This policy note is motivated by a
recent international conference hosted by the Mongolian
Ministry of Finance and the World Bank in Ulaanbaatar on
20-21 March 2013.... Show More +
International guests joined Mongolian
government officials, Members of Parliament and civil
society to discuss what lessons could be gathered from
international experience to guide the design of an effective
Sovereign Wealth Fund (SWF). Experiences of natural
resource management were shared between practioners from
Mongolia and Norway, Chile, Botswana, Timor-Leste, Trinidad
and Tobago and Abu Dhabi. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 77699
Date: May 09, 2013
Author:
Smith, Gregory ;
Lee, Tae Hyun
In 2012, Mongolia's economy
continued to experience a high growth rate of 12.3 percent.
This growth rate was however lower than anticipated as
Mongolia saw its coal... Show More +
exports drop significantly due to
China's economic slowdown. Most noticeably, Mongolia
had to finance a large fiscal deficit of 8.4 percent of
gross domestic product (GDP), a record in the last 13 years.
It is concerning that similar fiscal trends might continue
in 2013 with the economy growing at a double-digit rate but
also accumulating another large fiscal deficit. As Mongolia
embarks on its largest infrastructure investments ever which
can be in part financed through a first successful sovereign
Chinggis bonds issuance- greater attention has to be paid:
(i) to preparing those investments rigorously to ensure
maximum socioeconomic return and avoid potential wastage of
public resources; and (ii) to reflecting their financing
transparently in the national budget. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 77697
Date: Apr 01, 2013
Author:
Shiilegmaa, Altantsetseg; Gombosuren,
Khandtsooj; Smith, Gregory
Ulaanbaatar's (UB) population has
swollen from half a million in 2001 to approximately 1.2
million in 2011, accounting for over 40 percent of the
country's population.... Show More +
This trend is likely to continue
as economic growth is increasingly concentrated in UB. With
its growing population and concerns in rising inequality,
the city is facing increasing pressure to maintain and
expand service provision (especially infrastructure). The
local tax on wages is expected to continue to provide
substantial revenues to the UB government, which will assist
the growing demand for services. Additionally, a new
'capital city tax' is expected to come into effect
in 2013. The decision of the central government (CG) to
pursue further decentralization gives greater leadership to
the UB government and its districts. It also provides local
broader decision-making authority as well as opportunity for
citizen's participation and for the improvement of
governance and transparency. Therefore, a key challenge for
UB and its districts is ensuring that the local fiscal
system is sound and ready to handle a greater volume of
revenues to achieve sustainable and inclusive growth. The
city also needs to develop a robust and transparent fiscal
management system if it is to make an effective use of new
revenue sources. The main objective of this study is to
understand the inner workings of the municipal finance
system in Ulaanbaatar and its districts. Show Less -
Type: Other Financial Sector Study
Report#: 72514
Date: Jan 01, 2013
The objective of this report is to
analyze in depth the current public investment management
system and to assess whether or not it is able to meet this
challenge of... Show More +
delivering good quality projects in the
priority areas in a macro-economically sustainable manner;
and to recommend what needs to be done to improve the system
so that it is able to effectively transform natural resource
revenues into sustainable capital assets. In making its
recommendations, this report focuses on some of the details
that need to be laid out in implementing regulations in
order to make the Fiscal Stability Law (FSL), Budget Law of
Mongolia (IBL), and Public Procurement Law of Mongolia
(PPLM) work. The report also suggests amendments to some of
the existing laws that pose a risk to meeting the four
objectives. In proposing policy options, the report is
conscious of the political economy of reform and, wherever
possible, analyzes the compatibility of the technical
solutions with the political interests of policy-makers. Show Less -
Type: Other Infrastructure Study
Report#: 74944
Date: Jan 01, 2013
Author:
Sacks, Audrey ;
Narmandakh, Munkhnasan ;
Hanusch, Marek ;
Hasnain, Zahid
Mongolia has made strong progress on key
gender-related Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) in recent
years. Gender indicators in education and health are also
better... Show More +
in many respects than in comparator countries in the
East Asia and Pacific region. Women have a limited presence
in higher level managerial positions and in entrepreneurial
work, and working women also have to shoulder most of the
household and care duties compared to men. These
inequalities can have large impacts on development, growth
and productivity as well as pervasive intergenerational
social costs. Removing impediments to full and equal
participation for women in the economy, providing equal
access to economic resources and opportunities and
eliminating discrimination can boost productivity and
competitiveness for firms with wider benefits for the
economy and within the household. A range of potential
policy actions can be considered, including improving
employment outcomes (wages, career progression) for women in
the public sector, introducing more friendly parental leave
policies that cover both fathers and mothers, improving
child care services and introducing affirmative action
policies in sectors where women are acutely
under-represented such as mining. In addition, business
regulations can be streamlined to make it easier to start
and operate businesses for both men and women. Other
policies that may be helpful include promoting awareness of
and encouraging the development of (appropriately regulated
and supervised) micro-lending institutions. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 77508
Date: Jan 01, 2013
Author:
Khan, Tehmina; Brink, Rogier Van Den; Aslam, Monazza
As Mongolia has begun to develop its
abundant mineral resources over the past decade, the share
of mining in gross domestic product (GDP) has more than
tripled to around... Show More +
20 percent currently. The sector has also
contributed up to a third of total government receipts in
recent years and more than 80 percent of exports in 2010.
