00:02 Hi everyone,
00:03 just er if I could ask everyone to mute your mics please,
00:07 when you're not speaking,
00:08 that would be great so that we can all
00:11 hear each other.
00:13 Uh,
00:14 welcome
00:15 everyone
00:16 to our webinar on Including Women in Financial cooperatives,
00:21 Uphill Battle or Good Business.
00:25 Uh,
00:25 please everyone mute your mic,
00:28 um,
00:28 and I will start my video,
00:30 um.
00:32 Yeah,
00:32 so my name is Rachel Sparrow Kessler,
00:34 and I work at the World Bank.
00:37 Um,
00:37 focusing on agriculture finance,
00:40 rural finance,
00:41 and financial cooperatives,
00:42 and very happy to be
00:44 with you today.
00:44 Over to you,
00:45 Ruby.
00:47 Thank you,
00:47 Rachel.
00:48 Also welcome from my side.
00:49 My name is Ruby Garcia Kumaran,
00:52 and I work for Rabo Partnerships with the,
00:54 which is a department of the Rabobank,
00:57 focusing on financial inclusion,
00:59 private sector development,
01:00 and food security.
01:02 And I mainly focus on
01:04 uh cooperative development,
01:06 and I'm very glad and honored to be part of this webinar today,
01:09 and I look forward to the insights that it's gonna bring us.
01:14 Perfect.
01:15 So,
01:16 this webinar is organized as part of the partnership between
01:21 the World Bank,
01:22 Rabo Partnerships,
01:23 and Rabo Foundation to strengthen financial cooperatives around the world.
01:29 Um,
01:30 in this,
01:30 uh,
01:31 partnership,
01:31 we have,
01:32 um,
01:32 two components.
01:33 One is the Country program,
01:36 operational projects,
01:37 and
01:38 another component is the knowledge work through our
01:41 Center of Excellence.
01:42 And I think Ruby just,
01:43 uh,
01:43 shared the,
01:45 the link to our website.
01:47 And this Center of Excellence is focused on
01:49 disseminating knowledge on financial cooperatives.
01:53 So we're organizing this webinar
01:55 today on including women in Financial cooperatives,
01:59 an uphill Battle for Good Business.
02:01 This is a very special webinar.
02:04 Uh,
02:05 before I introduce the topic,
02:06 a few housekeeping issues.
02:08 One,
02:09 please meet your,
02:09 uh,
02:10 mics when you're not speaking.
02:11 Second,
02:11 this meeting is recorded,
02:13 so,
02:13 um,
02:14 so that it can be shared with other people after the awards,
02:17 but,
02:17 uh,
02:18 let's keep an informal tone even though it's recorded.
02:21 Uh,
02:21 so it's a very special webinar.
02:23 Uh,
02:24 because it's a special topic,
02:26 uh,
02:27 but also because we have a special format for it.
02:29 So the topic itself,
02:31 I think,
02:31 is very special.
02:33 Um,
02:35 our Center of Excellence has focused on a variety of topics over the past,
02:39 uh,
02:40 years
02:41 on deposit insurance,
02:43 on digitization,
02:44 on the impact of COVID,
02:46 and a range of transversal
02:48 topics.
02:50 The first time we talk about gender and gender
02:53 has become a priority
02:55 uh within the financial inclusion community,
02:57 and,
02:58 uh,
02:58 Greta Boll,
02:59 who is the CEO of CGAP,
03:00 recently said,
03:01 we have to put a gender lens on everything we do.
03:05 So,
03:06 this is a crucial topic for financial inclusion and it's the first time
03:11 we explore
03:12 the specific role of financial cooperatives
03:15 to close the gender gap in financial
03:19 inclusion.
03:20 What's
03:21 the role of financial cooperatives?
03:22 Do they really serve women?
03:24 Do they really include women?
03:26 Can they really play a role in closing the gender gap?
03:29 Let's discuss this today.
03:30 So that's
03:31 our special topic.
03:33 It's also a special format because,
03:35 um,
03:36 for this webinar,
03:37 because this is not a starting point discussion.
03:40 This is actually more of a midpoint discussion.
03:43 We've actually worked on a draft paper
03:46 on this topic,
03:47 together,
03:48 World Bank and Rabo Foundation,
03:50 and we,
03:51 uh,
03:51 we shared this,
03:52 uh,
03:53 paper.
03:53 I think Ruby just shared the link,
03:55 uh,
03:55 in the chat panel.
03:56 Uh,
03:57 and so this,
03:58 the goal of this webinar is to share some insights from this draft paper.
04:03 And also to get some feedback from our panelists,
04:06 but also from the audience.
04:08 So please,
04:09 everyone,
04:09 feel free to
04:10 put in the chat panel any question,
04:12 any comments you may have on this paper,
04:15 or also,
04:15 after our webinar,
04:16 please feel free to share your thoughts
04:18 by writing us uh on this uh email address CFI gender feedback@gmail.com,
04:24 which is also in the chat panel now.
04:26 So,
04:27 Special format and also final thing,
04:30 because we wanna hear from you,
04:32 this is not gonna be the typical webinar where we have
04:34 a 1 hour discussion and then a 5 minute Q&A.
04:38 No,
04:38 we have organized the webinar in 3 themes,
04:40 and at the end of each theme,
04:43 we will have a Q&A.
04:45 So now that we know that it's a special topic in a special format,
04:48 let me turn
04:50 to our very special panelists,
04:53 and we have uh two distinguished speakers for opening remarks.
04:58 Um,
04:59 we will have uh Daya Belchica and then,
05:03 uh,
05:03 uh,
05:04 Lena.
05:04 Koummopoulos,
05:05 um,
05:06 and Daya is the lead technical,
05:09 uh,
05:10 specialist on gender targeting and social inclusion at IFAD,
05:15 which is the International Fund for Agricultural Development,
05:18 the international institution focused on
05:21 rural economy transformation.
05:24 And,
05:25 um,
05:26 and then we will hear from Lena Giacomopoulos,
05:29 and she is the program director of
05:32 uh the Global Women's Leadership Network at WOCCU,
05:36 uh,
05:37 the World Council of Credit Unions.
05:39 So we'll first hear from Daya about general
05:42 thoughts on why it's important to
05:44 include women and to
05:47 Uh,
05:47 to why it's important to close the gender
05:49 gap in rural development and rural finance,
05:51 and then we'll focus on financial cooperatives and
05:53 why it's important to close the gender gap in
05:56 financial cooperatives.
05:57 So,
05:57 um,
05:59 let's start with,
05:59 uh,
06:00 Nya.
06:00 Uh,
06:01 I,
06:02 can you turn on your camera?
06:05 Hello,
06:05 Ndaya.
06:07 Yes,
06:07 my camera is on.
06:08 Can you see it?
06:09 Perfect.
06:10 OK,
06:10 how are you?
06:12 I'm fine,
06:12 thank you.
06:12 How are you?
06:14 Good,
06:14 thank you so much for,
06:15 for being here.
06:17 Uh,
06:17 so tell us,
06:18 Daya,
06:20 uh,
06:21 IFA has a strong priority on gender,
06:24 why is that?
06:25 And can you share with us,
06:27 um,
06:28 what you're doing in that space?
06:30 Sure.
06:31 Um,
06:31 thank you so much,
06:32 uh,
06:32 Rachel.
06:33 Thank you.
06:33 Good morning,
06:34 everyone.
06:34 Good afternoon.
06:36 So,
06:36 it's a pleasure to be here.
06:37 Um,
06:38 so let me briefly introduce IFAD to you for
06:41 those who are not familiar with my institution.
06:44 So,
06:44 IFAD,
06:45 uh,
06:45 is both a UN agency and international financial institution with a mandate
06:50 to invest to empower the rural women and men to lead their own development.
06:56 So we are still finishing the 2020 report.
06:59 So let just me share some few numbers,
07:02 2019 numbers with you.
07:04 So we had uh 200,
07:06 about 200 ongoing projects
07:08 with an outreach of 131 million,
07:11 roughly 50% of women,
07:14 and EA financing amount to 7.5 billion,
07:19 with about 9.2 billion of domestic and international co-financing.
07:24 That's what the numbers.
07:25 So,
07:26 IFAD's mandate strongly rests on the principle of gender equality,
07:32 primarily because it is the right thing to do.
07:35 And secondly,
07:36 as Rachel mentioned,
07:37 it is also,
07:37 it makes perfect
07:38 business sense.
07:40 Over the past decades,
07:42 IFAD made the commitment to look at all its investments
07:46 through the lens
07:48 of gender
07:49 and to mainstream gender it's,
07:52 in its portfolio.
07:54 So learning from evidence and experience in the field,
07:57 it has evolved from mainstreaming gender in its portfolio to now
08:02 adopt what we call gender transformative approaches
08:06 which identify
08:08 the root causes of gender inequality of women disempowerment.
08:13 In that trajectory,
08:14 so IFAD is promoting gender equality and women's empowerment at
08:18 one of these commitments and continues to learn and improve
08:22 as we continue to develop and implement the project.
08:26 So let me share with you one example of a recently concluded
08:30 Desashwini project.
08:32 It's a rural women empowerment project in India.
08:36 The project transformed the lives of thousands of poor women
08:40 in the low-income state of Madhya Pradesh in central India.
08:45 Women from over 24,000 240,000 rural households
08:50 targeted by the program took steps to change their
08:53 lives by being enrolled in 18,000 self-help groups.
08:58 Those self-help groups were a conduit for women to do a number of things.
09:03 They were able to acquire awareness on how to use kitchen gardens to save money
09:09 and substantially improve the nutritional status of the households.
09:13 They increased income.
09:15 Through some self-reflection and community support,
09:18 they empowered themselves to devise a
09:21 solution
09:21 to their own problems.
09:23 And they also organize themselves for collective actions
09:27 at different levels,
09:29 at the village level but also at the federal level.
09:33 Key to this approach used by the program were the self-help groups,
09:37 which gave women the power to make decisions and for many,
09:42 for the first time in their lives to actually gain control over their lives,
09:46 make decisions for themselves
09:48 and for their loved ones within the households.
09:52 The groups also facilitated savings and credit
09:56 and enabled women to resolve common situations
10:00 such as gender-based violence,
10:02 premature marriages,
10:04 and cases of suspected future trafficking
10:07 through what is called the Courage Brigades.
10:10 The Kurdish Brigades,
10:11 which stem from self-help groups have been so successful
10:16 that they've been replicated by the government across
10:19 all the districts in the Maya Pradesh.
10:23 Let's talk about scaling up.
10:26 A very good example just has to show how powerful this can be.
10:30 I just want to share with you briefly the story of Rega
10:35 Pradham,
10:36 who at age 34 is an inspiring example of what can be achieved
10:40 through projects that aim not only to improve the livelihoods,
10:44 income,
10:44 and nutrition,
10:45 but also to seek to increase women's empowerment.
10:50 Rika was born in a poor family,
10:52 and she joined the Self-help groups in 2008.
10:57 A few years later,
10:58 she then represented her village and
11:01 the village as well as the community at the federal level,
11:05 and 10 years later,
11:07 she ended up representing the project
11:10 at the 2017 Commission on the Status of Women in New York
11:14 while she had never traveled before.
