
1:01:58 so,
1:01:59 and Bijou was really pushing the importance of.
1:02:01 Epathy and dialogue and I could not agree more.
1:02:05 There's a huge movement in positive psychology that is doing this
1:02:08 there now.
1:02:10 My concern about it is it's a little bit too voluntaristic,
1:02:13 and I think we really need to think about
1:02:15 really spreading around the narratives that this is
1:02:19 I hate to use the word engineering,
1:02:21 but engineering our societies differently.
1:02:23 In terms of what messages circulate about how
1:02:26 we should address the problems and you will remember
1:02:29 the Prime Minister of uh
1:02:31 of New Zealand how unbelievably inspiring she was in that crucial moment.
1:02:36 So
1:02:37 I don't know if it would have happened without her,
1:02:39 but the fact that she was so out there
1:02:41 and putting the messages truly made a huge difference.
1:02:44 So
1:02:44 I agree with you,
1:02:45 the deliberation and you have both of you done a lot of things.
1:02:49 There's a bowling alone by.
1:02:51 Uh,
1:02:52 Bob Putnam was the bible in the social sciences for several years and then
1:02:56 people really moved away saying,
1:02:57 oh,
1:02:58 it's just nostalgic about the little town in Ohio where
1:03:00 we grew up where in fact everyone was white and
1:03:03 and Protestant,
1:03:04 you know,
1:03:05 uh,
1:03:06 and we need to think differently about,
1:03:08 uh,
1:03:09 how to engage in deliberation,
1:03:10 and I know that that's some of the work that you've done,
1:03:13 right,
1:03:13 to really study empirically
1:03:15 the culture of deliberation and to help us move away from the ethnocentrism.
1:03:19 That is characteristic of some of the world of development experts that uh we all
1:03:26 experience.
1:03:26 So
1:03:27 yes,
1:03:27 thank you so much for your comments for both of you.
1:03:30 Thank you Michelle.
1:03:31 Uh,
1:03:32 so that was uh
1:03:33 uh uh wonderful to hear
1:03:35 from Michelle and now
1:03:37 we're gonna leave it,
1:03:37 uh,
1:03:38 out to the audience.
1:03:39 Uh,
1:03:39 I'm gonna take questions online as well,
1:03:42 uh,
1:03:42 and I'll try to coordinate both yes please go ahead.
1:03:46 Hi,
1:03:47 thanks for a fantastic talk.
1:03:48 Um,
1:03:49 I'm a social scientist too,
1:03:50 so this is all music to my ears.
1:03:54 Two quick questions.
1:03:55 Um,
1:03:56 you have this very tantalizing slide about how to broaden
1:04:00 social inclusion.
1:04:01 Could you speak to that a little bit?
1:04:04 And secondly,
1:04:05 um,
1:04:06 you mentioned,
1:04:07 I mean,
1:04:07 you've all three of you mentioned changing narratives,
1:04:10 specially now that the bank is talking about working more with youth.
1:04:15 And I say with rather than for youth,
1:04:18 um,
1:04:19 how can a bureaucracy like the bank get better at
1:04:24 one collecting and secondly,
1:04:26 understanding and responding to youth
1:04:28 narratives
1:04:30 about what will make their lives better.
1:04:33 Thanks.
1:04:33 Wow,
1:04:34 that's a difficult one.
1:04:38 I'll just put the slides that I think you were referring to,
1:04:41 it's this one,
1:04:42 right?
1:04:44 Yeah,
1:04:45 um,
1:04:47 Yeah,
1:04:47 well,
1:04:47 it's here what I was gonna do in my presentation was really revisiting some of the
1:04:53 path dependency through which we can broaden inclusion.
1:04:56 I mean there's also what can everyday citizens do,
1:05:00 uh,
1:05:01 like
1:05:02 promoting aploristic criteria of work.
1:05:04 I have already,
1:05:05 uh,
1:05:06 explained that a little bit with the
1:05:07 example of employers who are promoting care work
1:05:10 as a dimension of the life of their workers,
1:05:13 the celebration of ordinary universalism.
1:05:16 Uh,
1:05:17 is central in what Gen Zs are in their fight for the pronouns,
1:05:20 the non-binary pronouns,
1:05:22 and also the bathrooms,
1:05:24 which many people don't understand what it's about,
1:05:26 but I think it's extremely central.
1:05:28 The reduction of stigma.
1:05:30 I explained it very briefly with the.
1:05:32 The role of knowledge workers and social movement activists
1:05:36 in transforming.