Evidence suggests that women tend to miss out on the
potential benefits associated with a booming mining sector.
In addition, large scale mines typically tend to be the
dominant employers in remote locations. The policy note
starts by gauging potential growth and employment effects
associated with the expansion of the mining sector on other
sectors, using a computable general equilibrium model
specially calibrated for the Mongolian economy. It then
considers experience and lessons from other countries that
are trying to integrate and ensure the participation of
women in large-scale mining and the practical policy
recommendations to do so. The key findings are that there is
a high degree of occupational segmentation in the mining
sector, with women mostly located in service support roles,
although this is by no means unique to Mongolia. However in
Mongolia's case, this segmentation also likely reflects
Mongolian labor regulations that existed until 2008 and
which limited womens participation in the sector. Evidence
from around the world indicates that gender equal laws are a
necessary and crucial first step towards guaranteeing gender
equality and equity, but by themselves are not sufficient.
Companies may also consider revising recruitment or hiring
strategies with the objective of raising the share of female
employment across all professional categories in the mining sector. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 77511
Date: Jan 01, 2013
Author:
Khan, Tehmina; Brink, Rogier Van Den;
Baasanjav, Oyunbileg
The 2013 budget approved by the
Parliament on November 15 has an important implication as
the first annual fiscal plan prepared under the fully
effective Fiscal Stability... Show More +
Law (FSL). The budget proclaims
that the Government will be committed to the FSL by setting
the structural fiscal deficit at 2 percent. While this is a
progress toward a more sound fiscal policy, the budget also
has significant potential risks of undermining the goal of
the FSL with optimistic revenue projections and expansionary
spending plans. The recent involvement of the BoM in the
Price Stabilization Program and the ambiguity on the use of
sovereign bond proceeds are adding to concerns on growing
tendency to bypass the FSL. Participation of the BoM in the
Governments price stabilization measures through providing
a subsidized financing is beyond the traditional role of
monetary authorities. Clear plan for the exit of the central
bank needs to be drawn up to disconnect the possibility of
it turning into another off-budget financing vehicle. While
it is a sign of growing interest from global financial
markets in Mongolian economy, the new bond issue could
become a significant fiscal risk without prudent plans to
use the proceeds. It must be noted that the recent bond
issue cannot be an off-budget financing channel and that the
receipt and the use of the proceeds need to be properly
recorded in the budget. The Government also needs to take
adequate time and extra caution to select and appraise
projects to be financed by the proceeds, considering the
financial cost of the external borrowing and economy's
capacity constraint. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 74821
Date: Dec 01, 2012
This tenth edition of Doing Business
sheds light on how easy or difficult it is for a local
entrepreneur to open and run a small to medium-size business
when complying... Show More +
with relevant regulations. It measures and
tracks changes in regulations affecting eleven areas in the
life cycle of a business: starting a business, dealing with
construction permits, getting electricity, registering
property, getting credit, protecting investors, paying
taxes, trading across borders, enforcing contracts,
resolving insolvency and employing workers. Doing Business
presents quantitative indicators on business regulations and
the protection of property rights that can be compared
across 185 economies, from Afghanistan to Zimbabwe, over
time. The indicators are used to analyze economic outcomes
and identify what reforms have worked, where and why. This
economy profile presents the Doing Business indicators for
Mongolia. To allow useful comparison, it also provides data
for other selected economies (comparator economies) for each
indicator. The data in this report are current as of June 1,
2012 (except for the paying taxes indicators, which cover
the period January - December 2011). Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 73976
Date: Oct 23, 2012
The World Bank's Mongolia quarterly
economic update assesses recent economic and social
developments and policies in Mongolia. It also presents
findings of ongoing World... Show More +
Bank activities in Mongolia. The
Mongolian economy is at the start of a huge expansion as it
begins to develop its mineral wealth. The construction of
the Oyu Tolgoi (OT) copper-gold mine-among the five largest
in the world-lifted Gross Domestic Product (GDP) growth
above 17 percent in 2011 and the economy has since continued
to grow in double-digits, albeit at a slower pace. The
economy however, faces significant risks in the near term,
as reflected in the steep drop in exports in July and
August. These risks reflect an uncertain global economic
outlook and slowing growth in China, and pro-cyclical fiscal
policy over the past three years with large increases in
government spending contributing to high inflation and
pressure on the balance of payments. The 2013 budget, being
discussed in the on-going fall session of Parliament
presents an opportunity to mitigate these risks by reining
in spending and anchoring fiscal policy to the fiscal
stability law that goes into effect on January 1, 2013.