11:17 Bringing now to the lens of rural finance,
11:20 we can see that even through that project,
11:22 finance was also an important instrument.
11:25 What we've recently done at IFAD,
11:27 we conducted a synthesis evaluation to understand
11:31 what would work
11:32 and then what can be improved in the case of rural finance.
11:36 What we were able to see
11:38 was that there were
11:40 significant gender results
11:42 when we look at the financial
11:44 institutions that were community-based financial organizations.
11:48 While when we look at the commercial banks,
11:50 credit union,
11:51 and other credit cooperatives,
11:53 the gender performance was not so strong.
11:57 One of the reasons that some of
11:59 the community-based financial organizations were relatively successful
12:03 is because they did a number of things.
12:06 One is that they were based on
12:13 One
12:14 is that they were based primarily on focusing
12:17 on the institutions that were targeting women.
12:20 They also offered very small loan size,
12:24 so in a sense they were self-targeting
12:27 women,
12:27 given that many of the women were involved in the informal economy.
12:32 And also they were linking the financial services with some empowerment,
12:37 which enabled the women to feel a lot more
12:40 confident into taking on new services and new activities.
12:45 Looking at the rural financial services,
12:47 we can see there are two sides to look at it if
12:49 we want to strengthen and provide better services to rural women.
12:53 They are on the demand side as well on the supply side.
12:57 On the demand side,
12:58 and I will be very brief,
13:00 I would just touch on
13:01 the fact that income and access to collateral,
13:04 as well as some constraint with some procedures.
13:08 Prevent women from having a broad access to financial services.
13:12 Typically women are involved
13:13 in the informal economy.
13:15 They do not have access to land,
13:17 which is one of the primary collateral,
13:19 and therefore when we do not provide those services,
13:22 it is unlikely that they would benefit from
13:24 loans or even for other services.
13:27 Another
13:29 issue on the demand side is the
13:32 lack of education or the lack of financial literacy,
13:35 as well as the lack of access to information,
13:38 because this one,
13:38 when we look at the education,
13:40 it is in fact a gateway
13:42 to access technology and information.
13:45 And if there is a lack of education,
13:46 then the illiteracy related to finance
13:49 would also enable,
13:51 prevent the women to have or to develop self-confidence
13:54 in order to access a different type of services.
13:57 On the supply side,
13:59 there are a number of things that we can
14:01 address or to look at.
14:02 One is that
14:04 very rarely are the staff trained into providing the relevant services to women.
14:09 And most of them are men.
14:11 Within those institutions.
14:12 Also,
14:13 women are not
14:14 represented.
14:16 So therefore,
14:16 when it comes time to develop the relevant financial services,
14:20 they are not giving a voice to develop the services that
14:23 they might need for home care or then for their businesses,
14:28 and this could be explained by a number of things.
14:31 And equally important,
14:32 many of those institutions do not have.
14:35 They don't necessarily
14:36 consider gender as a priority,
14:38 and very few of them would have gender
14:40 in the vision or in the mission statements or would
14:43 actually even have indicators that would track gender per se.
14:48 So we see that there are a number of inadequate service,
14:51 um,
14:51 and
14:52 Uh,
14:53 products.
14:53 I know that now you're gonna be discussing the good practices
14:57 as well as
14:58 focusing on innovation and tailored approaches,
15:01 and as such,
15:01 I will turn this over to the next speaker.
15:03 Thank you very much.
15:05 Thank you so much,
15:06 Ninaya.
15:06 That was a great opening statement.
15:08 Over to you,
15:09 um,
15:11 over to you,
15:12 uh,
15:12 Lena,
15:13 um,
15:14 what,
15:14 uh,
15:15 what's happening at WC?
15:17 Why do you focus especially on gender and what do you do
15:21 at the Global Women's Leadership Network to close the gender gap?
15:31 Thank you,
15:31 Rachel,
15:32 and,
15:32 and if I may ask you to uh speak in
15:35 less than 5 minutes,
15:36 that would be great.
15:36 Thank you.
15:38 Thank you.
15:39 Uh,
15:39 good morning,
15:40 good afternoon,
15:40 and good evening,
15:41 I should say,
15:42 everyone.
15:42 Uh,
15:42 thank you for having me join you today.
15:45 I'm really excited to be here.
15:47 And,
15:47 you know,
15:48 listening to the previous speaker,
15:49 and,
15:50 uh,
15:50 uh,
15:51 first,
15:51 let me give everyone a little,
15:52 uh,
15:53 background to GWL and,
15:55 um,
15:56 an,
15:56 an initiative that began by the World Council actually in 2009.
16:00 And it was initiated by
16:02 Women working in,
16:03 uh,
16:04 cooperatives in financial,
16:05 in credit unions in South America.
16:08 And they asked if we had a place
16:10 where women could get together,
16:12 could
16:12 join each other,
16:13 and actually support one another
16:15 and talk about
16:17 their advancement of their development in the credit union space.
16:20 And that's literally how the program came to be.
16:23 And as we fast forward to where we are today.
16:27 For the world,
16:28 uh,
16:28 for Global Women's Leadership Network.
16:31 Uh,
16:31 the program has engaged more than 4500 women and men,
16:34 uh,
16:35 in 86 countries to date,
16:37 um,
16:38 since its inception.
16:39 So,
16:39 it's very exciting to see.
16:40 And
16:41 I have to,
16:42 to,
16:42 to stress that
16:44 the work that we do is working together with women
16:46 and men.
16:47 OK?
16:47 We have to engage our male counterparts.
16:49 This isn't about,
16:51 uh,
16:51 um,
16:52 solely a woman.
16:53 Issue or a man issue.
16:54 This is a workplace issue and if we want to be able
16:57 to continue making it be good business
17:00 and actually better business for our organizations,
17:03 we need to focus on working together with our colleagues.
17:06 That's,
17:06 that's the one big thing that we stress,
17:08 uh,
17:09 through GWLN.
17:10 Now,
17:10 on,
17:11 on a more localized and individualized level,
17:13 I should say,
17:14 how we function for GWLN and how we work together
17:18 is through a mechanism we call.
17:19 All our sister societies,
17:21 which are,
17:22 it is the way that credit union women,
17:24 uh,
17:24 leaders,
17:25 CEOs,
17:26 board members,
17:27 and industry partners
17:28 in various parts of the world get together at a more localized level
17:32 and are able to
17:34 discuss the topics that are affecting
17:36 their credit union,
17:37 how they can function better as businesses.
17:39 Look at strategies and ways that they can increase
17:42 and get more women on their boards,
17:44 more women in leadership.
17:45 Roles
17:46 and look at other issues that on a more
17:48 personal level are going to be able to empower women
17:51 to do what they do every day in their lives.
17:54 And um presently we have about 145 of these
17:57 sister societies in nearly 30 countries through GWLN.
18:01 So there,
18:02 there are a lot of ways
18:03 that all of this comes together.
18:05 I think it's important for us to see
18:07 in different parts of the world what we're doing,
18:09 you know,
18:09 in Asia,
18:10 it is about giving.
18:11 Women access to,
18:12 to,
18:12 to capital and giving them a loans so they can
18:16 conduct their businesses,
18:17 entrepreneurs,
18:18 and,
18:18 and startups.
18:19 In Africa,
18:20 it is about
18:21 showing
18:22 the younger generation of women
18:23 that they can have that seat at the table,
18:25 that there are
18:26 women who are on boards,
18:28 and that the diversity,
18:29 equity and inclusion is an important part
18:32 of,
18:32 of their credit unions.
18:33 In,
18:34 in South America,
18:35 they talk about cultural bias and seeing.
18:38 How
18:38 they're,
18:39 they're,
18:39 they're dealing with it in their part of the world.
18:41 So,
18:41 there are different types
18:43 of approaches,
18:44 I,
18:44 I would say in,
18:45 in our different parts of the world.
18:47 There isn't a one answer and uh one
18:50 tool all across the board,
18:52 but it's important for us to continue focusing
18:55 on the impact that our network is making.
18:57 And that's what it is.
18:58 It,
18:58 it is a network,
18:59 and we learn from one another.
19:01 And many times when we have these sister society meetings,
19:04 one of the first questions that comes up is,
19:06 Look at the board,
19:07 look at your board,
19:08 look at your credit union board,
19:09 or look at the leadership team in your credit union,
19:12 in your financial cooperative.
19:13 How many women do you have on that board?
19:15 OK.
19:16 And um
19:17 if you think you don't have a seat at that table at that board,
19:20 you're wrong,
19:21 and you need another woman or another man to pull
19:23 that seat up for you and have you join in.
19:26 So,
19:26 it is about empowering women,
19:28 but it's about creating allies,
19:30 finding the strength in the network,
19:32 and working together.
19:33 Because,
19:34 you know,
19:35 pre-COVID,
19:35 we,
19:36 we've seen the data,
19:36 you know,
19:37 the World Economic Forum told us that we needed 99.5 years to close the gender gap.
19:42 And now,
19:42 we're at 137 years.
19:44 So,
19:44 that's an entire generation.
19:46 That the COVID the pandemic has pushed us back.
19:49 And that makes us want to continue doing what we're doing
19:52 and,
19:52 and realize how important it is of the work that we're doing for future generations,
19:57 not just for our,
19:57 our,
19:58 our work today.
19:59 So,
19:59 yes,
19:59 it is good business,
20:00 and I say we need to continue doing uh uh
20:03 what we're doing to make it even better business.
20:06 Thank you,
20:06 Rachel.
20:09 Fantastic.
20:10 Thank you so much,
20:11 Lena.
20:11 And if I hear you correctly,
20:13 you're saying that one size doesn't fit all and there's
20:15 not one model of inclusion of women in financial cooperatives,
20:19 and I think this is something we'll discuss with panelists uh today.
20:23 Before we do that,
20:24 uh,
20:24 I'd like to share with you a few insights,
20:27 um,
20:28 From our draft paper and uh Lena and Daya you're welcome to stay
20:33 and ask any questions and comments in the chat panel.
20:37 So here are a few insights from our uh
20:40 paper,
20:42 from our draft paper.
20:43 You,
20:43 you see my screen,
20:44 right?
20:47 Perfect.
20:48 So,
20:49 when we started uh researching this topic
20:52 of inclusion of women in financial cooperatives,
20:55 our first thought was,
20:57 please,
20:58 uh,
20:58 everyone,
20:58 you could mute yourself,
20:59 that would be great.
21:01 Our first thought was,
21:03 what is the share of women in,
21:07 let me just,
21:08 uh,
21:08 mute that person,
21:10 uh.
21:11 I
21:13 have one person who is
21:14 uh or Jaya you could do it
21:19 uh isn't this if Jaya you could uh mute that person that would be great.
21:23 Um,
21:24 so,
21:25 um,
21:26 when we started researching this topic,
21:28 uh,
21:28 our first thought was,
21:29 let's look at the share,
21:31 oops,
21:33 I think we still have a little,
21:34 uh,
21:34 technical issue.
21:38 Joan,
21:39 uh.
21:40 OK,
21:41 good.
21:41 Thank you.
