col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-12
col-lg-12
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-12
col-lg-12
videoType
dynamic-media
videoDmUrl
https://delivery-p136806-e1377785.adobeaemcloud.com/adobe/assets/urn:aaid:aem:38f47a77-f2f6-4f91-abfe-858f27a3786d/play?assetname=Including+women+in+Financial+cooperatives.mp4
keyFrameImage
timestamp

00:02 Hi everyone,

00:03 just er if I could ask everyone to mute your mics please,

00:07 when you're not speaking,

00:08 that would be great so that we can all

00:11 hear each other.

00:13 Uh,

00:14 welcome

00:15 everyone

00:16 to our webinar on Including Women in Financial cooperatives,

00:21 Uphill Battle or Good Business.

00:25 Uh,

00:25 please everyone mute your mic,

00:28 um,

00:28 and I will start my video,

00:30 um.

00:32 Yeah,

00:32 so my name is Rachel Sparrow Kessler,

00:34 and I work at the World Bank.

00:37 Um,

00:37 focusing on agriculture finance,

00:40 rural finance,

00:41 and financial cooperatives,

00:42 and very happy to be

00:44 with you today.

00:44 Over to you,

00:45 Ruby.

00:47 Thank you,

00:47 Rachel.

00:48 Also welcome from my side.

00:49 My name is Ruby Garcia Kumaran,

00:52 and I work for Rabo Partnerships with the,

00:54 which is a department of the Rabobank,

00:57 focusing on financial inclusion,

00:59 private sector development,

01:00 and food security.

01:02 And I mainly focus on

01:04 uh cooperative development,

01:06 and I'm very glad and honored to be part of this webinar today,

01:09 and I look forward to the insights that it's gonna bring us.

01:14 Perfect.

01:15 So,

01:16 this webinar is organized as part of the partnership between

01:21 the World Bank,

01:22 Rabo Partnerships,

01:23 and Rabo Foundation to strengthen financial cooperatives around the world.

01:29 Um,

01:30 in this,

01:30 uh,

01:31 partnership,

01:31 we have,

01:32 um,

01:32 two components.

01:33 One is the Country program,

01:36 operational projects,

01:37 and

01:38 another component is the knowledge work through our

01:41 Center of Excellence.

01:42 And I think Ruby just,

01:43 uh,

01:43 shared the,

01:45 the link to our website.

01:47 And this Center of Excellence is focused on

01:49 disseminating knowledge on financial cooperatives.

01:53 So we're organizing this webinar

01:55 today on including women in Financial cooperatives,

01:59 an uphill Battle for Good Business.

02:01 This is a very special webinar.

02:04 Uh,

02:05 before I introduce the topic,

02:06 a few housekeeping issues.

02:08 One,

02:09 please meet your,

02:09 uh,

02:10 mics when you're not speaking.

02:11 Second,

02:11 this meeting is recorded,

02:13 so,

02:13 um,

02:14 so that it can be shared with other people after the awards,

02:17 but,

02:17 uh,

02:18 let's keep an informal tone even though it's recorded.

02:21 Uh,

02:21 so it's a very special webinar.

02:23 Uh,

02:24 because it's a special topic,

02:26 uh,

02:27 but also because we have a special format for it.

02:29 So the topic itself,

02:31 I think,

02:31 is very special.

02:33 Um,

02:35 our Center of Excellence has focused on a variety of topics over the past,

02:39 uh,

02:40 years

02:41 on deposit insurance,

02:43 on digitization,

02:44 on the impact of COVID,

02:46 and a range of transversal

02:48 topics.

02:50 The first time we talk about gender and gender

02:53 has become a priority

02:55 uh within the financial inclusion community,

02:57 and,

02:58 uh,

02:58 Greta Boll,

02:59 who is the CEO of CGAP,

03:00 recently said,

03:01 we have to put a gender lens on everything we do.

03:05 So,

03:06 this is a crucial topic for financial inclusion and it's the first time

03:11 we explore

03:12 the specific role of financial cooperatives

03:15 to close the gender gap in financial

03:19 inclusion.

03:20 What's

03:21 the role of financial cooperatives?

03:22 Do they really serve women?

03:24 Do they really include women?

03:26 Can they really play a role in closing the gender gap?

03:29 Let's discuss this today.

03:30 So that's

03:31 our special topic.

03:33 It's also a special format because,

03:35 um,

03:36 for this webinar,

03:37 because this is not a starting point discussion.

03:40 This is actually more of a midpoint discussion.

03:43 We've actually worked on a draft paper

03:46 on this topic,

03:47 together,

03:48 World Bank and Rabo Foundation,

03:50 and we,

03:51 uh,

03:51 we shared this,

03:52 uh,

03:53 paper.

03:53 I think Ruby just shared the link,

03:55 uh,

03:55 in the chat panel.

03:56 Uh,

03:57 and so this,

03:58 the goal of this webinar is to share some insights from this draft paper.

04:03 And also to get some feedback from our panelists,

04:06 but also from the audience.

04:08 So please,

04:09 everyone,

04:09 feel free to

04:10 put in the chat panel any question,

04:12 any comments you may have on this paper,

04:15 or also,

04:15 after our webinar,

04:16 please feel free to share your thoughts

04:18 by writing us uh on this uh email address CFI gender feedback@gmail.com,

04:24 which is also in the chat panel now.

04:26 So,

04:27 Special format and also final thing,

04:30 because we wanna hear from you,

04:32 this is not gonna be the typical webinar where we have

04:34 a 1 hour discussion and then a 5 minute Q&A.

04:38 No,

04:38 we have organized the webinar in 3 themes,

04:40 and at the end of each theme,

04:43 we will have a Q&A.

04:45 So now that we know that it's a special topic in a special format,

04:48 let me turn

04:50 to our very special panelists,

04:53 and we have uh two distinguished speakers for opening remarks.

04:58 Um,

04:59 we will have uh Daya Belchica and then,

05:03 uh,

05:03 uh,

05:04 Lena.

05:04 Koummopoulos,

05:05 um,

05:06 and Daya is the lead technical,

05:09 uh,

05:10 specialist on gender targeting and social inclusion at IFAD,

05:15 which is the International Fund for Agricultural Development,

05:18 the international institution focused on

05:21 rural economy transformation.

05:24 And,

05:25 um,

05:26 and then we will hear from Lena Giacomopoulos,

05:29 and she is the program director of

05:32 uh the Global Women's Leadership Network at WOCCU,

05:36 uh,

05:37 the World Council of Credit Unions.

05:39 So we'll first hear from Daya about general

05:42 thoughts on why it's important to

05:44 include women and to

05:47 Uh,

05:47 to why it's important to close the gender

05:49 gap in rural development and rural finance,

05:51 and then we'll focus on financial cooperatives and

05:53 why it's important to close the gender gap in

05:56 financial cooperatives.

05:57 So,

05:57 um,

05:59 let's start with,

05:59 uh,

06:00 Nya.

06:00 Uh,

06:01 I,

06:02 can you turn on your camera?

06:05 Hello,

06:05 Ndaya.

06:07 Yes,

06:07 my camera is on.

06:08 Can you see it?

06:09 Perfect.

06:10 OK,

06:10 how are you?

06:12 I'm fine,

06:12 thank you.

06:12 How are you?

06:14 Good,

06:14 thank you so much for,

06:15 for being here.

06:17 Uh,

06:17 so tell us,

06:18 Daya,

06:20 uh,

06:21 IFA has a strong priority on gender,

06:24 why is that?

06:25 And can you share with us,

06:27 um,

06:28 what you're doing in that space?

06:30 Sure.

06:31 Um,

06:31 thank you so much,

06:32 uh,

06:32 Rachel.

06:33 Thank you.

06:33 Good morning,

06:34 everyone.

06:34 Good afternoon.

06:36 So,

06:36 it's a pleasure to be here.

06:37 Um,

06:38 so let me briefly introduce IFAD to you for

06:41 those who are not familiar with my institution.

06:44 So,

06:44 IFAD,

06:45 uh,

06:45 is both a UN agency and international financial institution with a mandate

06:50 to invest to empower the rural women and men to lead their own development.

06:56 So we are still finishing the 2020 report.

06:59 So let just me share some few numbers,

07:02 2019 numbers with you.

07:04 So we had uh 200,

07:06 about 200 ongoing projects

07:08 with an outreach of 131 million,

07:11 roughly 50% of women,

07:14 and EA financing amount to 7.5 billion,

07:19 with about 9.2 billion of domestic and international co-financing.

07:24 That's what the numbers.

07:25 So,

07:26 IFAD's mandate strongly rests on the principle of gender equality,

07:32 primarily because it is the right thing to do.

07:35 And secondly,

07:36 as Rachel mentioned,

07:37 it is also,

07:37 it makes perfect

07:38 business sense.

07:40 Over the past decades,

07:42 IFAD made the commitment to look at all its investments

07:46 through the lens

07:48 of gender

07:49 and to mainstream gender it's,

07:52 in its portfolio.

07:54 So learning from evidence and experience in the field,

07:57 it has evolved from mainstreaming gender in its portfolio to now

08:02 adopt what we call gender transformative approaches

08:06 which identify

08:08 the root causes of gender inequality of women disempowerment.

08:13 In that trajectory,

08:14 so IFAD is promoting gender equality and women's empowerment at

08:18 one of these commitments and continues to learn and improve

08:22 as we continue to develop and implement the project.

08:26 So let me share with you one example of a recently concluded

08:30 Desashwini project.

08:32 It's a rural women empowerment project in India.

08:36 The project transformed the lives of thousands of poor women

08:40 in the low-income state of Madhya Pradesh in central India.

08:45 Women from over 24,000 240,000 rural households

08:50 targeted by the program took steps to change their

08:53 lives by being enrolled in 18,000 self-help groups.

08:58 Those self-help groups were a conduit for women to do a number of things.

09:03 They were able to acquire awareness on how to use kitchen gardens to save money

09:09 and substantially improve the nutritional status of the households.

09:13 They increased income.

09:15 Through some self-reflection and community support,

09:18 they empowered themselves to devise a

09:21 solution

09:21 to their own problems.

09:23 And they also organize themselves for collective actions

09:27 at different levels,

09:29 at the village level but also at the federal level.

09:33 Key to this approach used by the program were the self-help groups,

09:37 which gave women the power to make decisions and for many,

09:42 for the first time in their lives to actually gain control over their lives,

09:46 make decisions for themselves

09:48 and for their loved ones within the households.

09:52 The groups also facilitated savings and credit

09:56 and enabled women to resolve common situations

10:00 such as gender-based violence,

10:02 premature marriages,

10:04 and cases of suspected future trafficking

10:07 through what is called the Courage Brigades.

10:10 The Kurdish Brigades,

10:11 which stem from self-help groups have been so successful

10:16 that they've been replicated by the government across

10:19 all the districts in the Maya Pradesh.

10:23 Let's talk about scaling up.

10:26 A very good example just has to show how powerful this can be.

10:30 I just want to share with you briefly the story of Rega

10:35 Pradham,

10:36 who at age 34 is an inspiring example of what can be achieved

10:40 through projects that aim not only to improve the livelihoods,

10:44 income,

10:44 and nutrition,

10:45 but also to seek to increase women's empowerment.

10:50 Rika was born in a poor family,

10:52 and she joined the Self-help groups in 2008.

10:57 A few years later,

10:58 she then represented her village and

11:01 the village as well as the community at the federal level,

11:05 and 10 years later,

11:07 she ended up representing the project

11:10 at the 2017 Commission on the Status of Women in New York

11:14 while she had never traveled before.

11:17 Bringing now to the lens of rural finance,

11:20 we can see that even through that project,

11:22 finance was also an important instrument.

11:25 What we've recently done at IFAD,

11:27 we conducted a synthesis evaluation to understand

11:31 what would work

11:32 and then what can be improved in the case of rural finance.

11:36 What we were able to see

11:38 was that there were

11:40 significant gender results

11:42 when we look at the financial

11:44 institutions that were community-based financial organizations.

11:48 While when we look at the commercial banks,

11:50 credit union,

11:51 and other credit cooperatives,

11:53 the gender performance was not so strong.

11:57 One of the reasons that some of

11:59 the community-based financial organizations were relatively successful

12:03 is because they did a number of things.

12:06 One is that they were based on

12:13 One

12:14 is that they were based primarily on focusing

12:17 on the institutions that were targeting women.

12:20 They also offered very small loan size,

12:24 so in a sense they were self-targeting

12:27 women,

12:27 given that many of the women were involved in the informal economy.

12:32 And also they were linking the financial services with some empowerment,

12:37 which enabled the women to feel a lot more

12:40 confident into taking on new services and new activities.

12:45 Looking at the rural financial services,

12:47 we can see there are two sides to look at it if

12:49 we want to strengthen and provide better services to rural women.

12:53 They are on the demand side as well on the supply side.

12:57 On the demand side,

12:58 and I will be very brief,

13:00 I would just touch on

13:01 the fact that income and access to collateral,

13:04 as well as some constraint with some procedures.

13:08 Prevent women from having a broad access to financial services.

13:12 Typically women are involved

13:13 in the informal economy.

13:15 They do not have access to land,

13:17 which is one of the primary collateral,

13:19 and therefore when we do not provide those services,

13:22 it is unlikely that they would benefit from

13:24 loans or even for other services.

13:27 Another

13:29 issue on the demand side is the

13:32 lack of education or the lack of financial literacy,

13:35 as well as the lack of access to information,

13:38 because this one,

13:38 when we look at the education,

13:40 it is in fact a gateway

13:42 to access technology and information.

13:45 And if there is a lack of education,

13:46 then the illiteracy related to finance

13:49 would also enable,

13:51 prevent the women to have or to develop self-confidence

13:54 in order to access a different type of services.

13:57 On the supply side,

13:59 there are a number of things that we can

14:01 address or to look at.

14:02 One is that

14:04 very rarely are the staff trained into providing the relevant services to women.

14:09 And most of them are men.

14:11 Within those institutions.

14:12 Also,

14:13 women are not

14:14 represented.

14:16 So therefore,

14:16 when it comes time to develop the relevant financial services,

14:20 they are not giving a voice to develop the services that

14:23 they might need for home care or then for their businesses,

14:28 and this could be explained by a number of things.

14:31 And equally important,

14:32 many of those institutions do not have.

14:35 They don't necessarily

14:36 consider gender as a priority,

14:38 and very few of them would have gender

14:40 in the vision or in the mission statements or would

14:43 actually even have indicators that would track gender per se.

14:48 So we see that there are a number of inadequate service,

14:51 um,

14:51 and

14:52 Uh,

14:53 products.

14:53 I know that now you're gonna be discussing the good practices

14:57 as well as

14:58 focusing on innovation and tailored approaches,

15:01 and as such,

15:01 I will turn this over to the next speaker.

15:03 Thank you very much.

15:05 Thank you so much,

15:06 Ninaya.

15:06 That was a great opening statement.

15:08 Over to you,

15:09 um,

15:11 over to you,

15:12 uh,

15:12 Lena,

15:13 um,

15:14 what,

15:14 uh,

15:15 what's happening at WC?

15:17 Why do you focus especially on gender and what do you do

15:21 at the Global Women's Leadership Network to close the gender gap?

15:31 Thank you,

15:31 Rachel,

15:32 and,

15:32 and if I may ask you to uh speak in

15:35 less than 5 minutes,

15:36 that would be great.

15:36 Thank you.

15:38 Thank you.

15:39 Uh,

15:39 good morning,

15:40 good afternoon,

15:40 and good evening,

15:41 I should say,

15:42 everyone.

15:42 Uh,

15:42 thank you for having me join you today.

15:45 I'm really excited to be here.

15:47 And,

15:47 you know,

15:48 listening to the previous speaker,

15:49 and,

15:50 uh,

15:50 uh,

15:51 first,

15:51 let me give everyone a little,

15:52 uh,

15:53 background to GWL and,

15:55 um,

15:56 an,

15:56 an initiative that began by the World Council actually in 2009.

16:00 And it was initiated by

16:02 Women working in,

16:03 uh,

16:04 cooperatives in financial,

16:05 in credit unions in South America.

16:08 And they asked if we had a place

16:10 where women could get together,

16:12 could

16:12 join each other,

16:13 and actually support one another

16:15 and talk about

16:17 their advancement of their development in the credit union space.

16:20 And that's literally how the program came to be.

16:23 And as we fast forward to where we are today.

16:27 For the world,

16:28 uh,

16:28 for Global Women's Leadership Network.

16:31 Uh,

16:31 the program has engaged more than 4500 women and men,

16:34 uh,

16:35 in 86 countries to date,

16:37 um,

16:38 since its inception.

16:39 So,

16:39 it's very exciting to see.

16:40 And

16:41 I have to,

16:42 to,

16:42 to stress that

16:44 the work that we do is working together with women

16:46 and men.

16:47 OK?

16:47 We have to engage our male counterparts.

16:49 This isn't about,

16:51 uh,

16:51 um,

16:52 solely a woman.

16:53 Issue or a man issue.

16:54 This is a workplace issue and if we want to be able

16:57 to continue making it be good business

17:00 and actually better business for our organizations,

17:03 we need to focus on working together with our colleagues.

17:06 That's,

17:06 that's the one big thing that we stress,

17:08 uh,

17:09 through GWLN.

17:10 Now,

17:10 on,

17:11 on a more localized and individualized level,

17:13 I should say,

17:14 how we function for GWLN and how we work together

17:18 is through a mechanism we call.