1:05:36 So the example I give in this paper
1:05:39 is people with HIV AIDS who have been able to really destigmatize that
1:05:44 identity over the last several decades and it was done in part by.
1:05:48 Uh,
1:05:48 mobilizing a lot of medical workers who said,
1:05:51 you know,
1:05:52 having,
1:05:52 uh,
1:05:52 AIDS is not because you lead an immoral life.
1:05:56 Anyone can get it,
1:05:57 so it was,
1:05:57 you know,
1:05:58 we draw in this paper on a couple of secondary sources
1:06:01 that show why,
1:06:02 um,
1:06:04 HIV AIDS was destigmatized while obesity was not.
1:06:07 So the point is always that these are accomplishments
1:06:11 that require collaboration between groups and once we
1:06:14 understand that we can participate in that.
1:06:16 Yeah,
1:06:17 so,
1:06:17 and for the youth,
1:06:18 I mean,
1:06:18 you probably know much better than I do.
1:06:20 I don't know exactly
1:06:22 what um
1:06:24 the World Bank does to to create a dialogue with young people.
1:06:28 I'm a little bit more familiar with what Ford does,
1:06:30 but uh
1:06:31 maybe you can provide some background.
1:06:35 Let me,
1:06:35 let me try to respond to the youth thing a bit.
1:06:37 Um,
1:06:38 I'll give you a particular example,
1:06:39 you know,
1:06:40 so,
1:06:40 so.
1:06:41 In the Indian Constitution,
1:06:43 all villages are supposed to have village meetings,
1:06:46 uh,
1:06:46 4 times a year,
1:06:47 approximately to,
1:06:48 to,
1:06:48 to make collective decisions,
1:06:50 yeah.
1:06:51 Um,
1:06:52 about 20 years ago
1:06:53 I was peripherally involved with this,
1:06:55 uh,
1:06:55 but many,
1:06:56 many other people were,
1:06:58 we all started something that we call children's village meetings,
1:07:01 yeah,
1:07:02 where basically
1:07:03 instead of just having adults come and make those decisions,
1:07:05 we restricted it to people below the age of 18,
1:07:08 yeah,
1:07:09 and.
1:07:10 And I've written about this.
1:07:12 It was tremendous.
1:07:13 Yeah.
1:07:13 These kids were,
1:07:14 I mean,
1:07:14 I,
1:07:14 I'll never forget this meeting I attended,
1:07:16 the kids meeting.
1:07:18 school kid must have been 14 years old,
1:07:20 a young,
1:07:21 14-year-old girl,
1:07:23 woman,
1:07:23 young woman,
1:07:24 uh,
1:07:24 stood up and said,
1:07:26 You know,
1:07:26 in our school,
1:07:28 there is a uh
1:07:30 a water reservoir that's,
1:07:31 that's on the verge of breaking,
1:07:33 and if we don't do something about it,
1:07:34 it's going to kill all of us.
1:07:35 Yeah.
1:07:36 Another girl standing up and saying we don't have bathrooms,
1:07:38 so.
1:07:39 Asking for practical things which by the way
1:07:42 they listened to and they fixed immediately,
1:07:44 right?
1:07:45 So that's simply by way of saying that dialogue I mean
1:07:48 kids are tremendously able to engage
1:07:51 in dialogue yeah
1:07:52 just as we are uh in fact better sometimes if they come to it with less bias,
1:07:55 yeah.
1:07:56 So collecting those narratives,
1:07:59 understanding those narratives,
1:07:59 engaging in dialogue with them,
1:08:02 I'm happy to talk about what the different techniques are that we could do this with,
1:08:05 but that's,
1:08:05 that's the way to go,
1:08:06 yeah,
1:08:07 uh,
1:08:07 we have many,
1:08:08 many different tools to do this,
1:08:09 uh,
1:08:09 qualitative tools,
1:08:11 machine learning tools,
1:08:11 lots of things we could do,
1:08:13 but,
1:08:13 but I think it's eminently possible so that would be the
1:08:15 process by which you bring in their ideas in order to formulate
1:08:19 whatever policies you devise to work with them,
1:08:22 yeah,
1:08:22 so have them,
1:08:23 have them engaged in that conversation.
1:08:29 Uh,
1:08:30 if you could introduce yourselves before you ask a question,
1:08:32 that'd be great.
1:08:32 Thank you.
1:08:40 They
1:08:42 don't seem to work.
1:08:44 Mhm
1:08:45 Hi
1:08:46 hi uh thanks a lot for your talk.
1:08:47 My name is Massi Santini.
1:08:48 I work here at the World Bank in Private Sector Development.
