This Country Partnership Strategy (CPS)
for FY2009-12 marks Indonesia's re-emergence as a
confident middle income country (MIC) that has graduated
from International... Show More +
Development Association, or IDA, and is
enjoying a rising regional and global standing. With a
Government that is demanding dependable and timely support
for its own development priorities and its poverty-reduction
agenda, this CPS positions the World Bank Group (WBG) to
respond better to these challenges, thereby ensuring the WBG
continued relevance in the new Indonesia. Ten years ago,
Indonesia was in the middle of an extremely severe economic
crisis. Today, Indonesia is a different country. It has
embarked upon a far-reaching institutional transformation
and has become one of the region's most vibrant
democracies. Its sub-national governments are now major
players in service delivery. The fight against corruption
has moved to the center of the Government's program and
relevant institutions have been strengthened. This CPS is
designed to use the WBG's limited resources to better
meet Indonesia's needs and aspirations as a
middle-income country. By leveraging Indonesia's own
institutions, the CPS aims to help the country to move to
the next phase of its ongoing and incomplete transformation,
a phase that once complete will allow Indonesia to take its
place among Southeast Asia's most successful economies. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 69193
Date: January 1, 2012
The National Program for Community
Empowerment (PNPM) Mandiri program is the key component of
the Indonesian Government's cluster two poverty
alleviation program. The... Show More +
work of the PNPM Support Facility
(PSF) goes beyond coordination. The PSF provides technical
assistance in the continuous effort to build capacities of
communities, governments at the local, provincial and
national level, and civil society. It assists the
development of a very robust monitoring and evaluation
framework which supports continuous improvements to the
program. It makes sure that donor funds are used
appropriately. The PSF also facilitates the implementation
of analytical work that forms the foundation for the
planning, management, and improvement of government
poverty-reduction programs. A key element of the PSF
approach is innovation: it provides space for explorations
and experimentation. PSF's pilot initiatives are highly
innovative and carry the potential for high rewards. The PSF
has various comparative advantages. By tapping into the
World Bank's global knowledge base, it can facilitate
access to international best practices across a range of
development areas. The success of the PSF has not gone
unnoticed. In recent years, PNPM has served as a model for
the development of similar community-driven development
programs, such as in Afghanistan. The PSF plays a direct
role in this. Knowledge sharing continues to expand between
the PSF and parties interested in emulating the success of PNPM. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 69621
Date: January 1, 2012
The National Program for Community
Empowerment or PNPM Mandiri is a nationwide program for
community empowerment aimed at accelerating poverty
reduction. The goal of... Show More +
this program is to empower rural and
urban communities to proactively participate in development.
PNPM will nurture the solidarity and spirit of cooperation
within the community for self-help. The PNPM Support
Facility (PSF) provides support to the Government of
Indonesia's management and technical implementation of
the overall PNPM Mandiri program, and harmonizes donor
contributions. Through PSF, donors can provide high-quality,
coordinated technical assistance, planning advice and
dialogue, as well as targeted financial assistance to the
Government of Indonesia (GOI) in support of PNPM Mandiri.
