2124. Social Exclusion and Land Administration in Orissa, India

Robin Mearns and Saurabh Sinha
(May 1999)

Which factors prevent the rural poor and other socially excluded groups from having access to land in Orissa, India?

Mearns and Sinha report on the first empirical study of its kind to examine—from the perspective of transaction costs—factors that constrain access to land for the rural poor and other socially excluded groups in India. They find that:

• Land reform has reduced large landholdings since the 1950s. Medium-size farms have gained most. Formidable obstacles still prevent the poor from gaining access to land.
• The complexity of land revenue administration in Orissa is partly the legacy of distinctly different systems, which produced more or less complete and accurate land records. These not-so-distant historical records can be important in resolving contemporary land disputes.
• Orissa tried legally to abolish land-leasing. Concealed tenancy persisted, with tenants having little protection under the law.
• Women's access to and control over land, and their bargaining power with their husbands about land, may be enhanced through joint land titling, a principle yet to be realized in Orissa.
• Land administration is viewed as a burden on the state rather than a service, and land records and registration systems are not coordinated. Doing so will improve rights for the poor and reduce transaction costs—but only if the system is transparent and the powerful do not retain the leverage over settlement officers that has allowed land grabs.

Land in Orissa may be purchased, inherited, rented (leased), or—in the case of public land and the commons—encroached upon. Each type of transaction—and the state's response, through land law and administration—has implications for poor people's access to land. Mearns and Sinha find that:

• Land markets are thin and transaction costs are high, limiting the amount of agricultural land that changes hands.
• The fragmentation of landholdings into tiny, scattered plots is a brake on agricultural productivity, but efforts to consolidate land may discriminate against the rural poor. Reducing transaction costs in land markets will help.
• Protecting the rural poor's rights of access to common land requires raising public awareness and access to information.
• Liberalizing land-lease markets for the rural poor will help, but only if the poor are ensured access to institutional credit.

This paper—a product of the Rural Development Sector Unit, South Asia Region—is part of a larger effort in the region to promote access to land and to foster more demand-driven and socially inclusive institutions in rural development. Copies of the paper are available free from the World Bank, 1818 H Street NW, Washington, DC 20433. Please contact Geraldine Burnett, room MC10-156, telephone 202-458-2111, fax 202-522-2420, Internet address gburnett@worldbank.org. Robin Mearns may be contacted at rmearns@worldbank.org. (72 pages)

The full report is available in PDF format.