1:08:51 I've done some work on political narratives in the
1:08:53 past and I've seen that both you and uh
1:08:56 and the discussion brought up narratives quite a bit.
1:08:59 I was interested in knowing whether in your research
1:09:02 you came across with
1:09:03 specific factors,
1:09:05 uh,
1:09:06 that differentiate successful narrative from non-successful narratives.
1:09:11 Is it about,
1:09:12 um.
1:09:13 Different system of values that they tap into,
1:09:16 is it about,
1:09:17 uh,
1:09:17 emotional systems in people's heart that they tapped into,
1:09:21 um,
1:09:22 or is it about
1:09:23 other factors?
1:09:24 Thank you.
1:09:26 Well,
1:09:26 that's a literature that is mostly
1:09:31 Developed by psychologists so I cannot talk about
1:09:34 it with a great deal of uh knowledge,
1:09:37 but I know that the question of emotional resonance is absolutely crucial
1:09:41 so there are for instance famous experiments of showing in Malawi,
1:09:45 uh,
1:09:46 you know,
1:09:46 films about contraception and how is it,
1:09:48 you know,
1:09:49 the question of the content and the resonance is absolutely crucial,
1:09:52 but I'm not the person to give you detailed information about that.
1:09:56 Maybe you know better than I do.
1:10:00 Unfortunately,
1:10:00 I mean,
1:10:01 you know,
1:10:01 they they they they
1:10:02 they.
1:10:05 there is some work done on this even at the bank,
1:10:08 uh,
1:10:08 not by,
1:10:09 not by Michael or me,
1:10:10 but by others.
1:10:10 So,
1:10:11 but,
1:10:11 but it's not a literature.
1:10:14 I'm not looking at my research colleagues here.
1:10:16 No,
1:10:16 OK,
1:10:17 uh,
1:10:18 so,
1:10:18 so,
1:10:19 um,
1:10:19 no,
1:10:20 but,
1:10:20 but yeah.
1:10:23 I know the key concept is resonance,
1:10:25 so you may want to look at the work of Frances Capoeta.
1:10:28 She has a book titled Inventing Social Ties that is basically about that.
1:10:35 OK,
1:10:35 any more questions?
1:10:39 Uh,
1:10:41 no.
1:10:42 OK,
1:10:44 I maybe
1:10:45 Michael and I can ask you a couple of questions.
1:10:46 So,
1:10:47 um,
1:10:48 so,
1:10:48 so Michelle,
1:10:49 you,
1:10:49 you didn't have much time,
1:10:50 uh,
1:10:51 to go into,
1:10:52 I mean,
1:10:52 we're a practical organization,
1:10:54 right?
1:10:54 And so
1:10:55 the question then again becomes beyond what we talk about what is it that we could do?
1:10:59 You,
1:10:59 you also have a lot of experience with the UN now and,
1:11:01 and of course the UN in some ways has been ahead of the bank on these issues.
1:11:04 Um,
1:11:05 what can we do differently?
1:11:07 How,
1:11:07 how do we,
1:11:08 how do we do development differently,
1:11:10 yeah.
1:11:11 Uh,
1:11:11 and just go all out.
1:11:12 You're,
1:11:12 you're not from the bank.
1:11:13 Please be free to speak.
1:11:19 Human Development,
1:11:20 and that's very special,
1:11:21 right,
1:11:21 because it's informed by the
1:11:23 capability approach and the person who directs that office,
1:11:27 Pedro
1:11:28 Conciro,
1:11:28 he really was ready to really open the black box in a very radical way
1:11:33 because if you read this report,
1:11:35 I mean it cites,
1:11:36 you know,
1:11:37 narratives every 3.
1:11:38 Lines.
1:11:38 It really didn't want
1:11:40 the previous report had been co-chaired by Piketty,
1:11:43 who's already very,
1:11:44 very interdisciplinary,
1:11:46 but he wanted to bring me in,
1:11:47 and the other co-director was the person who was
1:11:50 recently elected as the Prime Minister of Singapore,
1:11:54 who is a very,
1:11:55 yeah,
1:11:55 very interesting,
1:11:57 yeah,
1:11:57 a president,
1:11:58 yes,
1:11:58 and very adventurous person.
1:12:00 So I guess my,
1:12:02 what I would draw as conclusion from this experience is having leadership
1:12:06 that is ready to,
1:12:07 you know,
1:12:08 take on a very adventurous position.