The overall objective of PSF is to assist the GOI in
providing the most effective leadership and management of
the PNPM Mandiri. Its specific objectives are to: a) ensure
better coordination across grants and amongst donors
supporting PNPM Mandiri; b) develop capacity at all levels
to plan, manage, and improve poverty reduction programs; c)
reduce poverty through government and civil society
partnerships; and d) support high quality monitoring and
evaluation. The GOI is committed to maximizing management
effectiveness during the PNPM Mandiri scale-up and
developing capacity at the local government level. Toward
this end, General Guidelines were issued to ensure that all
involved parties, including all levels of government and
PNPM Mandiri implementing staff, have the same understanding
of PNPM Mandiri's principles and mechanisms. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 69616
Date: January 1, 2012
The National Program for Community
Empowerment or PNPM Support Facility (PSF) was established
in 2007 to support the management and technical
implementation of the Government... Show More +
of Indonesia's (GOI)
flagship community-based poverty alleviation program, the
PNPM, or Program Nasional Pemberdayaan Masyarakat Mandiri
(PNPM Mandiri). PNPM Mandiri is the GOI's operational
umbrella for all poverty programs that use a community
empowerment approach to ensure the poor benefit from
improved socioeconomic and governance conditions. Through
the PSF, development partners provide high-quality,
coordinated technical assistance, policy and planning
advice, as well as targeted financial assistance to the GOI
to support PNPM Mandiri. The overarching objective of the
PSF is to assist the GOI in providing effective leadership
and management of PNPM Mandiri. Its specific objectives are
to: a) ensure better coordination amongst development
partners and across grants supporting PNPM Mandiri; b)
develop capacity at all levels to plan, manage, and improve
poverty reduction programs; c) reduce poverty through
government and civil society partnerships; and d) support
high quality monitoring and evaluation efforts. The
governments of the Netherlands, Denmark, Australia, and the
United Kingdom have contributed more than US$67 million to
the Facility. The GOI and the World Bank are also engaged in
discussions with other prospective development partners,
such as the European Commission and USAID, regarding
additional contributions to support PNPM Mandiri. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 69617
Date: January 1, 2012
Indonesia is an oil producing country
and is the only East Asian member of the Organization of
Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC). Over the years, this
endowment of... Show More +
oil resources has been steadily exploited with
substantial rents flowing to the government from production
and exports of crude oil. The country is also one of the
world's largest exporters of another petroleum
resource, liquefied natural gas. The introduction of a new
oil and gas law in 2001 (the law) provides the policy and
legal basis for moving away from the present ineffective and
fiscally inefficient fuel pricing and subsidy regime,
towards the goal of an independent, reliable, transparent,
competitive, efficient, and environmentally friendly
petroleum sector that encourages the growth of the national
potential and role and at the same time does not exclude the
Government of Indonesia (GoI) fully meeting its social
responsibility towards certain community groups.
Implementation towards achieving the goals set out in the
Law has been slow and hesitant. The Indonesian treasury is
still saddled with a rather inefficient and ineffective fuel
pricing and subsidies regime. This present report identifies
a way forward for Indonesia to meet the requirements of the
Law. That way forward will progressively eliminate the waste
inherent in the present system, signal correct market
behaviors to consumers, achieve large fiscal savings and
help the economy grow while the any negative impact on the
poor and vulnerable are cushioned. Chapter one tracks the
recent history to the present situation in terms of
petroleum fuels utilization, supply, pricing and subsidies,
and identifies some of the key impacts of the prevailing
policies. Chapter two identifies the target petroleum fuel
market regime based on the goals established in the law,
evaluates where the present policy falls short, and proposes
measures that will help Indonesia achieve the outcomes that
are consistent with the law. Chapter three proposes a
step-wise transition that will be required to transform the
present regime and at the same time opening the oil products
market to the beneficial forces of competition and
restructuring Pertamina's downstream operations. Show Less -
Type: Energy Study
Report#: 70420
Date: January 1, 2012
Doing Business in Indonesia 2012 is the
second subnational report of the doing business series in
Indonesia. In 2010, quantitative indicators on business
regulations... Show More +
were analyzed for 14 cities: Balikpapan, Banda
Aceh, Bandung, Denpasar, Jakarta, Makassar, Manado, Palangka
Raya, Palembang, Pekanbaru, Semarang, Surabaya, Surakarta,
and Yogyakarta. This year, doing business in Indonesia 2012
documents improvements in the 14 cities previously measured
and expands the analysis to 6 new cities across the nation:
Batam, Gorontalo, Jambi, Mataram, Medan, and Pontianak.
Doing business investigates the regulations that enhance
business activity and those that constrain it. Regulations
affecting 3 stages of the life of a business are measured at
the subnational level in Indonesia: starting a business,
dealing with construction permits, and registering property.
