World Bank Group

Search Index Feedback Help 

Operations Evaluation Department OED Banner
Home > Independent Evaluation > Countries > CAE > Russia CAE
Search IEG Evaluations
Advanced Search
CAE Home
Completed CAEs
Joint CAEs
Forthcoming CAEs
CAE Methodology
CAE Ratings
All IEG Evaluations
Toolkit
Order a CAE
Receive IEG alerts
Contact us

 

 
 
IEG: Country Assistance Evaluations (CAEs)
Russia CAE

Main Documents:
Main Report (2002) 152 pages - 700KB
Precis (2002) 4 pages - 1MB

Background Papers:
Bank Assistance for the Energy Sector (Richard Berney) [Russian]
Bank Assistance for the Energy Sector (Youri Bobylev and Jacek Cukrowski) [Russian]
Bank Assistance for Financial Sector Development [Russian]
Bank Assistance for Public Financial Accountability [Russian]
Bank Assistance for Public Sector Management and Governance [Russian]
Bank Assistance for Private Sector Development [Russian]
Bank Assistance for Private Sector and Financial Sector Developments [Russian]
Thoughts on the Privatization Debates A Decade Later [Russian]
Bank Assistance for Social Protection (Lawrence Thompson) [Russian]
Bank Assistance for Social Protection (Marina Kolosnitsyna and Irena Topinska) [Russian]

The Country Assistance Evaluation (CAE) for Russia, covering the period from 1992 to 2001, showed disappointing but improving results for the World Bank’s activities in the Russian Federation. Although IEG rated the outcome of World Bank assistance to Russia as unsatisfactory during 1992-1998, with only a modest impact on institutional development, for the period 1998-2001 it rated the outcome satisfactory and institutional development impact substantial.

The Russia CAE found that an assistance strategy oriented around analytical and advisory services (AAA) with limited financial support for Russia would have been more appropriate than one involving large volumes of adjustment lending, since such lending in 1996-97 may have delayed rather than accelerated needed reforms. Disbursements should have rewarded actions rather than promises. In support of its overall outcome rating through June 1998, IEG highlighted the large size of quick-disbursing and investment loans with unsatisfactory outcomes. It noted that research and evaluation findings confirmed that large amounts of lending could not be relied upon to ensure country ownership.

 
Featured CAEs

CAE Retrospective
China
India
Russia


Latest CAEs

Bolivia (English | Spanish)
Mauritania
Romania
CAE Retrospective
Pacific Member Countries
Bosnia-Herzegovina
Croatia


Month's Popular CAEs

Moldova
Tunisia
Lithuania

 

The Independent Evaluation Group (IEG) is an independent unit within the World Bank; it reports directly to the Bank's Board of Executive Directors. The goals of IEG 's evaluations are to draw lessons from Bank experience, and to provide an objective basis for assessing the results of the Bank's work.

Search | Index | Feedback | Help | WB Home
© 2007 The World Bank Group, All Rights Reserved. Terms and Conditions