17:19 All our sister societies,

17:21 which are,

17:22 it is the way that credit union women,

17:24 uh,

17:24 leaders,

17:25 CEOs,

17:26 board members,

17:27 and industry partners

17:28 in various parts of the world get together at a more localized level

17:32 and are able to

17:34 discuss the topics that are affecting

17:36 their credit union,

17:37 how they can function better as businesses.

17:39 Look at strategies and ways that they can increase

17:42 and get more women on their boards,

17:44 more women in leadership.

17:45 Roles

17:46 and look at other issues that on a more

17:48 personal level are going to be able to empower women

17:51 to do what they do every day in their lives.

17:54 And um presently we have about 145 of these

17:57 sister societies in nearly 30 countries through GWLN.

18:01 So there,

18:02 there are a lot of ways

18:03 that all of this comes together.

18:05 I think it's important for us to see

18:07 in different parts of the world what we're doing,

18:09 you know,

18:09 in Asia,

18:10 it is about giving.

18:11 Women access to,

18:12 to,

18:12 to capital and giving them a loans so they can

18:16 conduct their businesses,

18:17 entrepreneurs,

18:18 and,

18:18 and startups.

18:19 In Africa,

18:20 it is about

18:21 showing

18:22 the younger generation of women

18:23 that they can have that seat at the table,

18:25 that there are

18:26 women who are on boards,

18:28 and that the diversity,

18:29 equity and inclusion is an important part

18:32 of,

18:32 of their credit unions.

18:33 In,

18:34 in South America,

18:35 they talk about cultural bias and seeing.

18:38 How

18:38 they're,

18:39 they're,

18:39 they're dealing with it in their part of the world.

18:41 So,

18:41 there are different types

18:43 of approaches,

18:44 I,

18:44 I would say in,

18:45 in our different parts of the world.

18:47 There isn't a one answer and uh one

18:50 tool all across the board,

18:52 but it's important for us to continue focusing

18:55 on the impact that our network is making.

18:57 And that's what it is.

18:58 It,

18:58 it is a network,

18:59 and we learn from one another.

19:01 And many times when we have these sister society meetings,

19:04 one of the first questions that comes up is,

19:06 Look at the board,

19:07 look at your board,

19:08 look at your credit union board,

19:09 or look at the leadership team in your credit union,

19:12 in your financial cooperative.

19:13 How many women do you have on that board?

19:15 OK.

19:16 And um

19:17 if you think you don't have a seat at that table at that board,

19:20 you're wrong,

19:21 and you need another woman or another man to pull

19:23 that seat up for you and have you join in.

19:26 So,

19:26 it is about empowering women,

19:28 but it's about creating allies,

19:30 finding the strength in the network,

19:32 and working together.

19:33 Because,

19:34 you know,

19:35 pre-COVID,

19:35 we,

19:36 we've seen the data,

19:36 you know,

19:37 the World Economic Forum told us that we needed 99.5 years to close the gender gap.

19:42 And now,

19:42 we're at 137 years.

19:44 So,

19:44 that's an entire generation.

19:46 That the COVID the pandemic has pushed us back.

19:49 And that makes us want to continue doing what we're doing

19:52 and,

19:52 and realize how important it is of the work that we're doing for future generations,

19:57 not just for our,

19:57 our,

19:58 our work today.

19:59 So,

19:59 yes,

19:59 it is good business,

20:00 and I say we need to continue doing uh uh

20:03 what we're doing to make it even better business.

20:06 Thank you,

20:06 Rachel.

20:09 Fantastic.

20:10 Thank you so much,

20:11 Lena.

20:11 And if I hear you correctly,

20:13 you're saying that one size doesn't fit all and there's

20:15 not one model of inclusion of women in financial cooperatives,

20:19 and I think this is something we'll discuss with panelists uh today.

20:23 Before we do that,

20:24 uh,

20:24 I'd like to share with you a few insights,

20:27 um,

20:28 From our draft paper and uh Lena and Daya you're welcome to stay

20:33 and ask any questions and comments in the chat panel.

20:37 So here are a few insights from our uh

20:40 paper,

20:42 from our draft paper.

20:43 You,

20:43 you see my screen,

20:44 right?

20:47 Perfect.

20:48 So,

20:49 when we started uh researching this topic

20:52 of inclusion of women in financial cooperatives,

20:55 our first thought was,

20:57 please,

20:58 uh,

20:58 everyone,

20:58 you could mute yourself,

20:59 that would be great.

21:01 Our first thought was,

21:03 what is the share of women in,

21:07 let me just,

21:08 uh,

21:08 mute that person,

21:10 uh.

21:11 I

21:13 have one person who is

21:14 uh or Jaya you could do it

21:19 uh isn't this if Jaya you could uh mute that person that would be great.

21:23 Um,

21:24 so,

21:25 um,

21:26 when we started researching this topic,

21:28 uh,

21:28 our first thought was,

21:29 let's look at the share,

21:31 oops,

21:33 I think we still have a little,

21:34 uh,

21:34 technical issue.

21:38 Joan,

21:39 uh.

21:40 OK,

21:41 good.

21:41 Thank you.

21:42 So,

21:43 again,

21:44 when we started researching this topic,

21:46 our first thought was,

21:47 let's look at the share of women in

21:50 the membership of credit unions,

21:51 and to do so,

21:53 we turned to Wu and we looked at Woku reports

21:56 that gather a lot of data

21:57 on credit unions

21:59 worldwide

22:00 and

22:01 We have data on assets and number of members and savings and credits,

22:06 but

22:07 we couldn't find

22:09 gender disaggregated data

22:11 on

22:13 membership,

22:14 so we thought that was an interesting finding in itself.

22:19 Give me a second

22:21 to try to find this.

22:26 Maybe

22:26 let's try headphones.

22:27 Maybe the sound.

22:28 Um,

22:30 and,

22:30 uh,

22:31 and so

22:32 we thought,

22:32 OK,

22:33 so then we don't have much data,

22:35 but,

22:35 uh,

22:36 walker shared with us some data on

22:38 the share of women

22:39 in

22:40 as board members and as seniors of credit unions,

22:43 and I think here the number that stands out is the 60%.

22:46 percent

22:47 of

22:48 CEOs

22:49 in Europe that are women,

22:51 but besides that number,

22:53 we see that

22:55 actually women account for a minority of

22:59 board members and CEOs

23:02 worldwide.

23:04 I'm

23:05 sorry,

23:05 I'm just trying to fix this

23:08 issue,

23:08 uh.

23:13 OK.

23:18 And um

23:19 so,

23:20 uh,

23:20 so yes,

23:21 besides that,

23:22 especially in developing countries,

23:25 uh,

23:25 the share of women among board members and CEOs is less than 30%.

23:29 So we didn't have much data on

23:31 women in membership of credit unions,

23:33 so we thought,

23:34 OK,

23:34 then let's just pick.

23:37 Specific

23:38 corporate um er financial cooperatives

23:41 and understand to which extent they serve and include

23:44 women and ask them how they do it,

23:47 how successful they are,

23:48 what are their challenges and opportunities they seek.

23:51 We wanted to select

23:53 financial cooperatives that had developed gender-sensitive

23:57 approaches for a long time.

23:58 We wanted to learn from them,

24:00 and that's why we selected 3,

24:02 based on

24:03 interviews with experts.

24:04 We selected Mandesi,

24:06 CIFF,

24:07 and FedInvest.

24:08 Mandeshi,

24:09 just to give you a snapshot of these 3 organizations,

24:12 and we have representatives from these 3 organizations today.

24:15 Mandeshi is in India,

24:16 has about 30,000 members,

24:18 $85 million

24:21 USD in assets,

24:22 and it's a women-only cooperative.

24:25 So men

24:26 can actually save at Mandeshi,

24:29 but they cannot get

24:30 credit.

24:31 They cannot become members.

24:33 CIF is the Confederation des Institutional Financier the DAR de West,

24:37 so it's

24:38 the Confederation of Financial Institutions in West Africa.

24:41 It covers

24:42 6

24:43 networks of um financial cooperatives in 5 countries Benin,

24:47 Togo,

24:48 Senegal,

24:48 Mali,

24:48 Burkina Faso.

24:50 It's

24:51 Uh,

24:51 it covers 4.5 million

24:53 members,

24:54 $1.5 billion USD in assets,

24:56 so much larger than Mandeshi,

24:59 and it's not

25:00 only focused on women,

25:01 it's an open cooperative or mixed cooperative,

25:04 but it offers specific products to women,

25:07 and it has developed what we call a group approach,

25:09 so mainly joint liability groups.

25:12 Finally,

25:13 Fed Invest

25:15 is the first microfinance institution in Albania,

25:19 covers 78,000 members,

25:22 about $60 million USD in assets,

25:24 and again,

25:25 it's open to anyone,

25:27 so men and women,

25:28 and it doesn't have specific products for

25:31 women.

25:32 So,

25:33 men and women have access to exactly the same products.

25:36 However,

25:37 uh,

25:37 Fed Invest has developed what they call the household approach,

25:40 and we'll hear about that.

25:42 For all of these three

25:44 organizations,

25:45 we started the conversation with them,

25:46 asking them the exact same question.

25:49 What's the share of,

25:50 uh,

25:50 women in your membership?

25:52 What's the share of women in your employees?

25:54 What's the share of women at the board?

25:57 For Mandesi,

25:58 by design,

25:59 they are a women-only cooperative,

26:00 so 100% of their members are women.

26:04 At SIF,

26:05 38% of their members are women.

26:07 At Fed Invest,

26:08 37% of members are women.

26:11 So we thought,

26:12 OK,

26:12 so what do these numbers mean?

26:15 Is 38% of members at CIFF a good number?

26:18 Does it mean they are inclusive?

26:19 We started debating on this

26:21 and on the interpretation of these numbers,

26:23 and what we did was

26:26 We decided to benchmark

26:28 these cooperative financial institutions to other

26:31 financial institutions in their country.

26:33 So we actually asked for CIF that focuses on

26:37 5 countries to give us country-level data membership,

26:40 and we used Findex data.

26:42 So Findex data about the share of women with account at a financial institution.

26:47 We converted that number into the share of women

26:50 account holders in total number of account numbers,

26:52 uh holders.

26:54 And we compare that number

26:56 to the share of women in selected CFI's membership.

27:00 And here is what we,

27:01 we,

27:01 we,

27:02 we got.

27:04 Some CFIs are less inclusive than other financial institutions

27:09 in terms of women inclusion.

27:12 We see at the top,

27:13 displayed in red,

27:14 India,

27:15 Senegal,

27:15 Benin.

27:16 These are the financial cooperatives that

27:20 include women in their membership more than other financial institutions,

27:24 but all the others

27:25 are less inclusive of women

27:27 than other financial institutions.

27:30 We were surprised by this

27:33 because

27:34 these networks are actually selected

27:36 based on the fact that they have developed gender

27:38 sensitive approaches and gender strategies for a long time.

27:42 So,

27:42 why is that?

27:43 Why do we have some financial cooperatives that are

27:46 less inclusive than other financial institutions of women?

27:49 And in our paper,

27:50 we have two types of factors that we suggest.

27:53 First

27:54 types of factors are

27:55 external factors.

27:57 So,

27:57 the fact that

27:59 finance

27:59 that financial cooperatives operate in rural areas where

28:03 perhaps there are stronger gender norms or where women have

28:07 more challenges in accessing

28:10 assets in

28:12 in financial education.

28:13 Perhaps this

28:14 is the reason why

28:16 we see these,

28:16 these gender gaps.

28:18 But we also think that there might be also

28:20 internal factors in the way financial cooperatives operate.

28:24 Perhaps it could be that

28:26 this inclusive,

28:27 I mean it could be that this

28:29 collective decision process

28:31 in financial cooperatives,

28:33 perhaps it

28:34 could be that it doesn't really work well for Some women in rural areas that are

28:39 mobility and time constraints.

28:40 So,

28:41 here are some initial thoughts,

28:43 and of course,

28:44 we want to highlight that some cooperatives are better

28:46 equipped than others to serve and include women.

28:50 So,

28:50 with that,

28:51 I would like to hand it over to Ruby to discuss this in more details.

28:56 Thank you.

28:57 Thank you,

28:57 Rachel,

28:58 and having summarized the main findings of our paper,

29:01 I think uh it is time to hear the insights on this from our distinguished panelists.

29:07 So it is my pleasure to introduce them to you.

29:10 Um,

29:11 on the panel,

29:11 we have

29:13 Chetna Sinha,

29:14 who is the founder and chairperson of the Mandeshi Bank and Mandeshi Foundation

29:19 in India.

29:20 We have Madieu,

29:21 Matthieu Suglonu,

29:23 who is the general director

29:25 of CIF,

29:26 and we have Albana Beta,

29:28 the head of the legal department of

29:31 uh Fed Invest in Albania.

29:33 So a very warm welcome to all of you and thank you very much for joining the panel.

29:39 Uh,

29:40 before I will give the word to you,

29:41 I would like to quickly explain the structure of today's webinar.

29:47 We will first focus on

29:49 the why and the how of including women in financial cooperatives,

29:53 followed by the potential of digitization to improve women's inclusion,

29:59 and lastly,

30:00 recommendations to cooperatives and governments.

30:03 And

30:05 as Rachel already said,

30:06 the chat box is

30:08 open for all participants,

30:10 so we would

30:11 still encourage you to actively use this in case of any.

30:15 Uh,

30:16 questions or comments arise,

30:18 and then,

30:18 uh,

30:19 Rachel and I will make sure to handle them at the right time.

30:24 So the 3 financial institutions we have selected

30:29 all have a

30:31 specific way to include women,

30:33 and they have all

30:34 developed a specific strategy over the years.

30:38 But as we saw in Rachel's introduction,

30:41 these three ways also differ from each other.

30:44 Uh,

30:45 Chetna,

30:45 I would like to start with you because at Mandeshi,

30:49 you have

30:50 the women-only model.

30:53 Can you explain to us why you chose for this model,

30:56 and does this also indicate that women alone represent a

31:00 sufficient business case for financial cooperatives to be profitable?

31:16 I see Chetna is in the

31:17 chats.

31:20 Are you

31:22 on mute,

31:22 Jenna?

31:39 Rachel,

31:40 maybe you can unmute the.

31:43 Chenna

31:44 Yeah,

31:45 uh,

31:47 it was locked centrally from your side.

31:50 Yeah.

31:51 So sorry for that,

31:52 and am I audible?

31:54 Yes,

31:56 yeah,

31:57 so,

31:57 uh,

31:58 thanks,

31:59 Rubi,

31:59 and I mean thanks Rubika and thanks Rachel

32:03 for inviting me to share my

32:05 experiences

32:06 and your question that why did I choose to do that.

32:11 Uh,

32:12 in fact,

32:12 very honestly,

32:14 It was not like

32:16 decided or chosen.

32:18 I,

32:19 I mean,

32:20 I was,

32:21 I never thought that I would start a women's bank,

32:23 Women's cooperative Bank.

32:25 Um,

32:26 that was.

32:27 It was just that

32:29 I was uh very young,

32:31 at a very young age.

32:32 I was,

32:32 when I was doing my undergraduate program,

32:35 I got into Gandhian organization

32:37 and I visited some villages which were drought affected.

32:41 And when I saw the life there,

32:43 then I decided that I'll be staying there and work there.

32:46 And I'm married to my husband who is a farmer from this village,

32:51 must work where I started the bank.

32:53 And when I was staying with my husband here,

32:56 some women came to me and they wanted to do savings.

33:00 And so I went with them to the banks.

33:03 To get their accounts open

33:06 because these one,

33:07 these women wanted to do savings.

33:09 One of them,

33:10 uh,

33:11 who you can see a film on YouTube also,

33:14 Tanta Bai,

33:14 who was a street vendor.

33:16 So,

33:16 but the banks denied opening the account of these women.

33:20 And why?

33:22 Because their savings were too small,

33:24 that is why.

33:25 In fact,

33:25 they were not even asking interest on that.

33:28 They were ready to pay a fee for their

33:30 savings administration.

33:33 In spite of that,

33:34 banks thought that they are not an affordable client.

33:38 So then when I saw that,

33:40 I felt that

33:41 if banks are not opening the account,

33:43 why not start a bank for

33:46 women,

33:46 those who are street vendors,

33:48 those who are so active

33:50 throughout their lives economically.

33:52 And they need the bank most because they want to save it

33:56 every day.

33:57 So then I went to Central Bank of India,

33:59 Reserve Bank of India,

34:00 that how can we start a bank

34:03 for women like Kamtabai,

34:04 and I was told that there is the only window where

34:07 you can start a women's bank is through a cooperative.

34:10 And so then we thought we'll apply for the banking license.

34:13 So it was like no

34:15 pre-planned or something,

34:17 but it was very clear

34:19 that our women wanted to do banking,

34:21 our women wanted to do savings,

34:23 and the big banks were not ready to do

34:26 because their businesses were too small for them.

34:29 And so then we thought,

34:31 why not,

34:31 and we applied for the banking license.

34:34 The journey was not very easy.

34:37 The license was rejected by the Central Bank of India.

34:41 And you know why?

34:42 Because

34:43 the our women did not have a signatures.

34:45 They had a thumb impression

34:47 because they couldn't read and write.

34:49 And the central bank said that we cannot issue a license to the bank

34:53 who's promoting members are.

34:56 I was devastated,

34:57 but women were very clear.