21:42 So,
21:43 again,
21:44 when we started researching this topic,
21:46 our first thought was,
21:47 let's look at the share of women in
21:50 the membership of credit unions,
21:51 and to do so,
21:53 we turned to Wu and we looked at Woku reports
21:56 that gather a lot of data
21:57 on credit unions
21:59 worldwide
22:00 and
22:01 We have data on assets and number of members and savings and credits,
22:06 but
22:07 we couldn't find
22:09 gender disaggregated data
22:11 on
22:13 membership,
22:14 so we thought that was an interesting finding in itself.
22:19 Give me a second
22:21 to try to find this.
22:26 Maybe
22:26 let's try headphones.
22:27 Maybe the sound.
22:28 Um,
22:30 and,
22:30 uh,
22:31 and so
22:32 we thought,
22:32 OK,
22:33 so then we don't have much data,
22:35 but,
22:35 uh,
22:36 walker shared with us some data on
22:38 the share of women
22:39 in
22:40 as board members and as seniors of credit unions,
22:43 and I think here the number that stands out is the 60%.
22:46 percent
22:47 of
22:48 CEOs
22:49 in Europe that are women,
22:51 but besides that number,
22:53 we see that
22:55 actually women account for a minority of
22:59 board members and CEOs
23:02 worldwide.
23:04 I'm
23:05 sorry,
23:05 I'm just trying to fix this
23:08 issue,
23:08 uh.
23:13 OK.
23:18 And um
23:19 so,
23:20 uh,
23:20 so yes,
23:21 besides that,
23:22 especially in developing countries,
23:25 uh,
23:25 the share of women among board members and CEOs is less than 30%.
23:29 So we didn't have much data on
23:31 women in membership of credit unions,
23:33 so we thought,
23:34 OK,
23:34 then let's just pick.
23:37 Specific
23:38 corporate um er financial cooperatives
23:41 and understand to which extent they serve and include
23:44 women and ask them how they do it,
23:47 how successful they are,
23:48 what are their challenges and opportunities they seek.
23:51 We wanted to select
23:53 financial cooperatives that had developed gender-sensitive
23:57 approaches for a long time.
23:58 We wanted to learn from them,
24:00 and that's why we selected 3,
24:02 based on
24:03 interviews with experts.
24:04 We selected Mandesi,
24:06 CIFF,
24:07 and FedInvest.
24:08 Mandeshi,
24:09 just to give you a snapshot of these 3 organizations,
24:12 and we have representatives from these 3 organizations today.
24:15 Mandeshi is in India,
24:16 has about 30,000 members,
24:18 $85 million
24:21 USD in assets,
24:22 and it's a women-only cooperative.
24:25 So men
24:26 can actually save at Mandeshi,
24:29 but they cannot get
24:30 credit.
24:31 They cannot become members.
24:33 CIF is the Confederation des Institutional Financier the DAR de West,
24:37 so it's
24:38 the Confederation of Financial Institutions in West Africa.
24:41 It covers
24:42 6
24:43 networks of um financial cooperatives in 5 countries Benin,
24:47 Togo,
24:48 Senegal,
24:48 Mali,
24:48 Burkina Faso.
24:50 It's
24:51 Uh,
24:51 it covers 4.5 million
24:53 members,
24:54 $1.5 billion USD in assets,
24:56 so much larger than Mandeshi,
24:59 and it's not
25:00 only focused on women,
25:01 it's an open cooperative or mixed cooperative,
25:04 but it offers specific products to women,
25:07 and it has developed what we call a group approach,
25:09 so mainly joint liability groups.
25:12 Finally,
25:13 Fed Invest
25:15 is the first microfinance institution in Albania,
25:19 covers 78,000 members,
25:22 about $60 million USD in assets,
25:24 and again,
25:25 it's open to anyone,
25:27 so men and women,
25:28 and it doesn't have specific products for
25:31 women.
25:32 So,
25:33 men and women have access to exactly the same products.
25:36 However,
25:37 uh,
25:37 Fed Invest has developed what they call the household approach,
25:40 and we'll hear about that.
25:42 For all of these three
25:44 organizations,
25:45 we started the conversation with them,
25:46 asking them the exact same question.
25:49 What's the share of,
25:50 uh,
25:50 women in your membership?
25:52 What's the share of women in your employees?
25:54 What's the share of women at the board?
25:57 For Mandesi,
25:58 by design,
25:59 they are a women-only cooperative,
26:00 so 100% of their members are women.
26:04 At SIF,
26:05 38% of their members are women.
26:07 At Fed Invest,
26:08 37% of members are women.
26:11 So we thought,
26:12 OK,
26:12 so what do these numbers mean?
26:15 Is 38% of members at CIFF a good number?
26:18 Does it mean they are inclusive?
26:19 We started debating on this
26:21 and on the interpretation of these numbers,
26:23 and what we did was
26:26 We decided to benchmark
26:28 these cooperative financial institutions to other
26:31 financial institutions in their country.
26:33 So we actually asked for CIF that focuses on
26:37 5 countries to give us country-level data membership,
26:40 and we used Findex data.
26:42 So Findex data about the share of women with account at a financial institution.
26:47 We converted that number into the share of women
26:50 account holders in total number of account numbers,
26:52 uh holders.
26:54 And we compare that number
26:56 to the share of women in selected CFI's membership.
27:00 And here is what we,
27:01 we,
27:01 we,
27:02 we got.
27:04 Some CFIs are less inclusive than other financial institutions
27:09 in terms of women inclusion.
27:12 We see at the top,
27:13 displayed in red,
27:14 India,
27:15 Senegal,
27:15 Benin.
27:16 These are the financial cooperatives that
27:20 include women in their membership more than other financial institutions,
27:24 but all the others
27:25 are less inclusive of women
27:27 than other financial institutions.
27:30 We were surprised by this
27:33 because
27:34 these networks are actually selected
27:36 based on the fact that they have developed gender
27:38 sensitive approaches and gender strategies for a long time.
27:42 So,
27:42 why is that?
27:43 Why do we have some financial cooperatives that are
27:46 less inclusive than other financial institutions of women?
27:49 And in our paper,
27:50 we have two types of factors that we suggest.
27:53 First
27:54 types of factors are
27:55 external factors.
27:57 So,
27:57 the fact that
27:59 finance
27:59 that financial cooperatives operate in rural areas where
28:03 perhaps there are stronger gender norms or where women have
28:07 more challenges in accessing
28:10 assets in
28:12 in financial education.
28:13 Perhaps this
28:14 is the reason why
28:16 we see these,
28:16 these gender gaps.
28:18 But we also think that there might be also
28:20 internal factors in the way financial cooperatives operate.
28:24 Perhaps it could be that
28:26 this inclusive,
28:27 I mean it could be that this
28:29 collective decision process
28:31 in financial cooperatives,
28:33 perhaps it
28:34 could be that it doesn't really work well for Some women in rural areas that are
28:39 mobility and time constraints.
28:40 So,
28:41 here are some initial thoughts,
28:43 and of course,
28:44 we want to highlight that some cooperatives are better
28:46 equipped than others to serve and include women.
28:50 So,
28:50 with that,
28:51 I would like to hand it over to Ruby to discuss this in more details.
28:56 Thank you.
28:57 Thank you,
28:57 Rachel,
28:58 and having summarized the main findings of our paper,
29:01 I think uh it is time to hear the insights on this from our distinguished panelists.
29:07 So it is my pleasure to introduce them to you.
29:10 Um,
29:11 on the panel,
29:11 we have
29:13 Chetna Sinha,
29:14 who is the founder and chairperson of the Mandeshi Bank and Mandeshi Foundation
29:19 in India.
29:20 We have Madieu,
29:21 Matthieu Suglonu,
29:23 who is the general director
29:25 of CIF,
29:26 and we have Albana Beta,
29:28 the head of the legal department of
29:31 uh Fed Invest in Albania.
29:33 So a very warm welcome to all of you and thank you very much for joining the panel.
29:39 Uh,
29:40 before I will give the word to you,
29:41 I would like to quickly explain the structure of today's webinar.
29:47 We will first focus on
29:49 the why and the how of including women in financial cooperatives,
29:53 followed by the potential of digitization to improve women's inclusion,
29:59 and lastly,
30:00 recommendations to cooperatives and governments.
30:03 And
30:05 as Rachel already said,
30:06 the chat box is
30:08 open for all participants,
30:10 so we would
30:11 still encourage you to actively use this in case of any.
30:15 Uh,
30:16 questions or comments arise,
30:18 and then,
30:18 uh,
30:19 Rachel and I will make sure to handle them at the right time.
30:24 So the 3 financial institutions we have selected
30:29 all have a
30:31 specific way to include women,
30:33 and they have all
30:34 developed a specific strategy over the years.
30:38 But as we saw in Rachel's introduction,
30:41 these three ways also differ from each other.
30:44 Uh,
30:45 Chetna,
30:45 I would like to start with you because at Mandeshi,
30:49 you have
30:50 the women-only model.
30:53 Can you explain to us why you chose for this model,
30:56 and does this also indicate that women alone represent a
31:00 sufficient business case for financial cooperatives to be profitable?
31:16 I see Chetna is in the
31:17 chats.
31:20 Are you
31:22 on mute,
31:22 Jenna?
31:39 Rachel,
31:40 maybe you can unmute the.
31:43 Chenna
31:44 Yeah,
31:45 uh,
31:47 it was locked centrally from your side.
31:50 Yeah.
31:51 So sorry for that,
31:52 and am I audible?
31:54 Yes,
31:56 yeah,
31:57 so,
31:57 uh,
31:58 thanks,
31:59 Rubi,
31:59 and I mean thanks Rubika and thanks Rachel
32:03 for inviting me to share my
32:05 experiences
32:06 and your question that why did I choose to do that.
32:11 Uh,
32:12 in fact,
32:12 very honestly,
32:14 It was not like
32:16 decided or chosen.
32:18 I,
32:19 I mean,
32:20 I was,
32:21 I never thought that I would start a women's bank,
32:23 Women's cooperative Bank.
32:25 Um,
32:26 that was.
32:27 It was just that
32:29 I was uh very young,
32:31 at a very young age.
32:32 I was,
32:32 when I was doing my undergraduate program,
32:35 I got into Gandhian organization
32:37 and I visited some villages which were drought affected.
32:41 And when I saw the life there,
32:43 then I decided that I'll be staying there and work there.
32:46 And I'm married to my husband who is a farmer from this village,
32:51 must work where I started the bank.
32:53 And when I was staying with my husband here,
32:56 some women came to me and they wanted to do savings.
33:00 And so I went with them to the banks.
33:03 To get their accounts open
33:06 because these one,
33:07 these women wanted to do savings.
33:09 One of them,
33:10 uh,
33:11 who you can see a film on YouTube also,
33:14 Tanta Bai,
33:14 who was a street vendor.
33:16 So,
33:16 but the banks denied opening the account of these women.
33:20 And why?
33:22 Because their savings were too small,
33:24 that is why.
33:25 In fact,
33:25 they were not even asking interest on that.
33:28 They were ready to pay a fee for their
33:30 savings administration.
33:33 In spite of that,
33:34 banks thought that they are not an affordable client.
33:38 So then when I saw that,
33:40 I felt that
33:41 if banks are not opening the account,
33:43 why not start a bank for
33:46 women,
33:46 those who are street vendors,
33:48 those who are so active
33:50 throughout their lives economically.