Growth slowed in Q2 to 11 percent year-on-year from 16.5
percent in Q1, but should remain in double digits for 2012
as a whole, barring any severe negative shock. Accordingly
growth is likely to slow further in the second half of the
year and the outturn for the year as a whole is likely to be
close to 12 percent barring any negative shocks to the
global economy. If however, substantial downside risks to
the global economy do materialize then growth could be
lower, at below 10 percent. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 73446
Date: Oct 01, 2012
Mongolia's mineral-rich economy was
hit extremely hard by the global downturn during 2008-9,
when copper prices plunged, external demand fell, and growth
collapsed.... Show More +
The shock exposed serious underlying weaknesses
in the management of the country's natural resource
wealth, particularly the lack of policies to insulate the
economy from commodity cycles and real exchange rate
appreciation pressures, an inadequate safety net, and poor
public investment planning. These issues gained further
urgency with the signing of a major copper mining deal in
2009 that further increased the country's mineral
dependence. As part of its reform efforts and with the
assistance of the World Bank and the International Monetary
Fund (IMF), the government began an intensive south-south
exchange, notably with Chile, another major copper producer,
on strengthening the policy environment. The dialogue proved
critical in the passage of several landmark laws within the
space of a few years, including a fiscal stability law
modeled after Chile, and the accompanying integrated budget
and procurement and social welfare laws. These reforms will
be crucial in managing the boom-bust cycle of mineral prices
and mitigating Dutch disease effects by anchoring a prudent
countercyclical fiscal policy, strengthening public
financial management, increasing savings, and providing a
fiscally sustainable social safety net targeted to the poor. Show Less -
Type: Brief
Report#: 72946
Date: Sep 01, 2012
Author:
Brink, Rogier van den ;
Sayed, Arshad ;
Barnett, Steve ;
Aninat, Eduardo ;
Hasnain, Zahid ;
Parrado, Eric ;
Khan, Tehmina
The report was prepared to assist the
authorities to make informed policy reform decisions by
evaluating the benefits and financial costs of current
pension provisions... Show More +
and of different reform options. The
report outlines a possible three tier approach to old age
income protection in Mongolia which has been consistent with
the Government's approach. The report evaluated four
different design options (currently under consideration by
the authorities) for post-1960 cohorts in the pension
insurance scheme concluding that parameters such as the
contribution rate, accrual rate, and retirement age had much
more substantial impact on pension system costs and benefits
than the scheme designs themselves. The report also
evaluated options for improving future retirement incomes of
herders and those in the informal sector and suggested
several measures, including replacement of existing minimum
pension and social welfare pension provisions with a
Targeted Social Pension. Earmarking a portion of mining
royalties to finance a Pension Reserve Fund can provide one
instrument to manage natural resource revenues as part of a
more consistent policy and governance framework. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 72247
Date: Aug 30, 2012
Dzud is the Mongolian term for a winter
weather disaster in which deep snow, severe cold, or other
conditions render forage unavailable or inaccessible and
lead to high... Show More +
livestock mortality. Dzud is a regular
occurrence in Mongolia, and plays an important role in
regulating livestock populations. However, dzud, especially
when combined with other environmental or socio-economic
stresses and changes, can have a significant impact on
household well-being as well as local and national
economies. This study aims to fill this gap in knowledge by
conducting in-depth case studies of four communities
responses to the 2009-2010 dzud to document both
household-and community-level impacts and responses. The
case studies use a mixed-methods approach employing
qualitative and quantitative data collection and analysis
techniques including interviews, focus groups, household
questionnaires, photovoice and document review, and were
carried out in two soums (districts) located in the
forest-steppe zone of Arkhangai Aimag (province), Ikhtamir
and Undur Ulaan, and two soums in the Gobi desert-steppe
zone of Bayankhongor Aimag, Jinst and Bayantsagaan. The
specific objectives of this study are to assess herder
household and community vulnerability, adaptive capacity,
and medium-term recovery and resilience from the dzud of 2010. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 71844
Date: Aug 01, 2012
Author:
Fernandez-Gimenez, Maria E. ;
Batjav, Batbuyan ;
Baival, Batkhishig
The health equity and financial
protection datasheets provide a picture of equity and
financial protection in the health sectors of low-and
middle-income countries.... Show More +
Topics covered include:
inequalities in health outcomes, health behavior and health
care utilization; benefit incidence analysis; financial
protection; and the progressivity of health care financing.