34:59 They said that we learn to read and write.

35:01 We applied again.

35:03 And at that time,

35:04 15 women accompanied me

35:06 and they challenged the officer.

35:08 They said we cannot read and write,

35:10 but we can count.

35:12 And they challenged the officers,

35:14 asking them

35:16 that ask us to calculate the interest of any principal amount.

35:20 If we fail,

35:21 don't issue the license,

35:23 but tell your officers to do it without a calculator

35:27 and see who can calculate faster.

35:30 Needless to say,

35:31 we've got the banking license.

35:32 It is the first rural women's bank in India,

35:35 and I'm so proud to share with you,

35:38 Ruby,

35:38 that,

35:39 you know,

35:39 when this,

35:40 when,

35:41 when women were coming forward,

35:43 everybody said that these women cannot read and write,

35:45 but today we are one of the largest rural women's bank in the.

35:49 Country

35:50 and the other banks which were cooperative banks which were started by like very

35:56 powerful people,

35:57 member of parliament and all.

35:58 Our bank is bigger than that,

36:01 that,

36:01 and not only that,

36:03 I am also so proud that

36:05 actually we have two types of membership.

36:08 One is that

36:10 membership of AGM,

36:12 an annual general meeting.

36:14 Where we have more than 37,000 women now,

36:17 but the other is that the general membership,

36:20 a general membership with the bank,

36:23 we have more than 600,000.

36:26 Now when I say that,

36:27 it's very interesting that as I said that

36:30 it wasn't that I chose to set up this bank.

36:33 Women chose to have the bank.

36:36 And you know when women decide

36:38 what happens.

36:39 So now we have a business school for rural women who have never been to the school.

36:43 We have schools at doorstep with the buses,

36:46 we have digital buses which go doorstep,

36:49 and we have radio which is operated by them.

36:53 And our,

36:54 our bank is managed by 100% women.

36:58 Most of us are nearly 94% of our employees are women.

37:03 But now for diversity,

37:04 because a lot of people are asking us now that why no men.

37:08 So we have some of the men

37:11 as a part of the diversity in our institution.

37:14 But having said all this,

37:16 I would just

37:17 like I've narrated the

37:19 thing that we are working

37:20 with now we have foundation also with the bank,

37:24 but

37:24 while operating with the bank,

37:26 what are the things which I learned from women?

37:29 Number 1,

37:30 you cannot read and write,

37:32 but you can count and manage the finance.

37:35 Number 2,

37:36 that

37:38 even with the small businesses,

37:39 you all are.

37:40 Your

37:42 cooperative bank

37:43 can be profitable and sustainable.

37:46 It may not have a huge balance sheet,

37:49 but it,

37:50 and then so we are very proud that some banks were bigger than us,

37:54 but today they are not,

37:55 they don't even exist.

37:57 But our bank has been sustained and for the last

38:00 15 years,

38:02 our women are getting dividends.

38:04 And it is the first rural Women's Bank

38:07 where the bank was able to give dividend to its member.

38:10 So with this,

38:11 I would just like to share with you that,

38:14 you know,

38:14 these are the lessons I have learned from our women

38:17 and one of the biggest lessons I've learned from them is

38:21 that understand the cash flow.

38:22 Listen to women,

38:23 design the product according to their needs.

38:26 These are very,

38:27 very important

38:28 things.

38:29 And so

38:30 we do not really have cash credit for street vendors.

38:34 And when I was going to Taos to co-chair World Forum,

38:38 I asked our women,

38:39 you know.

38:40 So many people come and cars

38:43 where we talk about billions and trillions.

38:46 What should I speak to them?

38:47 What should I tell them?

38:48 You know what our women said?

38:50 They said,

38:51 go and tell them

38:53 that our courage is.

38:55 And the second thing they said,

38:56 which always

38:58 equals me,

38:59 and that is that

39:01 never give poor solutions to poor people,

39:04 and that is possible when women lead the

39:07 organization.

39:09 So thank you so much.

39:12 Always very

39:13 inspiring to hear Mandeshi stories and thank you very much.

39:17 Good to hear that

39:19 currently women do represent a good business case for Mandeshi.

39:23 Uh,

39:24 I would like to go over to Matthieu.

39:27 Matthieu,

39:27 are you

39:28 in the call and available to answer a question?

39:41 Yes,

39:41 uh,

39:42 Ruby and Rachel,

39:43 I do.

39:45 I am the,

39:46 can you hear me?

39:47 Yes,

39:48 great.

39:48 Hi.

39:50 Thank you for joining.

39:52 Uh,

39:53 I was wondering because,

39:54 uh,

39:55 at Mondeshi,

39:55 they have the women-only model,

39:57 and at SIF you have applied a different approach,

39:59 namely the group approach.

40:01 And why do you think at SIF it is important to include women and what do you,

40:05 have you done specifically to do so?

40:10 Thank you.

40:12 Thank you for giving me the opportunity to tell

40:14 about what SIF is doing in West Africa.

40:18 To

40:19 include

40:20 Women financially and to cover the gender gap

40:23 at this level.

40:26 Why it's important for us to employ women,

40:29 you know,

40:29 in West Africa specifically,

40:32 there is like some division of labor

40:35 between women and men

40:37 when it's come

40:39 to administrate the households.

40:42 While

40:42 the man is focused on the big investments like

40:47 the,

40:47 the house,

40:48 or the

40:50 assets,

40:51 the big assets

40:53 of the family.

40:54 Women is more focused on day to day.

40:58 Resources to cover

41:01 Needs such as foods,

41:04 such as

41:05 uh scholarship for,

41:07 for,

41:07 for young people,

41:09 for,

41:09 for,

41:09 for their children,

41:11 etc.

41:13 Uh,

41:13 and also women in West Africa.

41:17 Uh,

41:19 appear like

41:20 the

41:21 Very suck

41:23 of the developments at the local level.

41:27 When women

41:30 have resources.

41:32 In West Africa,

41:33 particularly.

41:34 They're more focused on

41:36 the

41:38 behavior,

41:38 to improve the behavior of the family.

41:41 I'm sorry,

41:42 I'm a man,

41:43 but women are more focused on how to improve the health of family

41:47 than uh men in West Africa.

41:49 And uh also the women

41:52 is respecting their commitment when it's come

41:55 to pay back the credits.

41:57 So,

41:58 why we chose

42:00 to provide.

42:02 Some financial services

42:04 to women in West Africa.

42:07 How we,

42:07 we,

42:07 we proceed.

42:09 We proceeds by a group approach.

42:13 Uh,

42:14 specifically by using what,

42:16 what,

42:16 what we call,

42:19 uh,

42:19 to plan iffier,

42:20 it's something

42:22 to,

42:23 uh,

42:24 allow women.

42:25 To provide

42:27 every day.

42:29 Some resources in terms of uh saving

42:32 every day and to be able to raise the money

42:37 at the end of the month.

42:39 With the institution.

42:41 And,

42:41 and we create a group.

42:44 Uh,

42:45 and in each group,

42:47 the group of 30.

42:49 50

42:51 independent

42:52 women.

42:53 Who

42:55 Every day

42:57 A deposits.

43:00 To be able to raise

43:03 The money at the end of the month or to get credits.

43:09 The experience we,

43:09 we,

43:10 we did with uh Benin physical in Benin.

43:14 Right now,

43:14 we have uh uh we have 60,000

43:18 women.

43:20 We collects.

43:24 40 million

43:26 Yes

43:28 I still

43:29 Uh

43:30 yeah.

43:32 It means that

43:33 women have capacity to save.

43:37 And also we provide them

43:39 credits

43:40 to develop their business.

43:43 In

43:44 Burkina Faso,

43:46 we developed some specific products with uh FCPB.

43:52 Much

43:53 Financial services with

43:55 financial literacy.

43:58 And also we

44:00 Reproductive

44:02 and sexual.

44:05 sensitization to

44:06 to empower women.

44:08 To make the choice.

44:11 Decides

44:12 whether they could

44:15 do the term.

44:17 For children

44:18 or to use

44:19 the term for the business

44:21 that they negotiate this term.

44:23 In the family with the husband.

44:31 We learn

44:34 is that

44:36 when we combine.

44:38 A financial product with financial literacy.

44:43 And sexual reposition.

44:46 Education.

44:47 We get more results of women.

44:51 And where

44:53 We

44:54 provide only

44:55 the financial services.

44:59 What we learn is also

45:01 that we need

45:03 to

45:05 Identify

45:07 The value

45:10 value chain where women is more focused.

45:14 And develop specific products.

45:16 To target the needs of women.

45:19 In this

45:21 value chain.

45:23 What we learned also is that sometimes

45:27 The lack of

45:29 Having the ID cards.

45:31 Lack of access to lands.

45:35 Oh,

45:36 the

45:37 lack

45:38 of access

45:39 to

45:40 education.

45:42 Sometime

45:45 Appear as a barrier

45:47 for women

45:48 to access financial services.

45:52 We also learned that when women

45:55 walk.

45:57 And assess responsibility in

45:59 financial cooperative.

46:02 Local level.

46:04 Some of them were able.

46:07 To become

46:08 a political leader.

46:10 In their

46:11 community,

46:12 in their region,

46:13 or at national level.

46:16 And be,

46:16 and to be elected like parliamentary

46:20 mayor,

46:21 and so on.

46:23 Why we

46:24 commit ourselves to continue to increase.

46:28 With access to financial services within its network.

46:33 Thank you.

46:34 Thank you so much.

46:36 It's very interesting to hear that uh by developing specific products,

46:40 it has managed to reach women.

46:43 And as we heard in the introduction,

46:45 it's not one size fits all.

46:47 So

46:48 it's really interesting to see that in different countries,

46:50 you have also uh developed different products.

46:55 Albana at Fan Invest,

46:58 you have a long history of focusing on women inclusion,

47:02 and one of the tools through which you do this

47:04 is the household approach or the co-signing of spouses.

47:08 Can you elaborate a bit more on this and why you think it is so important to use this

47:13 in including women in Fed Invest?

47:16 Uh yes.

47:18 Uh,

47:18 hello,

47:19 everyone.

47:19 Uh my name is Albana.

47:21 Uh,

47:21 I represent here,

47:23 uh,

47:23 FedInvest,

47:24 uh,

47:24 which is the,

47:25 the,

47:26 uh,

47:28 microfinance institution established in 1992 in Albania.

47:33 Uh,

47:33 so it's,

47:34 uh,

47:35 I can proudly say the oldest one operating in Albania.

47:39 Uh,

47:39 we count now,

47:40 uh,

47:40 63 branches.

47:42 Uh,

47:42 we operate in almost

47:44 Uh,

47:44 2000 small villages and uh

47:48 we have uh nearly 78,000 members.

47:52 We are focused in the rural areas and uh we serve to different clients,

47:57 uh,

47:58 from them who are excluded from the financial services and banking services

48:03 to them who might need uh an SME.

48:06 Uh,

48:07 we are a cooperative governance,

48:09 uh,

48:11 so we are a mixed structure,

48:12 uh,

48:13 made from the administrative staff and also elected people,

48:17 um.

48:20 In Fed Invest,

48:21 we believe that uh women and men,

48:23 same in the same boat,

48:24 so,

48:24 uh,

48:25 we are not here to,

48:26 to differentiate uh women from men,

48:30 uh,

48:30 or vice versa.

48:32 Uh,

48:32 important for us is,

48:33 uh,

48:34 not to exclude women from the financial services and products.

48:39 So

48:39 we offer the same services,

48:41 the same products,

48:42 the same trainings for women and men,

48:44 but,

48:45 uh,

48:45 what we see is the difference in the product usage because

48:50 Uh,

48:50 of the type of the product and uh how they are involved,

48:55 um.

48:56 From our practice,

48:57 we understood and we learned that uh

49:00 uh women tend to work more uh in tailor shop or uh as a hairdresser,

49:07 um,

49:08 in agritourism and uh also in the family farm together with their husbands.

49:14 um.

49:16 We know also uh from our practice that um because

49:21 uh we offer not only credit but also deposit products

49:24 and we know that uh women uh

49:27 know uh better than men

49:29 uh how to save

49:31 um.

49:33 I believe this is because they feel less comfortable

49:36 with borrowing beyond their needs or to to put

49:40 the family finance in over indebtedness,

49:44 so for them it's important to take smaller loans,

49:47 but they are responsible because they have,

49:50 they have better repayment loans

49:54 regarding the contract,

49:55 the credit contract,

49:57 we co-signed the contract both from the husband and the wife.

50:01 Uh,

50:02 so we

50:04 make this not only to empower women but also to let them know about the loan,

50:09 the,

50:09 the conditions of the loan,

50:11 how to repay this

50:12 and things like this.

50:14 So,

50:15 um,

50:16 this is our way to ensure that the household does not borrow beyond its needs,

50:20 uh,

50:21 but it is also more comfortable for the family members to,

50:25 to prior discuss and to,

50:27 to take the decision together for the loan,

50:29 um,

50:31 uh,

50:32 they will not only feel more comfortable but also more sure about this decision,

50:37 uh,

50:38 discussing and,

50:39 uh,

50:39 and taking this decision together,

50:41 uh.

50:43 Women play an important role in the family finance.

50:47 Um,

50:49 Anyway,

50:50 um,

50:52 Our experience has shown that it is important

50:54 uh also uh what our loan officers do because

50:58 uh they go to to the member to go our members

51:02 and uh they explain the conditions of the contract,

51:05 uh uh what is foreseen in the agreement,

51:08 what they need to do,

51:10 uh,

51:10 and we try to do this uh in the same way with the

51:14 husband and with the wife or with both people who signed the contract.

51:20 Um,

51:21 this is what,

51:21 uh,

51:22 in general we do in Fed Invest,

51:24 of course,

51:24 our practice is,

51:25 uh,

51:26 is very long,

51:27 um,

51:28 but I,

51:30 I

51:31 I try to keep in simple words.

51:35 Great,

51:35 thank you so much,

51:36 Alvanna,

51:37 and I think that explains really well how

51:39 Fed Invest uses the household uh approach to

51:43 uh better include women,

51:44 but also to prevent uh people from borrowing beyond their needs.

51:49 Um,

51:50 Rachel,

51:50 is there any questions?

51:53 Yes,

51:53 absolutely.

51:54 We have a question from Berhan Kidano,

51:56 uh,

51:57 about,

51:58 uh,

51:58 financial and non-financial services for women,

52:01 and the question is,

52:02 to what extent do projects consider it seriously

52:06 bundling of non-financial with financial services

52:10 and set aside budgets accordingly?

52:13 Who among our speakers would like to take that question?

52:25 Chetna,

52:26 yeah,

52:27 shall I.

52:28 It's the one thing,

52:29 I mean,

52:29 uh.

52:31 While,

52:32 uh,

52:32 when we started bank,

52:33 actually,

52:35 um,

52:36 nobody was talking about financial literacy.

52:39 Nobody was talking about business literacy,

52:42 nobody.

52:43 But I remember that in 1999,

52:45 our women themselves,

52:47 they said

52:48 that you know,

52:49 we are taking loans but we would like to understand more about

52:54 businesses,

52:55 about

52:56 market,

52:57 about,

52:58 you know,

52:58 how can we,

52:59 how can we reduce the cost of our

53:02 products and,

53:03 and so,

53:04 and as Rachel men mentioned that,

53:07 you know,

53:07 the women don't like to take

53:10 more bigger size loan also.

53:12 It's very they're very conservative in that approach.

53:16 So I do see that you know when women come to financial institution,

53:21 they always want

53:23 the financial service,

53:24 other services than financial,

53:27 and that was the reason in fact,

53:29 it Mandehi,

53:30 a bank is totally,

53:32 there's no outside investors,

53:33 it's women's money,

53:35 women's bank,

53:36 women's credit,

53:36 women's saving,

53:37 women's profit.

53:39 But then we found the foundation

53:41 for the non-financial.

53:43 Because

53:43 our financial institution cannot afford to do that

53:47 and so that is a separate,

53:49 uh,

53:50 foundation we did it and that's why I always think that

53:53 when you work with women because there are many issues,

53:56 right,

53:56 the whole ecosystem is operating against them.

53:59 Like they don't have collateral.

54:01 They don't get enough.

54:03 There is no parity as far as education is concerned in

54:07 many countries.

54:08 So when such situation is there,

54:10 you do require a non-financial services

54:14 and particularly to women or a low income.

54:17 And so it's very important that how do you address that?

54:21 And now that is the,

54:22 I mean,

54:23 yeah,

54:23 the reply to the question.

54:26 Thank you.

54:27 Um,

54:28 Rachel,

54:29 I saw another question.

54:30 Yes,

54:31 we have one more question before we move to the next block.

54:34 We talked a lot about inclusion of women in membership,

54:37 but we have a question of Juan Bona on what actions do the

54:41 three entities undertake to facilitate an active participation of women in the.

54:46 The General Assembly.

54:47 Do you also promote participation of women in management.

54:51 So perhaps we could hear from Matthieu.

54:53 Um,

54:54 what do you,

54:55 do you do

54:56 in terms of,

54:57 uh,

54:58 improving the inclusion of women at the board and,

55:01 uh,

55:02 among your,

55:02 uh,

55:03 employees

55:04 and the management?

55:07 OK,

55:07 thank you.

55:08 What is,

55:08 what it is easy for us to do is to include women in the bods.

55:14 And also in the,

55:16 the,

55:16 the,

55:16 the

55:19 Top

55:19 management.