1:12:11 I think that Pedro in part
1:12:13 probably because he was put there in place because it's the capability approach,
1:12:17 maybe the window was already open to do things that were not standard there,
1:12:21 but I was extremely impressed by how he was also able to mobilize his team
1:12:25 to do things that they just don't do normally.
1:12:27 He was extremely ready to think about outside the box,
1:12:32 so that's one,
1:12:33 you know,
1:12:34 leadership I would say is crucial.
1:12:36 That that's absolutely right.
1:12:37 I think there's a question
1:12:39 online,
1:12:39 uh,
1:12:40 from Isha Zaberi.
1:12:41 Could you reflect on how power shapes these narratives,
1:12:44 even in terms of,
1:12:45 um,
1:12:46 methods and,
1:12:47 oh gosh.
1:12:50 Try to
1:12:51 having trouble moving down here
1:12:53 uh yeah even in terms of uh
1:12:55 methods and approaches uh how some decisions
1:12:58 are privileged by those who have power,
1:13:00 including power derived from expertise position or resources
1:13:03 how does power matter?
1:13:05 Well that's a very big one
1:13:07 and to answer it,
1:13:08 I'll put another hat.
1:13:09 I wrote a book titled How Professors Think,
1:13:12 which is about criteria of excellence across the social sciences.
1:13:16 So I,
1:13:16 it goes from
1:13:17 philosophy,
1:13:18 history,
1:13:18 and literature to
1:13:21 political science,
1:13:21 sociology,
1:13:22 and economics,
1:13:23 and I did indepth interviews with 80 some people who served on funding.
1:13:27 Panels
1:13:27 about how do they recognize good work so there I think the issue of economics
1:13:32 is very peculiar because it's a culture that has a
1:13:35 very strong consensus about what's good and what's not good
1:13:38 so I think the boundary closing within this profession
1:13:42 operates in a way that is in some ways not facilitating
1:13:46 uh intellectual diversity
1:13:49 uh and it is not true of other fields such
1:13:51 as uh history and literature where you had the uh.
1:13:55 You know,
1:13:56 new historicism an approach that emerged 20
1:13:58 years ago that really revolutionized the,
1:14:00 the discipline from the inside,
1:14:03 uh,
1:14:03 so I think the issue of internal boundary making in the disciplines is
1:14:07 crucial and there's a couple of really good books that have come out
1:14:11 on this topic in recent years,
1:14:12 Marion Foucat Economics and Society being one of them.
1:14:16 And the other one is titled Thinking Like an Economist.
1:14:19 It's a brilliant book,
1:14:20 so I think
1:14:21 understanding
1:14:22 would require really maybe like for
1:14:26 throwing this out there for the World Bank to organize reading groups to ask itself
1:14:30 what is it that we don't see like my book aims to be
1:14:34 addressing the blind spots
1:14:36 of.
1:14:36 Literatures right how we think about inequality and
1:14:39 what is so like if there were a systematic
1:14:42 collective thinking experiment about you know how do we approach development,
1:14:46 how could we approach it differently?
1:14:48 What is missing?
1:14:49 Is it the the voices of the people equal agency,
1:14:52 some of the themes that you mentioned that could be really,
1:14:54 really interesting,
1:14:55 but it would require.
1:14:57 The leadership to think that this can be fruitful and that it
1:15:01 would be healthy for the World Bank to do something like this,
1:15:04 shaking the machine a little bit,
1:15:05 you know,
1:15:06 let the 100,000 flower bloom.
1:15:11 Uh yes,
1:15:12 please.
1:15:13 Um,
1:15:14 sorry,
1:15:14 I didn't introduce myself last time.
1:15:16 My name is Sonia Sultan,
1:15:17 and I'm the global lead for social inclusion at the bank.
1:15:21 So my question on the youth narratives maybe I I didn't pose it the
1:15:26 right way it's not just for the bank but in your research when you
1:15:30 mentioned there's an alternative narrative about success,
1:15:34 what happens when that narrative
1:15:36 clashes with the dominant narrative
1:15:40 so in the US
1:15:41 where you still have
1:15:43 uh people in policy making positions powerful.
1:15:46 Political positions pushing the
1:15:49 making money,
1:15:50 having a good job and then you have this new narrative
1:15:54 how do the shifts happen?
1:15:56 and I guess for me I was
1:15:58 thinking in the bank,
1:15:59 you know,
1:16:00 we know how to listen to young people,
1:16:03 but
1:16:04 can we then move from listening to young people to actually thinking
1:16:08 OK maybe they don't just want good jobs.
1:16:11 Jobs in addition to good jobs
1:16:13 they care about certain other things
1:16:15 and we need to get better at responding to that.