These indicators were selected because they cover areas of
local jurisdiction or practice. The indicators are used to
identify business reforms and the extent to which these have
been effective in simplifying the procedures, saving time,
and lowering the cost of doing business. The data in doing
business in Indonesia 2012 are current as of July 2011. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 74674
Date: January 1, 2012
International financial markets remain
turbulent, dominated by the political and economic
challenges of the Euro zone debt crisis and signs of
weakening global growth.... Show More +
However, to date, although
portfolio outflows have been seen, Indonesia's domestic
economy continues to perform strongly. The economy remains
relatively well-positioned to weather future external shocks
and steps have been taken to improve crisis preparedness,
for example, by increasing the flexibility of any fiscal
response. The Euro zone continues to grapple with the policy
responses to stem the crisis. The political and policy
responses to the Euro zone debt crisis have been evolving on
an almost daily basis, influencing global financial markets,
risk appetite and capital flows to emerging economies such
as Indonesia. Increased funding stress for European
financial institutions was followed by a coordinated
announcement of liquidity swap arrangements by central banks
including the Federal Reserve and European Central Bank. In
addition to putting in place policies to address the
near-term impacts of any future shocks, with a protracted
weakness in external demand likely, it is an opportune time
to move forward with investments and reforms which can
enhance domestic productivity and growth and attract more
stable and longer-term capital flows. Indeed, the 2012
budget again significantly boosts capital expenditure,
although ongoing budget execution challenges could hinder
the effectiveness of the increased allocation on
infrastructure improved infrastructure and investment
climate can help to promote further the positive recent
performance of Indonesia's manufacturing sector, after
its weakness in the decade following the Asian crisis. The
scope for productivity growth within manufacturing and other
sectors through technology adoption and adaption can also be
enhanced by further improvements in the quality of education
of the labor force and the institutional environment for
research and development. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 65978
Date: December 1, 2011
Using Indonesian manufacturing census
data (1991-2001), this paper rejects the hypothesis that the
East Asian crisis unequivocally improved the reallocative
process.... Show More +
The correlation between productivity and employment
growth did not strengthen and the crisis induced the exit of
relatively productive firms. The attenuation of the
relationship between productivity and survival was stronger
in provinces with comparatively lower reductions in minimum
wages, but not due to reduced entry, changing loan
conditions, or firms connected to the Suharto regime
suffering disproportionately. On the bright side, firms that
entered during the crisis were relatively more productive,
which helped mitigate the reduction in aggregate productivity. Show Less -
Type: Policy Research Working Paper
Report#: WPS5869
Date: November 1, 2011
Author:
Hallward-Driemeier, Mary ;
Rijkers, Bob
This paper estimates average and
marginal returns to schooling in Indonesia using a
non-parametric selection model estimated by local
instrumental variables, and data... Show More +
from the Indonesia Family
Life Survey. The analysis finds that the return to upper
secondary schooling varies widely across individual: it can
be as high as 50 percent per year of schooling for those
very likely to enroll in upper secondary schooling, or as
low as -10 percent for those very unlikely to do so. Returns
to the marginal student (14 percent) are well below those
for the average student attending upper secondary schooling
(27 percent). Show Less -
Type: Policy Research Working Paper
Report#: WPS5878
Date: November 1, 2011
Author:
Lokshin, Michael ;
Umapathi, Nithin ;
Carneiro, Pedro ;
Ridao-Cano, Cristobal
Inter-Regional Cooperation (IRC) is an
instrument for regional development. It is a form of
collaboration between several regions aimed at achieving
specific and collectively... Show More +
agreed outcomes. Although IRC has
yet to be widely adopted in Indonesia, a few examples exist
in central Java that can demonstrate the benefits of IRC to
regional stakeholders. The Kartamantul Joint Secretariat in
the Yogyakarta region and involves three local governments
is a good example, with programs to improve waste
management, drinking water distribution, road, drainage, and
transport management. The Barlingmascakeb Regional
Management forum works with farmers' groups and has
increased farmers' incomes by marketing agricultural
products collectively. Subosukawonosraten in Central Java
has successfully collaborated with tourism and furniture
producer associations to increase revenues. Since 2005, many
other IRC initiatives have been set up with the support of
government agencies (e.g. Ministry for the Development of
Disadvantaged Regions, KPDT) and non-governmental
organizations (e.g. LEKAD and GIZ). This paper provides an
overview of the development of IRC in Indonesia and its
current status. Lessons from experiences in Europe (Germany
and Austria) are drawn upon, and problems in implementation
at both national and regional levels are identified.