55:21 That's

55:21 when it's coming to the membership.

55:24 It provides

55:26 Product that meets the needs of women.

55:30 To participate in the general assembly.

55:33 To be honest,

55:34 sometimes women choose

55:36 to pursue their business

55:38 and to call

55:40 a political issue

55:41 as generally assembly.

55:43 We continue

55:44 to provide uh

55:45 some sensibization,

55:47 some financial education or financial literacy to them.

55:51 To make sure that

55:52 they they be a part of the decision.

55:55 They're taken at a local level concerning the

55:59 financial cooperative.

56:01 That's,

56:02 it's

56:03 a process.

56:05 Because they need

56:07 To make a choice

56:09 between

56:09 come to assembly

56:11 or to go for their business.

56:13 And usually,

56:14 most of them

56:16 choose to go for the business because

56:19 They are not the majority

56:21 when it's come

56:22 for

56:24 election.

56:24 And when in some society in West Africa,

56:27 when the husbands are there,

56:30 women cannot be elected unless

56:33 she has

56:34 authorization from

56:35 her husband.

56:37 It's,

56:38 it's a process,

56:40 a social process.

56:41 They work on it.

56:44 Thank you.

56:46 Thank you,

56:47 Mair.

56:48 I hope that answers one's question as well.

56:51 Uh,

56:51 and now that we know a bit more about the why and the how,

56:54 I think we can move on to digitization

56:57 because all three institutions have mentioned digitization as one of the ways

57:02 going forward to better include women.

57:05 And,

57:06 uh,

57:06 to us,

57:06 it seems that this can go both ways.

57:08 So on the one hand,

57:09 we have,

57:10 uh,

57:11 demands,

57:11 so,

57:12 uh,

57:12 for the women.

57:13 And on the other hand,

57:14 the supply side,

57:15 we have the financial cooperatives.

57:18 But this also raises some questions,

57:20 um,

57:21 because Chetna,

57:23 uh,

57:23 you mentioned that,

57:25 uh,

57:25 Mandeshi's clients,

57:27 uh,

57:28 have a strong interest in digital financial products.

57:32 Um,

57:32 you even mentioned that they see smartphones as the gateway to the world.

57:37 But uh we also see a gender gap in India

57:41 when it comes to phone uh ownership and mobile money usage.

57:46 So do you think uh that uh women and

57:49 then especially in lower income segments in rural areas

57:53 will truly benefit from the development of digital financial services?

58:00 So responding to the,

58:01 your question,

58:02 I would say that,

58:03 you know,

58:03 it's very interesting

58:05 that anything new comes in the household.

58:08 Who gets the access first,

58:10 right?

58:11 Who gets the access?

58:12 See,

58:13 for example,

58:13 when we are talking about the digitalization and now,

58:16 I mean,

58:17 a lot of digitalization of the digital banking happens on the cellphone,

58:21 right.

58:22 So then

58:23 if that's the one household,

58:25 one cellphone.

58:26 Will women get the excessive pay?

58:29 And it was very interesting that in India

58:32 we have these jandan accounts

58:34 which are household accounts.

58:37 They are not individual accounts,

58:39 which is a government pushing to the

58:41 Jandan account to give the government facilities

58:44 or direct benefit transfer to low-income groups.

58:48 It was interesting to see that women started questioning it,

58:52 that we want our individual

58:55 accounts,

58:56 number one.

58:57 Why?

58:57 Because we can have control on finance,

59:00 not just access.

59:02 So when it's digitalization also,

59:06 even that

59:07 with Peshi,

59:08 our experience was that women were ready to buy a cellphone,

59:12 take a loan and buy a cellphone because they wanted.

59:16 Their own digital wallet.

59:18 So I do feel that,

59:21 you know,

59:21 I,

59:22 I'm just being very brief for your answer.

59:24 We can discuss,

59:25 but

59:26 the whole thing is that actually,

59:29 Any technology is always an enabler,

59:33 but at the same time,

59:35 it should not just have an access,

59:37 but it should have a control also when it comes to gender.

59:41 So when we started our digital wallet,

59:44 it was interesting to see that,

59:46 you know,

59:46 we had PIN number

59:48 to operate digital wallet,

59:50 and our women said that we don't want PIN number.

59:53 You also add something like,

59:55 you know,

59:56 why don't you add biometric,

59:57 and we were saying pin number is easier.

1:00:00 You will remember,

1:00:01 you will have to be take a financial literacy for that.

1:00:04 So they were not ready for that.

1:00:06 They wanted a biometric

1:00:08 and we now have,

1:00:09 uh,

1:00:09 customized it with biometric.

1:00:11 And when we did that,

1:00:13 you know what our women said,

1:00:15 He said anybody can open my

1:00:17 account,

1:00:18 my PIN number,

1:00:19 but nobody can open my digital wallet

1:00:22 because it's a biometric.

1:00:24 So it's very interesting that,

1:00:26 you know,

1:00:26 even when technology comes.

1:00:29 It is very interesting that how that technology gives the control to these women,

1:00:34 it's the most important part.

1:00:36 And of course it would if

1:00:39 technology enables,

1:00:40 but on the demand side,

1:00:42 they are very clear that we want control.

1:00:44 So on the supply side,

1:00:45 I feel,

1:00:46 I think this technology company,

1:00:48 vendors,

1:00:48 fintech company,

1:00:50 they always have to

1:00:53 understand the demand side that they are not talking about excess.

1:00:56 Women are talking about control also,

1:00:59 and this technology enabling that.

1:01:02 Thank you,

1:01:03 Channa.

1:01:04 So if I understand you correctly,

1:01:06 technology can be an enabler,

1:01:07 but it is very important to keep looking at the demand side and what women truly need

1:01:12 when developing this enabler.

1:01:16 Albana,

1:01:16 um,

1:01:17 you mentioned that among your clients,

1:01:19 uh,

1:01:20 women are generally more eager to learn and

1:01:22 engage in training and then especially digital,

1:01:25 uh,

1:01:25 literacy trainings

1:01:27 in comparison to men.

1:01:29 Um,

1:01:29 how does this reflect in the strategy of Fed Infest?

1:01:32 What is the role in Fedinfest,

1:01:35 uh,

1:01:35 of digital and especially when it comes to including women?

1:01:40 Um,

1:01:41 in the same time I was trying to give answers also to the questions because,

1:01:45 uh,

1:01:45 I,

1:01:46 I see that,

1:01:47 uh,

1:01:47 uh,

1:01:48 we have here some very interesting questions.

1:01:51 Anyway,

1:01:51 I will give my answer about the digitalization,

1:01:54 um,

1:01:55 we left 2020.

1:01:57 Uh,

1:01:57 I believe,

1:01:58 uh,

1:01:59 the most difficult year for,

1:02:00 for the world,

1:02:02 uh,

1:02:02 where we met and knew what was,

1:02:04 uh,

1:02:05 the,

1:02:05 the COVID and the virus

1:02:07 who,

1:02:08 uh,

1:02:09 enforced us to,

1:02:11 to make,

1:02:11 uh,

1:02:12 a new way of living,

1:02:14 uh,

1:02:14 so we,

1:02:15 uh,

1:02:16 came from the physical

1:02:18 life into a digital and online life.

1:02:21 Uh,

1:02:22 and saying this,

1:02:23 uh,

1:02:23 also,

1:02:24 uh,

1:02:25 our everyday and also our,

1:02:27 um,

1:02:29 professional life,

1:02:30 uh,

1:02:30 came to,

1:02:31 to online life,

1:02:33 uh,

1:02:34 for sure,

1:02:35 uh,

1:02:35 what we want now is to

1:02:39 Not only as Fed Invest,

1:02:40 but I think,

1:02:41 uh,

1:02:41 uh,

1:02:42 everyone and,

1:02:42 uh,

1:02:43 every company,

1:02:44 uh,

1:02:45 needs to more go online.

1:02:47 Uh,

1:02:48 also Fed Invest needs

1:02:50 and uh also desire to further develop the usage of the financial services,

1:02:55 um,

1:02:56 and,

1:02:57 um,

1:02:58 following this step in Fed Invest,

1:03:00 we launched um a platform which is,

1:03:03 uh,

1:03:04 online and also,

1:03:05 uh,

1:03:06 a physical office.

1:03:07 Uh,

1:03:08 we call this,

1:03:08 uh,

1:03:09 agribusiness assistance,

1:03:10 uh,

1:03:11 which is,

1:03:12 uh,

1:03:12 a plot,

1:03:12 uh,

1:03:13 platform,

1:03:13 and,

1:03:14 uh,

1:03:14 also an office where

1:03:15 our members,

1:03:16 uh,

1:03:17 can get,

1:03:18 uh,

1:03:18 financial

1:03:19 education,

1:03:19 trainings,

1:03:20 uh,

1:03:20 market information,

1:03:22 but also networking opportunities.

1:03:25 Um.

1:03:27 Saying this,

1:03:27 we also created uh a network with women,

1:03:31 uh,

1:03:31 where we share weekly information about our services,

1:03:35 uh,

1:03:35 about our products,

1:03:37 um,

1:03:38 uh,

1:03:38 about our new staff or new members of the institution,

1:03:42 uh,

1:03:42 what are,

1:03:43 uh,

1:03:44 the needs of the clients,

1:03:45 the success stories and things like this.

1:03:47 So it's a very active group,

1:03:49 uh,

1:03:49 where we communicate,

1:03:51 uh,

1:03:51 with each other.

1:03:53 Um,

1:03:54 what we knew is,

1:03:55 uh,

1:03:56 that,

1:03:56 uh,

1:03:56 as we launched ABBA,

1:03:57 this agribusiness assistance last year,

1:04:00 uh,

1:04:01 according to the visits

1:04:02 that people made in,

1:04:03 uh,

1:04:04 this website and in this,

1:04:05 uh,

1:04:06 platform,

1:04:07 uh,

1:04:07 and also in our social media such as,

1:04:10 uh,

1:04:10 Facebook,

1:04:11 LinkedIn,

1:04:11 or,

1:04:12 um,

1:04:12 even Instagram,

1:04:14 we understood that,

1:04:15 uh,

1:04:16 more than half of the visitors were women.

1:04:19 And um

1:04:20 this let us know that they are more eager to learn and to be trained.

1:04:24 So um

1:04:25 this um

1:04:26 this strong interest in digital channels translate

1:04:30 um into a higher usage of digital channels by human.

1:04:35 Um,

1:04:36 following our digital strategy,

1:04:38 uh,

1:04:39 last year also,

1:04:40 uh,

1:04:40 we launched,

1:04:41 uh,

1:04:42 the current account,

1:04:43 um.

1:04:45 We launched also Fed Online and uh uh utility payment.

1:04:50 Uh,

1:04:50 Fed Online is um

1:04:53 um uh the web where uh our members can get information

1:04:57 and uh also can have online services from the institution.

1:05:02 Uh,

1:05:02 so,

1:05:03 uh,

1:05:03 we foresee that uh not only the number of our,

1:05:07 uh,

1:05:07 women members will increase,

1:05:09 but also

1:05:10 the number of the women members who profit from our uh products and services.

1:05:17 Thank you,

1:05:17 Alban.

1:05:17 Interesting to hear all these

1:05:20 interesting uh initiatives that are going on at Fed Invest.

1:05:23 I'm also curious to hear from Majou.

1:05:26 Uh,

1:05:27 about the digital strategy of TIFF going forward.

1:05:31 Uh,

1:05:32 for example,

1:05:32 you have recently launched,

1:05:34 uh,

1:05:34 uh,

1:05:34 a platform called Diana Cash,

1:05:36 which,

1:05:37 which is a digital platform for transfers.

1:05:40 Uh,

1:05:40 do you think that this platform will play a role towards increased gender equality?

1:05:48 Thank you.

1:05:49 Why we come to the digital platform for SIFE Network.

1:05:55 Because we realize that uh

1:05:56 the digitalization provide more security.

1:06:00 Substractive operation.

1:06:03 Provide the confidentiality.

1:06:05 And also supreme more resources for women because when

1:06:10 Women are using

1:06:12 the usually support the book

1:06:15 for the saving.

1:06:17 The husband

1:06:18 can get access to the book

1:06:21 and know how much

1:06:23 they have in their accounts.

1:06:27 But

1:06:28 with digitization.

1:06:30 It is not possible.

1:06:32 Without the permission of women.

1:06:36 Who providing the pin codes to the husband to get

1:06:40 information

1:06:41 on how much women

1:06:43 have in their accounts.

1:06:47 The reason not only provides.

1:06:50 Fast-track services,

1:06:52 women,

1:06:53 but also see.

1:06:55 They see him

1:06:56 and the occupation.

1:06:59 And what this strategy is at 3 levels.

1:07:02 The first one is

1:07:04 about our.

1:07:06 Process

1:07:07 The second is about our support,

1:07:12 and the last one is about our operation and services.

1:07:17 Janaya cash

1:07:18 is a part

1:07:19 of our

1:07:21 operation and services.

1:07:23 If there are cash today.

1:07:26 Any clients of

1:07:28 the safe network member.

1:07:34 Save

1:07:36 functional resources.

1:07:37 And have

1:07:39 automatically within the mobile phone,

1:07:43 uh,

1:07:44 the bank card because Da card also is with the bank cards.

1:07:47 They can access resources everywhere.

1:07:51 I

1:07:52 Digitalization is

1:07:54 not.

1:07:56 Whether we can do or not

1:07:59 is for us the

1:08:02 P

1:08:04 To more encourage women

1:08:06 to save

1:08:08 their resources,

1:08:09 to secure their resources,

1:08:11 and to,

1:08:12 to help them

1:08:13 to do business

1:08:15 more secure.

1:08:17 If you take a country like Burkina Faso.

1:08:20 Where we are facing

1:08:22 A security issue.

1:08:25 Women

1:08:27 withization can move

1:08:28 from NCQ.

1:08:30 Zone

1:08:31 The zone to make the business

1:08:34 or vice versa

1:08:36 without

1:08:38 fear to be attacked

1:08:40 by the terrorists and gather the resources.

1:08:45 It's where we are investing

1:08:47 in digitalization in West Africa.

1:08:49 And instead,

1:08:50 we have

1:08:51 4.5 million clients.

1:08:56 Within SI network.

1:08:59 If we are,

1:08:59 we are able

1:09:01 To digitize

1:09:02 the process,

1:09:04 the operation of all.

1:09:06 We feel

1:09:08 stiff.

1:09:09 It's become a big platform

1:09:11 for

1:09:12 everybody

1:09:13 to provide not only financial services,

1:09:16 but also to provide.

1:09:19 Inputs

1:09:20 for agriculture,

1:09:21 financial education,

1:09:23 or other services

1:09:24 to women.

1:09:27 Cilization is

1:09:30 The key

1:09:31 To breathe down

1:09:33 The gap

1:09:35 is the key to get

1:09:37 the last mile

1:09:38 to serve women.

1:09:41 Thank you so much,

1:09:42 Richard,

1:09:42 and good to see that

1:09:44 all three of you agree on the fact that digitization can play an important role.

1:09:49 Uh,

1:09:49 Rachel,

1:09:49 I saw some traffic in the chat.

1:09:51 Is there anything we can touch upon right now?

1:09:54 Yes,

1:09:54 absolutely.

1:09:55 We have a question from Anuk Arts,

1:09:58 um,

1:09:58 and the question.

1:09:59 is,

1:10:00 could we say that financial cooperatives are better placed

1:10:04 than normal

1:10:05 banks to reach out to women?

1:10:07 If I could try to answer that question based on our initial paper,

1:10:10 well,

1:10:11 based on the sample of cooperative financial institutions that we interviewed,

1:10:15 some are better,

1:10:16 some are not as good.

1:10:18 Uh,

1:10:18 but happy to hear panels on this,

1:10:20 and the question is,

1:10:22 which factors play a crucial role here?

1:10:25 To what extent are financial cooperatives,

1:10:28 better or not,

1:10:29 placed

1:10:30 to provide fintech solutions?

1:10:33 Who would like to go ahead

1:10:35 and provide some insights on this,

1:10:38 uh,

1:10:38 question?

1:10:41 OK.

1:10:42 I will start and click on complete.

1:10:46 So,

1:10:48 if,

1:10:48 if financial cooperative can

1:10:51 Provides

1:10:53 Better solution to the clay than

1:10:56 Fintech.

1:10:56 So what I can say is that

1:10:59 Uh,

1:11:00 I don't know what happened in,

1:11:01 uh,

1:11:01 uh,

1:11:01 uh,

1:11:02 Latin America and,

1:11:03 uh,

1:11:04 or in India,

1:11:05 but in

1:11:06 West Africa,

1:11:08 women

1:11:09 needs is not only financial.

1:11:12 There is on the needs of hush.

1:11:15 There is the need also of

1:11:18 cultural exchange

1:11:20 to where financial cooperative is important.

1:11:24 That we noticed that the bank and finance and the FEC are providing.

1:11:30 Today financial solution to the women

1:11:32 and

1:11:33 financial cooperative should

1:11:36 Innovates.

1:11:38 They uh

1:11:40 Partnership with Fintech.

1:11:42 Or create their own FinTech

1:11:44 to be able to continue to provide.

1:11:47 As well,

1:11:48 financial services

1:11:50 and

1:11:51 non-financial services to the member.

1:11:54 As if we commit for that is why we launch.

1:11:58 expression of interest.

1:12:01 To

1:12:02 Right.

