Assessing Aid

Aid and Reform in Africa

Aid Effectiveness Home

Related Sites
    Economic Growth Research
    World Bank Research

Does Participation Improve Performance?: Establishing Causality with Subjective Data
by Jonathan Isham, Deepa Narayan, and Lant Pritchett

ABSTRACT

Data from 121 diverse rural water projects provide strong statistical findings that increasing beneficiary participation directly causes better project outcomes. Three possible econometric objections to these findings are addressed and answered. The subjective nature of the data does not preclude valid, cardinal measures of participation appropriate for statistical analysis. "Halo effects"—changes in the measurement of one variable because of the observed state of another variable—do not seem to induce a strong upward bias in the measurement of participation or project performance. Reverse causation is unlikely: estimation using instrumental variables, data on project timing, and documentation of case studies suppport the cause-effect relation between participation and better project performance.

Back to Research Papers