Finally, an assessment is made on aspects that need to be
addressed to help ensure that IRC reaches its potential to
improve service delivery and develop regions' economies. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 67591
Date: November 1, 2011
Author:
Anwar, Makhdonal
A decade of implementation of
decentralization and regional autonomy in Indonesia has
produced a mixture of positive and negative results.
Indonesia has made much progress... Show More +
in implementing regional
autonomy, but urgent problems remain to be solved (USAID,
2009; Dwiyanto et al., 2007). In an attempt to address
various issues surrounding functional assignment, research
and public consultations have been undertaken with the
following two strategic purposes: (1) in the short-term, to
gather input to revise and improve the national policy on
decentralization and regional autonomy as stated in Law No.
32 Year 2004; and (2) in the long-term, to formulate a Grand
Design for Regional Autonomy (GDRA). This study focuses on
the assignment of governmental functions due to the
topic's widespread and extensive implications on
government administration in the regions. As has frequently
been documented, the implementation of regional autonomy in
Indonesia still leaves many problems related to functional
assignment among central, provincial, and district/city
governments (Ferrazzi, 2008; Ministry of Home Affairs,
2009). This paper will explain the findings of the research
conducted in the three aforementioned provinces. The
elaborations in this paper constitute problems and obstacles
in functional assignment, implications of the lack of
clarity in functional assignment toward various aspects of
regional government, and recommended actions to rectify and
reform functional assignment across government levels.
Recommendations are classified based on recommendations for
the revision of Law No. 32 Year 2004 and the formulation of GDRA. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 67652
Date: November 1, 2011
Author:
Dwiyanto, Agus
Regional civil service management reform
has been an urgent agenda in the regional autonomy
implementation. After more than a decade of the regional
autonomy, the facts... Show More +
are that there have been various
problems with the regional civil service management. Among
these problems are: mismatch between the apparatus'
competencies and their functions, politicized civil
apparatus, commoditization of bureaucratic positions and
functions, and ethnically and locally spatial fragmentation,
and strengthened values of primodialism. The accumulation of
such problems certainly has negative impacts on
regions' performance in public service delivery.
Regional autonomy expected to accelerate the reform of
public services to enhance public welfare in regions may be
inhibited by lack of regional apparatus'
professionalism. Citizens' demand for efficient,
effective and accountable public services when the
government becomes closer to them cannot be fulfilled
because its apparatus who serves them is not professional
and competent. Consequently, the government's promise
of regional autonomy to improve access to and quality of
public services is still far from satisfaction. The case
study covered three sectors, i.e. education, health, and
public works. The three sectors were selected because they
play a significant strategic role in improving the
socioeconomic welfare of citizens and regional development.