1:12:03 So fintech

1:12:05 To help us

1:12:06 to increase

1:12:08 our digital solution to our members in West Africa.

1:12:12 The process is

1:12:13 ongoing now.

1:12:15 Thank you.

1:12:20 Thank you,

1:12:20 Mattie.

1:12:21 I think that is a good moment to move on to the last,

1:12:25 uh,

1:12:25 topic of the conclusions and recommendations.

1:12:29 So Rachel,

1:12:30 over to you.

1:12:32 Sure,

1:12:32 thank you,

1:12:32 Ruby.

1:12:33 Um,

1:12:34 as we enter this final block of conclusions and recommendations,

1:12:39 I would like to ask all three of you,

1:12:41 panelists,

1:12:42 the same question,

1:12:43 and if you could just give us like your 32nd or

1:12:48 maximum 1 minute answer to that question,

1:12:51 which is the key question of our webinar.

1:12:54 Now that we've discussed all of this,

1:12:56 what do you think?

1:12:57 Is including women

1:12:59 in financial cooperatives

1:13:00 an uphill battle or good business?

1:13:03 Over to you,

1:13:04 uh,

1:13:05 let's start with Albana.

1:13:09 Um,

1:13:11 as I mentioned before,

1:13:12 um,

1:13:13 and we have the same rights for women and men,

1:13:16 uh,

1:13:17 of course it's not an uphill battle,

1:13:18 um,

1:13:19 uphill battle,

1:13:21 um,

1:13:22 uh,

1:13:22 of course it's a good business,

1:13:24 including women,

1:13:25 um,

1:13:26 is,

1:13:26 uh,

1:13:26 I think,

1:13:27 uh,

1:13:27 the best opportunity for,

1:13:28 uh,

1:13:29 uh,

1:13:29 the wife and the husband to have the same rights and to collaborate in the same way,

1:13:33 uh,

1:13:34 and to discuss and to take decisions together for their families.

1:13:38 Um,

1:13:38 is also.

1:13:39 So,

1:13:39 uh,

1:13:40 the,

1:13:40 the good example for,

1:13:42 for the kids and for the,

1:13:44 uh,

1:13:44 society where they live and,

1:13:46 uh,

1:13:46 also where they work.

1:13:48 Uh,

1:13:48 so,

1:13:49 uh,

1:13:49 I think it's the best business to include women in,

1:13:52 uh,

1:13:53 in the financial,

1:13:54 uh,

1:13:55 institutions or in the financial inclusions.

1:13:59 Perfect,

1:13:59 thank you.

1:14:00 So not an uphill battle according to you and good business.

1:14:03 And I remember you also shared previously with us that

1:14:06 women had higher,

1:14:08 uh,

1:14:08 at lower non-performing loan rates than men at,

1:14:12 um,

1:14:13 at Fed Invest.

1:14:14 So yes,

1:14:14 it seems that it could be good business in terms of,

1:14:17 uh,

1:14:17 credit repayment.

1:14:18 Over to you,

1:14:19 Matthieu.

1:14:20 What would be your 32nd answer to that question?

1:14:23 Good business or uphill battle?

1:14:28 to

1:14:29 Who's gonna be there tomorrow.

1:14:32 Because

1:14:33 women

1:14:35 have came back

1:14:36 alone

1:14:37 more than

1:14:38 that

1:14:39 because

1:14:40 men and women.

1:14:42 Perfect.

1:14:43 They use resources for the family.

1:14:47 Doctor,

1:14:48 amen.

1:14:49 For

1:14:52 the is.

1:14:53 You for.

1:14:58 Great,

1:14:59 I think the,

1:14:59 the,

1:15:00 the sound was not great,

1:15:01 but

1:15:01 I really liked

1:15:02 the way you framed it.

1:15:05 Uphill battle today,

1:15:06 good business for tomorrow.

1:15:07 Interesting.

1:15:08 Over to you,

1:15:09 Chetna,

1:15:09 what do you think?

1:15:12 You know,

1:15:12 I would,

1:15:13 first I,

1:15:14 first of all,

1:15:14 I would like to say that

1:15:17 um

1:15:19 Even even if

1:15:21 I mean

1:15:21 if you need a business and if you want an economy to really grow

1:15:26 and with

1:15:28 with equity,

1:15:29 there is no other alternative,

1:15:31 but we have to

1:15:33 invest in gender.

1:15:34 We have to invest in these financial cooperatives

1:15:38 where

1:15:38 we women get an equal.

1:15:40 It's not just in,

1:15:41 in,

1:15:42 I don't believe in

1:15:43 talking about excess but control on finance and for that I do believe.

1:15:48 That

1:15:48 you know

1:15:49 either it is in the board,

1:15:50 either it is in the membership,

1:15:52 either it is in NGM

1:15:54 either it is in,

1:15:55 you have to have women and

1:15:57 ownership of property,

1:15:59 ownership of businesses.

1:16:01 Economy is not going to grow

1:16:03 and per capita income of the whole population is not going to grow

1:16:08 unless women own their businesses and have an

1:16:11 equal share in

1:16:13 particularly financial sector.

1:16:17 Thank you,

1:16:18 Chetna,

1:16:18 we hear you.

1:16:20 So,

1:16:21 um,

1:16:22 Now,

1:16:23 let's move to

1:16:24 the way forward,

1:16:25 and we at Rabo Foundation

1:16:28 and World Bank

1:16:29 are very interested in disseminating good practice and sharing insights

1:16:34 both at uh with supervisors and governments and with financial cooperatives.

1:16:39 So,

1:16:40 uh,

1:16:40 let me take just a few seconds to share with you

1:16:44 some emerging recommendations that

1:16:47 we,

1:16:47 uh,

1:16:48 highlighted in our paper.

1:16:51 Our emerging recommendations are the following for governments and supervisors.

1:16:56 We have 4.

1:16:57 The first one is

1:16:59 require and help

1:17:01 for supervisors.

1:17:02 Require and help

1:17:04 cooperative financial institutions to report

1:17:06 gender desegregated data on membership,

1:17:09 on loans,

1:17:09 on savings.

1:17:10 What gets measured

1:17:12 gets managed.

1:17:13 So that would be our number 1 suggestion.

1:17:15 Our #2 suggestion would be require and help CFI,

1:17:19 cooperative Financial Institutions,

1:17:21 report to the credit bureau so that a data trail is generated for

1:17:25 CFIA clients.

1:17:26 And we didn't talk about it today,

1:17:28 but

1:17:28 with Chetna,

1:17:29 we talked earlier about

1:17:31 Mandey sharing credit scores

1:17:34 built on their women clients with other financial institutions,

1:17:38 and we think this idea is actually really interesting

1:17:41 and um this was some of the inspiration for

1:17:44 for that recommendation.

1:17:46 Number 3,

1:17:47 we would like that um to,

1:17:50 to suggest to promote gender-sensitive financial

1:17:53 education campaigns and ensure customer protection through

1:17:57 grievance mechanisms,

1:17:58 and that's very important and that came out from discussions with you,

1:18:01 Matthew,

1:18:02 and other people at SIFF who mentioned to us that,

1:18:05 yes,

1:18:06 they developed

1:18:07 uh specific products for women,

1:18:09 targeting women,

1:18:09 but actually,

1:18:10 when

1:18:11 they did so,

1:18:12 They faced

1:18:13 lots of challenges

1:18:15 with people actually taking advantage of some women that were

1:18:20 uh

1:18:21 that had limited financial education.

1:18:22 So,

1:18:23 so that's our third recommendation.

1:18:25 And our fourth recommendation is

1:18:29 to allow sound cooperative financial institutions to

1:18:30 benefit from existing partial credit guarantee schemes.

1:18:34 We know that there are many partial credit guarantee schemes in many countries,

1:18:38 but

1:18:39 Oftentimes,

1:18:40 financial cooperatives are not eligible

1:18:43 for these guarantees,

1:18:45 and

1:18:46 increasing,

1:18:47 making them eligible would

1:18:49 allow them to increase their outreach to women who oftentimes lack collateral.

1:18:54 So that would be

1:18:55 some of our emerging recommendations for supervisors for governments.

1:19:00 For

1:19:01 cooperatives themselves,

1:19:02 we have two

1:19:03 very high-level recommendations,

1:19:05 one for federations.

1:19:07 We believe that

1:19:08 they can play

1:19:09 an instrumental role in conducting the market research

1:19:12 to better

1:19:14 to better understand the specificities of women clients.

1:19:18 And also in product development.

1:19:21 And for financial cooperatives themselves,

1:19:24 we definitely invite financial cooperatives

1:19:26 to develop gender sensitive approaches,

1:19:29 but

1:19:29 whatever the,

1:19:30 the the best model is,

1:19:31 it could be a woman-only model like Mandii,

1:19:34 it could be a group approach

1:19:35 like see if,

1:19:36 it could be a household approach like Fed Invest,

1:19:39 but we think

1:19:40 uh all of these models could be interesting inspirations and references.

1:19:44 So,

1:19:45 let me turn now to our panelists for our final question before we close.

1:19:50 Do you have any further thoughts on key recommendations,

1:19:54 suggestions going forward?

1:19:56 Uh,

1:19:57 Albana,

1:19:57 you come from a country in Albania that

1:20:00 has very progressive rules and laws and legislation

1:20:04 to promote gender equality.

1:20:06 What,

1:20:07 what else do you think should be done in Albania

1:20:10 so that to promote inclusion of women in financial cooperatives?

1:20:15 Um,

1:20:17 so,

1:20:17 uh,

1:20:18 here the floor is mine because I come from the legal department and,

1:20:21 um,

1:20:22 I can say that in Albania,

1:20:24 uh,

1:20:24 the laws are very good,

1:20:26 uh,

1:20:26 they provide,

1:20:27 um,

1:20:28 uh,

1:20:28 very good,

1:20:29 uh,

1:20:29 uh,

1:20:30 the things,

1:20:30 uh,

1:20:31 because we follow the,

1:20:33 the recommendations or the laws

1:20:35 in the European Union.

1:20:37 Um,

1:20:40 Uh,

1:20:40 we do not discriminate,

1:20:42 uh,

1:20:43 uh,

1:20:43 women and men,

1:20:44 uh,

1:20:45 they have the same right,

1:20:46 uh,

1:20:46 they can,

1:20:47 uh,

1:20:47 co-sign the contract,

1:20:49 uh,

1:20:49 in the same way,

1:20:50 uh,

1:20:51 they can have in the same way and also the collateral,

1:20:54 uh,

1:20:55 they can open,

1:20:55 uh,

1:20:55 uh,

1:20:57 the account in the same way,

1:20:58 so,

1:20:59 um,

1:20:59 they have the same rights,

1:21:00 uh,

1:21:02 regarding the law.

1:21:03 What it happens in the practice or maybe in Fed Invest because we,

1:21:07 uh,

1:21:08 we are extended more in the rural area,

1:21:10 uh,

1:21:12 what we see is that we find difficulties in,

1:21:15 in,

1:21:15 uh,

1:21:15 making this uh happen.

1:21:18 Um.

1:21:19 Of course they have,

1:21:20 uh,

1:21:21 women and men have the same rights,

1:21:23 but,

1:21:23 um,

1:21:23 uh,

1:21:24 it's not that in practice happens always like this,

1:21:27 uh,

1:21:27 in our case,

1:21:28 uh,

1:21:28 what I,

1:21:29 uh,

1:21:30 what I see is that,

1:21:31 um,

1:21:32 mm,

1:21:33 our practice shows also that,

1:21:35 uh,

1:21:35 we have less,

1:21:36 um,

1:21:36 uh,

1:21:37 women member than uh than men than uh men,

1:21:40 uh,

1:21:41 so,

1:21:42 um.

1:21:44 Mm,

1:21:44 my recommendation about the,

1:21:46 the,

1:21:47 the law to,

1:21:48 to improve something about uh

1:21:50 uh women inclusion is

1:21:52 only to,

1:21:53 to have some uh uh fiscal facilities uh for,

1:21:57 for women,

1:21:57 for example,

1:21:58 for the start-up businesses,

1:22:00 uh,

1:22:01 the,

1:22:01 the taxes and fees zero for the beginning or,

1:22:04 or,

1:22:04 uh,

1:22:05 um,

1:22:06 to,

1:22:06 to.

1:22:08 Uh,

1:22:09 to have something,

1:22:10 uh,

1:22:10 something,

1:22:10 um,

1:22:11 mm,

1:22:12 simple or,

1:22:12 or a good example to follow in the beginning,

1:22:15 uh,

1:22:16 training to,

1:22:17 to,

1:22:18 to be sent to them,

1:22:19 um,

1:22:20 and also giving the answer,

1:22:22 uh,

1:22:22 for Bjorn,

1:22:23 uh,

1:22:24 from,

1:22:24 uh,

1:22:25 my side,

1:22:26 uh,

1:22:26 and,

1:22:27 uh,

1:22:27 as Fed Invest,

1:22:28 I think that,

1:22:29 uh.

1:22:30 Uh,

1:22:30 it's not that we are not near to,

1:22:32 to,

1:22:32 to our member,

1:22:33 we are very near to our members,

1:22:35 but,

1:22:35 uh,

1:22:36 we need more to hear them voice.

1:22:38 Uh,

1:22:39 saying this,

1:22:40 I repeat,

1:22:40 it's not that we do not hear their voice,

1:22:43 we are here to serve from,

1:22:45 uh,

1:22:45 for them and to give,

1:22:46 uh,

1:22:46 our best,

1:22:47 uh,

1:22:48 for,

1:22:48 for what they need.

1:22:50 Um,

1:22:51 if we,

1:22:51 if we,

1:22:53 uh,

1:22:53 give our services in a smoother way,

1:22:56 in a more simple way,

1:22:57 things will be better even for them.

1:23:00 Um,

1:23:01 Of course it's a good business to include uh woman uh in the finance,

1:23:05 but,

1:23:06 uh,

1:23:06 saying what,

1:23:07 uh,

1:23:08 I,

1:23:08 following what I said before about the,

1:23:10 the digitalization,

1:23:12 uh,

1:23:13 I can confirm that,

1:23:14 uh,

1:23:14 it's not simple for us to,

1:23:16 to,

1:23:17 to,

1:23:17 to launch,

1:23:18 uh,

1:23:18 our service Fed online,

1:23:20 uh,

1:23:21 because,

1:23:21 uh,

1:23:21 in the rural area there are some people that,

1:23:24 uh,

1:23:24 even do not have a cellphone.

1:23:27 Uh,

1:23:27 but we are trying to do our best,

1:23:29 uh,

1:23:29 our,

1:23:30 uh,

1:23:30 marketing campaigns and,

1:23:32 uh,

1:23:32 services,

1:23:33 uh,

1:23:34 are tend to go even in the rural areas.

1:23:36 So,

1:23:37 uh,

1:23:38 for the moment,

1:23:38 uh,

1:23:39 we are working like this.

1:23:41 Um,

1:23:42 these are,

1:23:43 these were my only two recommendations.

1:23:46 Uh,

1:23:46 perfect.

1:23:47 Thanks a lot,

1:23:48 Albana.

1:23:48 So fiscal incentives for women-owned,

1:23:51 uh,

1:23:51 businesses and also more investment in training

1:23:55 and,

1:23:56 uh,

1:23:56 I want to,

1:23:57 before I turn to,

1:23:58 um,

1:23:58 Chetna,

1:23:59 uh,

1:24:00 everyone,

1:24:00 please feel free to share your thoughts

1:24:03 and recommendations in the chat panel and also

1:24:06 in,

1:24:06 uh,

1:24:07 by,

1:24:07 uh,

1:24:08 sending us an email at um.

1:24:11 Uh,

1:24:11 CFI gender feedback at gmail.com.

1:24:15 Uh,

1:24:16 Chetna,

1:24:17 what,

1:24:17 I know you faced several

1:24:19 regulatory and legal hurdles in setting up Mandey.

1:24:23 What would be your number one advice,

1:24:25 uh,

1:24:25 to governments,

1:24:26 to,

1:24:26 to supervisors to promote financial inclusion?

1:24:31 So the,

1:24:33 the most important,

1:24:34 sorry,

1:24:35 sorry,

1:24:35 I think Matthew wanted to say something,

1:24:37 uh,

1:24:38 quickly,

1:24:39 sorry,

1:24:39 Chetna.

1:24:41 OK,

1:24:41 no,

1:24:41 Matthew has issues with connection.

1:24:46 Uh

1:24:49 OK.

1:24:50 Thank you,

1:24:51 Matthieu.

1:24:53 Go ahead.

1:24:56 Can,

1:24:56 can you?

1:24:58 Yes.

1:25:00 I mean

1:25:02 Yes,

1:25:02 we do.

1:25:11 So

1:25:13 Before

1:25:16 Uh,

1:25:16 I want

1:25:17 to provide my remission.

1:25:19 First one is,

1:25:19 uh,

1:25:20 what our solution is more focused on the clients approach.

1:25:25 Yeah,

1:25:26 listen,

1:25:26 this is

1:25:30 the best

1:25:31 to.

1:25:36 To invest

1:25:38 Sorry,

1:25:38 Matthew,

1:25:39 the connection is not good actually.

1:25:41 So

1:25:42 I think uh we will,

1:25:44 thank you a lot

1:25:45 and uh say goodbye and turn to Che.

1:25:51 So one thing I would like to say is that,

1:25:53 as I've been emphasizing is that

1:25:56 um

1:25:57 law is there but I do think that the most important part

1:26:01 for on the gender issue if we really want to address is ownership of property rights.