33:52 And they need the bank most because they want to save it
33:56 every day.
33:57 So then I went to Central Bank of India,
33:59 Reserve Bank of India,
34:00 that how can we start a bank
34:03 for women like Kamtabai,
34:04 and I was told that there is the only window where
34:07 you can start a women's bank is through a cooperative.
34:10 And so then we thought we'll apply for the banking license.
34:13 So it was like no
34:15 pre-planned or something,
34:17 but it was very clear
34:19 that our women wanted to do banking,
34:21 our women wanted to do savings,
34:23 and the big banks were not ready to do
34:26 because their businesses were too small for them.
34:29 And so then we thought,
34:31 why not,
34:31 and we applied for the banking license.
34:34 The journey was not very easy.
34:37 The license was rejected by the Central Bank of India.
34:41 And you know why?
34:42 Because
34:43 the our women did not have a signatures.
34:45 They had a thumb impression
34:47 because they couldn't read and write.
34:49 And the central bank said that we cannot issue a license to the bank
34:53 who's promoting members are.
34:56 I was devastated,
34:57 but women were very clear.
34:59 They said that we learn to read and write.
35:01 We applied again.
35:03 And at that time,
35:04 15 women accompanied me
35:06 and they challenged the officer.
35:08 They said we cannot read and write,
35:10 but we can count.
35:12 And they challenged the officers,
35:14 asking them
35:16 that ask us to calculate the interest of any principal amount.
35:20 If we fail,
35:21 don't issue the license,
35:23 but tell your officers to do it without a calculator
35:27 and see who can calculate faster.
35:30 Needless to say,
35:31 we've got the banking license.
35:32 It is the first rural women's bank in India,
35:35 and I'm so proud to share with you,
35:38 Ruby,
35:38 that,
35:39 you know,
35:39 when this,
35:40 when,
35:41 when women were coming forward,
35:43 everybody said that these women cannot read and write,
35:45 but today we are one of the largest rural women's bank in the.
35:49 Country
35:50 and the other banks which were cooperative banks which were started by like very
35:56 powerful people,
35:57 member of parliament and all.
35:58 Our bank is bigger than that,
36:01 that,
36:01 and not only that,
36:03 I am also so proud that
36:05 actually we have two types of membership.
36:08 One is that
36:10 membership of AGM,
36:12 an annual general meeting.
36:14 Where we have more than 37,000 women now,
36:17 but the other is that the general membership,
36:20 a general membership with the bank,
36:23 we have more than 600,000.
36:26 Now when I say that,
36:27 it's very interesting that as I said that
36:30 it wasn't that I chose to set up this bank.
36:33 Women chose to have the bank.
36:36 And you know when women decide
36:38 what happens.
36:39 So now we have a business school for rural women who have never been to the school.
36:43 We have schools at doorstep with the buses,
36:46 we have digital buses which go doorstep,
36:49 and we have radio which is operated by them.
36:53 And our,
36:54 our bank is managed by 100% women.
36:58 Most of us are nearly 94% of our employees are women.
37:03 But now for diversity,
37:04 because a lot of people are asking us now that why no men.
37:08 So we have some of the men
37:11 as a part of the diversity in our institution.
37:14 But having said all this,
37:16 I would just
37:17 like I've narrated the
37:19 thing that we are working
37:20 with now we have foundation also with the bank,
37:24 but
37:24 while operating with the bank,
37:26 what are the things which I learned from women?
37:29 Number 1,
37:30 you cannot read and write,
37:32 but you can count and manage the finance.
37:35 Number 2,
37:36 that
37:38 even with the small businesses,
37:39 you all are.
37:40 Your
37:42 cooperative bank
37:43 can be profitable and sustainable.
37:46 It may not have a huge balance sheet,
37:49 but it,
37:50 and then so we are very proud that some banks were bigger than us,
37:54 but today they are not,
37:55 they don't even exist.
37:57 But our bank has been sustained and for the last
38:00 15 years,
38:02 our women are getting dividends.
38:04 And it is the first rural Women's Bank
38:07 where the bank was able to give dividend to its member.
38:10 So with this,
38:11 I would just like to share with you that,
38:14 you know,
38:14 these are the lessons I have learned from our women
38:17 and one of the biggest lessons I've learned from them is
38:21 that understand the cash flow.
38:22 Listen to women,
38:23 design the product according to their needs.
38:26 These are very,
38:27 very important
38:28 things.
38:29 And so
38:30 we do not really have cash credit for street vendors.
38:34 And when I was going to Taos to co-chair World Forum,
38:38 I asked our women,
38:39 you know.
38:40 So many people come and cars
38:43 where we talk about billions and trillions.
38:46 What should I speak to them?
38:47 What should I tell them?
38:48 You know what our women said?
38:50 They said,
38:51 go and tell them
38:53 that our courage is.
38:55 And the second thing they said,
38:56 which always
38:58 equals me,
38:59 and that is that
39:01 never give poor solutions to poor people,
39:04 and that is possible when women lead the
39:07 organization.
39:09 So thank you so much.
39:12 Always very
39:13 inspiring to hear Mandeshi stories and thank you very much.
39:17 Good to hear that
39:19 currently women do represent a good business case for Mandeshi.
39:23 Uh,
39:24 I would like to go over to Matthieu.
39:27 Matthieu,
39:27 are you
39:28 in the call and available to answer a question?
39:41 Yes,
39:41 uh,
39:42 Ruby and Rachel,
39:43 I do.
39:45 I am the,
39:46 can you hear me?
39:47 Yes,
39:48 great.
39:48 Hi.
39:50 Thank you for joining.
39:52 Uh,
39:53 I was wondering because,
39:54 uh,
39:55 at Mondeshi,
39:55 they have the women-only model,
39:57 and at SIF you have applied a different approach,
39:59 namely the group approach.
40:01 And why do you think at SIF it is important to include women and what do you,
40:05 have you done specifically to do so?
40:10 Thank you.
40:12 Thank you for giving me the opportunity to tell
40:14 about what SIF is doing in West Africa.
40:18 To
40:19 include
40:20 Women financially and to cover the gender gap
40:23 at this level.
40:26 Why it's important for us to employ women,
40:29 you know,
40:29 in West Africa specifically,
40:32 there is like some division of labor
40:35 between women and men
40:37 when it's come
40:39 to administrate the households.
40:42 While
40:42 the man is focused on the big investments like
40:47 the,
40:47 the house,
40:48 or the
40:50 assets,
40:51 the big assets
40:53 of the family.
40:54 Women is more focused on day to day.
40:58 Resources to cover
41:01 Needs such as foods,
41:04 such as
41:05 uh scholarship for,
41:07 for,
41:07 for young people,
41:09 for,
41:09 for,
41:09 for their children,
41:11 etc.
41:13 Uh,
41:13 and also women in West Africa.
41:17 Uh,
41:19 appear like
41:20 the
41:21 Very suck
41:23 of the developments at the local level.
41:27 When women
41:30 have resources.
41:32 In West Africa,
41:33 particularly.
41:34 They're more focused on
41:36 the
41:38 behavior,
41:38 to improve the behavior of the family.
41:41 I'm sorry,
41:42 I'm a man,
41:43 but women are more focused on how to improve the health of family
41:47 than uh men in West Africa.
41:49 And uh also the women
41:52 is respecting their commitment when it's come
41:55 to pay back the credits.
41:57 So,
41:58 why we chose
42:00 to provide.
42:02 Some financial services
42:04 to women in West Africa.
42:07 How we,
42:07 we,
42:07 we proceed.
42:09 We proceeds by a group approach.
42:13 Uh,
42:14 specifically by using what,
42:16 what,
42:16 what we call,
42:19 uh,
42:19 to plan iffier,
42:20 it's something
42:22 to,
42:23 uh,
42:24 allow women.
42:25 To provide
42:27 every day.
42:29 Some resources in terms of uh saving
42:32 every day and to be able to raise the money
42:37 at the end of the month.
42:39 With the institution.
42:41 And,
42:41 and we create a group.
42:44 Uh,
42:45 and in each group,
42:47 the group of 30.
42:49 50
42:51 independent
42:52 women.
42:53 Who
42:55 Every day
42:57 A deposits.
43:00 To be able to raise
43:03 The money at the end of the month or to get credits.
43:09 The experience we,
43:09 we,
43:10 we did with uh Benin physical in Benin.
43:14 Right now,
43:14 we have uh uh we have 60,000
43:18 women.
43:20 We collects.
43:24 40 million
43:26 Yes
43:28 I still
43:29 Uh
43:30 yeah.
43:32 It means that
43:33 women have capacity to save.
43:37 And also we provide them
43:39 credits
43:40 to develop their business.
43:43 In
43:44 Burkina Faso,
43:46 we developed some specific products with uh FCPB.
43:52 Much
43:53 Financial services with
43:55 financial literacy.
43:58 And also we
44:00 Reproductive
44:02 and sexual.
44:05 sensitization to
44:06 to empower women.
44:08 To make the choice.
44:11 Decides
44:12 whether they could
44:15 do the term.
44:17 For children
44:18 or to use
44:19 the term for the business
44:21 that they negotiate this term.
44:23 In the family with the husband.
44:31 We learn
44:34 is that
44:36 when we combine.
44:38 A financial product with financial literacy.
44:43 And sexual reposition.
44:46 Education.
44:47 We get more results of women.
44:51 And where
44:53 We
44:54 provide only
44:55 the financial services.
44:59 What we learn is also
45:01 that we need
45:03 to
45:05 Identify
45:07 The value
45:10 value chain where women is more focused.
45:14 And develop specific products.
45:16 To target the needs of women.
45:19 In this
45:21 value chain.
45:23 What we learned also is that sometimes
45:27 The lack of
45:29 Having the ID cards.
45:31 Lack of access to lands.
45:35 Oh,
45:36 the
45:37 lack
45:38 of access
45:39 to
45:40 education.
45:42 Sometime
45:45 Appear as a barrier
45:47 for women
45:48 to access financial services.
45:52 We also learned that when women
45:55 walk.
45:57 And assess responsibility in
45:59 financial cooperative.
46:02 Local level.
46:04 Some of them were able.
46:07 To become
46:08 a political leader.
46:10 In their
46:11 community,
46:12 in their region,
46:13 or at national level.
46:16 And be,
46:16 and to be elected like parliamentary
46:20 mayor,
46:21 and so on.
46:23 Why we
46:24 commit ourselves to continue to increase.
46:28 With access to financial services within its network.
46:33 Thank you.
46:34 Thank you so much.
46:36 It's very interesting to hear that uh by developing specific products,
46:40 it has managed to reach women.
46:43 And as we heard in the introduction,
46:45 it's not one size fits all.
46:47 So
46:48 it's really interesting to see that in different countries,
46:50 you have also uh developed different products.
46:55 Albana at Fan Invest,
46:58 you have a long history of focusing on women inclusion,
47:02 and one of the tools through which you do this
47:04 is the household approach or the co-signing of spouses.
47:08 Can you elaborate a bit more on this and why you think it is so important to use this
47:13 in including women in Fed Invest?
47:16 Uh yes.
47:18 Uh,
47:18 hello,
47:19 everyone.
47:19 Uh my name is Albana.
