Logo The World Bank Group Contact Us • Help/FAQ • Index • Search  
About Countries Data Evaluation Learning News Opportunities Projects Publications Research Topics
single line tv line
 
Transport Sector Overview
Economics & Policy
Ports & Logistics
Railways
Roads & Highways
Overview
Construction and Maintenance
Institutional and Management Structures for Roads
Planning of Roads and Highways
Poverty Reduction and Social Assessments
Roads and the Environment
Road Financing and Road Funds
Road Safety
Roads Software Tools
Road Transport
Toll Roads and Concessions
Rural Transport
Urban Transport
Publications
Terms of Reference
Data & Statistics
Calendar of Events
Events Proceedings & Presentations
Transport Lending
Transport in the Regions
Partners
Related World Bank Sites
Useful External Links
Site Tools
  Transport Help Desk
  Site Help
  Site Updates
Road Transport


Assessing Regulatory Policy
Establishing a Strategy for Improving Regulation
Developing the Role Played by Trucking
Ensuring Competitive Bus Transport
Terms of Reference
Bibliography

This topic deals with issues concerning the provision of road transport services on the road network. Issues specific to urban transport and the environment, such as air pollution and noise that are associated with growing motorization, are dealt with in greater depth elsewhere. It covers how to assess road transport performance and to define strategies for regulatory change to promote efficiency and to meet broad environmental concerns, especially for trucking and bus services.

KEY ISSUES

The following list focuses on the key issues that you need to know about road transport to ensure that it is performing well, that government regulatory policy toward it is appropriate and effective, that environmental concerns are being duly addressed, and that benefits from investments in improved roads will be passed on to road users and the broader economy through responsive road transport services.

The list covers ways of identifying and assessing problems associated with regulation, ways of defining strategies for tackling these problems in accordance with established good practice, and ways of tackling important issues affecting the development of trucking and passenger public transport services.

  1. Assessing Regulatory Policy

    Many indicators of national road transport performance can be defined to assess costs, efficiency and level of service of road transport, but in practice adequate data are rarely available for use in meaningful analysis. The accuracy of national road transport statistics is generally poor and so assessing performance requires surveys to be carried out.

    The effectiveness of regulatory policy can be assessed broadly in terms of how well it promotes competition and efficient use of roads while meeting safety and environmental concerns (ideally by including, in the cost of transport, the environmental cost imposed on society by transport activity). When assessing regulatory policy, account should be taken of the following considerations:

    1. Many road transport regulations arise, historically, from the desire to give unjustifiable protection to railways (and even established bus operators).

    2. Studies of the economic characteristics of road transport suggest that there is little need for intervention by government to ensure efficient allocation of resources, except to ensure that there is free competition and that safety, environmental and other externality considerations are taken fully into account (meaning that there is rarely need for tariff or entry controls designed to balance supply and demand).

    3. Justifiable regulations should take account of the costs and benefits. (For example, the setting of safety standards for buses should take into account that the consequent higher costs may deter some would-be users.)

    4. Transport regulation is more effective when focussing on outputs rather than inputs. (For example, ensuring that drivers do not drive when drunk is more effective than specifying how bus and truck operators should check drunkenness of their drivers.)

    5. Ultimately the rules applying to transport activities should be clear and known to road users, so that compliance is encouraged and enforcement made more transparent.

    In many cases regulations fail to set minimum acceptable safety standards and they impose unjustifiable constraints on transport services. Market distortion may arise from other government interventions, such as state ownership of transport enterprises. For more details on how to spot possible regulatory problems and for terms of reference of a study to assess regulatory policy, see Assessing Regulation of Road Transport. For a description of a suitable approach to analysing regulatory problems, see Approach to Analysis. For futher details on assessing the potential for reducing accidents and other environmental impacts, see the Road Safety and the Roads and Environment transport Web sites.

    Significant benefits have been estimated to result from regulatory reform, especially from deregulating the trucking and intercity bus businesses. The extent of the benefits will depend on the degree to which the former regulatory regime imposed harmful constraints - consequently greater benefits have been estimated from trucking deregulation in the USA and Mexico (where costs reductions of typically 20% were observed) than in Canada. Even greater reductions in costs have been achieved from deregulating bus services (up to 35-45%), reflecting the extent to which they were formerly regulated. Cost reductions occur not only through lowering of staff costs and profit margins, but also through the development of more efficient services. Some of the cost reductions on certain bus services arise from abolishing cross subsidies. Within urban areas the effects of deregulation and related policy issues are more complicated. For further discussion of policy issues concerning deregulation of urban bus transport, visit the Urban Transport Web site.


    Return to top of document

  2. Establishing a Strategy for Improving Regulation

    An effective strategy for improving regulation could involve, among other things:

    1. reviewing road transport policy, to provide a clear direction for improved regulation,

    2. reviewing and amending the legal framework, and

    3. institutional strengthening measures in the regulatory agencies.

    The precise needs vary depending on circumstances. The scope of changes can be considerable for countries without a history of a market economy, where the legal system has remained unaltered for many years or is based on an inappropriate legal system developed by a former colonial power. A priority concern is usually to put in place an effective means of setting and enforcing driving and vehicle standards (including size and weight limits), the main constraint usually being the administrative capacity of the government to enforce these standards in practice.