1:26:07 And

1:26:08 with that we need governments to give the incentive

1:26:12 to

1:26:12 See that women own property.

1:26:15 Once they have that laws are there,

1:26:17 but still their culture is very different,

1:26:20 so that is one.

1:26:21 And I do think we have not much discussed,

1:26:24 but

1:26:24 with the digitalization,

1:26:26 not only for women,

1:26:28 but this whole cybersecurity

1:26:30 will be a very big issue

1:26:32 and how do you

1:26:34 Uh,

1:26:35 it would be a very,

1:26:36 uh,

1:26:37 different exercise and tricky exercise

1:26:39 about the cybersecurity

1:26:42 and the trust.

1:26:43 These are the two things I find it very important.

1:26:48 Perfect.

1:26:49 Thanks a lot Chetna.

1:26:50 Thanks a lot Albana.

1:26:51 Thanks a lot,

1:26:52 Matthew and everyone in the audience.

1:26:54 I think uh we're coming to the end of our webinar.

1:26:57 I want to thank

1:26:58 all of you for this really fruitful discussion.

1:27:01 In terms of next steps,

1:27:02 we will update,

1:27:04 improve,

1:27:04 uh,

1:27:05 our paper based on all this discussion we had and also

1:27:09 from the feedback you may share with us uh by email.

1:27:12 We'll wait for your feedback uh uh before the end.

1:27:15 Of this week.

1:27:16 And also,

1:27:17 uh,

1:27:17 please,

1:27:18 everyone stay tuned for future events.

1:27:22 Here you see a list of upcoming webinars,

1:27:25 so

1:27:26 all of you interested in gender,

1:27:28 please feel free to look at the Mercy Corps Agrofin annual uh learning event,

1:27:33 lots,

1:27:33 lots of events before the end of the month.

1:27:35 And for all of you interested in financial cooperatives,

1:27:38 we have in mid-July,

1:27:39 another event that we will organize on

1:27:42 Cooperative financial institutions in the context of fragility,

1:27:46 conflict,

1:27:47 and violence.

1:27:48 And with this,

1:27:49 I would like to thank all of you and say goodbye.

1:27:55 Thank you,

1:27:55 thank you,

1:27:55 bye.

1:27:56 Thank you,

1:27:57 everyone.

1:27:57 Bye bye.

1:27:58 Thank you.

1:28:01 Bye.