47:21 Uh,
47:21 I represent here,
47:23 uh,
47:23 FedInvest,
47:24 uh,
47:24 which is the,
47:25 the,
47:26 uh,
47:28 microfinance institution established in 1992 in Albania.
47:33 Uh,
47:33 so it's,
47:34 uh,
47:35 I can proudly say the oldest one operating in Albania.
47:39 Uh,
47:39 we count now,
47:40 uh,
47:40 63 branches.
47:42 Uh,
47:42 we operate in almost
47:44 Uh,
47:44 2000 small villages and uh
47:48 we have uh nearly 78,000 members.
47:52 We are focused in the rural areas and uh we serve to different clients,
47:57 uh,
47:58 from them who are excluded from the financial services and banking services
48:03 to them who might need uh an SME.
48:06 Uh,
48:07 we are a cooperative governance,
48:09 uh,
48:11 so we are a mixed structure,
48:12 uh,
48:13 made from the administrative staff and also elected people,
48:17 um.
48:20 In Fed Invest,
48:21 we believe that uh women and men,
48:23 same in the same boat,
48:24 so,
48:24 uh,
48:25 we are not here to,
48:26 to differentiate uh women from men,
48:30 uh,
48:30 or vice versa.
48:32 Uh,
48:32 important for us is,
48:33 uh,
48:34 not to exclude women from the financial services and products.
48:39 So
48:39 we offer the same services,
48:41 the same products,
48:42 the same trainings for women and men,
48:44 but,
48:45 uh,
48:45 what we see is the difference in the product usage because
48:50 Uh,
48:50 of the type of the product and uh how they are involved,
48:55 um.
48:56 From our practice,
48:57 we understood and we learned that uh
49:00 uh women tend to work more uh in tailor shop or uh as a hairdresser,
49:07 um,
49:08 in agritourism and uh also in the family farm together with their husbands.
49:14 um.
49:16 We know also uh from our practice that um because
49:21 uh we offer not only credit but also deposit products
49:24 and we know that uh women uh
49:27 know uh better than men
49:29 uh how to save
49:31 um.
49:33 I believe this is because they feel less comfortable
49:36 with borrowing beyond their needs or to to put
49:40 the family finance in over indebtedness,
49:44 so for them it's important to take smaller loans,
49:47 but they are responsible because they have,
49:50 they have better repayment loans
49:54 regarding the contract,
49:55 the credit contract,
49:57 we co-signed the contract both from the husband and the wife.
50:01 Uh,
50:02 so we
50:04 make this not only to empower women but also to let them know about the loan,
50:09 the,
50:09 the conditions of the loan,
50:11 how to repay this
50:12 and things like this.
50:14 So,
50:15 um,
50:16 this is our way to ensure that the household does not borrow beyond its needs,
50:20 uh,
50:21 but it is also more comfortable for the family members to,
50:25 to prior discuss and to,
50:27 to take the decision together for the loan,
50:29 um,
50:31 uh,
50:32 they will not only feel more comfortable but also more sure about this decision,
50:37 uh,
50:38 discussing and,
50:39 uh,
50:39 and taking this decision together,
50:41 uh.
50:43 Women play an important role in the family finance.
50:47 Um,
50:49 Anyway,
50:50 um,
50:52 Our experience has shown that it is important
50:54 uh also uh what our loan officers do because
50:58 uh they go to to the member to go our members
51:02 and uh they explain the conditions of the contract,
51:05 uh uh what is foreseen in the agreement,
51:08 what they need to do,
51:10 uh,
51:10 and we try to do this uh in the same way with the
51:14 husband and with the wife or with both people who signed the contract.
51:20 Um,
51:21 this is what,
51:21 uh,
51:22 in general we do in Fed Invest,
51:24 of course,
51:24 our practice is,
51:25 uh,
51:26 is very long,
51:27 um,
51:28 but I,
51:30 I
51:31 I try to keep in simple words.
51:35 Great,
51:35 thank you so much,
51:36 Alvanna,
51:37 and I think that explains really well how
51:39 Fed Invest uses the household uh approach to
51:43 uh better include women,
51:44 but also to prevent uh people from borrowing beyond their needs.
51:49 Um,
51:50 Rachel,
51:50 is there any questions?
51:53 Yes,
51:53 absolutely.
51:54 We have a question from Berhan Kidano,
51:56 uh,
51:57 about,
51:58 uh,
51:58 financial and non-financial services for women,
52:01 and the question is,
52:02 to what extent do projects consider it seriously
52:06 bundling of non-financial with financial services
52:10 and set aside budgets accordingly?
52:13 Who among our speakers would like to take that question?
52:25 Chetna,
52:26 yeah,
52:27 shall I.
52:28 It's the one thing,
52:29 I mean,
52:29 uh.
52:31 While,
52:32 uh,
52:32 when we started bank,
52:33 actually,
52:35 um,
52:36 nobody was talking about financial literacy.
52:39 Nobody was talking about business literacy,
52:42 nobody.
52:43 But I remember that in 1999,
52:45 our women themselves,
52:47 they said
52:48 that you know,
52:49 we are taking loans but we would like to understand more about
52:54 businesses,
52:55 about
52:56 market,
52:57 about,
52:58 you know,
52:58 how can we,
52:59 how can we reduce the cost of our
53:02 products and,
53:03 and so,
53:04 and as Rachel men mentioned that,
53:07 you know,
53:07 the women don't like to take
53:10 more bigger size loan also.
53:12 It's very they're very conservative in that approach.
53:16 So I do see that you know when women come to financial institution,
53:21 they always want
53:23 the financial service,
53:24 other services than financial,
53:27 and that was the reason in fact,
53:29 it Mandehi,
53:30 a bank is totally,
53:32 there's no outside investors,
53:33 it's women's money,
53:35 women's bank,
53:36 women's credit,
53:36 women's saving,
53:37 women's profit.
53:39 But then we found the foundation
53:41 for the non-financial.
53:43 Because
53:43 our financial institution cannot afford to do that
53:47 and so that is a separate,
53:49 uh,
53:50 foundation we did it and that's why I always think that
53:53 when you work with women because there are many issues,
53:56 right,
53:56 the whole ecosystem is operating against them.
53:59 Like they don't have collateral.
54:01 They don't get enough.
54:03 There is no parity as far as education is concerned in
54:07 many countries.
54:08 So when such situation is there,
54:10 you do require a non-financial services
54:14 and particularly to women or a low income.
54:17 And so it's very important that how do you address that?
54:21 And now that is the,
54:22 I mean,
54:23 yeah,
54:23 the reply to the question.
54:26 Thank you.
54:27 Um,
54:28 Rachel,
54:29 I saw another question.
54:30 Yes,
54:31 we have one more question before we move to the next block.
54:34 We talked a lot about inclusion of women in membership,
54:37 but we have a question of Juan Bona on what actions do the
54:41 three entities undertake to facilitate an active participation of women in the.
54:46 The General Assembly.
54:47 Do you also promote participation of women in management.
54:51 So perhaps we could hear from Matthieu.
54:53 Um,
54:54 what do you,
54:55 do you do
54:56 in terms of,
54:57 uh,
54:58 improving the inclusion of women at the board and,
55:01 uh,
55:02 among your,
55:02 uh,
55:03 employees
55:04 and the management?
55:07 OK,
55:07 thank you.
55:08 What is,
55:08 what it is easy for us to do is to include women in the bods.
55:14 And also in the,
55:16 the,
55:16 the,
55:16 the
55:19 Top
55:19 management.
55:21 That's
55:21 when it's coming to the membership.
55:24 It provides
55:26 Product that meets the needs of women.
55:30 To participate in the general assembly.
55:33 To be honest,
55:34 sometimes women choose
55:36 to pursue their business
55:38 and to call
55:40 a political issue
55:41 as generally assembly.
55:43 We continue
55:44 to provide uh
55:45 some sensibization,
55:47 some financial education or financial literacy to them.
55:51 To make sure that
55:52 they they be a part of the decision.
55:55 They're taken at a local level concerning the
55:59 financial cooperative.
56:01 That's,
56:02 it's
56:03 a process.
56:05 Because they need
56:07 To make a choice
56:09 between
56:09 come to assembly
56:11 or to go for their business.
56:13 And usually,
56:14 most of them
56:16 choose to go for the business because
56:19 They are not the majority
56:21 when it's come
56:22 for
56:24 election.
56:24 And when in some society in West Africa,
56:27 when the husbands are there,
56:30 women cannot be elected unless
56:33 she has
56:34 authorization from
56:35 her husband.
56:37 It's,
56:38 it's a process,
56:40 a social process.
56:41 They work on it.
56:44 Thank you.
56:46 Thank you,
56:47 Mair.
56:48 I hope that answers one's question as well.
56:51 Uh,
56:51 and now that we know a bit more about the why and the how,
56:54 I think we can move on to digitization
56:57 because all three institutions have mentioned digitization as one of the ways
57:02 going forward to better include women.
57:05 And,
57:06 uh,
57:06 to us,
57:06 it seems that this can go both ways.
57:08 So on the one hand,
57:09 we have,
57:10 uh,
57:11 demands,
57:11 so,
57:12 uh,
57:12 for the women.
57:13 And on the other hand,
57:14 the supply side,
57:15 we have the financial cooperatives.
57:18 But this also raises some questions,
57:20 um,
57:21 because Chetna,
57:23 uh,
57:23 you mentioned that,
57:25 uh,
57:25 Mandeshi's clients,
57:27 uh,
57:28 have a strong interest in digital financial products.
57:32 Um,
57:32 you even mentioned that they see smartphones as the gateway to the world.
57:37 But uh we also see a gender gap in India
57:41 when it comes to phone uh ownership and mobile money usage.
57:46 So do you think uh that uh women and
57:49 then especially in lower income segments in rural areas
57:53 will truly benefit from the development of digital financial services?
58:00 So responding to the,
58:01 your question,
58:02 I would say that,
58:03 you know,
58:03 it's very interesting
58:05 that anything new comes in the household.
58:08 Who gets the access first,
58:10 right?
58:11 Who gets the access?
58:12 See,
58:13 for example,
58:13 when we are talking about the digitalization and now,
58:16 I mean,
58:17 a lot of digitalization of the digital banking happens on the cellphone,
58:21 right.
58:22 So then
58:23 if that's the one household,
58:25 one cellphone.
58:26 Will women get the excessive pay?
58:29 And it was very interesting that in India
58:32 we have these jandan accounts
58:34 which are household accounts.
58:37 They are not individual accounts,
58:39 which is a government pushing to the
58:41 Jandan account to give the government facilities
58:44 or direct benefit transfer to low-income groups.
58:48 It was interesting to see that women started questioning it,
58:52 that we want our individual
58:55 accounts,
58:56 number one.
58:57 Why?
58:57 Because we can have control on finance,
59:00 not just access.
59:02 So when it's digitalization also,
59:06 even that
59:07 with Peshi,
59:08 our experience was that women were ready to buy a cellphone,
59:12 take a loan and buy a cellphone because they wanted.
59:16 Their own digital wallet.
59:18 So I do feel that,
59:21 you know,
59:21 I,
59:22 I'm just being very brief for your answer.
59:24 We can discuss,
59:25 but
59:26 the whole thing is that actually,
59:29 Any technology is always an enabler,
59:33 but at the same time,
59:35 it should not just have an access,
59:37 but it should have a control also when it comes to gender.