The tables in this report show how health outcomes, risky
behaviors and health care utilization vary across asset
(wealth) quintiles and periods. The quintiles are based on
an asset index constructed using principal components
analysis. Benefit-Incidence Analysis (BIA) shows whether,
and by how much, government health expenditure
disproportionately benefits the poor. The distribution of
subsidies depends on the assumptions made to allocate
subsidies to households. Under the constant unit cost
assumption, each unit of utilization is assumed to cost the
same and is equal to total costs incurred in delivering this
type of service divided by the number of units of utilization. Show Less -
Type: Brief
Report#: 72114
Date: Aug 01, 2012
The health equity and financial
protection reports are short country-specific volumes that
provide a picture of equity and financial protection in the
health sectors... Show More +
of low- and middle-income countries. Topics
covered include: inequalities in health outcomes, health
behavior and health care utilization; benefit incidence
analysis; financial protection; and the progressivity of
health care financing. This report analyses equity and
financial protection in the health sector of Mongolia. In
particular, it examines inequalities in health outcomes and
health care utilization; benefit incidence analysis;
financial protection; and the progressivity of health care
financing. Data are drawn from the 2005 Mongolia multiple
indicator cluster survey and the 2007-08 Mongolia household
socio-economic survey. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 72450
Date: Jul 23, 2012
Author:
Wagstaff, Adam ;
Bredenkamp, Caryn
The Mongolian economy is continuing to
grow at a very rapid pace, expanding by 16.7 percent
year-on-year (yoy) in Q1. This high growth however, is also
fuelling inflation... Show More +
which touched 16 percent in April, well
above the Bank of Mongolia's (BoM) inflation target of
10 percent. Increasing government spending on wages and
salaries, large cash handouts to the general population, and
burgeoning capital expenditures are adding to the demand
pressures. Meanwhile, the worsening global economic outlook,
in particular a faster than expected slowdown in China,
Mongolia's largest trading partner, has negatively
impacted export growth, resulting in deterioration in
external balances. Under these circumstances, the advice to
Mongolian policy-makers is to 'hold your horses'
and adopt a more cautious macro-economic stance, tightening
both monetary and fiscal policy to prevent further
over-heating of the economy. Show Less -
Type: Brief
Report#: 70213
Date: Jun 20, 2012
This technical note summarizes findings
and recommendations on measures for the strengthening of the
capital markets in Mongolia. The authorities have taken bold
steps... Show More +
in the last two years to modernize the Mongolian Stock
Exchange (MSE) and put in place modern legal, regulatory and
market infrastructure for the capital market. Improving the
institutional, regulatory and supervisory framework is a key
priority, and the enactment of a new securities market law
should lay a sound foundation for the regulation and
supervision of the securities markets. However, its current
draft has several gaps that should be addressed.