showAllTimestamps
no
transcript
Hi everyone, just er if I could ask everyone to mute your mics please, when you're not speaking, that would be great so that we can all hear each other. Uh, welcome everyone to our webinar on Including Women in Financial cooperatives, Uphill Battle or Good Business. Uh, please everyone mute your mic, um, and I will start my video, um. Yeah, so my name is Rachel Sparrow Kessler, and I work at the World Bank. Um, focusing on agriculture finance, rural finance, and financial cooperatives, and very happy to be with you today. Over to you, Ruby. Thank you, Rachel. Also welcome from my side. My name is Ruby Garcia Kumaran, and I work for Rabo Partnerships with the, which is a department of the Rabobank, focusing on financial inclusion, private sector development, and food security. And I mainly focus on uh cooperative development, and I'm very glad and honored to be part of this webinar today, and I look forward to the insights that it's gonna bring us. Perfect. So, this webinar is organized as part of the partnership between the World Bank, Rabo Partnerships, and Rabo Foundation to strengthen financial cooperatives around the world. Um, in this, uh, partnership, we have, um, two components. One is the Country program, operational projects, and another component is the knowledge work through our Center of Excellence. And I think Ruby just, uh, shared the, the link to our website. And this Center of Excellence is focused on disseminating knowledge on financial cooperatives. So we're organizing this webinar today on including women in Financial cooperatives, an uphill Battle for Good Business. This is a very special webinar. Uh, before I introduce the topic, a few housekeeping issues. One, please meet your, uh, mics when you're not speaking. Second, this meeting is recorded, so, um, so that it can be shared with other people after the awards, but, uh, let's keep an informal tone even though it's recorded. Uh, so it's a very special webinar. Uh, because it's a special topic, uh, but also because we have a special format for it. So the topic itself, I think, is very special. Um, our Center of Excellence has focused on a variety of topics over the past, uh, years on deposit insurance, on digitization, on the impact of COVID, and a range of transversal topics. The first time we talk about gender and gender has become a priority uh within the financial inclusion community, and, uh, Greta Boll, who is the CEO of CGAP, recently said, we have to put a gender lens on everything we do. So, this is a crucial topic for financial inclusion and it's the first time we explore the specific role of financial cooperatives to close the gender gap in financial inclusion. What's the role of financial cooperatives? Do they really serve women? Do they really include women? Can they really play a role in closing the gender gap? Let's discuss this today. So that's our special topic. It's also a special format because, um, for this webinar, because this is not a starting point discussion. This is actually more of a midpoint discussion. We've actually worked on a draft paper on this topic, together, World Bank and Rabo Foundation, and we, uh, we shared this, uh, paper. I think Ruby just shared the link, uh, in the chat panel. Uh, and so this, the goal of this webinar is to share some insights from this draft paper. And also to get some feedback from our panelists, but also from the audience. So please, everyone, feel free to put in the chat panel any question, any comments you may have on this paper, or also, after our webinar, please feel free to share your thoughts by writing us uh on this uh email address CFI gender feedback@gmail.com, which is also in the chat panel now. So, Special format and also final thing, because we wanna hear from you, this is not gonna be the typical webinar where we have a 1 hour discussion and then a 5 minute Q&A. No, we have organized the webinar in 3 themes, and at the end of each theme, we will have a Q&A. So now that we know that it's a special topic in a special format, let me turn to our very special panelists, and we have uh two distinguished speakers for opening remarks. Um, we will have uh Daya Belchica and then, uh, uh, Lena. Koummopoulos, um, and Daya is the lead technical, uh, specialist on gender targeting and social inclusion at IFAD, which is the International Fund for Agricultural Development, the international institution focused on rural economy transformation. And, um, and then we will hear from Lena Giacomopoulos, and she is the program director of uh the Global Women's Leadership Network at WOCCU, uh, the World Council of Credit Unions. So we'll first hear from Daya about general thoughts on why it's important to include women and to Uh, to why it's important to close the gender gap in rural development and rural finance, and then we'll focus on financial cooperatives and why it's important to close the gender gap in financial cooperatives. So, um, let's start with, uh, Nya. Uh, I, can you turn on your camera? Hello, Ndaya. Yes, my camera is on. Can you see it? Perfect. OK, how are you? I'm fine, thank you. How are you? Good, thank you so much for, for being here. Uh, so tell us, Daya, uh, IFA has a strong priority on gender, why is that? And can you share with us, um, what you're doing in that space? Sure. Um, thank you so much, uh, Rachel. Thank you. Good morning, everyone. Good afternoon. So, it's a pleasure to be here. Um, so let me briefly introduce IFAD to you for those who are not familiar with my institution. So, IFAD, uh, is both a UN agency and international financial institution with a mandate to invest to empower the rural women and men to lead their own development. So we are still finishing the 2020 report. So let just me share some few numbers, 2019 numbers with you. So we had uh 200, about 200 ongoing projects with an outreach of 131 million, roughly 50% of women, and EA financing amount to 7.5 billion, with about 9.2 billion of domestic and international co-financing. That's what the numbers. So, IFAD's mandate strongly rests on the principle of gender equality, primarily because it is the right thing to do. And secondly, as Rachel mentioned, it is also, it makes perfect business sense. Over the past decades, IFAD made the commitment to look at all its investments through the lens of gender and to mainstream gender it's, in its portfolio. So learning from evidence and experience in the field, it has evolved from mainstreaming gender in its portfolio to now adopt what we call gender transformative approaches which identify the root causes of gender inequality of women disempowerment. In that trajectory, so IFAD is promoting gender equality and women's empowerment at one of these commitments and continues to learn and improve as we continue to develop and implement the project. So let me share with you one example of a recently concluded Desashwini project. It's a rural women empowerment project in India. The project transformed the lives of thousands of poor women in the low-income state of Madhya Pradesh in central India. Women from over 24,000 240,000 rural households targeted by the program took steps to change their lives by being enrolled in 18,000 self-help groups. Those self-help groups were a conduit for women to do a number of things. They were able to acquire awareness on how to use kitchen gardens to save money and substantially improve the nutritional status of the households. They increased income. Through some self-reflection and community support, they empowered themselves to devise a solution to their own problems. And they also organize themselves for collective actions at different levels, at the village level but also at the federal level. Key to this approach used by the program were the self-help groups, which gave women the power to make decisions and for many, for the first time in their lives to actually gain control over their lives, make decisions for themselves and for their loved ones within the households. The groups also facilitated savings and credit and enabled women to resolve common situations such as gender-based violence, premature marriages, and cases of suspected future trafficking through what is called the Courage Brigades. The Kurdish Brigades, which stem from self-help groups have been so successful that they've been replicated by the government across all the districts in the Maya Pradesh. Let's talk about scaling up. A very good example just has to show how powerful this can be. I just want to share with you briefly the story of Rega Pradham, who at age 34 is an inspiring example of what can be achieved through projects that aim not only to improve the livelihoods, income, and nutrition, but also to seek to increase women's empowerment. Rika was born in a poor family, and she joined the Self-help groups in 2008. A few years later, she then represented her village and the village as well as the community at the federal level, and 10 years later, she ended up representing the project at the 2017 Commission on the Status of Women in New York while she had never traveled before. Bringing now to the lens of rural finance, we can see that even through that project, finance was also an important instrument. What we've recently done at IFAD, we conducted a synthesis evaluation to understand what would work and then what can be improved in the case of rural finance. What we were able to see was that there were significant gender results when we look at the financial institutions that were community-based financial organizations. While when we look at the commercial banks, credit union, and other credit cooperatives, the gender performance was not so strong. One of the reasons that some of the community-based financial organizations were relatively successful is because they did a number of things. One is that they were based on One is that they were based primarily on focusing on the institutions that were targeting women. They also offered very small loan size, so in a sense they were self-targeting women, given that many of the women were involved in the informal economy. And also they were linking the financial services with some empowerment, which enabled the women to feel a lot more confident into taking on new services and new activities. Looking at the rural financial services, we can see there are two sides to look at it if we want to strengthen and provide better services to rural women. They are on the demand side as well on the supply side. On the demand side, and I will be very brief, I would just touch on the fact that income and access to collateral, as well as some constraint with some procedures. Prevent women from having a broad access to financial services. Typically women are involved in the informal economy. They do not have access to land, which is one of the primary collateral, and therefore when we do not provide those services, it is unlikely that they would benefit from loans or even for other services. Another issue on the demand side is the lack of education or the lack of financial literacy, as well as the lack of access to information, because this one, when we look at the education, it is in fact a gateway to access technology and information. And if there is a lack of education, then the illiteracy related to finance would also enable, prevent the women to have or to develop self-confidence in order to access a different type of services. On the supply side, there are a number of things that we can address or to look at. One is that very rarely are the staff trained into providing the relevant services to women. And most of them are men. Within those institutions. Also, women are not represented. So therefore, when it comes time to develop the relevant financial services, they are not giving a voice to develop the services that they might need for home care or then for their businesses, and this could be explained by a number of things. And equally important, many of those institutions do not have. They don't necessarily consider gender as a priority, and very few of them would have gender in the vision or in the mission statements or would actually even have indicators that would track gender per se. So we see that there are a number of inadequate service, um, and Uh, products. I know that now you're gonna be discussing the good practices as well as focusing on innovation and tailored approaches, and as such, I will turn this over to the next speaker. Thank you very much. Thank you so much, Ninaya. That was a great opening statement. Over to you, um, over to you, uh, Lena, um, what, uh, what's happening at WC? Why do you focus especially on gender and what do you do at the Global Women's Leadership Network to close the gender gap? Thank you, Rachel, and, and if I may ask you to uh speak in less than 5 minutes, that would be great. Thank you. Thank you. Uh, good morning, good afternoon, and good evening, I should say, everyone. Uh, thank you for having me join you today. I'm really excited to be here. And, you know, listening to the previous speaker, and, uh, uh, first, let me give everyone a little, uh, background to GWL and, um, an, an initiative that began by the World Council actually in 2009. And it was initiated by Women working in, uh, cooperatives in financial, in credit unions in South America. And they asked if we had a place where women could get together, could join each other, and actually support one another and talk about their advancement of their development in the credit union space. And that's literally how the program came to be. And as we fast forward to where we are today. For the world, uh, for Global Women's Leadership Network. Uh, the program has engaged more than 4500 women and men, uh, in 86 countries to date, um, since its inception. So, it's very exciting to see. And I have to, to, to stress that the work that we do is working together with women and men. OK? We have to engage our male counterparts. This isn't about, uh, um, solely a woman. Issue or a man issue. This is a workplace issue and if we want to be able to continue making it be good business and actually better business for our organizations, we need to focus on working together with our colleagues. That's, that's the one big thing that we stress, uh, through GWLN. Now, on, on a more localized and individualized level, I should say, how we function for GWLN and how we work together is through a mechanism we call. All our sister societies, which are, it is the way that credit union women, uh, leaders, CEOs, board members, and industry partners in various parts of the world get together at a more localized level and are able to discuss the topics that are affecting their credit union, how they can function better as businesses. Look at strategies and ways that they can increase and get more women on their boards, more women in leadership. Roles and look at other issues that on a more personal level are going to be able to empower women to do what they do every day in their lives. And um presently we have about 145 of these sister societies in nearly 30 countries through GWLN. So there, there are a lot of ways that all of this comes together. I think it's important for us to see in different parts of the world what we're doing, you know, in Asia, it is about giving. Women access to, to, to capital and giving them a loans so they can conduct their businesses, entrepreneurs, and, and startups. In Africa, it is about showing the younger generation of women that they can have that seat at the table, that there are women who are on boards, and that the diversity, equity and inclusion is an important part of, of their credit unions. In, in South America, they talk about cultural bias and seeing. How they're, they're, they're dealing with it in their part of the world. So, there are different types of approaches, I, I would say in, in our different parts of the world. There isn't a one answer and uh one tool all across the board, but it's important for us to continue focusing on the impact that our network is making. And that's what it is. It, it is a network, and we learn from one another. And many times when we have these sister society meetings, one of the first questions that comes up is, Look at the board, look at your board, look at your credit union board, or look at the leadership team in your credit union, in your financial cooperative. How many women do you have on that board? OK. And um if you think you don't have a seat at that table at that board, you're wrong, and you need another woman or another man to pull that seat up for you and have you join in. So, it is about empowering women, but it's about creating allies, finding the strength in the network, and working together. Because, you know, pre-COVID, we, we've seen the data, you know, the World Economic Forum told us that we needed 99.5 years to close the gender gap. And now, we're at 137 years. So, that's an entire generation. That the COVID the pandemic has pushed us back. And that makes us want to continue doing what we're doing and, and realize how important it is of the work that we're doing for future generations, not just for our, our, our work today. So, yes, it is good business, and I say we need to continue doing uh uh what we're doing to make it even better business. Thank you, Rachel. Fantastic. Thank you so much, Lena. And if I hear you correctly, you're saying that one size doesn't fit all and there's not one model of inclusion of women in financial cooperatives, and I think this is something we'll discuss with panelists uh today. Before we do that, uh, I'd like to share with you a few insights, um, From our draft paper and uh Lena and Daya you're welcome to stay and ask any questions and comments in the chat panel. So here are a few insights from our uh paper, from our draft paper. You, you see my screen, right? Perfect. So, when we started uh researching this topic of inclusion of women in financial cooperatives, our first thought was, please, uh, everyone, you could mute yourself, that would be great. Our first thought was, what is the share of women in, let me just, uh, mute that person, uh. I have one person who is uh or Jaya you could do it uh isn't this if Jaya you could uh mute that person that would be great. Um, so, um, when we started researching this topic, uh, our first thought was, let's look at the share, oops, I think we still have a little, uh, technical issue. Joan, uh. OK, good. Thank you. So, again, when we started researching this topic, our first thought was, let's look at the share of women in the membership of credit unions, and to do so, we turned to Wu and we looked at Woku reports that gather a lot of data on credit unions worldwide and We have data on assets and number of members and savings and credits, but we couldn't find gender disaggregated data on membership, so we thought that was an interesting finding in itself. Give me a second to try to find this. Maybe let's try headphones. Maybe the sound. Um, and, uh, and so we thought, OK, so then we don't have much data, but, uh, walker shared with us some data on the share of women in as board members and as seniors of credit unions, and I think here the number that stands out is the 60%. percent of CEOs in Europe that are women, but besides that number, we see that actually women account for a minority of board members and CEOs worldwide. I'm sorry, I'm just trying to fix this issue, uh. OK. And um so, uh, so yes, besides that, especially in developing countries, uh, the share of women among board members and CEOs is less than 30%. So we didn't have much data on women in membership of credit unions, so we thought, OK, then let's just pick. Specific corporate um er financial cooperatives and understand to which extent they serve and include women and ask them how they do it, how successful they are, what are their challenges and opportunities they seek. We wanted to select financial cooperatives that had developed gender-sensitive approaches for a long time. We wanted to learn from them, and that's why we selected 3, based on interviews with experts. We selected Mandesi, CIFF, and FedInvest. Mandeshi, just to give you a snapshot of these 3 organizations, and we have representatives from these 3 organizations today. Mandeshi is in India, has about 30,000 members, $85 million USD in assets, and it's a women-only cooperative. So men can actually save at Mandeshi, but they cannot get credit. They cannot become members. CIF is the Confederation des Institutional Financier the DAR de West, so it's the Confederation of Financial Institutions in West Africa. It covers 6 networks of um financial cooperatives in 5 countries Benin, Togo, Senegal, Mali, Burkina Faso. It's Uh, it covers 4.5 million members, $1.5 billion USD in assets, so much larger than Mandeshi, and it's not only focused on women, it's an open cooperative or mixed cooperative, but it offers specific products to women, and it has developed what we call a group approach, so mainly joint liability groups. Finally, Fed Invest is the first microfinance institution in Albania, covers 78,000 members, about $60 million USD in assets, and again, it's open to anyone, so men and women, and it doesn't have specific products for women. So, men and women have access to exactly the same products. However, uh, Fed Invest has developed what they call the household approach, and we'll hear about that. For all of these three organizations, we started the conversation with them, asking them the exact same question. What's the share of, uh, women in your membership? What's the share of women in your employees? What's the share of women at the board? For Mandesi, by design, they are a women-only cooperative, so 100% of their members are women. At SIF, 38% of their members are women. At Fed Invest, 37% of members are women. So we thought, OK, so what do these numbers mean? Is 38% of members at CIFF a good number? Does it mean they are inclusive? We started debating on this and on the interpretation of these numbers, and what we did was We decided to benchmark these cooperative financial institutions to other financial institutions in their country. So we actually asked for CIF that focuses on 5 countries to give us country-level data membership, and we used Findex data. So Findex data about the share of women with account at a financial institution. We converted that number into the share of women account holders in total number of account numbers, uh holders. And we compare that number to the share of women in selected CFI's membership. And here is what we, we, we, we got. Some CFIs are less inclusive than other financial institutions in terms of women inclusion. We see at the top, displayed in red, India, Senegal, Benin. These are the financial cooperatives that include women in their membership more than other financial institutions, but all the others are less inclusive of women than other financial institutions. We were surprised by this because these networks are actually selected based on the fact that they have developed gender sensitive approaches and gender strategies for a long time. So, why is that? Why do we have some financial cooperatives that are less inclusive than other financial institutions of women? And in our paper, we have two types of factors that we suggest. First types of factors are external factors. So, the fact that finance that financial cooperatives operate in rural areas where perhaps there are stronger gender norms or where women have more challenges in accessing assets in in financial education. Perhaps this is the reason why we see these, these gender gaps. But we also think that there might be also internal factors in the way financial cooperatives operate. Perhaps it could be that this inclusive, I mean it could be that this collective decision process in financial cooperatives, perhaps it could be that it doesn't really work well for Some women in rural areas that are mobility and time constraints. So, here are some initial thoughts, and of course, we want to highlight that some cooperatives are better equipped than others to serve and include women. So, with that, I would like to hand it over to Ruby to discuss this in more details. Thank you. Thank you, Rachel, and having summarized the main findings of our paper, I think uh it is time to hear the insights on this from our distinguished panelists. So it is my pleasure to introduce them to you. Um, on the panel, we have Chetna Sinha, who is the founder and chairperson of the Mandeshi Bank and Mandeshi Foundation in India. We have Madieu, Matthieu Suglonu, who is the general director of CIF, and we have Albana Beta, the head of the legal department of uh Fed Invest in Albania. So a very warm welcome to all of you and thank you very much for joining the panel. Uh, before I will give the word to you, I would like to quickly explain the structure of today's webinar. We will first focus on the why and the how of including women in financial cooperatives, followed by the potential of digitization to improve women's inclusion, and lastly, recommendations to cooperatives and governments. And as Rachel already said, the chat box is open for all participants, so we would still encourage you to actively use this in case of any. Uh, questions or comments arise, and then, uh, Rachel and I will make sure to handle them at the right time. So the 3 financial institutions we have selected all have a specific way to include women, and they have all developed a specific strategy over the years. But as we saw in Rachel's introduction, these three ways also differ from each other. Uh, Chetna, I would like to start with you because at Mandeshi, you have the women-only model. Can you explain to us why you chose for this model, and does this also indicate that women alone represent a sufficient business case for financial cooperatives to be profitable? I see Chetna is in the chats. Are you on mute, Jenna? Rachel, maybe you can unmute the. Chenna Yeah, uh, it was locked centrally from your side. Yeah. So sorry for that, and am I audible? Yes, yeah, so, uh, thanks, Rubi, and I mean thanks Rubika and thanks Rachel for inviting me to share my experiences and your question that why did I choose to do that. Uh, in fact, very honestly, It was not like decided or chosen. I, I mean, I was, I never thought that I would start a women's bank, Women's cooperative Bank. Um, that was. It was just that I was uh very young, at a very young age. I was, when I was doing my undergraduate program, I got into Gandhian organization and I visited some villages which were drought affected. And when I saw the life there, then I decided that I'll be staying there and work there. And I'm married to my husband who is a farmer from this village, must work where I started the bank. And when I was staying with my husband here, some women came to me and they wanted to do savings. And so I went with them to the banks. To get their accounts open because these one, these women wanted to do savings. One of them, uh, who you can see a film on YouTube also, Tanta Bai, who was a street vendor. So, but the banks denied opening the account of these women. And why? Because their savings were too small, that is why. In fact, they were not even asking interest on that. They were ready to pay a fee for their savings administration. In spite of that, banks thought that they are not an affordable client. So then when I saw that, I felt that if banks are not opening the account, why not start a bank for women, those who are street vendors, those who are so active throughout their lives economically. And they need the bank most because they want to save it every day. So then I went to Central Bank of India, Reserve Bank of India, that how can we start a bank for women like Kamtabai, and I was told that there is the only window where you can start a women's bank is through a cooperative. And so then we thought we'll apply for the banking license. So it was like no pre-planned or something, but it was very clear that our women wanted to do banking, our women wanted to do savings, and the big banks were not ready to do because their businesses were too small for them. And so then we thought, why not, and we applied for the banking license. The journey was not very easy. The license was rejected by the Central Bank of India. And you know why? Because the our women did not have a signatures. They had a thumb impression because they couldn't read and write. And the central bank said that we cannot issue a license to the bank who's promoting members are. I was devastated, but women were very clear. They said that we learn to read and write. We applied again. And at that time, 15 women accompanied me and they challenged the officer. They said we cannot read and write, but we can count. And they challenged the officers, asking them that ask us to calculate the interest of any principal amount. If we fail, don't issue the license, but tell your officers to do it without a calculator and see who can calculate faster. Needless to say, we've got the banking license. It is the first rural women's bank in India, and I'm so proud to share with you, Ruby, that, you know, when this, when, when women were coming forward, everybody said that these women cannot read and write, but today we are one of the largest rural women's bank in the. Country and the other banks which were cooperative banks which were started by like very powerful people, member of parliament and all. Our bank is bigger than that, that, and not only that, I am also so proud that actually we have two types of membership. One is that membership of AGM, an annual general meeting. Where we have more than 37,000 women now, but the other is that the general membership, a general membership with the bank, we have more than 600,000. Now when I say that, it's very interesting that as I said that it wasn't that I chose to set up this bank. Women chose to have the bank. And you know when women decide what happens. So now we have a business school for rural women who have never been to the school. We have schools at doorstep with the buses, we have digital buses which go doorstep, and we have radio which is operated by them. And our, our bank is managed by 100% women. Most of us are nearly 94% of our employees are women. But now for diversity, because a lot of people are asking us now that why no men. So we have some of the men as a part of the diversity in our institution. But having said all this, I would just like I've narrated the thing that we are working with now we have foundation also with the bank, but while operating with the bank, what are the things which I learned from women? Number 1, you cannot read and write, but you can count and manage the finance. Number 2, that even with the small businesses, you all are. Your cooperative bank can be profitable and sustainable. It may not have a huge balance sheet, but it, and then so we are very proud that some banks were bigger than us, but today they are not, they don't even exist. But our bank has been sustained and for the last 15 years, our women are getting dividends. And it is the first rural Women's Bank where the bank was able to give dividend to its member. So with this, I would just like to share with you that, you know, these are the lessons I have learned from our women and one of the biggest lessons I've learned from them is that understand the cash flow. Listen to women, design the product according to their needs. These are very, very important things. And so we do not really have cash credit for street vendors. And when I was going to Taos to co-chair World Forum, I asked our women, you know. So many people come and cars where we talk about billions and trillions. What should I speak to them? What should I tell them? You know what our women said? They said, go and tell them that our courage is. And the second thing they said, which always equals me, and that is that never give poor solutions to poor people, and that is possible when women lead the organization. So thank you so much. Always very inspiring to hear Mandeshi stories and thank you very much. Good to hear that currently women do represent a good business case for Mandeshi. Uh, I would like to go over to Matthieu. Matthieu, are you in the call and available to answer a question? Yes, uh, Ruby and Rachel, I do. I am the, can you hear me? Yes, great. Hi. Thank you for joining. Uh, I was wondering because, uh, at Mondeshi, they have the women-only model, and at SIF you have applied a different approach, namely the group approach. And why do you think at SIF it is important to include women and what do you, have you done specifically to do so? Thank you. Thank you for giving me the opportunity to tell about what SIF is doing in West Africa. To include Women financially and to cover the gender gap at this level. Why it's important for us to employ women, you know, in West Africa specifically, there is like some division of labor between women and men when it's come to administrate the households. While the man is focused on the big investments like the, the house, or the assets, the big assets of the family. Women is more focused on day to day. Resources to cover Needs such as foods, such as uh scholarship for, for, for young people, for, for, for their children, etc. Uh, and also women in West Africa. Uh, appear like the Very suck of the developments at the local level. When women have resources. In West Africa, particularly. They're more focused on the behavior, to improve the behavior of the family. I'm sorry, I'm a man, but women are more focused on how to improve the health of family than uh men in West Africa. And uh also the women is respecting their commitment when it's come to pay back the credits. So, why we chose to provide. Some financial services to women in West Africa. How we, we, we proceed. We proceeds by a group approach. Uh, specifically by using what, what, what we call, uh, to plan iffier, it's something to, uh, allow women. To provide every day. Some resources in terms of uh saving every day and to be able to raise the money at the end of the month. With the institution. And, and we create a group. Uh, and in each group, the group of 30. 