59:41 So when we started our digital wallet,
59:44 it was interesting to see that,
59:46 you know,
59:46 we had PIN number
59:48 to operate digital wallet,
59:50 and our women said that we don't want PIN number.
59:53 You also add something like,
59:55 you know,
59:56 why don't you add biometric,
59:57 and we were saying pin number is easier.
1:00:00 You will remember,
1:00:01 you will have to be take a financial literacy for that.
1:00:04 So they were not ready for that.
1:00:06 They wanted a biometric
1:00:08 and we now have,
1:00:09 uh,
1:00:09 customized it with biometric.
1:00:11 And when we did that,
1:00:13 you know what our women said,
1:00:15 He said anybody can open my
1:00:17 account,
1:00:18 my PIN number,
1:00:19 but nobody can open my digital wallet
1:00:22 because it's a biometric.
1:00:24 So it's very interesting that,
1:00:26 you know,
1:00:26 even when technology comes.
1:00:29 It is very interesting that how that technology gives the control to these women,
1:00:34 it's the most important part.
1:00:36 And of course it would if
1:00:39 technology enables,
1:00:40 but on the demand side,
1:00:42 they are very clear that we want control.
1:00:44 So on the supply side,
1:00:45 I feel,
1:00:46 I think this technology company,
1:00:48 vendors,
1:00:48 fintech company,
1:00:50 they always have to
1:00:53 understand the demand side that they are not talking about excess.
1:00:56 Women are talking about control also,
1:00:59 and this technology enabling that.
1:01:02 Thank you,
1:01:03 Channa.
1:01:04 So if I understand you correctly,
1:01:06 technology can be an enabler,
1:01:07 but it is very important to keep looking at the demand side and what women truly need
1:01:12 when developing this enabler.
1:01:16 Albana,
1:01:16 um,
1:01:17 you mentioned that among your clients,
1:01:19 uh,
1:01:20 women are generally more eager to learn and
1:01:22 engage in training and then especially digital,
1:01:25 uh,
1:01:25 literacy trainings
1:01:27 in comparison to men.
1:01:29 Um,
1:01:29 how does this reflect in the strategy of Fed Infest?
1:01:32 What is the role in Fedinfest,
1:01:35 uh,
1:01:35 of digital and especially when it comes to including women?
1:01:40 Um,
1:01:41 in the same time I was trying to give answers also to the questions because,
1:01:45 uh,
1:01:45 I,
1:01:46 I see that,
1:01:47 uh,
1:01:47 uh,
1:01:48 we have here some very interesting questions.
1:01:51 Anyway,
1:01:51 I will give my answer about the digitalization,
1:01:54 um,
1:01:55 we left 2020.
1:01:57 Uh,
1:01:57 I believe,
1:01:58 uh,
1:01:59 the most difficult year for,
1:02:00 for the world,
1:02:02 uh,
1:02:02 where we met and knew what was,
1:02:04 uh,
1:02:05 the,
1:02:05 the COVID and the virus
1:02:07 who,
1:02:08 uh,
1:02:09 enforced us to,
1:02:11 to make,
1:02:11 uh,
1:02:12 a new way of living,
1:02:14 uh,
1:02:14 so we,
1:02:15 uh,
1:02:16 came from the physical
1:02:18 life into a digital and online life.
1:02:21 Uh,
1:02:22 and saying this,
1:02:23 uh,
1:02:23 also,
1:02:24 uh,
1:02:25 our everyday and also our,
1:02:27 um,
1:02:29 professional life,
1:02:30 uh,
1:02:30 came to,
1:02:31 to online life,
1:02:33 uh,
1:02:34 for sure,
1:02:35 uh,
1:02:35 what we want now is to
1:02:39 Not only as Fed Invest,
1:02:40 but I think,
1:02:41 uh,
1:02:41 uh,
1:02:42 everyone and,
1:02:42 uh,
1:02:43 every company,
1:02:44 uh,
1:02:45 needs to more go online.
1:02:47 Uh,
1:02:48 also Fed Invest needs
1:02:50 and uh also desire to further develop the usage of the financial services,
1:02:55 um,
1:02:56 and,
1:02:57 um,
1:02:58 following this step in Fed Invest,
1:03:00 we launched um a platform which is,
1:03:03 uh,
1:03:04 online and also,
1:03:05 uh,
1:03:06 a physical office.
1:03:07 Uh,
1:03:08 we call this,
1:03:08 uh,
1:03:09 agribusiness assistance,
1:03:10 uh,
1:03:11 which is,
1:03:12 uh,
1:03:12 a plot,
1:03:12 uh,
1:03:13 platform,
1:03:13 and,
1:03:14 uh,
1:03:14 also an office where
1:03:15 our members,
1:03:16 uh,
1:03:17 can get,
1:03:18 uh,
1:03:18 financial
1:03:19 education,
1:03:19 trainings,
1:03:20 uh,
1:03:20 market information,
1:03:22 but also networking opportunities.
1:03:25 Um.
1:03:27 Saying this,
1:03:27 we also created uh a network with women,
1:03:31 uh,
1:03:31 where we share weekly information about our services,
1:03:35 uh,
1:03:35 about our products,
1:03:37 um,
1:03:38 uh,
1:03:38 about our new staff or new members of the institution,
1:03:42 uh,
1:03:42 what are,
1:03:43 uh,
1:03:44 the needs of the clients,
1:03:45 the success stories and things like this.
1:03:47 So it's a very active group,
1:03:49 uh,
1:03:49 where we communicate,
1:03:51 uh,
1:03:51 with each other.
1:03:53 Um,
1:03:54 what we knew is,
1:03:55 uh,
1:03:56 that,
1:03:56 uh,
1:03:56 as we launched ABBA,
1:03:57 this agribusiness assistance last year,
1:04:00 uh,
1:04:01 according to the visits
1:04:02 that people made in,
1:04:03 uh,
1:04:04 this website and in this,
1:04:05 uh,
1:04:06 platform,
1:04:07 uh,
1:04:07 and also in our social media such as,
1:04:10 uh,
1:04:10 Facebook,
1:04:11 LinkedIn,
1:04:11 or,
1:04:12 um,
1:04:12 even Instagram,
1:04:14 we understood that,
1:04:15 uh,
1:04:16 more than half of the visitors were women.
1:04:19 And um
1:04:20 this let us know that they are more eager to learn and to be trained.
1:04:24 So um
1:04:25 this um
1:04:26 this strong interest in digital channels translate
1:04:30 um into a higher usage of digital channels by human.
1:04:35 Um,
1:04:36 following our digital strategy,
1:04:38 uh,
1:04:39 last year also,
1:04:40 uh,
1:04:40 we launched,
1:04:41 uh,
1:04:42 the current account,
1:04:43 um.
1:04:45 We launched also Fed Online and uh uh utility payment.
1:04:50 Uh,
1:04:50 Fed Online is um
1:04:53 um uh the web where uh our members can get information
1:04:57 and uh also can have online services from the institution.
1:05:02 Uh,
1:05:02 so,
1:05:03 uh,
1:05:03 we foresee that uh not only the number of our,
1:05:07 uh,
1:05:07 women members will increase,
1:05:09 but also
1:05:10 the number of the women members who profit from our uh products and services.
1:05:17 Thank you,
1:05:17 Alban.
1:05:17 Interesting to hear all these
1:05:20 interesting uh initiatives that are going on at Fed Invest.
1:05:23 I'm also curious to hear from Majou.
1:05:26 Uh,
1:05:27 about the digital strategy of TIFF going forward.
1:05:31 Uh,
1:05:32 for example,
1:05:32 you have recently launched,
1:05:34 uh,
1:05:34 uh,
1:05:34 a platform called Diana Cash,
1:05:36 which,
1:05:37 which is a digital platform for transfers.
1:05:40 Uh,
1:05:40 do you think that this platform will play a role towards increased gender equality?
1:05:48 Thank you.
1:05:49 Why we come to the digital platform for SIFE Network.
1:05:55 Because we realize that uh
1:05:56 the digitalization provide more security.
1:06:00 Substractive operation.
1:06:03 Provide the confidentiality.
1:06:05 And also supreme more resources for women because when
1:06:10 Women are using
1:06:12 the usually support the book
1:06:15 for the saving.
1:06:17 The husband
1:06:18 can get access to the book
1:06:21 and know how much
1:06:23 they have in their accounts.
1:06:27 But
1:06:28 with digitization.
1:06:30 It is not possible.
1:06:32 Without the permission of women.
1:06:36 Who providing the pin codes to the husband to get
1:06:40 information
1:06:41 on how much women
1:06:43 have in their accounts.
1:06:47 The reason not only provides.
1:06:50 Fast-track services,
1:06:52 women,
1:06:53 but also see.
1:06:55 They see him
1:06:56 and the occupation.
1:06:59 And what this strategy is at 3 levels.
1:07:02 The first one is
1:07:04 about our.
1:07:06 Process
1:07:07 The second is about our support,
1:07:12 and the last one is about our operation and services.
1:07:17 Janaya cash
1:07:18 is a part
1:07:19 of our
1:07:21 operation and services.
1:07:23 If there are cash today.
1:07:26 Any clients of
1:07:28 the safe network member.
1:07:34 Save
1:07:36 functional resources.
1:07:37 And have
1:07:39 automatically within the mobile phone,
1:07:43 uh,
1:07:44 the bank card because Da card also is with the bank cards.
1:07:47 They can access resources everywhere.
1:07:51 I
1:07:52 Digitalization is
1:07:54 not.
1:07:56 Whether we can do or not
1:07:59 is for us the
1:08:02 P
1:08:04 To more encourage women
1:08:06 to save
1:08:08 their resources,
1:08:09 to secure their resources,
1:08:11 and to,
1:08:12 to help them
1:08:13 to do business
1:08:15 more secure.
1:08:17 If you take a country like Burkina Faso.
1:08:20 Where we are facing
1:08:22 A security issue.
1:08:25 Women
1:08:27 withization can move
1:08:28 from NCQ.
1:08:30 Zone
1:08:31 The zone to make the business
1:08:34 or vice versa
1:08:36 without
1:08:38 fear to be attacked
1:08:40 by the terrorists and gather the resources.
1:08:45 It's where we are investing
1:08:47 in digitalization in West Africa.
1:08:49 And instead,
1:08:50 we have
1:08:51 4.5 million clients.
1:08:56 Within SI network.
1:08:59 If we are,
1:08:59 we are able
1:09:01 To digitize
1:09:02 the process,
1:09:04 the operation of all.
1:09:06 We feel
1:09:08 stiff.
1:09:09 It's become a big platform
1:09:11 for
1:09:12 everybody
1:09:13 to provide not only financial services,
1:09:16 but also to provide.
1:09:19 Inputs
1:09:20 for agriculture,
1:09:21 financial education,
1:09:23 or other services
1:09:24 to women.
1:09:27 Cilization is
1:09:30 The key
1:09:31 To breathe down
1:09:33 The gap
1:09:35 is the key to get
1:09:37 the last mile
1:09:38 to serve women.
1:09:41 Thank you so much,
1:09:42 Richard,
1:09:42 and good to see that
1:09:44 all three of you agree on the fact that digitization can play an important role.