Nonetheless, development of the domestic securities market
in Mongolia should take into account the inherent problems
for small markets, because a central feature of the
securities market is economies of scale. Currently, the
local capital market is not representative of the full
universe of Mongolian enterprises that are operating in the
country at present. As a result, it may be difficult to
attract foreign investors interest if the country's
most attractive firms are not listed domestically. One of
the most important elements for a strong domestic capital
market is a diversified institutional investor base, and the
regulatory agencies involved should pursue a concerted
strategy toward developing the investor base. Mongolia needs
to provide an enabling environment to attract a diverse
range of institutional investors participation, including
investors from abroad. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 73099
Date: Jun 13, 2012
The new 'lessons from practice:
assessing scalability' report aims to provide specific
tools and guidance to World Bank Task Team Leaders (TTLs)
and other agricultural... Show More +
development specialists which can
assist them in identifying the potential for scaling up
small, innovative projects throughout the entire project
cycle - from inception through completion. The report,
developed in collaboration with the Heller school for social
policy and management at Brandeis University, draws on
lessons from the experience of the Development Marketplace
(DM) in funding small innovation projects and offers
strategic advice to agricultural practitioners on assessing
the scalability of such projects. This note is based on a
case study from Mongolia from the report. Show Less -
Type: Brief
Report#: 69572
Date: Jun 01, 2012
Author:
Mackedon, John ;
Antikainen, Kaisa ;
Larson, Gunnar
The World Bank's Mongolia quarterly
economic update assesses recent economic and social
developments and policies in Mongolia. It also presents
findings of ongoing World... Show More +
Bank activities in Mongolia. The
Mongolian economy is continuing to grow at a very rapid
pace, expanding by 16.7 percent year-on-year (yoy) in first
quarter (Q1). This high growth however, is also fuelling
inflation which touched 16 percent in April, well above the
Bank of Mongolia's (BoM) inflation target of 10
percent. Increasing government spending on wages and
salaries, large cash handouts to the general population, and
burgeoning capital expenditures are adding to the demand
pressures. Meanwhile, the worsening global economic outlook,
in particular a faster than expected slowdown in China,
Mongolia's largest trading partner, has negatively
impacted export growth, resulting in deterioration in
external balances. Under these circumstances, the advice to
Mongolian policy-makers is to 'hold your horses'
and adopt a more cautious macro-economic stance, tightening
both monetary and fiscal policy to prevent further
over-heating of the economy. The global economic outlook has
deteriorated considerably in recent months. Financial
conditions in high-income Europe, higher oil prices, and,
most importantly, the slowing Chinese economy pose risks for
Mongolia. The channels through which these operate include
financial and trade linkages namely volatility in commodity
prices and through demand from China for its mineral
exports. Indeed, signs of these are already visible as
demonstrated by the decline in exports in April. Other
financial market linkages should also not be discounted:
Mongolia's banking system, which has shown signs of
overheating over the past year, is highly dollarized, with
about a third of deposits denominated in dollars and easy
convertibility out of the Mongolia Togrog. A sharp economic
slowdown and/or an increased macroeconomic instability could
expose the liquidity and asset quality vulnerabilities in
individual banks and system overall. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 70210
Date: Jun 01, 2012
Mongolia's economy has embarked on
a very high, long-term growth trajectory. To realize fully
its economic potential, Mongolia needs to build a
diversified, efficient... Show More +
and stable financial system, capable
of intermediating both on a large scale and in specific
market segments. Access to financial services in Mongolia is
relatively high when measured by the demographic penetration
of branches. The aim of this technical note is to assess the
level of access to finance in Mongolia, and especially for
Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs), to identify key
obstacles to improving access, and to provide
recommendations to overcome these obstacles. The technical
note is organized as follows. Section one provides a broad
overview of the macroeconomic environment and is followed by
section two on the status of access to finance in Mongolia.
Section three discusses products and market segments.
Section four examines the supply of financial services by
analyzing the role of key market players. Section five
examines the demand for financial services by drawing on
enterprise surveys to assess firms perceptions of their
access to finance, and analyzes financing conditions for
MSMEs. Section six examines obstacles in the regulatory,
supervisory framework, and financial infrastructure for
access to finance. Section seven describes the main
government programs related to access to finance. In
conclusion, section eight provides policy recommendations
for overcoming obstacles to enhancing access to finance. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 73100
Date: Jun 01, 2012
Author:
Perolli, Bujana
Owing primarily to extensive investment
in new mining projects, Mongolia's economy is on a path
of very rapid long-term growth. While financial
intermediation in Mongolia... Show More +
has been growing fast, access to
finance remains a critical constraint for enterprises, and
especially for Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs).
Improving access to financial services will require
strengthening the legal and regulatory framework and
financial infrastructure, including the secured transactions
framework, creditor rights and insolvency regime, credit
information sharing system, platform for technology-based
banking products, regulation and supervision of nonbank
financial institutions, and consumer protection in financial
services. To realize fully its economic potential, Mongolia
needs to build a diversified, efficient and stable financial
system, capable of intermediating both on a large scale and
in specific market segments. Due to its focus on the
development agenda, and specifically on access to finance
for the SME sector, capital markets development, and housing
finance market development, this report does not address
financial sector stability issues. Financial intermediation
in Mongolia has grown significantly in recent years; credit
and deposit penetration are on par with the average in the
East Asia and the Pacific (EAP) region. Access to finance is
particularly constrained for SMEs, which are also more
sensitive to an unstable macroeconomic environment,
characterized by high inflation and exchange rate fluctuations. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 73098
Date: Jun 01, 2012