    In other cases the main need for reform may just concern the regulation of passenger and freight services, especially to remove obstacles to providing a level playing-field and encouraging passenger and freight services that are efficient and responsive to demand. In the case of countries wishing to develop improved trade and transport links with other countries in their region, involving new international agreements and protocols, there will usually be a need to develop effective international road transport and customs agreements and to incorporate these agreements into national law.


    Return to top of document

  3. Developing the Role Played by Trucking

    Raising professional standards in trucking is important if road transport is to play its full role and offer high quality services. Two approaches (not mutually exclusive) are possible here: regulation by government through some form of operator licensing, or self-regulation by the trucking industry through setting of professional standards of certification. Enforcement constraints limit the scope for using operator licensing, although this is common practice in European and other developed countries. Accreditation can be used by qualifying operators to attract potential customers, can increase the creditworthiness of operators, and provides the practical basis in the longer term for incorporating effective professional standards into operator licensing and gaining support in the industry for enforcement efforts.

    For road transport to play its full role in international transport, particular attention must be given to minimizing border delays due to customs and other procedures. These cause significant impediments to trade in regions such as Europe, where transit movements are common, and become an issue where trade facilitating measures are proposed in other regions, such as by SADC in Africa and ESCAP in South East Asia. Although international treaties or agreements, such as the TIR road transit agreement, are being adopted increasingly in such areas, implementation is far from easy due to the need to build up trust and appropriate safeguards among operators and customs. Furthermore governments are often concerned about their national trucking industries being unable to compete with foreign companies from more developed economies with higher technical and professional standards. However, protection of national operators only increases impediments to trade and does not encourage efficiency - so the preferred solution is to enable the operators to adapt to the higher international standards. See International Transport for a description of how international road transport agreements are being introduced in a phased way in the SADC region and how border delays can be reduced through introducing the TIR system. See European Community Legislation on Road Transport in Accession Candidate Countries for information on what laws, etc. countries aspiring to join the EU will have to adopt.


    Return to top of document

  4. Ensuring Competitive Bus Transport

    Ensuring adequate competition in bus transport is not easy. It is not unusual for established operators to dominate certain services, partly due to government intervention through entry and fares controls and through state ownership of major bus companies. Even without government intervention competition is not assured on every route, because dominant operators or groups of small operators can adopt anti-competitive practices to deter small independent operators from offering alternatives.

    Three important issues commonly arise when seeking to improve regulation:

    1. What should be the basis of competition, either free competition (or 'competition in the market') or some kind of contracting or franchising (or 'competition for the market')?

    2. What rules should apply for accessing and developing bus stations, both to allow equal access by operators to main stations and to allow bus operators to establish alternative facilities?

    3. How is a government to monitor services and control anti-competitive abuses?

    In the case of urban bus services, particular issues arise over planning and regulating services, and these are discussed at length in the Urban Transport Web Site. For non-urban bus services there rarely appears to be a case for major intervention by government in planning and controlling services. Leaving operators free to plan services in accordance with the needs of the passenger encourages service innovation and frees government to concentrate on the important task of setting and enforcing safety standards and of ensuring that competitive conditions prevail. In non-urban bus transport, unjustifiable intervention by government in bus station provision can distort service patterns and increase transport costs. To avoid this, bus operators should be free to choose whether or not to use bus stations, subject to basic safety considerations. If necessary alternative uses for superfluous bus stations, or means of financing them, should be found. Monitoring of bus service competition can often be carried out without much additional information collection beyond that already possessed by regulatory authorities. The main issue is how to combat anti-monopoly behavior. Punitive action could be controversial and risk causing disruption, so a more effective approach could be to encourage more competition by ensuring that other operators have access to bus stations and removing unnecessary entry barriers. See Bus Competition for further discussion on these topics.


Return to top of document

Selected Terms of Reference




Return to top of document

Bibliography

    Documents available on-line:

    Gwilliam Kenneth, Zmarak Shalizi. 1996. "Sustainable Transport: Priorities for Policy Reform." World Bank, Washington, DC. (13,249KB)

    Smith G., T. Michell and B. Shin "Assessing the Effects of Trucking Regulation in Korea." World Bank Transportation Department, May 1986.

    Documents available from other Web sites:

    International Road Union. Handbook on the Harmonisation of European Transport Legislation, 2nd Edition, 1998. Available at the IRU on-line bookstore.

    Hine J. L. and Chilver A. S. "Pakistan Road Freight Industry: An overview." TRL Research Report 314. TRL. Crowthorne UK. 1991. For more information on this publication, visit the Transportation Research Laboratory Web site.

    Jenkins Ian A. 1994. "All Change - New Directions for the Road Transport Industries of Russia, Ukraine, Kazakhstan and Belarus". Transport Reviews, Vol. 14, No. 4, 289-320.

    Rizet C. and Hine J. L. "A Comparison of The Costs And Productivity of Road Freight Transport In Africa And Pakistan". Transport Reviews, Vol. 13, No. 2, 151-165.

    For more information on the above two publications visit the Taylor & Francis Web site (publishers of Transport Reviews).

    Robbins D. K. and White P.R. "The Experiences of Express Coach Deregulation in Great Britain". World Conference on Transport Research, 1986. For more information on this publication, visit the WCTR Web site.

    Please contact the Transport Help Desk transport@worldbank.org. for more information on the following document(s):

    Carbajo, Josť (Editor). 1993. "Regulatory Reform in Transport - Some Recent Experiences". A World Bank Symposium

Back to top
Top
 
Globe logo Contact Us | Help/FAQ Site Index | Search Home