1:09:49 Uh,
1:09:49 Rachel,
1:09:49 I saw some traffic in the chat.
1:09:51 Is there anything we can touch upon right now?
1:09:54 Yes,
1:09:54 absolutely.
1:09:55 We have a question from Anuk Arts,
1:09:58 um,
1:09:58 and the question.
1:09:59 is,
1:10:00 could we say that financial cooperatives are better placed
1:10:04 than normal
1:10:05 banks to reach out to women?
1:10:07 If I could try to answer that question based on our initial paper,
1:10:10 well,
1:10:11 based on the sample of cooperative financial institutions that we interviewed,
1:10:15 some are better,
1:10:16 some are not as good.
1:10:18 Uh,
1:10:18 but happy to hear panels on this,
1:10:20 and the question is,
1:10:22 which factors play a crucial role here?
1:10:25 To what extent are financial cooperatives,
1:10:28 better or not,
1:10:29 placed
1:10:30 to provide fintech solutions?
1:10:33 Who would like to go ahead
1:10:35 and provide some insights on this,
1:10:38 uh,
1:10:38 question?
1:10:41 OK.
1:10:42 I will start and click on complete.
1:10:46 So,
1:10:48 if,
1:10:48 if financial cooperative can
1:10:51 Provides
1:10:53 Better solution to the clay than
1:10:56 Fintech.
1:10:56 So what I can say is that
1:10:59 Uh,
1:11:00 I don't know what happened in,
1:11:01 uh,
1:11:01 uh,
1:11:01 uh,
1:11:02 Latin America and,
1:11:03 uh,
1:11:04 or in India,
1:11:05 but in
1:11:06 West Africa,
1:11:08 women
1:11:09 needs is not only financial.
1:11:12 There is on the needs of hush.
1:11:15 There is the need also of
1:11:18 cultural exchange
1:11:20 to where financial cooperative is important.
1:11:24 That we noticed that the bank and finance and the FEC are providing.
1:11:30 Today financial solution to the women
1:11:32 and
1:11:33 financial cooperative should
1:11:36 Innovates.
1:11:38 They uh
1:11:40 Partnership with Fintech.
1:11:42 Or create their own FinTech
1:11:44 to be able to continue to provide.
1:11:47 As well,
1:11:48 financial services
1:11:50 and
1:11:51 non-financial services to the member.
1:11:54 As if we commit for that is why we launch.
1:11:58 expression of interest.
1:12:01 To
1:12:02 Right.
1:12:03 So fintech
1:12:05 To help us
1:12:06 to increase
1:12:08 our digital solution to our members in West Africa.
1:12:12 The process is
1:12:13 ongoing now.
1:12:15 Thank you.
1:12:20 Thank you,
1:12:20 Mattie.
1:12:21 I think that is a good moment to move on to the last,
1:12:25 uh,
1:12:25 topic of the conclusions and recommendations.
1:12:29 So Rachel,
1:12:30 over to you.
1:12:32 Sure,
1:12:32 thank you,
1:12:32 Ruby.
1:12:33 Um,
1:12:34 as we enter this final block of conclusions and recommendations,
1:12:39 I would like to ask all three of you,
1:12:41 panelists,
1:12:42 the same question,
1:12:43 and if you could just give us like your 32nd or
1:12:48 maximum 1 minute answer to that question,
1:12:51 which is the key question of our webinar.
1:12:54 Now that we've discussed all of this,
1:12:56 what do you think?
1:12:57 Is including women
1:12:59 in financial cooperatives
1:13:00 an uphill battle or good business?
1:13:03 Over to you,
1:13:04 uh,
1:13:05 let's start with Albana.
1:13:09 Um,
1:13:11 as I mentioned before,
1:13:12 um,
1:13:13 and we have the same rights for women and men,
1:13:16 uh,
1:13:17 of course it's not an uphill battle,
1:13:18 um,
1:13:19 uphill battle,
1:13:21 um,
1:13:22 uh,
1:13:22 of course it's a good business,
1:13:24 including women,
1:13:25 um,
1:13:26 is,
1:13:26 uh,
1:13:26 I think,
1:13:27 uh,
1:13:27 the best opportunity for,
1:13:28 uh,
1:13:29 uh,
1:13:29 the wife and the husband to have the same rights and to collaborate in the same way,
1:13:33 uh,
1:13:34 and to discuss and to take decisions together for their families.
1:13:38 Um,
1:13:38 is also.
1:13:39 So,
1:13:39 uh,
1:13:40 the,
1:13:40 the good example for,
1:13:42 for the kids and for the,
1:13:44 uh,
1:13:44 society where they live and,
1:13:46 uh,
1:13:46 also where they work.
1:13:48 Uh,
1:13:48 so,
1:13:49 uh,
1:13:49 I think it's the best business to include women in,
1:13:52 uh,
1:13:53 in the financial,
1:13:54 uh,
1:13:55 institutions or in the financial inclusions.
1:13:59 Perfect,
1:13:59 thank you.
1:14:00 So not an uphill battle according to you and good business.
1:14:03 And I remember you also shared previously with us that
1:14:06 women had higher,
1:14:08 uh,
1:14:08 at lower non-performing loan rates than men at,
1:14:12 um,
1:14:13 at Fed Invest.
1:14:14 So yes,
1:14:14 it seems that it could be good business in terms of,
1:14:17 uh,
1:14:17 credit repayment.
1:14:18 Over to you,
1:14:19 Matthieu.
1:14:20 What would be your 32nd answer to that question?
1:14:23 Good business or uphill battle?
1:14:28 to
1:14:29 Who's gonna be there tomorrow.
1:14:32 Because
1:14:33 women
1:14:35 have came back
1:14:36 alone
1:14:37 more than
1:14:38 that
1:14:39 because
1:14:40 men and women.
1:14:42 Perfect.
1:14:43 They use resources for the family.
1:14:47 Doctor,
1:14:48 amen.
1:14:49 For
1:14:52 the is.
1:14:53 You for.
1:14:58 Great,
1:14:59 I think the,
1:14:59 the,
1:15:00 the sound was not great,
1:15:01 but
1:15:01 I really liked
1:15:02 the way you framed it.
1:15:05 Uphill battle today,
1:15:06 good business for tomorrow.
1:15:07 Interesting.
1:15:08 Over to you,
1:15:09 Chetna,
1:15:09 what do you think?
1:15:12 You know,
1:15:12 I would,
1:15:13 first I,
1:15:14 first of all,
1:15:14 I would like to say that
1:15:17 um
1:15:19 Even even if
1:15:21 I mean
1:15:21 if you need a business and if you want an economy to really grow
1:15:26 and with
1:15:28 with equity,
1:15:29 there is no other alternative,
1:15:31 but we have to
1:15:33 invest in gender.
1:15:34 We have to invest in these financial cooperatives
1:15:38 where
1:15:38 we women get an equal.
1:15:40 It's not just in,
1:15:41 in,
1:15:42 I don't believe in
1:15:43 talking about excess but control on finance and for that I do believe.
1:15:48 That
1:15:48 you know
1:15:49 either it is in the board,
1:15:50 either it is in the membership,
1:15:52 either it is in NGM
1:15:54 either it is in,
1:15:55 you have to have women and
1:15:57 ownership of property,
1:15:59 ownership of businesses.
1:16:01 Economy is not going to grow
1:16:03 and per capita income of the whole population is not going to grow
1:16:08 unless women own their businesses and have an
1:16:11 equal share in
1:16:13 particularly financial sector.
1:16:17 Thank you,
1:16:18 Chetna,
1:16:18 we hear you.
1:16:20 So,
1:16:21 um,
1:16:22 Now,
1:16:23 let's move to
1:16:24 the way forward,
1:16:25 and we at Rabo Foundation
1:16:28 and World Bank
1:16:29 are very interested in disseminating good practice and sharing insights
1:16:34 both at uh with supervisors and governments and with financial cooperatives.
1:16:39 So,
1:16:40 uh,
1:16:40 let me take just a few seconds to share with you
1:16:44 some emerging recommendations that
1:16:47 we,
1:16:47 uh,
1:16:48 highlighted in our paper.
1:16:51 Our emerging recommendations are the following for governments and supervisors.
1:16:56 We have 4.
1:16:57 The first one is
1:16:59 require and help
1:17:01 for supervisors.
1:17:02 Require and help
1:17:04 cooperative financial institutions to report
1:17:06 gender desegregated data on membership,
1:17:09 on loans,
1:17:09 on savings.
1:17:10 What gets measured
1:17:12 gets managed.
1:17:13 So that would be our number 1 suggestion.
1:17:15 Our #2 suggestion would be require and help CFI,
1:17:19 cooperative Financial Institutions,
1:17:21 report to the credit bureau so that a data trail is generated for
1:17:25 CFIA clients.
1:17:26 And we didn't talk about it today,
1:17:28 but
1:17:28 with Chetna,
1:17:29 we talked earlier about
1:17:31 Mandey sharing credit scores
1:17:34 built on their women clients with other financial institutions,
1:17:38 and we think this idea is actually really interesting
1:17:41 and um this was some of the inspiration for
1:17:44 for that recommendation.
1:17:46 Number 3,
1:17:47 we would like that um to,
1:17:50 to suggest to promote gender-sensitive financial
1:17:53 education campaigns and ensure customer protection through
1:17:57 grievance mechanisms,
1:17:58 and that's very important and that came out from discussions with you,
1:18:01 Matthew,
1:18:02 and other people at SIFF who mentioned to us that,
1:18:05 yes,
1:18:06 they developed
1:18:07 uh specific products for women,
1:18:09 targeting women,
1:18:09 but actually,
1:18:10 when
1:18:11 they did so,
1:18:12 They faced
1:18:13 lots of challenges
1:18:15 with people actually taking advantage of some women that were
1:18:20 uh
1:18:21 that had limited financial education.
1:18:22 So,
1:18:23 so that's our third recommendation.
1:18:25 And our fourth recommendation is
1:18:29 to allow sound cooperative financial institutions to
1:18:30 benefit from existing partial credit guarantee schemes.
1:18:34 We know that there are many partial credit guarantee schemes in many countries,
1:18:38 but
1:18:39 Oftentimes,
1:18:40 financial cooperatives are not eligible
1:18:43 for these guarantees,
1:18:45 and
1:18:46 increasing,
1:18:47 making them eligible would
1:18:49 allow them to increase their outreach to women who oftentimes lack collateral.
1:18:54 So that would be
1:18:55 some of our emerging recommendations for supervisors for governments.
1:19:00 For
1:19:01 cooperatives themselves,
1:19:02 we have two
1:19:03 very high-level recommendations,
1:19:05 one for federations.
1:19:07 We believe that
1:19:08 they can play
1:19:09 an instrumental role in conducting the market research
1:19:12 to better
1:19:14 to better understand the specificities of women clients.
1:19:18 And also in product development.
1:19:21 And for financial cooperatives themselves,
1:19:24 we definitely invite financial cooperatives
1:19:26 to develop gender sensitive approaches,
1:19:29 but
1:19:29 whatever the,
1:19:30 the the best model is,
1:19:31 it could be a woman-only model like Mandii,
1:19:34 it could be a group approach
1:19:35 like see if,
1:19:36 it could be a household approach like Fed Invest,
1:19:39 but we think
1:19:40 uh all of these models could be interesting inspirations and references.
