Contact Us FAQ Index Search

Beyond Transition 
THE NEWSLETTER ABOUT REFORMING ECONOMIES

About
Recent
Issues
Archives
Russian
Version
Submissions
Subscribe
Related
Web Sites
Search
Home Page

 

Monetary Transmission Mechanisms:  A Look at the Baltic Economies
by Rudolfs Bems

Over the last decade the three Baltic countries have been regarded as notable examples of successful macroeconomic stabilization programs and the subsequent exercise of monetary policy. Three separate studies presented in Baltic Economic Trends (2001, no. 2) look at the goals and instruments of monetary policy in Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania and investigate the importance of different monetary transmission mechanisms.

Currency board arrangements, introduced in Estonia in 1992 and in Lithuania in1997, have a major influence on monetary policy. Latvia has pegged its exchange rate to the SDR currency basket since 1994. As of mid-2001 the main goal of Estonia’s monetary policy has been to maintain the stability of the national currency, while in Latvia and Lithuania the goal is price stability. As Lithuania operates under a currency board, one might expect that the Bank of Lithuania would have a similar goal to its Estonian counterpart and regard stability of the national currency as its main objective. However, as the Lithuania study points out, Lithuanian policymakers are eager to exercise active monetary policy, which explains their concern about price stability.

Because of their currency boards the only monetary policy instrument that is actively applied in Estonia and Lithuania is the reserve requirement. This implies that most monetary policy effects come through the exchange rate window, which affects base money. In contrast, the Bank of Latvia is not constrained by a currency board, and therefore achieves its objective of price stability by intervening in the foreign exchange market and setting interest rates.

As their main contribution, the studies identify the channels of monetary policy transmission and assess the importance of different channels in Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania. The authors use different methodologies to achieve this goal and make the following observations:

  • The direct interest rate channel, as expected, was found to be present in all three countries. In Latvia interest rates set by the central bank have a direct impact on interest rates for domestic credit. Similarly, in Estonia changes in European Central Bank rates have a direct effect on local interest rates. In Lithuania this channel is present, but the impact of European Central Bank rate changes on local interest rates is weak. The study of Lithuania explains this difference by pointing out that the country’s banking sector is highly concentrated and that the level of competition among banks is low. Also, until the second quarter of 2000 the future of the currency board in Lithuania was uncertain, which added a considerable risk premium to local interest rates.

  • The credit channel was found to be important in Estonia and Latvia, but not in Lithuania. The study of Latvia finds that monetary shocks affect a variety of credit aggregates. In the case of Estonia, the study concludes that a credit channel probably exists, because banks are the basic financial intermediaries and the empirical evidence is in favor of credit rationing. The study of Lithuania is less explicit about the reasons why the credit channel proved less important.

  • The exchange rate channel was found to be important in Lithuania, insignificant in Latvia (the Estonian study did not consider this channel). A possible explanation could be the differences in anchor currencies and trade partners across the three countries. In Lithuania, the use of the dollar as the anchor currency together with the relatively high importance of trade with Russia implies that export and import prices are more affected by swings in the value of the Russian ruble and the dollar/euro exchange rate. By contrast, in Estonia a larger proportion of trade is settled in the anchor currency (formerly the deutschmark, but the euro as of January 1, 2001), and therefore the exchange rate channel is less important.

The Latvia and Estonia studies also point out that the effects of existing transmission channels on the real economy are small and short-lived. This is in line with findings for other emerging markets around the world.

Most important, the studies raise new questions about monetary policy in the Baltic states that may stimulate further work on this topic. A closer look is needed to confirm and expand upon the findings of these studies. Also, the three studies do not formally consider the effects of asset price channels and expectations, although the Lithuania study does provide some discussion of the effect of expectations. Future research could aim at filling this gap.

Finally, when evaluating and interpreting these studies one should keep in mind the challenges that such studies face in the Baltic states. First, even in industrial countries economists do not agree about the methods to use when examining their monetary transmission mechanisms. Second, the short history of monetary policy in the transition economies and the enormous structural changes these economies have experienced make identifying potential monetary policy shocks and their long-run effects particularly difficult.

The authors of the original three studies summarized here were Raoul Lättemä and Rasmus Pikkani of the Bank of Estonia; Veronica Babich of the International Graduate Program, Stockholm School of Economics; and Igor Vetlov of the Bank of Lithuania. Baltic Economic Trends is a publication of SITE and the Baltic International Centre for Economic Policy Studies (BICEPS), a new Riga-based policy and research center launched by SITE last spring (see www.biceps.org). Rudolfs Bems, a PhD candidate at the Stockholm School of Economics, is a research associate of SITE and BICEPS. He can be reached by email at rudolfs.bems@hhs.se

The World Bank Group
Contact Us | Help/FAQ | Index | Search
© 2001 The World Bank Group, All Rights Reserved. Terms and Conditions. Privacy Policy