They also represent the complexity encountered by the
government of Indonesia in managing its apparatus in
regions. The education and health sectors involve large
portions of regional apparatuses, particularly teachers and
paramedics. The problems faced in apparatus management in
these sectors represent the problems faced by most of the
regional apparatus. The study was conducted in three
provinces, i.e. West Java, West Kalimantan and East Nusa
Tenggara. The provinces were purposively sampled, each
representing regions with relatively developed, average and
underdeveloped socioeconomic conditions. The study was
conducted at the provincial and district levels. The
consultant team conducted an interview with key respondents
from selected provincial and district governments. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 67651
Date: November 1, 2011
Author:
Dwiyanto, Agus
Minimum Service Standards (MSS) in
Indonesia is a measurement for evaluation of the local
government performance in the implementation of obligatory
functions related... Show More +
to basic services. The combination of
obligatory functions, accompanied by MSS, aim to provide
access for citizens at the minimum level of quality at a
given time. The frameworks of MSS were developed started in
early 2000 in respond then Law 32/2004 been intensively
developed in Indonesia following the issuance of Law 32/2004
which stated in Articles 11 and 12 that while measuring the
performance of obligatory functions government will refer to
a MSS. These provisions are elaborated, which is defines MSS
as a measurement of a type and quality of basic public
service that all citizens have the right to receive. The
program is a Government of Indonesia (Directorate General
Bangda, MoHA) initiative, supported in its implementation by
Decentralization Support Facility (DSF)/World Bank. With a
view to improving the accessibility and quality of basic
public services, the program supports the implementation of
the minimum service standards by building government
capacity to cost and implement MSS in the regions. The
objectives of the program are to: strengthen MoHA capacity
to work with other ministries, to cost MSS for selected
sectors; improve central and provincial government support
to district/city for MSS implementation; develop local
government capacity for implementing MSS for selected
sectors; and analyze factors underlying the successful
implementation of MSS and possible relationships with the
achievement of the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs). Show Less -
Type: Other Urban Study
Report#: 68433
Date: November 1, 2011
The Water and Sanitation Program (WSP)
has implemented the Global Scaling up Rural Sanitation
Project since 2007. One of the central objectives of the
project is to... Show More +
improve sanitation at a scale sufficient to
meet the 2015 sanitation Millennium Developmental Goal (MDG)
targets in Indonesia, India, and Tanzania. The baseline
assessment of the enabling environment was completed in July
and August 2007, during the start-up phase of the overall
project. This follow up endline assessment was carried out
three years later in mid-2010. This report presents the main
findings and recommendations from the endline assessment of
the ability of the enabling environment to scale up,
sustain, and replicate sanitation improvements in East Java,
Indonesia. Community-Led Total Sanitation (CLTS) was
introduced into Indonesia in May 2005 through field trials
in six provinces.
The remarkable success of these
field trials, implemented with assistance from the Ministry
of Health (MoH) and two of its large rural water supply and
sanitation programs, caused the CLTS approach to spread to
several hundred additional communities, generated
significant demand from other districts, and led to its
subsequent adoption as the main methodology for sanitation
improvement in several large sector programs. Sanitation
remains a local government responsibility, and as a result
the decentralized and demand-responsive approach adopted by
the project in East Java has proved highly appropriate and
effective. In the absence of any larger central programs,
district governments were convinced to use their own
institutions and resources to implement the project,
resulting in sustainable arrangements and finance,
cost-effective use of local resources, as well as proactive
efforts to learn from others, innovate, and develop locally
appropriate approaches. The private resource agencies
contracted by the project were effective in supporting the
districts during this learning and development phase, and
most district governments now appear to be confident in
managing and sustaining their rural sanitation programs.
There is increasing consensus nationally that total
sanitation and sanitation marketing approaches are effective
program methodologies, with most rural sanitation programs
in Indonesia now utilizing some form of total sanitation
approach and many showing interest in developing a
sanitation marketing component. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 72095
Date: November 1, 2011
Author:
Robinson, Andy
Statistics from the UN Joint Monitoring
Program show sanitation progress in Indonesia to be
off-track coverage has to increase by more than 13
percentage points nationally... Show More +
from 2008 to 2015 to meet the
sanitation target of the Millennium Development Goals, which
the Government of Indonesia committed to in 2002. However,
after being a largely forgotten issue in the 15 years
following the Asian financial crisis of 1997-98, sanitation
is now receiving increasing attention from all levels of
government in Indonesia. Recently the Government of
Indonesia has made considerable efforts to mobilize
additional resources in order to finance the country's
needs for infrastructure projects. The purpose of the
Economics of Sanitation Initiative (ESI) is to promote
evidence-based decision making using improved methodologies
and data sets, thus increasing the effectiveness and
sustainability of public and private sanitation spending.
Better decision making techniques and economic evidence
themselves are also expected to stimulate additional
spending on sanitation to meet and surpass national coverage
targets. The specific purpose of the ESI phase two studies
is to generate robust evidence on the costs and benefits of
sanitation improvements in different programmatic and
geographic contexts in Indonesia, leading to information
about which are more efficient and sustainable sanitation
interventions and programs. Basic hygiene aspects are also
included, insofar as they affect health outcomes. Show Less -
Type: UNDP-Water & Sanitation Program
Report#: 72417
Date: November 1, 2011
External events have dominated economic
developments for Indonesia over the past quarter. The
outlook for global growth has weakened and the euro zone
sovereign debt... Show More +
crisis has intensified. International risk
aversion and market volatility have increased, although they
remain well below levels seen in late 2008. Equity markets
have fallen and emerging markets have seen capital outflows,
putting downward pressure on their currencies.
