ARV Treatment: Special Focus
Back to Main Page

Message Subject: Re: Economists, please take us beyond cost-effectiveness

Forum: ARV Conference Discussion Area
Re: Bulletin board for participants (Dave Witzel)
Re: AIDS and Economics Forum (Paurvi Bhatt)
Re: Details of AIDS Economics Network Meeting (John Stover)
Re: Economists, please take us beyond cost-effectiveness (Claudes Kamenga)
Re: Re: Economists, please take us beyond cost-effectiveness (Marina Mahathir)
Date: 08/May/1998 11:43
From: jbj@bassam.orstom.ci>

Excuse me, but I cannot agree with this approach (and that of Claude
Kamenga) to the problem. I know that people are suffering while we are
discussing. I know, too, that,  based on the same type of generous but short
thinking you are using today, the medical system developped and created huge
injustice ! I know why so many patients are not receiving the care they
need, even if they (or the society) can pay the cost ; I know that, at the
same time, physicians and the pharmaceutical industry are making money with
unnecessary care and undue margins !

We must now take into account the fact that no one society can afford the
cost of all medical care that would be in order to give every patient "all
that the modern medical science can offer", because of limited (individual
and national) resoources. Therefore we cannot answer the question with mere
compassionate thinking, with mere individualistic answers, we must discuss
the criteria for 'just' health care, for an equitable distribution of health
care among the patients. I tried to enter this discussion in my presentation
of an exemple : the UNAIDS strategy in Côte d'Ivoire. 
()

For a thorough discussion of the question of 'just' health care, as applied
to our problem, we certainly need the help of moral philosophy specialists :
may I suggest this line of discussion to be included in the agenda of the
forum ?


Professeur J. BRUNET-JAILLY
ORSTOM
04 BP 293
ABIDJAN 04
Côte d'Ivoire
tél : (225) 357067
fax : (225) 354015


Back to Top

ARV: Main Page | Overview | Discussion | Participants


AIDS Economics Home
AIDS Economics Home Page

ARV Treatment: Special Focus
Back to Main Page