1:16:18 Oh,
1:16:18 absolutely,
1:16:19 uh thank you for the clarification
1:16:21 we know with the great resignation,
1:16:23 right?
1:16:24 The,
1:16:24 the
1:16:25 lack of the the workforce being so limited post pandemic,
1:16:30 uh,
1:16:30 a lot of young people have been
1:16:32 voting with their feet,
1:16:33 walking away from jobs that seem meaningless to them.
1:16:36 And I think this is very much connected to climate change.
1:16:40 I think their time horizon is drastically different
1:16:44 from that of boomers,
1:16:45 you know,
1:16:45 we presume that we'll retire at 70,
1:16:47 75,
1:16:48 blah blah blah.
1:16:49 In their case,
1:16:50 from what I heard from our interviews,
1:16:53 many of them don't know if they're going to be alive in 20 years.
1:16:56 So the nihilism that is connected to,
1:16:59 it's not necessarily nihilism,
1:17:00 but it's hopelessness,
1:17:01 you know,
1:17:02 the number of them who don't want babies.
1:17:04 For instance is is staggering,
1:17:05 right?
1:17:06 So I think that employers and that's also another question I've been
1:17:09 asked to discuss in the context of the launch of this book
1:17:13 what should employers do to be able to recruit and and retain those
1:17:16 those young people and the idea
1:17:19 is very much to create a workplace in which they can feel and
1:17:22 they say that they can feel that they can bring their whole self
1:17:26 so and if we see the movement of unionization that
1:17:28 we've seen in the US for the last few months.
1:17:31 Like the uh Amazon strike,
1:17:33 one of the main demands was people wanted to have bathroom breaks
1:17:37 so isn't that about human dignity,
1:17:39 you know,
1:17:39 or
1:17:40 uh the Starbucks strike was in part about being able to display uh rainbow flags
1:17:47 and the Hollywood strike was also about
1:17:49 creativity for uh workers uh creative workers,
1:17:53 you know,
1:17:54 so I think there's been a little bit of a convergence between.
1:17:58 That generation being part of the Black Lives Matter and deciding we're
1:18:02 not where we want to put to push an organization of society
1:18:07 where the automobile industry will not be able to just benefit from
1:18:10 massive governmental subsidies and then not redistribute the profits so this urge
1:18:16 to create a more equal society I think is a very big um
1:18:20 uh motivation and uh you know there's just a lot of pushback happening.
1:18:26 And we know that there's still many places where there's not enough people to hire,
1:18:30 so I think
1:18:31 eventually my hope is that the employers will just
1:18:34 have to revisit how they organize the workplace.
1:18:37 So then the the theme of I want to be able,
1:18:39 I remember the first time an undergrad told me in my class,
1:18:43 I want to be able to.
1:18:44 Bring my best self to the classroom and I was so puzzled and I thought,
1:18:48 what do you mean your best self,
1:18:49 you know
1:18:50 what do you mean?
1:18:51 And it was really,
1:18:52 I think,
1:18:53 about the issue of
1:18:54 living your life fully now because you don't know what's going to happen next you
1:18:58 know I think there's a sense of urgency that is very real for them.
1:19:02 So,
1:19:03 um.
1:19:06 Let me,
1:19:06 let me try to come back to the question of power because I,
1:19:09 I think again,
1:19:10 reflecting
1:19:11 about it from the,
1:19:11 from the perspective of somebody who works at the bank.
1:19:15 Um,
1:19:16 you know,
1:19:16 one of the things that always struck me about the bank is.
1:19:19 People
1:19:20 at the bank are far more interesting in
1:19:21 their private lives than in their professional lives,
1:19:24 right?
1:19:24 Here we tend to be very.
1:19:27 Structured in a way we sort of it's going back to Goffman,
1:19:30 we it's a presentation of self,
1:19:33 yeah,
1:19:33 because we are so hierarchical
1:19:36 and we try so hard to please the
1:19:38 please please upward
1:19:40 that that we are scared of violating that in any way.
1:19:43 I mean,
1:19:43 it's all of us are subject to this.
1:19:46 Um,
1:19:47 which means that power,
1:19:49 internal power
1:19:50 plays,
1:19:51 I mean,
1:19:51 every time a president comes the whole world changes,
1:19:53 right?
1:19:53 We're all talking about climate change and we
1:19:54 weren't doing this even two months ago,
1:19:55 yeah,
1:19:56 so,
1:19:57 so,
1:19:57 so power
1:19:58 plays a huge role in how we function as an organization.