Indonesia's domestic economic performance has continued
to be strong but, as in other countries in the region, its
financial markets have not been immune from this turbulence.
Indonesia's domestic drivers of growth, its solid
fiscal position, accumulation of reserves, and strengthened
financial sector performance make it relatively well-placed
to deal with shocks arising from the above scenarios. This
improved resilience to external shocks, and a strong policy
response, was seen during the 2008- 09 crisis. The final
piece looks at the core development challenge of how to make
growth more inclusive, as well as higher, focusing on an
analysis of the province of East java. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 64797
Date: October 1, 2011
The book discusses basic concepts on key
topics to managing a small piped water system ideally for up
to 1,000 households. It presents tools that can be adapted
by Community-Based... Show More +
Water Organizations (CBOs) for use in
their operations, such as forms, checklists and procedural
guidelines. Illustrative examples have also been compiled
from the experiences of the district local governments,
support organizations and CBOs operating in East and West
Java, who participated in the Multi-Village Pooling (MVP)
Project. This toolkit seeks to compile a set of ready
resources for organizations supporting Indonesian CBOs and
CBOs themselves, which was not previously available despite
many years of rural water investment projects. The book
introduces fundamental concepts in an easy to-understand
way, so that a number of discussions have been simplified.
This will give users a basic understanding enough to seek
further resources or references or advice from experts,
which is encouraged. Show Less -
Type: UNDP-Water & Sanitation Program
Report#: 65995
Date: October 1, 2011
Author:
Sy, Jemima
Papua has abundant natural and fiscal
resources but also faces great development challenges. On
the one hand, Papua currently has the largest per capita
fiscal capacity... Show More +
after West Papua. Papua is rich in natural
resources such as non-oil-and-gas minerals and forest
products. On the other hand, development challenges in Papua
are significant, including geography, terrain and
demography. In general, Papua is still underdeveloped both
socially and in economic terms compared to other regions in
Indonesia. This underdevelopment is evident in most poverty,
education, health, and infrastructure indicators. The
economy and investment in Papua are dominated by the mining
sector and, in a distant second place, the agricultural
sector. Between 2004 and 2007, the mining sector accounted
for more than 50 percent of the Papua's gross regional
domestic product (GRDP). As a consequence, economic growth
was determined by fluctuations in mineral commodity prices.
The second largest sector is agriculture, which accounts for
about 14-18 percent of GRDP. This sector absorbed the most
workers in Papua province until 2008. Meanwhile, industry
continues to lag and contributed less than 10 percent to
GRDP. The PEA is a part of the PEACH (Public Expenditure
Analysis and Capacity Harmonization) program. This program
is an initiative of the Government of Papua to continuously
improve its public financial management performance.
Consequently, the analysis contained in this report
addresses issues that are the region's main focus.
Today, the Government of Papua is trying actively to achieve
a 'New Papua' through implementing the following
agenda: a) restructuring the local government; b) developing
a prosperous Papua; c) developing a safe and peaceful Papua;
and d) improving and accelerating the development of basic
infrastructure and facilities. Show Less -
Type: Working Paper
Report#: 71552
Date: October 1, 2011
Author:
Rofingatun, Siti ;
Karetji, Petrarca ;
Sihombing, Meiske ;
Bisai, Charley Michael ;
Citra, Anthonius ;
Putra, Transna ;
Allolayuk, Paulus ;
Purwadi, Marsi Adi ;
Fengler, Wolfgang ;
Subekti, Amin ;
Simanjuntak, Aaron ;
Purbariani, Ida Ayu ;
Salle, Agustinus ;
Saranga, Ester ;
Hafiziandra, Yundy ;
Marbun, Robert ;
Tupamahu, Caroline