50 independent women. Who Every day A deposits. To be able to raise The money at the end of the month or to get credits. The experience we, we, we did with uh Benin physical in Benin. Right now, we have uh uh we have 60,000 women. We collects. 40 million Yes I still Uh yeah. It means that women have capacity to save. And also we provide them credits to develop their business. In Burkina Faso, we developed some specific products with uh FCPB. Much Financial services with financial literacy. And also we Reproductive and sexual. sensitization to to empower women. To make the choice. Decides whether they could do the term. For children or to use the term for the business that they negotiate this term. In the family with the husband. We learn is that when we combine. A financial product with financial literacy. And sexual reposition. Education. We get more results of women. And where We provide only the financial services. What we learn is also that we need to Identify The value value chain where women is more focused. And develop specific products. To target the needs of women. In this value chain. What we learned also is that sometimes The lack of Having the ID cards. Lack of access to lands. Oh, the lack of access to education. Sometime Appear as a barrier for women to access financial services. We also learned that when women walk. And assess responsibility in financial cooperative. Local level. Some of them were able. To become a political leader. In their community, in their region, or at national level. And be, and to be elected like parliamentary mayor, and so on. Why we commit ourselves to continue to increase. With access to financial services within its network. Thank you. Thank you so much. It's very interesting to hear that uh by developing specific products, it has managed to reach women. And as we heard in the introduction, it's not one size fits all. So it's really interesting to see that in different countries, you have also uh developed different products. Albana at Fan Invest, you have a long history of focusing on women inclusion, and one of the tools through which you do this is the household approach or the co-signing of spouses. Can you elaborate a bit more on this and why you think it is so important to use this in including women in Fed Invest? Uh yes. Uh, hello, everyone. Uh my name is Albana. Uh, I represent here, uh, FedInvest, uh, which is the, the, uh, microfinance institution established in 1992 in Albania. Uh, so it's, uh, I can proudly say the oldest one operating in Albania. Uh, we count now, uh, 63 branches. Uh, we operate in almost Uh, 2000 small villages and uh we have uh nearly 78,000 members. We are focused in the rural areas and uh we serve to different clients, uh, from them who are excluded from the financial services and banking services to them who might need uh an SME. Uh, we are a cooperative governance, uh, so we are a mixed structure, uh, made from the administrative staff and also elected people, um. In Fed Invest, we believe that uh women and men, same in the same boat, so, uh, we are not here to, to differentiate uh women from men, uh, or vice versa. Uh, important for us is, uh, not to exclude women from the financial services and products. So we offer the same services, the same products, the same trainings for women and men, but, uh, what we see is the difference in the product usage because Uh, of the type of the product and uh how they are involved, um. From our practice, we understood and we learned that uh uh women tend to work more uh in tailor shop or uh as a hairdresser, um, in agritourism and uh also in the family farm together with their husbands. um. We know also uh from our practice that um because uh we offer not only credit but also deposit products and we know that uh women uh know uh better than men uh how to save um. I believe this is because they feel less comfortable with borrowing beyond their needs or to to put the family finance in over indebtedness, so for them it's important to take smaller loans, but they are responsible because they have, they have better repayment loans regarding the contract, the credit contract, we co-signed the contract both from the husband and the wife. Uh, so we make this not only to empower women but also to let them know about the loan, the, the conditions of the loan, how to repay this and things like this. So, um, this is our way to ensure that the household does not borrow beyond its needs, uh, but it is also more comfortable for the family members to, to prior discuss and to, to take the decision together for the loan, um, uh, they will not only feel more comfortable but also more sure about this decision, uh, discussing and, uh, and taking this decision together, uh. Women play an important role in the family finance. Um, Anyway, um, Our experience has shown that it is important uh also uh what our loan officers do because uh they go to to the member to go our members and uh they explain the conditions of the contract, uh uh what is foreseen in the agreement, what they need to do, uh, and we try to do this uh in the same way with the husband and with the wife or with both people who signed the contract. Um, this is what, uh, in general we do in Fed Invest, of course, our practice is, uh, is very long, um, but I, I I try to keep in simple words. Great, thank you so much, Alvanna, and I think that explains really well how Fed Invest uses the household uh approach to uh better include women, but also to prevent uh people from borrowing beyond their needs. Um, Rachel, is there any questions? Yes, absolutely. We have a question from Berhan Kidano, uh, about, uh, financial and non-financial services for women, and the question is, to what extent do projects consider it seriously bundling of non-financial with financial services and set aside budgets accordingly? Who among our speakers would like to take that question? Chetna, yeah, shall I. It's the one thing, I mean, uh. While, uh, when we started bank, actually, um, nobody was talking about financial literacy. Nobody was talking about business literacy, nobody. But I remember that in 1999, our women themselves, they said that you know, we are taking loans but we would like to understand more about businesses, about market, about, you know, how can we, how can we reduce the cost of our products and, and so, and as Rachel men mentioned that, you know, the women don't like to take more bigger size loan also. It's very they're very conservative in that approach. So I do see that you know when women come to financial institution, they always want the financial service, other services than financial, and that was the reason in fact, it Mandehi, a bank is totally, there's no outside investors, it's women's money, women's bank, women's credit, women's saving, women's profit. But then we found the foundation for the non-financial. Because our financial institution cannot afford to do that and so that is a separate, uh, foundation we did it and that's why I always think that when you work with women because there are many issues, right, the whole ecosystem is operating against them. Like they don't have collateral. They don't get enough. There is no parity as far as education is concerned in many countries. So when such situation is there, you do require a non-financial services and particularly to women or a low income. And so it's very important that how do you address that? And now that is the, I mean, yeah, the reply to the question. Thank you. Um, Rachel, I saw another question. Yes, we have one more question before we move to the next block. We talked a lot about inclusion of women in membership, but we have a question of Juan Bona on what actions do the three entities undertake to facilitate an active participation of women in the. The General Assembly. Do you also promote participation of women in management. So perhaps we could hear from Matthieu. Um, what do you, do you do in terms of, uh, improving the inclusion of women at the board and, uh, among your, uh, employees and the management? OK, thank you. What is, what it is easy for us to do is to include women in the bods. And also in the, the, the, the Top management. That's when it's coming to the membership. It provides Product that meets the needs of women. To participate in the general assembly. To be honest, sometimes women choose to pursue their business and to call a political issue as generally assembly. We continue to provide uh some sensibization, some financial education or financial literacy to them. To make sure that they they be a part of the decision. They're taken at a local level concerning the financial cooperative. That's, it's a process. Because they need To make a choice between come to assembly or to go for their business. And usually, most of them choose to go for the business because They are not the majority when it's come for election. And when in some society in West Africa, when the husbands are there, women cannot be elected unless she has authorization from her husband. It's, it's a process, a social process. They work on it. Thank you. Thank you, Mair. I hope that answers one's question as well. Uh, and now that we know a bit more about the why and the how, I think we can move on to digitization because all three institutions have mentioned digitization as one of the ways going forward to better include women. And, uh, to us, it seems that this can go both ways. So on the one hand, we have, uh, demands, so, uh, for the women. And on the other hand, the supply side, we have the financial cooperatives. But this also raises some questions, um, because Chetna, uh, you mentioned that, uh, Mandeshi's clients, uh, have a strong interest in digital financial products. Um, you even mentioned that they see smartphones as the gateway to the world. But uh we also see a gender gap in India when it comes to phone uh ownership and mobile money usage. So do you think uh that uh women and then especially in lower income segments in rural areas will truly benefit from the development of digital financial services? So responding to the, your question, I would say that, you know, it's very interesting that anything new comes in the household. Who gets the access first, right? Who gets the access? See, for example, when we are talking about the digitalization and now, I mean, a lot of digitalization of the digital banking happens on the cellphone, right. So then if that's the one household, one cellphone. Will women get the excessive pay? And it was very interesting that in India we have these jandan accounts which are household accounts. They are not individual accounts, which is a government pushing to the Jandan account to give the government facilities or direct benefit transfer to low-income groups. It was interesting to see that women started questioning it, that we want our individual accounts, number one. Why? Because we can have control on finance, not just access. So when it's digitalization also, even that with Peshi, our experience was that women were ready to buy a cellphone, take a loan and buy a cellphone because they wanted. Their own digital wallet. So I do feel that, you know, I, I'm just being very brief for your answer. We can discuss, but the whole thing is that actually, Any technology is always an enabler, but at the same time, it should not just have an access, but it should have a control also when it comes to gender. So when we started our digital wallet, it was interesting to see that, you know, we had PIN number to operate digital wallet, and our women said that we don't want PIN number. You also add something like, you know, why don't you add biometric, and we were saying pin number is easier. You will remember, you will have to be take a financial literacy for that. So they were not ready for that. They wanted a biometric and we now have, uh, customized it with biometric. And when we did that, you know what our women said, He said anybody can open my account, my PIN number, but nobody can open my digital wallet because it's a biometric. So it's very interesting that, you know, even when technology comes. It is very interesting that how that technology gives the control to these women, it's the most important part. And of course it would if technology enables, but on the demand side, they are very clear that we want control. So on the supply side, I feel, I think this technology company, vendors, fintech company, they always have to understand the demand side that they are not talking about excess. Women are talking about control also, and this technology enabling that. Thank you, Channa. So if I understand you correctly, technology can be an enabler, but it is very important to keep looking at the demand side and what women truly need when developing this enabler. Albana, um, you mentioned that among your clients, uh, women are generally more eager to learn and engage in training and then especially digital, uh, literacy trainings in comparison to men. Um, how does this reflect in the strategy of Fed Infest? What is the role in Fedinfest, uh, of digital and especially when it comes to including women? Um, in the same time I was trying to give answers also to the questions because, uh, I, I see that, uh, uh, we have here some very interesting questions. Anyway, I will give my answer about the digitalization, um, we left 2020. Uh, I believe, uh, the most difficult year for, for the world, uh, where we met and knew what was, uh, the, the COVID and the virus who, uh, enforced us to, to make, uh, a new way of living, uh, so we, uh, came from the physical life into a digital and online life. Uh, and saying this, uh, also, uh, our everyday and also our, um, professional life, uh, came to, to online life, uh, for sure, uh, what we want now is to Not only as Fed Invest, but I think, uh, uh, everyone and, uh, every company, uh, needs to more go online. Uh, also Fed Invest needs and uh also desire to further develop the usage of the financial services, um, and, um, following this step in Fed Invest, we launched um a platform which is, uh, online and also, uh, a physical office. Uh, we call this, uh, agribusiness assistance, uh, which is, uh, a plot, uh, platform, and, uh, also an office where our members, uh, can get, uh, financial education, trainings, uh, market information, but also networking opportunities. Um. Saying this, we also created uh a network with women, uh, where we share weekly information about our services, uh, about our products, um, uh, about our new staff or new members of the institution, uh, what are, uh, the needs of the clients, the success stories and things like this. So it's a very active group, uh, where we communicate, uh, with each other. Um, what we knew is, uh, that, uh, as we launched ABBA, this agribusiness assistance last year, uh, according to the visits that people made in, uh, this website and in this, uh, platform, uh, and also in our social media such as, uh, Facebook, LinkedIn, or, um, even Instagram, we understood that, uh, more than half of the visitors were women. And um this let us know that they are more eager to learn and to be trained. So um this um this strong interest in digital channels translate um into a higher usage of digital channels by human. Um, following our digital strategy, uh, last year also, uh, we launched, uh, the current account, um. We launched also Fed Online and uh uh utility payment. Uh, Fed Online is um um uh the web where uh our members can get information and uh also can have online services from the institution. Uh, so, uh, we foresee that uh not only the number of our, uh, women members will increase, but also the number of the women members who profit from our uh products and services. Thank you, Alban. Interesting to hear all these interesting uh initiatives that are going on at Fed Invest. I'm also curious to hear from Majou. Uh, about the digital strategy of TIFF going forward. Uh, for example, you have recently launched, uh, uh, a platform called Diana Cash, which, which is a digital platform for transfers. Uh, do you think that this platform will play a role towards increased gender equality? Thank you. Why we come to the digital platform for SIFE Network. Because we realize that uh the digitalization provide more security. Substractive operation. Provide the confidentiality. And also supreme more resources for women because when Women are using the usually support the book for the saving. The husband can get access to the book and know how much they have in their accounts. But with digitization. It is not possible. Without the permission of women. Who providing the pin codes to the husband to get information on how much women have in their accounts. The reason not only provides. Fast-track services, women, but also see. They see him and the occupation. And what this strategy is at 3 levels. The first one is about our. Process The second is about our support, and the last one is about our operation and services. Janaya cash is a part of our operation and services. If there are cash today. Any clients of the safe network member. Save functional resources. And have automatically within the mobile phone, uh, the bank card because Da card also is with the bank cards. They can access resources everywhere. I Digitalization is not. Whether we can do or not is for us the P To more encourage women to save their resources, to secure their resources, and to, to help them to do business more secure. If you take a country like Burkina Faso. Where we are facing A security issue. Women withization can move from NCQ. Zone The zone to make the business or vice versa without fear to be attacked by the terrorists and gather the resources. It's where we are investing in digitalization in West Africa. And instead, we have 4.5 million clients. Within SI network. If we are, we are able To digitize the process, the operation of all. We feel stiff. It's become a big platform for everybody to provide not only financial services, but also to provide. Inputs for agriculture, financial education, or other services to women. Cilization is The key To breathe down The gap is the key to get the last mile to serve women. Thank you so much, Richard, and good to see that all three of you agree on the fact that digitization can play an important role. Uh, Rachel, I saw some traffic in the chat. Is there anything we can touch upon right now? Yes, absolutely. We have a question from Anuk Arts, um, and the question. is, could we say that financial cooperatives are better placed than normal banks to reach out to women? If I could try to answer that question based on our initial paper, well, based on the sample of cooperative financial institutions that we interviewed, some are better, some are not as good. Uh, but happy to hear panels on this, and the question is, which factors play a crucial role here? To what extent are financial cooperatives, better or not, placed to provide fintech solutions? Who would like to go ahead and provide some insights on this, uh, question? OK. I will start and click on complete. So, if, if financial cooperative can Provides Better solution to the clay than Fintech. So what I can say is that Uh, I don't know what happened in, uh, uh, uh, Latin America and, uh, or in India, but in West Africa, women needs is not only financial. There is on the needs of hush. There is the need also of cultural exchange to where financial cooperative is important. That we noticed that the bank and finance and the FEC are providing. Today financial solution to the women and financial cooperative should Innovates. They uh Partnership with Fintech. Or create their own FinTech to be able to continue to provide. As well, financial services and non-financial services to the member. As if we commit for that is why we launch. expression of interest. To Right. So fintech To help us to increase our digital solution to our members in West Africa. The process is ongoing now. Thank you. Thank you, Mattie. I think that is a good moment to move on to the last, uh, topic of the conclusions and recommendations. So Rachel, over to you. Sure, thank you, Ruby. Um, as we enter this final block of conclusions and recommendations, I would like to ask all three of you, panelists, the same question, and if you could just give us like your 32nd or maximum 1 minute answer to that question, which is the key question of our webinar. Now that we've discussed all of this, what do you think? Is including women in financial cooperatives an uphill battle or good business? Over to you, uh, let's start with Albana. Um, as I mentioned before, um, and we have the same rights for women and men, uh, of course it's not an uphill battle, um, uphill battle, um, uh, of course it's a good business, including women, um, is, uh, I think, uh, the best opportunity for, uh, uh, the wife and the husband to have the same rights and to collaborate in the same way, uh, and to discuss and to take decisions together for their families. Um, is also. So, uh, the, the good example for, for the kids and for the, uh, society where they live and, uh, also where they work. Uh, so, uh, I think it's the best business to include women in, uh, in the financial, uh, institutions or in the financial inclusions. Perfect, thank you. So not an uphill battle according to you and good business. And I remember you also shared previously with us that women had higher, uh, at lower non-performing loan rates than men at, um, at Fed Invest. So yes, it seems that it could be good business in terms of, uh, credit repayment. Over to you, Matthieu. What would be your 32nd answer to that question? Good business or uphill battle? to Who's gonna be there tomorrow. Because women have came back alone more than that because men and women. Perfect. They use resources for the family. Doctor, amen. For the is. You for. Great, I think the, the, the sound was not great, but I really liked the way you framed it. Uphill battle today, good business for tomorrow. Interesting. Over to you, Chetna, what do you think? You know, I would, first I, first of all, I would like to say that um Even even if I mean if you need a business and if you want an economy to really grow and with with equity, there is no other alternative, but we have to invest in gender. We have to invest in these financial cooperatives where we women get an equal. It's not just in, in, I don't believe in talking about excess but control on finance and for that I do believe. That you know either it is in the board, either it is in the membership, either it is in NGM either it is in, you have to have women and ownership of property, ownership of businesses. Economy is not going to grow and per capita income of the whole population is not going to grow unless women own their businesses and have an equal share in particularly financial sector. Thank you, Chetna, we hear you. So, um, Now, let's move to the way forward, and we at Rabo Foundation and World Bank are very interested in disseminating good practice and sharing insights both at uh with supervisors and governments and with financial cooperatives. So, uh, let me take just a few seconds to share with you some emerging recommendations that we, uh, highlighted in our paper. Our emerging recommendations are the following for governments and supervisors. We have 4. The first one is require and help for supervisors. Require and help cooperative financial institutions to report gender desegregated data on membership, on loans, on savings. What gets measured gets managed. So that would be our number 1 suggestion. Our #2 suggestion would be require and help CFI, cooperative Financial Institutions, report to the credit bureau so that a data trail is generated for CFIA clients. And we didn't talk about it today, but with Chetna, we talked earlier about Mandey sharing credit scores built on their women clients with other financial institutions, and we think this idea is actually really interesting and um this was some of the inspiration for for that recommendation. Number 3, we would like that um to, to suggest to promote gender-sensitive financial education campaigns and ensure customer protection through grievance mechanisms, and that's very important and that came out from discussions with you, Matthew, and other people at SIFF who mentioned to us that, yes, they developed uh specific products for women, targeting women, but actually, when they did so, They faced lots of challenges with people actually taking advantage of some women that were uh that had limited financial education. So, so that's our third recommendation. And our fourth recommendation is to allow sound cooperative financial institutions to benefit from existing partial credit guarantee schemes. We know that there are many partial credit guarantee schemes in many countries, but Oftentimes, financial cooperatives are not eligible for these guarantees, and increasing, making them eligible would allow them to increase their outreach to women who oftentimes lack collateral. So that would be some of our emerging recommendations for supervisors for governments. For cooperatives themselves, we have two very high-level recommendations, one for federations. We believe that they can play an instrumental role in conducting the market research to better to better understand the specificities of women clients. And also in product development. And for financial cooperatives themselves, we definitely invite financial cooperatives to develop gender sensitive approaches, but whatever the, the the best model is, it could be a woman-only model like Mandii, it could be a group approach like see if, it could be a household approach like Fed Invest, but we think uh all of these models could be interesting inspirations and references. So, let me turn now to our panelists for our final question before we close. Do you have any further thoughts on key recommendations, suggestions going forward? Uh, Albana, you come from a country in Albania that has very progressive rules and laws and legislation to promote gender equality. What, what else do you think should be done in Albania so that to promote inclusion of women in financial cooperatives? Um, so, uh, here the floor is mine because I come from the legal department and, um, I can say that in Albania, uh, the laws are very good, uh, they provide, um, uh, very good, uh, uh, the things, uh, because we follow the, the recommendations or the laws in the European Union. Um, Uh, we do not discriminate, uh, uh, women and men, uh, they have the same right, uh, they can, uh, co-sign the contract, uh, in the same way, uh, they can have in the same way and also the collateral, uh, they can open, uh, uh, the account in the same way, so, um, they have the same rights, uh, regarding the law. What it happens in the practice or maybe in Fed Invest because we, uh, we are extended more in the rural area, uh, what we see is that we find difficulties in, in, uh, making this uh happen. Um. Of course they have, uh, women and men have the same rights, but, um, uh, it's not that in practice happens always like this, uh, in our case, uh, what I, uh, what I see is that, um, mm, our practice shows also that, uh, we have less, um, uh, women member than uh than men than uh men, uh, so, um. Mm, my recommendation about the, the, the law to, to improve something about uh uh women inclusion is only to, to have some uh uh fiscal facilities uh for, for women, for example, for the start-up businesses, uh, the, the taxes and fees zero for the beginning or, or, uh, um, to, to. Uh, to have something, uh, something, um, mm, simple or, or a good example to follow in the beginning, uh, training to, to, to be sent to them, um, and also giving the answer, uh, for Bjorn, uh, from, uh, my side, uh, and, uh, as Fed Invest, I think that, uh. Uh, it's not that we are not near to, to, to our member, we are very near to our members, but, uh, we need more to hear them voice. Uh, saying this, I repeat, it's not that we do not hear their voice, we are here to serve from, uh, for them and to give, uh, our best, uh, for, for what they need. Um, if we, if we, uh, give our services in a smoother way, in a more simple way, things will be better even for them. Um, Of course it's a good business to include uh woman uh in the finance, but, uh, saying what, uh, I, following what I said before about the, the digitalization, uh, I can confirm that, uh, it's not simple for us to, to, to, to launch, uh, our service Fed online, uh, because, uh, in the rural area there are some people that, uh, even do not have a cellphone. Uh, but we are trying to do our best, uh, our, uh, marketing campaigns and, uh, services, uh, are tend to go even in the rural areas. So, uh, for the moment, uh, we are working like this. Um, these are, these were my only two recommendations. Uh, perfect. Thanks a lot, Albana. So fiscal incentives for women-owned, uh, businesses and also more investment in training and, uh, I want to, before I turn to, um, Chetna, uh, everyone, please feel free to share your thoughts and recommendations in the chat panel and also in, uh, by, uh, sending us an email at um. Uh, CFI gender feedback at gmail.com. Uh, Chetna, what, I know you faced several regulatory and legal hurdles in setting up Mandey. What would be your number one advice, uh, to governments, to, to supervisors to promote financial inclusion? So the, the most important, sorry, sorry, I think Matthew wanted to say something, uh, quickly, sorry, Chetna. OK, no, Matthew has issues with connection. Uh OK. Thank you, Matthieu. Go ahead. Can, can you? Yes. I mean Yes, we do. So Before Uh, I want to provide my remission. First one is, uh, what our solution is more focused on the clients approach. Yeah, listen, this is the best to. To invest Sorry, Matthew, the connection is not good actually. So I think uh we will, thank you a lot and uh say goodbye and turn to Che. So one thing I would like to say is that, as I've been emphasizing is that um law is there but I do think that the most important part for on the gender issue if we really want to address is ownership of property rights. And with that we need governments to give the incentive to See that women own property. Once they have that laws are there, but still their culture is very different, so that is one. And I do think we have not much discussed, but with the digitalization, not only for women, but this whole cybersecurity will be a very big issue and how do you Uh, it would be a very, uh, different exercise and tricky exercise about the cybersecurity and the trust. These are the two things I find it very important. Perfect. Thanks a lot Chetna. Thanks a lot Albana. Thanks a lot, Matthew and everyone in the audience. I think uh we're coming to the end of our webinar. I want to thank all of you for this really fruitful discussion. In terms of next steps, we will update, improve, uh, our paper based on all this discussion we had and also from the feedback you may share with us uh by email. We'll wait for your feedback uh uh before the end. Of this week. And also, uh, please, everyone stay tuned for future events. Here you see a list of upcoming webinars, so all of you interested in gender, please feel free to look at the Mercy Corps Agrofin annual uh learning event, lots, lots of events before the end of the month. And for all of you interested in financial cooperatives, we have in mid-July, another event that we will organize on Cooperative financial institutions in the context of fragility, conflict, and violence. And with this, I would like to thank all of you and say goodbye. Thank you, thank you, bye. Thank you, everyone. Bye bye. Thank you. Bye.
showAllTranscripts
no
duration
PT1H28M26S
scene7File
worldbank/Including women in Financial cooperatives
scene7Domain
https://worldbank.scene7.com/
scene7FileAvs
worldbank/Including women in Financial cooperatives-AVS
title
Including women in Financial cooperatives
description
Including women in Financial cooperatives
showTimestampAndTranscript
yes
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-3
col-lg-3
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-7
col-lg-7
  • add-style
  • lp-body-content
To view the the video, click on the image. Including women in Financial cooperatives in India, Albania, West Africa. An uphill battle?
col-xs-12
col-sm-12
col-md-2
col-lg-2