1:20:01 We have enormous hierarchical,
1:20:03 yeah.
1:20:04 What happens with that is that the products that we produce
1:20:09 tend to be done to please that hierarchy,
1:20:11 and hierarchies,
1:20:12 particularly as you go higher up the ladder,
1:20:14 don't have time.
1:20:15 So they want to see everything neat and clean,
1:20:17 done in very nice ways,
1:20:19 very,
1:20:19 very,
1:20:20 you know,
1:20:20 beautifully packaged,
1:20:22 uh,
1:20:22 so that,
1:20:22 yes,
1:20:22 I've done this.
1:20:23 I mean,
1:20:23 you know,
1:20:24 the way our world is immensely messy,
1:20:27 yeah,
1:20:27 particularly where you want to engage with
1:20:29 these pluralistic empathetic ways of doing development,
1:20:32 it takes time
1:20:33 and it's messy.
1:20:35 The powers that we don't want to see that.
1:20:38 And that the ability to throw money at the problem,
1:20:40 but money just makes it worse.
1:20:43 You need less money.
1:20:43 You need more time and more tolerance of mess,
1:20:46 yeah,
1:20:47 uh,
1:20:48 and,
1:20:48 and this is the biggest frustration I felt being at the bank that I used
1:20:51 to run something called the Social Observatory that
1:20:53 was trying to do this kind of stuff
1:20:54 and I ended up pissing off
1:20:56 upsetting.
1:20:57 It was what it was research working with operations,
1:21:00 everybody in operations because they didn't like
1:21:01 being told they were doing things wrong
1:21:03 and everybody in research because I wasn't producing enough papers,
1:21:05 yeah,
1:21:06 so,
1:21:06 so,
1:21:07 so,
1:21:07 so,
1:21:07 so that,
1:21:08 that is,
1:21:08 it's almost an impossibility to do that kind of work here,
1:21:11 yeah.
1:21:12 I think if we don't change that,
1:21:14 we don't change how power functions and how we function,
1:21:18 we're gonna have this problem
1:21:19 again and again and again we're going to have these nicely packaged things
1:21:22 we talk about pluralism,
1:21:23 we talk about
1:21:24 boundaries and we talk about how to make the world a
1:21:26 better place in the ways that Michelle so beautifully talked about
1:21:29 we're gonna end up with a nice PowerPoint presentation
1:21:31 that we sent around and that's about it,
1:21:33 yeah.
1:21:34 Uh,
1:21:34 uh,
1:21:35 and nothing and very little real happens after that,
1:21:38 uh,
1:21:38 perhaps a lot of wasted money,
1:21:39 so
1:21:40 we have to change how we do things in order to,
1:21:42 to bring all the stuff in.
1:21:43 It's hard,
1:21:44 yeah,
1:21:45 and,
1:21:45 and I think
1:21:46 if we
1:21:47 let me use,
1:21:48 uh,
1:21:48 uh,
1:21:48 President Banga's words,
1:21:50 uh,
1:21:50 we should all recruit ourselves
1:21:52 to try and try and do that in a way
1:21:54 that keeps conscious
1:21:56 of the pressing issues of our time like climate change,
1:21:58 right?
1:21:59 OK,
1:21:59 I think,
1:22:00 uh,
1:22:00 why don't we,
1:22:01 but if there's anything more,
1:22:02 Michael,
1:22:02 if you want some,
1:22:03 there's a question there,
1:22:04 so go ahead please,
1:22:05 yes.
1:22:07 And please introduce yourself.
1:22:13 There you go.
1:22:14 Hello,
1:22:15 uh,
1:22:16 yeah,
1:22:16 my name is,
1:22:17 uh,
1:22:17 Mussini.
1:22:17 Uh,
1:22:18 I'm a Gen Z who joined the,
1:22:19 the bank,
1:22:20 uh,
1:22:20 last year as a McNamara Fellow,
1:22:21 which is an initiative to increase diversity in the research group at the bank.
1:22:26 Um,
1:22:26 last weekend on Netflix there was a movie released,
1:22:29 uh,
1:22:29 called Old Dads,
1:22:31 which is about,
1:22:31 um,
1:22:32 three friends who create a company and the company is being taken over
1:22:35 by a young startupper and there is a clash of culture happening,
1:22:39 um,
1:22:40 which makes me think about the question of
1:22:42 uh,
1:22:43 what do you,
1:22:43 how's the role of elderly people in this clash that you've been describing?
1:22:48 Because I just feel like as a young person,
1:22:51 we
1:22:52 have different aspirations,
1:22:53 but we also recognize that there's a lot we don't know.