1:19:44 So,
1:19:45 let me turn now to our panelists for our final question before we close.
1:19:50 Do you have any further thoughts on key recommendations,
1:19:54 suggestions going forward?
1:19:56 Uh,
1:19:57 Albana,
1:19:57 you come from a country in Albania that
1:20:00 has very progressive rules and laws and legislation
1:20:04 to promote gender equality.
1:20:06 What,
1:20:07 what else do you think should be done in Albania
1:20:10 so that to promote inclusion of women in financial cooperatives?
1:20:15 Um,
1:20:17 so,
1:20:17 uh,
1:20:18 here the floor is mine because I come from the legal department and,
1:20:21 um,
1:20:22 I can say that in Albania,
1:20:24 uh,
1:20:24 the laws are very good,
1:20:26 uh,
1:20:26 they provide,
1:20:27 um,
1:20:28 uh,
1:20:28 very good,
1:20:29 uh,
1:20:29 uh,
1:20:30 the things,
1:20:30 uh,
1:20:31 because we follow the,
1:20:33 the recommendations or the laws
1:20:35 in the European Union.
1:20:37 Um,
1:20:40 Uh,
1:20:40 we do not discriminate,
1:20:42 uh,
1:20:43 uh,
1:20:43 women and men,
1:20:44 uh,
1:20:45 they have the same right,
1:20:46 uh,
1:20:46 they can,
1:20:47 uh,
1:20:47 co-sign the contract,
1:20:49 uh,
1:20:49 in the same way,
1:20:50 uh,
1:20:51 they can have in the same way and also the collateral,
1:20:54 uh,
1:20:55 they can open,
1:20:55 uh,
1:20:55 uh,
1:20:57 the account in the same way,
1:20:58 so,
1:20:59 um,
1:20:59 they have the same rights,
1:21:00 uh,
1:21:02 regarding the law.
1:21:03 What it happens in the practice or maybe in Fed Invest because we,
1:21:07 uh,
1:21:08 we are extended more in the rural area,
1:21:10 uh,
1:21:12 what we see is that we find difficulties in,
1:21:15 in,
1:21:15 uh,
1:21:15 making this uh happen.
1:21:18 Um.
1:21:19 Of course they have,
1:21:20 uh,
1:21:21 women and men have the same rights,
1:21:23 but,
1:21:23 um,
1:21:23 uh,
1:21:24 it's not that in practice happens always like this,
1:21:27 uh,
1:21:27 in our case,
1:21:28 uh,
1:21:28 what I,
1:21:29 uh,
1:21:30 what I see is that,
1:21:31 um,
1:21:32 mm,
1:21:33 our practice shows also that,
1:21:35 uh,
1:21:35 we have less,
1:21:36 um,
1:21:36 uh,
1:21:37 women member than uh than men than uh men,
1:21:40 uh,
1:21:41 so,
1:21:42 um.
1:21:44 Mm,
1:21:44 my recommendation about the,
1:21:46 the,
1:21:47 the law to,
1:21:48 to improve something about uh
1:21:50 uh women inclusion is
1:21:52 only to,
1:21:53 to have some uh uh fiscal facilities uh for,
1:21:57 for women,
1:21:57 for example,
1:21:58 for the start-up businesses,
1:22:00 uh,
1:22:01 the,
1:22:01 the taxes and fees zero for the beginning or,
1:22:04 or,
1:22:04 uh,
1:22:05 um,
1:22:06 to,
1:22:06 to.
1:22:08 Uh,
1:22:09 to have something,
1:22:10 uh,
1:22:10 something,
1:22:10 um,
1:22:11 mm,
1:22:12 simple or,
1:22:12 or a good example to follow in the beginning,
1:22:15 uh,
1:22:16 training to,
1:22:17 to,
1:22:18 to be sent to them,
1:22:19 um,
1:22:20 and also giving the answer,
1:22:22 uh,
1:22:22 for Bjorn,
1:22:23 uh,
1:22:24 from,
1:22:24 uh,
1:22:25 my side,
1:22:26 uh,
1:22:26 and,
1:22:27 uh,
1:22:27 as Fed Invest,
1:22:28 I think that,
1:22:29 uh.
1:22:30 Uh,
1:22:30 it's not that we are not near to,
1:22:32 to,
1:22:32 to our member,
1:22:33 we are very near to our members,
1:22:35 but,
1:22:35 uh,
1:22:36 we need more to hear them voice.
1:22:38 Uh,
1:22:39 saying this,
1:22:40 I repeat,
1:22:40 it's not that we do not hear their voice,
1:22:43 we are here to serve from,
1:22:45 uh,
1:22:45 for them and to give,
1:22:46 uh,
1:22:46 our best,
1:22:47 uh,
1:22:48 for,
1:22:48 for what they need.
1:22:50 Um,
1:22:51 if we,
1:22:51 if we,
1:22:53 uh,
1:22:53 give our services in a smoother way,
1:22:56 in a more simple way,
1:22:57 things will be better even for them.
1:23:00 Um,
1:23:01 Of course it's a good business to include uh woman uh in the finance,
1:23:05 but,
1:23:06 uh,
1:23:06 saying what,
1:23:07 uh,
1:23:08 I,
1:23:08 following what I said before about the,
1:23:10 the digitalization,
1:23:12 uh,
1:23:13 I can confirm that,
1:23:14 uh,
1:23:14 it's not simple for us to,
1:23:16 to,
1:23:17 to,
1:23:17 to launch,
1:23:18 uh,
1:23:18 our service Fed online,
1:23:20 uh,
1:23:21 because,
1:23:21 uh,
1:23:21 in the rural area there are some people that,
1:23:24 uh,
1:23:24 even do not have a cellphone.
1:23:27 Uh,
1:23:27 but we are trying to do our best,
1:23:29 uh,
1:23:29 our,
1:23:30 uh,
1:23:30 marketing campaigns and,
1:23:32 uh,
1:23:32 services,
1:23:33 uh,
1:23:34 are tend to go even in the rural areas.
1:23:36 So,
1:23:37 uh,
1:23:38 for the moment,
1:23:38 uh,
1:23:39 we are working like this.
1:23:41 Um,
1:23:42 these are,
1:23:43 these were my only two recommendations.
1:23:46 Uh,
1:23:46 perfect.
1:23:47 Thanks a lot,
1:23:48 Albana.
1:23:48 So fiscal incentives for women-owned,
1:23:51 uh,
1:23:51 businesses and also more investment in training
1:23:55 and,
1:23:56 uh,
1:23:56 I want to,
1:23:57 before I turn to,
1:23:58 um,
1:23:58 Chetna,
1:23:59 uh,
1:24:00 everyone,
1:24:00 please feel free to share your thoughts
1:24:03 and recommendations in the chat panel and also
1:24:06 in,
1:24:06 uh,
1:24:07 by,
1:24:07 uh,
1:24:08 sending us an email at um.
1:24:11 Uh,
1:24:11 CFI gender feedback at gmail.com.
1:24:15 Uh,
1:24:16 Chetna,
1:24:17 what,
1:24:17 I know you faced several
1:24:19 regulatory and legal hurdles in setting up Mandey.
1:24:23 What would be your number one advice,
1:24:25 uh,
1:24:25 to governments,
1:24:26 to,
1:24:26 to supervisors to promote financial inclusion?
1:24:31 So the,
1:24:33 the most important,
1:24:34 sorry,
1:24:35 sorry,
1:24:35 I think Matthew wanted to say something,
1:24:37 uh,
1:24:38 quickly,
1:24:39 sorry,
1:24:39 Chetna.
1:24:41 OK,
1:24:41 no,
1:24:41 Matthew has issues with connection.
1:24:46 Uh
1:24:49 OK.
1:24:50 Thank you,
1:24:51 Matthieu.
1:24:53 Go ahead.
1:24:56 Can,
1:24:56 can you?
1:24:58 Yes.
1:25:00 I mean
1:25:02 Yes,
1:25:02 we do.
1:25:11 So
1:25:13 Before
1:25:16 Uh,
1:25:16 I want
1:25:17 to provide my remission.
1:25:19 First one is,
1:25:19 uh,
1:25:20 what our solution is more focused on the clients approach.
1:25:25 Yeah,
1:25:26 listen,
1:25:26 this is
1:25:30 the best
1:25:31 to.
1:25:36 To invest
1:25:38 Sorry,
1:25:38 Matthew,
1:25:39 the connection is not good actually.
1:25:41 So
1:25:42 I think uh we will,
1:25:44 thank you a lot
1:25:45 and uh say goodbye and turn to Che.
1:25:51 So one thing I would like to say is that,
1:25:53 as I've been emphasizing is that
1:25:56 um
1:25:57 law is there but I do think that the most important part
1:26:01 for on the gender issue if we really want to address is ownership of property rights.
1:26:07 And
1:26:08 with that we need governments to give the incentive
1:26:12 to
1:26:12 See that women own property.
1:26:15 Once they have that laws are there,
1:26:17 but still their culture is very different,
1:26:20 so that is one.
1:26:21 And I do think we have not much discussed,
1:26:24 but
1:26:24 with the digitalization,
1:26:26 not only for women,
1:26:28 but this whole cybersecurity
1:26:30 will be a very big issue
1:26:32 and how do you
1:26:34 Uh,
1:26:35 it would be a very,
1:26:36 uh,
1:26:37 different exercise and tricky exercise
1:26:39 about the cybersecurity
1:26:42 and the trust.
1:26:43 These are the two things I find it very important.
1:26:48 Perfect.
1:26:49 Thanks a lot Chetna.
1:26:50 Thanks a lot Albana.
1:26:51 Thanks a lot,
1:26:52 Matthew and everyone in the audience.
1:26:54 I think uh we're coming to the end of our webinar.
1:26:57 I want to thank
1:26:58 all of you for this really fruitful discussion.
1:27:01 In terms of next steps,
1:27:02 we will update,
1:27:04 improve,
1:27:04 uh,
1:27:05 our paper based on all this discussion we had and also
1:27:09 from the feedback you may share with us uh by email.
1:27:12 We'll wait for your feedback uh uh before the end.
1:27:15 Of this week.
1:27:16 And also,
1:27:17 uh,
1:27:17 please,
1:27:18 everyone stay tuned for future events.
1:27:22 Here you see a list of upcoming webinars,
1:27:25 so
1:27:26 all of you interested in gender,
1:27:28 please feel free to look at the Mercy Corps Agrofin annual uh learning event,
1:27:33 lots,
1:27:33 lots of events before the end of the month.
1:27:35 And for all of you interested in financial cooperatives,
1:27:38 we have in mid-July,
1:27:39 another event that we will organize on
1:27:42 Cooperative financial institutions in the context of fragility,
1:27:46 conflict,
1:27:47 and violence.
1:27:48 And with this,
1:27:49 I would like to thank all of you and say goodbye.
1:27:55 Thank you,
1:27:55 thank you,
1:27:55 bye.
1:27:56 Thank you,
1:27:57 everyone.
1:27:57 Bye bye.
1:27:58 Thank you.
1:28:01 Bye.
- add-style
- lp-body-content