1:22:56 Um,
1:22:56 so I was wondering how you see the role of
1:22:59 older people in
1:23:00 in this backlash.
1:23:03 Well,
1:23:03 one of the objective of the book is to really uh invite boomers to be allies
1:23:09 to you know to realize that OK
1:23:12 maybe they care about pronouns or things that most boomers don't care
1:23:15 about but the uh vision for an alternative society I mean.
1:23:20 At some level,
1:23:21 Gen Zs totally misunderstand the extent to which the boomers
1:23:24 were creating social change in the 60s and the 70s.
1:23:27 Like I'm the generation of second wave feminism.
1:23:30 I say in the first chapter,
1:23:32 I had fights with my brother regularly because he had to
1:23:35 mow the lawn once a month and I did the dishes every day.
1:23:38 So the practice of everyday feminism
1:23:40 is something that women of my generation really experience and
1:23:44 there's a lot of possibilities for allyship,
1:23:47 I think.
1:23:47 And uh to pit the generations against
1:23:50 each other is fundamentally very counterproductive.
1:23:53 There's a lot of experience.
1:23:54 Someone like Michael Wilcox,
1:23:56 I think,
1:23:56 you know,
1:23:57 like I think the experience of trying to create
1:24:00 change for decades from the bottom up,
1:24:02 there's a lot of expertise that could be better mobilized.
1:24:05 Right?
1:24:07 There's another,
1:24:08 there's another question,
1:24:09 Michael.
1:24:09 Let me,
1:24:09 let me just read it out because I don't wanna miss this one.
1:24:12 Hello.
1:24:12 How do we work,
1:24:13 do the work of recognition,
1:24:14 reconciliation,
1:24:15 and age of misinformation where one side is debating truth and facts
1:24:19 and,
1:24:19 uh,
1:24:19 uh,
1:24:20 presumably there's,
1:24:21 uh,
1:24:21 you know,
1:24:21 there's a lot of manipulation there,
1:24:23 um,
1:24:24 that would,
1:24:24 if I think that's a relevant question.
1:24:26 So
1:24:26 yeah,
1:24:27 well,
1:24:27 part of me wants to be less preoccupied with,
1:24:31 uh,
1:24:31 misinformation than most people are because after all,
1:24:34 the percentage of the.
1:24:35 Population that spends
1:24:37 its time on social media is
1:24:40 is far from being the majority.
1:24:43 The average American is still consuming their their news uh at the 6 o'clock TV
1:24:49 station,
1:24:49 you know.
1:24:50 So I think
1:24:51 the chapter that does an overview of how
1:24:54 the public media system is in the process of transforming
1:24:57 leads me to a since we're constantly talking
1:25:00 about social media and polarization to social media,
1:25:03 we forget.
1:25:03 The fact that you know a large proportion of the population is totally ready
1:25:08 to uh live with others
1:25:10 through indifference or through tolerance
1:25:13 and the light is constantly shed on the two ends of the political spectrum,
1:25:18 so I wish that someone would really provide a much more,
1:25:21 you know,
1:25:21 holistic vision of uh there's no problem question that like
1:25:25 there's a brilliant book by a guy named Reese Peck
1:25:30 titled Fox.
1:25:32 What is it?
1:25:33 Fox News?
1:25:34 No,
1:25:34 anyway,
1:25:34 it's a very good sociology of uh
1:25:37 uh the Fox Channel and it explains how
1:25:40 uh
1:25:42 Trump very systematically appealed to working class men by,
1:25:45 you know,
1:25:46 through his sense of humor through his sexism,
1:25:49 the connection of the habitus is absolutely crucial,
1:25:52 so there's a lot happening there,
1:25:53 no question,
1:25:54 but the public sphere of where actually people
1:25:56 get their news is far more complex than.
1:25:59 I think
1:25:59 most of the people who write about this study themselves social media,
1:26:03 so all we end up hearing about is that
1:26:05 so
1:26:06 thanks Michelle Michael,
1:26:07 your last words.
1:26:09 I,
1:26:09 I gave you my New Zealand story.
1:26:11 My other,
1:26:12 my other good story is Canada actually.
1:26:14 I last year I got invited to a meeting where
1:26:17 $26 billion
1:26:19 had just been appropriated by the Canadian government
1:26:21 as reparations for its First Nations people,
1:26:24 and
1:26:24 I was there from this sort of mixed methods perspective I'm
1:26:27 trying to sort of figure out how to have this,
1:26:29 but it was,
1:26:30 uh,
1:26:30 a version of the New Zealand story just wow.
1:26:33 This is a group that understands that there are
1:26:35 these administrative imperatives that have to be upheld.
1:26:38 This is not free money.
1:26:39 This is not just sort of showered out and sort of hope everybody's grateful.
1:26:42 There's a whole logic that goes with trying to administer this money.
1:26:46 And
1:26:47 on the other hand,
1:26:49 there isn't a singularity amongst First Nations people.
1:26:51 There's a whole diversity of ways,
1:26:53 ways of dealing with this,
1:26:55 uh,
1:26:55 uh,
1:26:56 long and unhappy history of,
1:26:58 of the beneficence of one group trying,
1:27:00 you know,
1:27:00 believing it knows how to fix the problems of another group.
1:27:04 And so you have these big discussions around one word,
1:27:08 neglect.
1:27:08 What does it mean to be neglectful of your children?
1:27:11 What does that mean in law?
1:27:12 What does that mean in English?
1:27:13 What does it mean in French?
1:27:14 What does it mean in dozens of other different First Nations languages?
1:27:18 Who's actually gonna prosecute that?
1:27:20 Who's gonna decide
1:27:21 in
1:27:22 middle of February in Saskatchewan that actually a line has been crossed here,
1:27:27 neglect has occurred.
1:27:28 I'm now gonna take your children away from you,
1:27:30 make you a ward of the state.
1:27:32 Great speech from the dean of the School
1:27:34 of Social Work in the University of Montreal.
1:27:36 OK,
1:27:36 what,
1:27:36 but what am I gonna teach my,
1:27:38 my graduate students in social work to do
1:27:41 when they are at the front lines of trying to mediate that,
1:27:44 for which there wasn't an,
1:27:45 of course,
1:27:45 there's no answer,
1:27:46 there's no rigor you can bring to that.
1:27:47 All you can do is get
1:27:49 good people in a room who know how to have a hard conversation
1:27:52 for hours,
1:27:53 for weeks,
1:27:54 for months,
1:27:54 if that's what it takes to get a good answer out of that.
1:27:57 Huge stakes.
1:27:59 And the moving part of it was saying wow,
1:28:00 these people have been doing this on the
1:28:03 advocacy side,
1:28:04 right,
1:28:04 well my my third point from before,
1:28:06 they knew how to advocate for this,
1:28:08 they knew to campaign for it,
1:28:09 and voila,
1:28:10 they actually succeeded.
1:28:11 Now
1:28:12 they're in a different space,
1:28:13 now they've gotta manage this money,
1:28:14 they've gotta figure out all these messy
1:28:16 details about how they're gonna reconcile,
1:28:18 integrate really different imperatives and incentives.
1:28:22 To make this work,
1:28:23 that's the room we with the bank should be much more
1:28:26 comfortable at at creating and participating if that's our job,
1:28:30 but I think we're really crude and really clumsy you know we,
1:28:32 we,
1:28:33 we,
1:28:33 we,
1:28:33 we uh haven't got the patience,
1:28:35 we haven't got the social skills and the
1:28:38 time invested in the space you need to be in to have that kind of conversation.
1:28:43 Thanks,
1:28:43 Michael.
1:28:44 On that note,
1:28:44 let's wrap up.
1:28:45 Thank you,
1:28:45 Michelle,
1:28:46 so much for coming and speaking to us.
1:28:50 Thank you.
1:28:51 Thanks everyone.
1:28:53 Do you have an extra copy of the book?
1:28:57 Uh,
1:28:58 no,
1:28:58 no,
1:28:58 so,
1:28:58 uh,
1:28:59 but,
1:28:59 but,
1:28:59 but,
1:29:00 but,
1:29:00 but Michael does have a copy and I have a copy at home,
1:29:02 but,
1:29:02 uh,
1:29:04 but it's available everywhere,
1:29:06 of course.
1:29:06 Thank you,
1:29:07 thank you.
1:29:14 I'm gonna have coffee.
- add-style
- lp-body-content
On October 24, 2023, Michèle Lamont (Professor, Harvard University) presented her new book Seeing Others: How Recognition Works and How it Can Heal a Divided World at an event at the World Bank in Washington, DC.
From the Publisher's Website
"In this capstone work, Michèle Lamont unpacks the power of recognition—rendering others as visible and valued—by drawing on nearly forty years of research and new interviews with young adults, and with cultural icons and change agents who intentionally practice recognition—from Nikole Hannah Jones and Cornel West to Michael Schur and Roxane Gay. She shows how new narratives are essential for everyone to feel respect and assert their dignity."